Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 1 of 43 h                       I THE I NI      ...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 2 of 43           a rnge nsf rde igt M o n c ul ...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 3 of 43           cour a es ng M ovant sPetton f...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 4 of 43           us ot rave             e he   ...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 5 of 43                                CERTI CAT...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 6 of 43A                                     EX ...
Wido Case t iPitMe sg *  n wsLj Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 71of 2/ 122:       ...
Wid wsLj H 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 8 4/ 2/0112 01 n o Case mal rn Me s e     ...
Wi   Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS ndowsLie Hot lPrntMess       vJ             mai i     age      Document 86 Entered on FLSD Doc...
n o Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 10 of 43 1 21: 9Wid wsLy HomalPitMes g      ...
Wi Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS è   ndowsLi Hot aiPrntMess         ye m l i        age    Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/...
W i Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS       Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 124/12/ 01121:                        ...
WidoCase 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 134/12/ 01121: *  n wsLy Ho mal rn Me s g   ...
WidoCase 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 144/ 2/ 112158 n wsLy Ho mal rn Me s ge     ...
Wido Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 15 of 43 121 5 n wsLy Ho mal rn Me s ge    ...
W i Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS  ndowsLie Hot lPrntMes        y     mai i    sage   Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/20...
Wi Case t l rn Mes age ndowsLieHo1:11-cv-20120-PAS       y   mai P it s            Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/2...
Wid wsLv Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 18 1 /43 215 n o Case t iP itMe s ge      ...
Wido Case t iP itMe s g n wsLy Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 19 1 /43 2157      i...
Wi Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS ndowsLv Ho maiP itMess       ie t l rn      age   Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 ...
W i Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS  ndowsLi Hot lPrntMes        ye mai i      sage   Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011...
Wido Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 22 /12/ 122: n wsLy Hot iP itMe s ge      i...
Wi o Case ot i PitMe s ge nd wsLy H1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 234/ 243 2 :      ...
Wi d wsLy Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 24 of/201122:2 n o Case t i PitMes a     ...
Wi Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS      Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 254/1 43 122: ndowsLi Hot aiPrntMess    ...
Wido Case t i P itMe s g      i 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 26 of 43 12 01 n wsLy...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 27 of 43                                   N o S...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 28 of 43                                        ...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 29 of 43                                 EXH I T...
Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 30 of 43                DI                 AGNOS...
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition

758
-1

Published on

0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
758
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
3
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Plaintiff's response to defendant's motion to dismeiss action for failure to appear at deposition

