Client-Side Performance Sucks Craig Walker, Chief Technology Officer And what you can do to make it suck less. www.xero.com

Your typical internal network: Easier to control Easier to predict Knowledge of almost everything from LAN speed to operating system

Easier to control

Easier to predict

Knowledge of almost everything from LAN speed to operating system

There's a reason why the words “world” and “wide” are in the acronym Control and knowledge are limited to your own environment. Even how the packets fly around the internet is out of your control. www.xero.com

The HTTP Request Server Browser Receive Last Byte Send Last Byte Send Data Establish Connection Initial Connection Open Socket Initial HTTP Request First Byte Receive First Byte Send First Byte Content Download ISP Get IP DNS Lookup

5% Server side performance often not the problem with response time 95% Most of the response time is taken up here

25% 75%

Empty Cache Primed Cache

Focus on the front-end 75-95% of the end-user response time for Xero customers is spent on the front end Much easier to optimise than server side performance Greater potential for improvement – especially from an end-users point-of-view Proven to work

75-95% of the end-user response time for Xero customers is spent on the front end

Much easier to optimise than server side performance

Greater potential for improvement – especially from an end-users point-of-view

Proven to work

Performance === Usability www.xero.com

The giants who’s shoulders I’m standing on Yahoo! Exceptional Performance team http://developer.yahoo.com/performance/ Steve Souders Former Chief of Performance at Yahoo! Now at Google Creator of YSlow and the 14 Rules Author of High Performance Web Sites Stoyan Stefanov, Patrick Meenan, Julien Lecomte, Stuart Colville, Ed Eliot and many more …

Yahoo! Exceptional Performance team

http://developer.yahoo.com/performance/

Steve Souders

Former Chief of Performance at Yahoo!

Now at Google

Creator of YSlow and the 14 Rules

Author of High Performance Web Sites

Stoyan Stefanov, Patrick Meenan, Julien Lecomte, Stuart Colville, Ed Eliot and many more …

Zip It! Significantly reduces download size – 60-80% saving on text based content 90% of browsers support compression Benefits ALL users Zip everything you can html (aspx), js, css, xml, txt, json (ashx, axd) Benefits you too: Reduces traffic costs Doesn’t require code changes

Significantly reduces download size – 60-80% saving on text based content

90% of browsers support compression

Benefits ALL users

Zip everything you can

html (aspx), js, css, xml, txt, json (ashx, axd)

Benefits you too:

Reduces traffic costs

Doesn’t require code changes

Fly’s down Zipped

Reduce HTTP Requests Less components means a faster page Every request is an overhead Combine scripts Combine CSS Combine images into CSS Sprites Don’t rely on cache: 304’s are still requests

Less components means a faster page

Every request is an overhead

Combine scripts

Combine CSS

Combine images into CSS Sprites

Don’t rely on cache: 304’s are still requests

CSS Sprites Combine all small images into one large image Use CSS to control the displaying of each image

Combine all small images into one large image

Use CSS to control the displaying of each image

The designers want what? 11 Images 11 HTTP Requests 3.3 KB total size

Obey your thirst ® 1 Image 1 HTTP Request 1.6 KB total size

And the CSS? <div class=&quot;buttons&quot;> <span class=&quot;large green button&quot;> <button type=&quot;button&quot;> <span class=&quot;checkbox icon&quot;> Approve </span> </button> </span> <span class=&quot;large blue button&quot;> <button type=&quot;button&quot;> <span> Save </span> </button> </span> <span class=&quot;large red button&quot;> <button type=&quot;button&quot;> <span class=&quot;delete icon&quot;> Delete </span> </button> </span> <span class=&quot;medium gray button&quot;> <button type=&quot;button&quot;> <span class=&quot;delete icon&quot;> Cancel </span> </button> </span> </div> .buttons span.button { background:transparent url(buttons.png) no-repeat 0 0; } .buttons span.button button, .buttons span.button a { background:transparent url(buttons.png) no-repeat 100% -120px; } .buttons span.blue { background-position: 0 -30px; } .buttons span.blue button, .buttons span.blue a { background-position: 100% -150px; } .buttons span.red { background-position: 0 -60px; } .buttons span.red button, .buttons span.red a { background-position: 100% -180px; } .buttons span.green { background-position: 0 -90px; } .buttons span.green button, .buttons span.green a { background-position: 100% -210px; } The HTML The CSS