  1. 1. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 1 of 43 h I THE I NI N J TED STATES DISTRI COURT FOR CT TH E SO UTHERN DISTRI OF FLORI CT DA CA SE N O. lI ZOI CI SEI SI ONTON : - ZO- V- TZ/ M TRAI BUJDU VEAN U, AN Pl ntF, ai i VS. Dlsm s cl txm r s,m c. ANA GI rm , SPERT, DEREK THOM A S and LA SI IANDA Ao o S Def nt enda s. / PLA I FF RESPONSE TO DEFENDANT M OTION TO DISM SS ACTION FO R NTI S S FA ILURE TO APPEAR AT D EPO SITION Pli ifTrin Bud a u, oSe, eeRe kn w a G a flsti rs ns t antf aa juven Pr h ra r o s t nt ie hs epo e o Mov , t Def nda M oton t Dim isActon f Faiur t AppearatDe ii puruantt he e nts i o s s i or l e o postons s o Fe ea Rult)o Ci l ocdue3 4)a d45b()d a g ,nds e a f lws d rl es f viPr e r 0094 n ()c() ndt a uts s olo : l. On December06,2011t Def he endant fl aM oton t Dim i Acton f Fa lze t s ied i o s ss i or ilr o Appe ra De sto ( ume #78 . a t po iin Doc nt ) 2. TheM ovantacknow ldgest tt Def mtsc ms a tm pt t s e ha he endr ot el te ed o chedul e de ii on t f l ng occasons Ocober 1 , 2011,November11 2011,and postons he olowi i ; t 0 , De e r5, 1( mpost Exhbi 1t Dee a smoin . cmbe 201 Co ie i t o fnd nt to ) 3. TheM ovantf he acu owl urt r edgest he t sandst i t ofs d de tons hat mder t he mporance ai posii f t publc i er ti expe tousr ol i ofltgaton, t cour need t m anage or he i s nt es n dii es uton ii i he ts o isdocke s. t t 4. I i msar ul oft st sandi t t M ova m ade ever ate ptt c ts es t hi mder t ng hat he nt y tm o omm uni e cat vi em a l bet a is ween t M ovantand t Def he he endantscouns ast hi i biiyt make el o s na lt o atn t d po iinsd t li do u ntda d c u t oc ee il se ( e te d he e sto ue o ls c me e n o r d k td lne s s Se Co ost Ex bt1t ti moi ) mp ie hii o hs ton . Furhe m or asevi i t back and f t e ai cores t r e, dent n he orh m l r pondences, t Def he endants c ms lma nor q s f c re me c l cl nst j tf t M o n a s rin ot e de e ue t or u rnt dia do l t o usiy he va ts se to me t he wasuna e t atendawhi t M ova w oul have be gl t pr de, s h hat bl o t ch he nt d en ad o ovi uc t s i docl e aton woul r ul i eihe ar chedulng oft M ova de ii hat a d lm nt i d es t n t r es i he nts poston t a tme t thewasphyscaly abl t appea f hi deposton,ors t ot r o i ha i l eo r or s ii uch hat he
  2. 2. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 2 of 43 a rnge nsf rde igt M o n c ul ber a o bl ma ei)vi tlp neo ra me t o posn he va t o d e s na y d e a ee ho r cos cr uit lvii ( eCo ieEx bi 1t t i moi ) l e ic t ee son Se mpost hi t o hs ton . 6. l i notclarast why t Def ts e o he endantscot mselwoul quesi t M ovantshealh as d ton he t hewasorgi l r eas fom t Def ntsHalway Hous t hom econf i naly el ed r he enda f eo mem ent due t se a m edi condii nam el bei di os wih He ii C i ecton, o ver l cal tons, y ng ar ed t patts nf i Cir i oft lver dibet ,c oni f tgue,de esson,t ombocyt ni as t rhos s he i , a es hr c a i pr i hr ope a, cies, l pl el cot ,anpos i e lvercanceri cat by elvat al f opr ei l s ow at et mt sbl i ndi ed e ed pha-et ot n evel s wn i blodts a d Mllr s ls( eo iial o ntsCo ai Exhi tA) ho n o e t n t e ut Se rgn M va mpl nt bi . 7. Gi t f t t onl s eque c ven he act hat he y ubs nt hangest t M ovantshealh condii has o he t ton been onesi whih hi healh hasf t rdet i atd,and t t M ovantbele i n c s t urhe eror e hat he i ved n good f t t t Def nda and t rcouns we e awa e oft e ciclms aih hat he e nts hei el r r hes r l tnces a , nd f t mor t tDef urher e ha endantscot eldi notr ms d eques any updaed m edi r cor fom t t cal e ds r t M ovanti catng acha i hi cur e m edi condii he di notpr de he ndi i nge n s r nt cal ton, d ovi ftt pr ofhi c tonsasi wasnotr trher oof s ondii t equesed orw ava ed unde t t l nt r he ci tmstnces. rcl a 8. The Def ntsc eli hi m oton as e st tbe us t M ovantwasabl t enda ouns n s i s rt ha ca e he eo appea atm e aton,pr par li M oton f Slmm ar J r di i e ed ls i or l y udgm e ,Stt m entofFact nt a e s, and Revied St em e sofFact,t M ovants d ha bee a e t m a i t t s at nt s he houl ve n bl o ke t o he schedul de ii ;howe t sas eri doesnott i o consder ton t f t ed postons ver hi s ton ake nt i a i hat or he f t l ts n mont ,t A s t t M ovanthasbeen batlng hascaus hi or he as eve hs he cies he ti ed s physcinst gi hi a 50/ cha ofs vi ng hi s i a o ve m 50 nce ur vi s chedul s ger whi hasbeen ed ur y, ch r chedul duet hi exa bat m edi condii a t f t thehasus what es ed o s cer ed cal ton, nd he act ha ed ltl r ani e gy hehad r m ai ng t pr pa e hi m otonsand courtdoclm ent ite em i ng ner e ni o e r s i l s. ( eCo st Ex bt2t t i moi n . Se mpo ie hii o hs to ) 9. Fe eal e s o Cii Pr c d e3 ( )4)d aswihtea miitain o ade ii d r Rult) f v l o e ur 0 b ( e l t h d n sr to f poston when a pary i physcaly t et atend a s heduld deposii i pr desaddii t s i l mabl o t c e ton t ovi tonal avenuesf obt ni t i or aton t a evesbot t Def ntsneed f or ai ng he nf m i hat chi h he enda or i or aton i r gar t t dicover and t M ovantsphyscalabiiy t compl nf m i n e ds o he s y he i lt o y: tBy Remot M eans Thepari m a si at t e . tes y tpul e--ort c may on m oton he ourt i or r t a deposii bet n by t ephoneorot r de- hat ton ake el her emot means Fort e . he pu pos oft sr l an Ruls28a , ( )( ) a 3 b)( ) t de ostontk s r e hi ue d e () 37 a 2 , nd 7( 1,he p ii a e pl wher t de ace e he ponentans rst quesi we he tons. 10.n i howe woul have r quied a courtor ,whih t Def s ver d e r der c he endantscouns was el unwil t a q r Sub vso ()(. l o d rt fcltt ls e pe i pr e ur , li o c uie. diiin b 4) n r e o a iiae e s x nsve oc d es ng . pr son i made f t r di oft tm ony by ot t senon phi m eans e. , ovii s or he ecor ng esi her han t c - g. by m ec c ,el toni orphot a c means Be et e met hanial ec r c, ogr phi . caus hes hodsgi rs t ve ie o pr e sofacc ac and tusworhi s t pary t ng t deposton i r r d t oblm ur y r t t nes , he t aki he ii s equie o appl f a c tor .The or i t s f how t t tm ony i t be r de y or our der der s o peciy he esi s o ecor d, pr er and fl and i may cont n what raddii lsa eguar t cour deem s es vedo ied, t ai eve tona f ds he t neces ar W hih l t M ovantt quesi whet rt Def s y. c eads he o ton he he endanttul quesi d r y tone t M ovantshealh condii orwhet rt swassm pl as he t ton, he hi i y ubver ve t tct a d t si ac i o voi he
  3. 3. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 3 of 43 cour a es ng M ovant sPetton f Slmm ar J t ddr si ii or l y udgm entast w e e f f of hey r ear ul stengt oft M ovantsc r h he ase. l . e37d)a h ie t dititc u tor q r a atr e opa t ra on bl 1 Rul ( utorz s he src o r t e uie n to n y y he e s a e t e p n e,n ldn atme sfe, a sdb tefi ro i cin t a p a a a x e ss icu ig t y e s c ue y h al e ft l to p e r t o u s e de oston, ls tec u tidsta tef tr wa sbsl ilyj tfe o t tote p ii e s h o r fn h th mlle s u t al usiid rha h r un mt cic msa e ma a a r o e ns st us e Rul 37 2) whihha te r u tnc s ke n wa d f xpe e mj tUnd r e 09( , c s h s meln a a Rue3 d ,hebu d nofs wi s bsa ta j tt to a s ca a a gu ge s l 7( ) t r e ho ng u tn ilusikain nd pe il cicum s a r t ncesi on t pary bei s tone Falt F Br ng Cor v.M il Br ng s he t ng anc i d. s a ewi p. ler ewi Co.7 F.d 7 ,7 4 ( t Ci.9 ) W etusa y tes mebtd nofpr ff Rul , 02 2 70 8 9h r1 83 . h ppl h a tr e oo or e 3 d) Si e M o nti teo he ei t c s fcngs n tons t btd nofpr ff 7( . nc , va s h ne r n he a e a i a c i ,he tr e oo or pr vi t a s bsa ilusi tonf sncinsflsonteDee a t a t i o ng h t u tnta j tt i or a to al h fnd n s nd her ka c t e, n ato j teDee d n c t e h spo e hmsl t b a e p ri te omsla d l u h h fn a ts omsl a r v n i efo e n x etn h h ar ofl w ,hi a ht t m ake m a e i satm ent off st dst M ovantsmedi l ea a s bi y o t ral t e s act owar he ca condii and a lt t makei t de ii i i quesi ton biiy o t o postons s n ton. 1 Thecourt ha a s f md i Hyde& Dr h v.Ke t R.Ba t : 2. s ve l o ot n at nneh ker hat t ec ç annotc ude t each oft a l ntc por i wass t i l W oncl hat he ppela or atons ubsantaly jsiidi fin t atn ted p st n . l Kn fi r t a p a wa u t e n al j o te d h e o io s Ony u gs al e o p er s f i i u s bsa ilyj tfe Alh ug weha de ln dt r a h teme isofte u tntal uslid. t o h ve cie o e c h rt h ag me th t u jwa e c sdfo atn igted p st n frh at ru n ta Kn s x u e rm t dn h e o io s o e l e i h r as ,we do decl t tKmg had,att l t agood f t diput conce ni e ons de ha t he eas, aih s e r ng teq et no wh te h wa o l ae t a p a i l h o hssro sin s. h u si f eh r e s bi td o y e rn i t f i eiu l es o g g l Hewa t rf r s bsa tal j tte i fil t a pe ra ted p iin. d. s he eo e u tn ily usi d n alng o p a t h e osto l i (nf c hes bs q nl de ofb anc n e) Ho v r a d sus e a ve no 1 a t u e ue ty id r i a c r. we e , s ic sd bo , ne oft ot cor a i have agood f t diput conce i t rf l est he her por tons aih s e m ng hei aiur o appear Exce f Kmg,Hyde& Dr h hasf l t show t tisclent we e . pt or t at aied o ha t i s r s bsa tal j tte i vi aig t c r dic v r or r .Hyd a d Drt v. u tn ily usi d n oltn he ou t s o e y de s ( e n ah i s Ke t R. k r e a ( F.d 11 :. nneh Ba e , t l 24 3 62 13.I t Def nda c elwastul convi f he e nts ouns r y ncedt t M ova w asavoi ngt r hat he nt di hei re tf dicove y vi deposton,t coul ha e ci e t rrght unde Feder ques or s r