.buttons span.button {

background:transparent url(buttons.png) no-repeat 0 0;

}

.buttons span.button button, .buttons span.button a {

background:transparent url(buttons.png) no-repeat 100% -120px;

}

.buttons span.blue {

background-position: 0 -30px;

}

.buttons span.blue button, .buttons span.blue a {

background-position: 100% -150px;

}

.buttons span.red {

background-position: 0 -60px;

}

.buttons span.red button, .buttons span.red a {

background-position: 100% -180px;

}

.buttons span.green {

background-position: 0 -90px;

}

.buttons span.green button, .buttons span.green a {

background-position: 100% -210px;

}

Maximise Parallel Downloads Most browsers are limited to 6 connections total and 2 connections per hostname Increase the number of hostnames to increase the number of parallel downloads (e.g., go.xero.com, gos1.xero.com, gos2.xero.com) Don’t overdo it! (DNS lookups are expensive so limit 2-4 domains) Browser Parallel Downloads Firefox 2 2 Firefox 3 6 Internet Explorer 7 2 Internet Explorer 8 6 Safari 3.1 4 Safari 4.0 4

Most browsers are limited to 6 connections total and 2 connections per hostname

Increase the number of hostnames to increase the number of parallel downloads (e.g., go.xero.com, gos1.xero.com, gos2.xero.com)

Don’t overdo it! (DNS lookups are expensive so limit 2-4 domains)

Maximise Parallel Downloads Stepped download (with 1 hostname) Increased parallelism (using 2 hostnames)

Stepped download

(with 1 hostname)

Use a CDN Content Delivery Network Distributes content closer to the last mile Distribute your static content before distributing your dynamic content Akamai most popular but very expensive Xero utilises a rudimentary CDN using IP lookup to determine location

Content Delivery Network

Distributes content closer to the last mile

Distribute your static content before distributing your dynamic content

Akamai most popular but very expensive

Xero utilises a rudimentary CDN using IP lookup to determine location

How it works: Images JS CSS <xsl:value-of select=&quot;Page:RegisterCSS('/common/style/xero.css','screen')&quot;/> <xsl:value-of select=&quot;Page:RegisterJavascript('/common/scripts/xero.js'&quot;/> <link rel=&quot;stylesheet&quot; type=&quot;text/css&quot; media=&quot;screen&quot; href=&quot;https://nzs1.xero.com/common/style/xero.css&quot; /> <script type=&quot;text/javascript&quot; src=&quot;https://nzs2.xero.com/common/scripts/xero.js&quot;></script> GET Request Response with HTML document Get location from IP

Maximise the cache Understand the ratio of cached vs uncached Add an Expires header Not just for images – should be used on all static content Set a “Never expire” or far future expires policy if you can Reduces HTTP requests – once component is served, the browser never asks for it again Date stamping in file names makes it easier Remove ETags ETags are another caching mechanism – sent with every request Uniquely created per web server – not good in web farms Just turn them off and use Expires headers instead

Understand the ratio of cached vs uncached

Add an Expires header

Not just for images – should be used on all static content

Set a “Never expire” or far future expires policy if you can

Reduces HTTP requests – once component is served, the browser never asks for it again

Date stamping in file names makes it easier

Remove ETags

ETags are another caching mechanism – sent with every request

Uniquely created per web server – not good in web farms

Just turn them off and use Expires headers instead

CSS external and on top Move all inline CSS to external style sheets for both reuse and caching Put all style sheet references at the top Firefox and IE will block rendering until all the CSS is downloaded Use <link> and NOT @import In IE @import is the same as putting <link> at the bottom

Move all inline CSS to external style sheets for both reuse and caching

Put all style sheet references at the top

Firefox and IE will block rendering until all the CSS is downloaded

Use <link> and NOT @import

In IE @import is the same as putting <link> at the bottom

JavaScript external and on the bottom Move scripts to external files for both reuse and caching Promotes better script design Push scripts as low as possible Often difficult with document.write or with inline calls requiring loaded JavaScript Be pragmatic – think about splitting JavaScript into “must be loaded” and “can be loaded on demand” Scripts will block both downloading and rendering until parsed Remove duplicate scripts (IE has a habit of downloading them again)