a ii hey d ve xer s d hei i s r al Rul ofCii Pr c d e45( ( )d a dt a fld aSu oe af rDe ii i whih e vl o e ur b)c( ) n g nd ie bp n o poston,n c t cour woul is a Comm and t Ate a De ton. Thi woul bedonei a he t d s ue o tnd posii s d n n e fr t ()1 Av dig Un eBu d n o Ex n e S cins A pa t o a t n y fo to c ( ) oi n du r e r pe s : an to . ry r tor e r ponsi e f is ng and s vi a s es bl or s ui er ng ubpoenam ustt r ona e sepst a d ake eas bl t o voi i igt ueb d n o e pe eonape s n s b e tt t s poe . eis n c u t mposn md ur e r x ns ro u j c o he ub na Th suig o r mus enf cet sdut a i pos a a opra es i whih may i ude l t t or hi y nd m e n ppr it ancton- c ncl os ear ngsand r onabl atom e sf --on a pa t orator who f l t compl I ni eas e t y ees ry t ney ais o y. n f l ng t r esofci lpr edur t cour woul i s and or f contm pti olowi he ul vi oc e, he t d s ue der or e n whih t is ng courtmay hol i cont c he s ui dn empta per on who,ha ng been s ved,f is s vi er al wihoutadequa eexc e t obey t s t t us o he ubpoena. 1 Gi t f tt D e endantscot lknow st tt y woul nothave m e t bur 4. ven he ac hat f mse ha he d t he den ofpr r quii t cour t is a s oof e rng he t o s ue ubpoe f t M ovantt appeari lghtoft na or he o n i he crtcalnat e ofhi healh condii t chos i t ad t cicum ve t spr s a ii ur s t ton, hey e nse o r nt hi oces , nd 3
  4. 4. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 4 of 43 us ot rave e he nuesofacli vi t sm ea t t i ends t r ng t cour ofis le ng hi ns o her , hus obbi he t t powert compelcom planc wih t rtl ofci lpr o i e t he zes vi ocedure. 1 A diti tcour haswi dicr i t esabls t tm eand pl ce ofdepostons. l r 5. src t de s eton o t ih he i a ii n e Stnd r M easCo p, 7F. 6 ,6 ( 0 Ci.9 ) c r. imis d 488U. 881 a a d tl r .81 2d 25 28 1 1 r1 87 , e td s s e , S. , 1 S. d. ,1 2 L. 2 1 ( 98 . r ,hes ca ma tre pli dt tiwas 09 Ct 201 0 Ed.d 71 1 8) Hee t pe il se x ane ha t nec a y f t Hong K ong depostonst Gkepl e i San Fr s s t tt c ess r or he ii o ac n ancico o ha he ourt coul over ee t pr edi snc appe lnt ha dir ded t pr vi deposton d s he oce ngs i e la s d s egar he e ous ii or r.Healo not t appelant had done busnes and fl s ti t Norhe n de s ed hat l s i s ied ui n he t r Diti ofCalf ni and s d t ef e e ctt ha t a art e. Thes f ct ar srct ior a houl her or xpe o ve o ppe her e a s e s ci t e a ih t t r w asno abus ofdicr i i or i t de ii t um ent o stbls hat he e e s eton n derng he postons o oc i Sa Fr ncico. cur n n a s 16.Be or a diti tcourtdim is a compl nt i m us w egh t fve f or pr rbed i f e sr c s s es ai ,t t i he i act s esc i n W a dee v. o tn, 0F. 65 6 ( t Ci.9 0) n e ted slc c ur mus n r r J hnso 9l 2d 2, 56 9h r1 9 . n,h it t o t t i fn ta ap rys e a iri i oigted p st n d mo srtdwillesb d id h t atb h vo n g rn h e o io s e n tae l n s, a i l f ih, rful. j ltdv. nc nHo aMotrCo.76 F.d 1 4,1 41(t at o a tF esa Ame a nd o , 2 2 33 3 9 h Ci.9 ) r1 85 . 1 Fi l t ffh f ct r r t diti cour t consderat nae, l ss r 7. naly, he it a or equies he srct t o i ler t es eve e, s nctonsbef e or rng dim i al To det mi whet t diti c f tled t s a i or de i s ss . er ne her he s ct ourt ulil hi o i to t r viwi c ur e mi swheh rt c r ( )e plctydic s e t blgain,he e e ng o t xa ne t e he ou t 1 x iil s u s d he f asbiiy ofl sdr tcs tonsa expl ned why ale na i s i woul be e i lt es asi anc i nd ai tr tve anctons d i pp o it , 2 i e ntdatmai s n to beo eo d rngds s a, n ( na r prae ( ) mplme e le tve a cins f r r e i imis l a d 3) war t pary oft pos biiy ofdim is bef eactz l or i i.Adrana,913 ned he t he si lt s s al or taly derng t i F. at1 2-1 But i tdicus i ofale nai i Inneces ar i t diti 2d 41 3. , ci s son expl tr tves s l s y f he srct cour ac aly ti alem atvesbef eempl ng t uli a es ton ofdim is . t m l res t i or oyi he tm t anc i s s al M al 833 F. a 132. one, 2d t W HERFORE gi t f t Def ven he act hat endantscounseli t e t es ih m alci i ent s mabl o ubls i ous nt , ba f t orf ti t M ovantsf l e t a rand beca e t Def d aih, aul n he aiur o ppea us he endantscot el ms r fus t exe cie t l l avaiabl optonsatt rdipos t appr e es o r s he egaly l e i hei s al o oach t cour t he to compelt M ovantt c he o ompl t M ovantr pectuly r quesst Def y, he es f l e t hat endantsM oton be i de ed. ni Dat Dece be 20,2011 ed: m r Res ctuly s nit , pe f l ubr ted > / W > pq TRAI BUJ AN DUVEAN U,PRO SE 4
  5. 5. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 5 of 43 CERTI CATE OF SERVI FI CE 1he e ceriy t on ora r by tf hat boutDECEM BER 20, 2011 at eand cor ectcopy oft nz r he f egoi doc entw ass ved upon t f l ng vi t Unied St esPos al or ng um er he olowi a he t at t Se ce,FhtCl sM ai: rvi s as l Di as Chartes I , sm ii , nc. 141 N. .1 St Avenue W Dani FL 33004- a, 2835 Ana Gi t sper Di m asCharii l s tes,nc. 141 N. .1 St Avenue W . Dani FL 33004- a, 2835 Derek Thom as Di asChari esl sm ti ,nc. 141 N. .1 St Avenue W . Dani FL 33004- a, 2835 Lashanda Adam s Di as Chari esl sm ti ,nc. 141 N. .1 St Avenue W . Dani , 33004- a FL 2835 Davi S.Chai , quie d etEs r At orney f Def t or endant s 4000 Holyw ood Boul l evard Suie 265- h t Sout Holywood,FL 33021 l EXECUTED ON THI 20 DAY OF DECEM BER,2011 S w z // z Z r // d21* TRAI BUJ AN DUVEANU, SE PR0 5601W .BROW ARD BLVD, , PLANTATI FL 33317 ON,
  6. 6. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 6 of 43A EX H I I 1 B T
  7. 7. Wido Case t iPitMe sg * n wsLj Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 71of 2/ 122: ie mal rn sa e 4/ 43 1 201 01 . R E: RE: Davi Chai ( h e@eii era c d et Dc ait sng lw.om) Tu 11 2 112: PM e / 9/ 31 Tr anBudu anu( i a ai j ve oron v@ms c n.om) 4 atachment t s Her you go.See you M onday. e Fr :Tr an Budu eanu ( lo: i av ms c om ai j v mai oron @ n.om) t Sent:Tuesday,November29,2011 2: 4 PM 1 To:Davi Chai d et Subj :RE: ect DearMr.Chai , et Thank you f youremai. or l l ver m uch appear t me as you ar t one qual i t m ak m edi as wel as cour deci ons i t s t y so e he ied o f e cal l t si n hi Case. As you have cat orcaly r used t pari pat i the dicover pr œ i l ef o tci e n s y ocess and mor t t you have t aly e han hat ot l i ed t t r r gnor he hid equestf di over Isugges t you wai fr f a cour answerand deci on on al or sc y, t hat t ist or t si I pendi motons. ng i Bes Regar t ds Tr a Buduv u ain j ean Fr :Dchai a ei nqeraw. om et si l com To:oronav@ msn. i com Sub e j d: Dat Tue,29 Nov 2011 19: 29 +0000 e: 05: Si, r
  8. 8. Wid wsLj H 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 8 4/ 2/0112 01 n o Case mal rn Me s e ie ot iPit sag 1of 43 2: 1 2 Asyouar welen e l ough t 5l mo i s pepar de l aton an atemptt ar e a he i ( a s y o e ton , r e car i s d t o gu arng 1 s ume ou radc ror srkn y rno ieofh arn ,Iwi s ey Mond f y de ston. e out der tiig ou tc s e ig) l e ou l ay or our po ii Davi Chai Esqui d et re Ei nger Br si , own,L s,Fr ewi ankel& Chai ,P. et A. Pr dentalCicl * Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Hol lywood Boul d evar Hol woo Flrda 330 l d, o i y 21 p:( 4)894- 95 3043 f ( 4)89 801 : 95 4- 5 dchai @ ei nqeraw .om i et si l c www a si l . ei nqeraw com Con i i iv and Prvac Notce:The i o m a i con ai i t scommuni ton, icldi if mato c ai i an fdentalt i v i nf r ton t ned n hi ca i n u ng n or in ont ned n y atachmens,i c i ilma b s j tt te at n cl tpr i ge, ycon iueisie i or i ,and i i ended onl t t s onf a , y e ubec o h torey- i i l ma st t n d nf maton dent en v e t s nt y f t us o t addr see.I i t e pr t o Ei n , Br or he e f he es t s h opery f siger own,Le s,Fr el Chait P. Unaut orz us , diclsur or wi ank & e , A. h ied e s o e copyng oft s c i hi omm uniat oran p t her fi s rc l pr i t an may be unlwf . I y hav r eied t s c muniat n c ion y ar t eo s tit ohbi y ed d a ul f ou e ec v hi om c i o i eror pl e no iyus i medit y by r t n e- aiorby e mait r eot n ei naera .c and des r y t s c muniat n n r , eas tf m a el e ur m l - l o ec i a si lw om, o to hi om c i o and al c es t eof i cl i g aIatachmen s. DebtColecton Di osur Pur tt t e Fai DebtCol ton Pr cesAct 1 opi her , n ud n I t t l i scl e: suan o h r l i adi ec , y ar advs t att s L Fim i a deb col ct a t tng t col ta deb , and an if mat ob ai d may be use f t ou e ied h hi aw r s t l or temp i o l e ec t y n or i on t ne d or hat pur ose. Advi e Di cl e: ensur c p Tax c s osur To e ompl n wi r r i ce t equiemen s i p ed byt I underCic ar230, we if m you a h t m os he RS r ul n or t atanywrtenadvie r atngt Feder tx isu c t ne i t scomm u c i , i cldi g i anyatachmen s, n h it c el i o ala s es onai d n hi niaton n u n n t t was ot it n ended norwr en t be us , andcanno b us b an peronf t puroseof 1) oii tx p ale t tmaybe i o d ed t e ed, y y s or he p ( av dng a en t s ha i i ed un t I enalRev ue Codeor( pr i maretngorr ommendig t an herparyanytans tonl)or mpos derhe ntr en 2) omotng, k i ec n o ot t r aci s ma t addr sedbytewrtenadvieconai i t sc teqs) es h it c t ned n hi ommuniai i l n i anyat c ton,ncudig n tachment . P Please consi the envi onm ent bef e pr nt ng thi e- ai. der r or i i s m l