Move scripts to external files for both reuse and caching

Promotes better script design

Push scripts as low as possible

Often difficult with document.write or with inline calls requiring loaded JavaScript

Be pragmatic – think about splitting JavaScript into “must be loaded” and “can be loaded on demand”

Scripts will block both downloading and rendering until parsed

Remove duplicate scripts (IE has a habit of downloading them again)

Notice the parallel download here … … until we hit the JavaScript files where they come down sequentially, blocking any other downloads

Minify all static content CSS, JavaScript, XML, JSON, HTML can all be minified Not a replacement for gzipping but is a perfect accompaniment to it Lots of tools: JSMin CSSTidy YUI Compressor JavaScript obfuscation can also be useful – just test that your app still works afterwards

CSS, JavaScript, XML, JSON, HTML can all be minified

Not a replacement for gzipping but is a perfect accompaniment to it

Lots of tools:

JSMin

CSSTidy

YUI Compressor

JavaScript obfuscation can also be useful – just test that your app still works afterwards

Optimise images Use PNGs instead of GIFs Avoid alpha filters – can block rendering and freeze the browser PNG8 is best and supported by IE6 (yes – even with transparency) Optimise further with PNGOUT or PNGCRUSH Make sure you have a favicon.ico Every browser will request it Best not to respond with a 404 Make it small and cacheable

Use PNGs instead of GIFs

Avoid alpha filters – can block rendering and freeze the browser

PNG8 is best and supported by IE6 (yes – even with transparency)

Optimise further with PNGOUT or PNGCRUSH

Make sure you have a favicon.ico

Every browser will request it

Best not to respond with a 404

Make it small and cacheable

Preloading … Preload components you’ll need in the future Unconditional preload Xero login page preloads all core components so that the dashboard experience is better Conditional preload Often based on where you think a user might go to next

Preload components you’ll need in the future

Unconditional preload

Xero login page preloads all core components so that the dashboard experience is better

Conditional preload

Often based on where you think a user might go to next

Reduce cookie weight Cookie’s are sent back with every request Keep cookie size small and only store what’s required – use server-side storage for everything else Consider cookie free domains for static content

Cookie’s are sent back with every request

Keep cookie size small and only store what’s required – use server-side storage for everything else

Consider cookie free domains for static content

Keep it clean Choose a good Ajax library – don’t go writing this stuff yourself Always asynchronous Use JSON over XML Accessing JSON faster and cheaper Less overhead than XML Use GET requests over POSTs wherever possible POST is a 2-step process: send headers, send body POST without a body is essentially a GET anyway And make sure the response is zipped!

Choose a good Ajax library – don’t go writing this stuff yourself

Always asynchronous

Use JSON over XML

Accessing JSON faster and cheaper

Less overhead than XML

Use GET requests over POSTs wherever possible

POST is a 2-step process: send headers, send body

POST without a body is essentially a GET anyway

And make sure the response is zipped!

Things to take away Focus on the front-end Be an advocate for your users Don’t let designers get in the way of performance But they will so optimise, optimise, optimise!

Focus on the front-end

Be an advocate for your users

Don’t let designers get in the way of performance

But they will so optimise, optimise, optimise!

YSlow Firebug extension Grades performance – not about response times but about how well a site has adopted the techniques suggested Response time inversely proportional to YSlow score – get as close to an A as possible to get the maximum performance gain

Firebug extension

Grades performance – not about response times but about how well a site has adopted the techniques suggested

Response time inversely proportional to YSlow score – get as close to an A as possible to get the maximum performance gain

Fiddler Microsoft built HTTP debugging proxy Inspect HTTP traffic, tamper with incoming and outgoing data and debug performance issues Works with all browsers

Microsoft built HTTP debugging proxy

Inspect HTTP traffic, tamper with incoming and outgoing data and debug performance issues

Works with all browsers

AOL PageTest Internal AOL utility gone public Browser plug-in for Internet Explorer Visually displays underlying requests and provides suggestions on how to improve your response times Also available as an external web-based tester at www.webpagetest.org

Internal AOL utility gone public

Browser plug-in for Internet Explorer

Visually displays underlying requests and provides suggestions on how to improve your response times

Also available as an external web-based tester at www.webpagetest.org

Any questions? www.xero.com

www.xero.com 0800 GET XERO