  9. 9. Wi Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS ndowsLie Hot lPrntMess vJ mai i age Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 9 4/12/ 01122:0 1of 43 2 0 D i as sm Davi Chai ( hae@eiiger c d et Dc it sn l om) aw. W e 11 30 11 2: PM d / / 36 Tr anBudu anu( i av nxom) ai j ve oron @ms c Pl ease confr w hetheryou w ilbe appearng f you deposii on M onday. im l i or ton Thank you Davi Chai Esquie d et r Ei nger Br si , own,Lewi Fr s, ankel& Chai ,P. et A. Pr dentalCicl * Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Hol lywood Boul d evar Holl ywood,Fl i 33021 orda p:( 8 3 954) 94-043 f ( 4)894- 5 : 95 801 dchai @ ei ngeraw . * et si l com wwwa si l com ei ngeraw. Confdental v and Prvacv Notce:Th i or i con ai d i t i c i ii t i i e nf maton t ne n hs ommuniat n, i udi i or i con ai i any c i ncl ng nf mat o on t ned n at tachment i conf ent , y b s j tt te at n - l pr i ge,ma con iueisie i or i ,an i i en onl s,s i i ma e ubec o h torey ci i l d al ent v e y st t n d nf maton d s nt ded y t f t e us oft addr se I i t pr t ofEi n , Br wn,Le s Fr or h e he es e. t s he opery siger o wi, ankel Ch et P. .Unau horz u dicosur or & ai , A t ied se, s l e c yi oft s comm u c i oran pad t er i s rc l pr bi and ma b unlwf . l you ha r ved t scomm unca i op ng hi niaton y h eof s tit ohi t y ed y e a ul f ve ecei hi i ton i e r , la en t yu i me it l b rt r e mal r ye malor c p in iig r w.o a dd sr yt i c mmu iain n r pe s oi s m daey y eu n - io b - it e e t @esn e l c m, n e to hs o nc t or f o a o and aIc es t eof i cl n aIatachmen s. I opi her , n udig I t t DebtColecton Di osur Pur tt t e Fai Deb Col ct Pr tce Ac , l i scl e: suan o h r t l i ac i s t e on y ar advs t att s L Fim i a d tcol ct a t tng t c l ta deb , an an i f ma i ob aied may b us f t t ou e ied h hi aw r s eb l or temp i o ol e ec t d y n or ton t n e ed or ha pur se.Tax Advi Di osur To en e c po ce scl e: sur ompl ce wi r r i an t equiement i p ed b t I underCi ar230,we i or you h s m os y he RS rcul nf m t anywrten advie r atng t Feder t x isu c t ne i t scommuniat n, i u ng i an atach en s, not hat it c el i o al a s es on ai d n hi c i ncldi n y t m t was o i end norwrt t b us andc nt ed ien o e ed, t annotbe u b anyperonf t pupos o ()a di t penalest maybe sed, y s orhe r e f 1 voi ng ax t hat i i os u t It nal mp ed nder he ner RevenueCode or( pr ig, k tngorr 2) omotn marei ecommendi t anoherparyanytans ont)or ng o t t r adi s maters addr s b t wrt ad cec aied i ti communiat n,i udi i an atac t t) es ed y he ien vi ont n n hs t c i ncl ng n y t hment o . P Pl e c dert envionmentbef e prntng t se- ai. eas onsi he r or i i hi m l
  10. 10. n o Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 10 of 43 1 21: 9Wid wsLy HomalPitMes g ie t i rn sa e 1 1 201 4/ 2/ 5 76 Davi Chai ( h e@eii l c d et Dc ait snger om) aw. Thu 1 / /1 11:8 AM 2 01 1 0 Da dCh et( h et sng l c ;Tr anBudu ean ( i av@ms c vi ai Dc ai @eii eraw.om) ai j v u oron n.om) 1 a/achment Pl ease confrm thatyou wilbe at i l tendi yourdeposi on on M onday. ng ti Pl ease see at ached. t Thank You Davi d
  11. 11. Wi Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS è ndowsLi Hot aiPrntMess ye m l i age Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 114/12/ 121: 9 1 of 43 201 5 . (No Subj ) ect Davi Chai ( ait iigera c d et Dch e@esn lw.om) Thu 1 / /11 156 PM 2 01 : Tr an Buduv u( i v@ms c ai j ean orona n.om) l you w oul lke t st tyourdepo eari i t day,pl f d i o ar ler n he ease l m e know . et 1c n s ar any i e a t 1 0 pm . a t t t m f er 03 Davi Chai Esqui e d et r Ei nger Br n,Lewi Fr el& Chai ,P. si , ow s, ank et A. Pr dentalCicl . Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Hol wood Boul d l y evar Holl ywood,Fl i 33021 orda p:( 4)894 30 95 - 43 f ( 4)8 801 : 95 94- 5 dchai @ eii l . * et sngeraw com www . si l . ei ngeraw com Confdental v and Prvacv Notce:The if ma in con ai i t scomm u ca i , icl n if maton c aied i any i ii t i i n or to t ned n hi ni ton n udig n or i ont n n atac t i coni talmaybesubectt t ator - in prvl mayc tt e i i if mai andi it t hmens,s fdeni , j o he t neycl t ii e ege, onsi nsde n or ton, s nendedonl ut y f t u oft e addr s I i t pr or he se h es ee.t s he opedy ofEii ,Br , L s Fr el& Chai , A.Unau hor ed use, scos e or snger own ewi, ank et P. t iz di l ur c ng oft s c muniat n orany par t eofi stity pr bt d and may be unlwf . I y h r eied t s c muniat n opyi hi om c i o t her s rc l ohiie a ul f ou ave ec v hi om c i o i eror plasenotyusi n r,e i mmedi el b r ur e maiorb e- lo r ton@eiiger c anddesr t scommuniat n f at y y et n - l y mait ecepi sn l om, aw. toy hi ci o and alcopi t eo ,i l ng aI a t I es her f ncudi l tachment DebtCol i Di osur Pur uan t t Fai Deb Col ton Pr cesAd , s. l on scl e: s t o he r t l i adi ect ec y ar advse t t s L Fim i a debtc lc oratemptn t c l ta debt and an i or i obt ned m a be us f t at ou e i d hat hi aw r s ol t t ig o ol e ec j y nf maton ai y ed or h pur e.Tax Advi Di osur To ens e compl ce wi r r pos ce scl e: ur i an t equiemen s i h t mpos b t I underCi ar230, we i or y ed y he RS rcul nf m ou t atan wr t a c r atng t Feder t isu con ai d i t s communiat n,i udi i an atac h y ien dvie el i o t al ax s es t ne n hi c i ncl ng n y t hmen s was not o t, it ded nor it t be u an c n en wrten o sed, d annotbeus byan p s f t pur eof( )avoiigt p ale t tma b ed, y eron or he pos 1 dn ax en t s ha y e i i mpose und te I er Rev d er h nt nal enueCodeor( pr tng,maretn orr ommen n t anot p t an tansacins)or 2) omoi k ig ec dig o her ary y r t l o mateqs addr s b t wrt adviecont nedi t sc t ) es ed y he ien c t ai n hi ommuniai icl ngi anyat c ton,n udi n tachmen . t P Pl e consi t envionm ent bef e pr nt ng t s e- ai. eas der he r or i i hi m l
  12. 12. W i Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 124/12/ 01121: 1 of 43 ndowsLie Hot lPrntMess y mai i age 2 58 F#?: Davi Chai ( ait sigera c d et Dch e@ein lw.om) Thu 1 / / 6: PM 2 01 11 55 Tr an Buduv ai j eanu( i v@ms c orona n.om) Fr :Davi Chai om d et Sent:Thur sday,Decem ber01,2011 1: PM 56 To: ai Buduv nu Tr an j ea Subj : e l you woul Ike to s tyourdepo earleri the day, pl f di tar i n ease I m e know . et Ican s ar anyti e aft 1030 pm . t t m er Davi Chai Esquie d et r Ei nger Br si , own,Lewi Frs, ankel& Chai ,P.A. et Pr dentalCicl . Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Holl ywood Boul d evar Hollywood,Fl i 33021 orda p:( 4)89 3043 95 4- f( 4 8 8 5 : 95 ) 94-01 dchai ei nneraw.om * etl si l c www. si l . ei ngeraw com Confdental v and Prvac Notce:The i or i c aied i t i c muniat n, i l ng i or a i con ai d i any i ii t i v i nf maton ont n n hs om c i ncudi nf m ton t ne n o at hment,i c i ilmaybe s j tt t ator - i tpii ge,mayc si ei i if mai , and i it tac s s onf a, dent ubec o he t neycl rvl en e on tt nsde nor ton ut s n ended onl y f t u oft e a ess . Ii te pr eryo Ei n , o Le s,Fr el Ch et P. Unau horz u di l ur or or he se h ddr ee ts h op t f sigerBrwn, wi ank & ai , A. t ied se, scos e c i o t scomm unia i oran p t er i s r t pr bi and m a b u awf . I y h r eied t s c muniat opyng f hi c ton y ad h eof s ti l ohi t cy ed y e nl ul f ou ave ec v hi om c i on i eror plasenotyusi n r,e i mmedi el byr ur e- l bye- lo rcepi eii lw com 1an desr t i c muniat f at y et n maior mait e ton@ snger a d toy hs om . c ion a aIc est eofi u ng alatac nd I opi her ,ncldi l t hment. DebtCol i Di cl e:Pur uant o t Fai Deb Col t n Pr di s Ac s l on s osur ect s t he r t l i a ce tec o , you ar advied t att s L Fim i a d col c oratemptng t c l ta debt and any i or i n ob ai may be us f t t e s h hi aw r s ebt l t t i o ol e ec , nf mato t ned ed or ha pur e. Advi Di osur To en e c pl nc wih r r en s i pos byt l und Cicuar230, we if m you pos Tax ce scl e: sur om i e t equi a em t m ed he RS er r l n or t tan wrt advie r atn t Feder t x is c ai i t scomm u c i , i u ng i an a t ha y i ent c el ig o al a s ues ont ned n hi niaton ncldi n y tachmen s, was n t ot
  13. 13. WidoCase 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 134/12/ 01121: * n wsLy Ho mal rn Me s g ie t iP it s a e 1 of 43 2 58 zj it n ended norwrten t be used, c tbe us , byan p s f t pur eof 1 av dngt pen t t tma be it o and anno ed y eron or he pos ( ) oii ax ali ha y es i ed un t I er Rev mpos der he nt nal enueCod or( pomoi maretn orr ommen ngt anoterp t an tan ont or e 2) r tng, k ig ec di o h ary y r sadi s) maters a ess b t wrt ad c c ai i t sc t t) ddr ed y he ien vie ont ned n hi ommuniai i l ngi an atac t c ton,ncudi n y t hment. P Pl ease c i t envionmentbef e prntng t se- l onsder he r or i i hi mai.
  14. 14. WidoCase 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 144/ 2/ 112158 n wsLy Ho mal rn Me s ge ie t iP it s a l of 43 1 20 : ( Subj ) No ect Davi Chai ( hae@eii era c d et Dc it sng lw.om) F i1 / / 2:9 PM r 2 02 11 2 Tr an Budu anu( i av n.om) ai j ve oron @ms c 1 atachm ent t Si r Iha notr cei c fr a i bac f om y r di y a t ve e ved on i m t on k r ou egar ng our t enda e a t deposton. nc t he ii Ac or ngl ,Ias um e t I il ee you a t dat , t m e and pl e oft deposton notc a t ched. c di y s hat w l s t he e i ac he ii ie t a Have a good w eekend. lt us that Iw ilsee you M onday. r t l Davi Chai Esquie d et r Ei nger Br si , own,Lewi Fr s, ankel& Chai ,P, . et A Pr dentalCicl . Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Holywood Boul d l evar Holl ywood,Fl i 33021 orda p:( 4)894-043 95 3 f ( 4 89 801 : 95 ) 4- 5 dchai @ ei nneraw.om * et si l c www . si l . ei ngeraw com Confdental v and Prvacv Notce: i or a i con ai i t scomm u c i , i cldi if mat con ai i any i ii t i i The nf m ton t ned n hi niaton n u ng n or ion t ned n atac t i c i talmayb s j tt te atorey-l pr i maycon iuei i i or in, and i i ended onl t hmens,s onfdeni , e ubec o h t n ci i l ent v ege, st t nsde nf mat t o s nt y f t us oft e addr s I i t pr or he e h es ee.t s he opedy o Eii er Br f s ng , own, s,Fr el Chait P. . Unau h ied u dicosur or Lewi ank & e, A t orz se, s l e c n oft s c opyig hi ommuniaton orany par t eo i stity pr i t an may be unlwf l l you hav r ceied t s communiaton c i t her f s rc l ohbied d a u. f e e v hi c i i eror pl e n i usi n r , eas oty mmedi el b r ur e- l bye- lor ept n@ ei n lw. , and des r y t s c u c i f at y y et n maior mait ec io sigera com to hi omm niaton and aIcopi t eo ,i l ng aI a t I es her f ncudi I tachmen s.DebtCol i Di osur Pur tt t e Fai Deb Col ct Pr tc Ac , t l on scl e: suan o h ect r t l i e on ac ies t you ar ad s t t i La Fim i a deb col t a t tng t col c a d t an an i or ton obt n ma b us f t e vied hat hs w r s t l or temp i o l t eb , d y nf ma i ec e aied y e ed or hat pur se.Tax Advi e Di osur To ens e c i e wi r quiemen si p po c scl e: ur ompl anc t e r h t m osed b t l underCi ar230, we i or y y he RS rcul nf m ou t atanywrten advie r atn t Feder t isue con aied i t i c muniat n, i l ng i an atac h it c el ig o al ax s s t n n hs om c i ncudi n y t hmens, o t was not it n ended norwr t t b us and c notbe use ,byanyp s f t puroseof 1) oi ngtx p t tat ien o e ed, t an d eron or he p ( av di a enales h maybe i
  15. 15. Wido Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 15 of 43 121 5 n wsLy Ho mal rn Me s ge ie t iP it s a 1 1 201 : 8 4/ 2/ i osedunderte I er Revenu Codeor( pr ig, kei orr mp h nt nal e 2) omot mar tng ecommendi t anoherparyanytansa onl)or n ng o t t r di s maters addr ed b t wrt ad c c ai i t sc t t) ess y he ien vie ont ned n hi ommuniat n,ncudi i an atac t c i i l ng n y t hmen. o t P Please consi the envionm ent bef e pri ng thi e- ai. der r or nti s m l
  16. 16. W i Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS ndowsLie Hot lPrntMes y mai i sage Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 16 of/43121:6 1 1 201 4/ 2 5 R E: Tr an Buj ai duveanu ( i a or v@ms c on n.om) Su 1 / 4/ 1 1 2 PM n 2 0 1 0:4 DavdCh et( hait sng lw.om) i ai dc e@eii era c DearM r.Chai , et Thank you agai f yourem ai. n or l Pl ease be ki and under and that Iw i t be ashel ulas possi e. nd st sh o pf bl How e Ic ver annota t yourdeposton s t by y , due to the i t end ii e ou nconveni ence ofbei ver sck. ng y i W e ne t r chedul t deposton durng a tm e t tI i be i good hea t and lha a c earm i , ed o es e he ii i i ha w l n l lh ve l nd as s es can cause m y m i t go com pl y bl oreven t m i em em berthi w hi coul dam age tr s nd o etel ank, o sr ngs ch d yourcause. Onc a n,Ibel t I ct ng her wi bet s hedul t deposton a t t Cour wil weraI e gai i he ogi hi eve e l o c l e he ii fer he t lans I pendi m oti ,and al af erm y sur y. ng ons so t ger Bes Regar t ds Tr i Bu du anu aan j ve F om:Dc e @eii er c r hait sng l om aw. To:oron v@ ms c ia n.om Sub e j d: Dat Fr,2 Dec 2011 19: 41 +0000 e: i 29: Si r I ve notr ei confr a i ba f om you r di yourat endan a t depos ton. ha ec ved im ton ck r egar ng t ce t he ii Accor ngl Ias e that Iw ilsee you atthe date, tm e and pl e oft deposton notc a t hed. di y, sum l i ac he ii i e t ac Have a good w eekend. Itr tthatjw ils you M onday. us l ee Davi Chai Esquie d et r
  17. 17. Wi Case t l rn Mes age ndowsLieHo1:11-cv-20120-PAS y mai P it s Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 17 of/201121:6 1 1 43 4/ 2 5 Ei nger Br si , own,Lew i Fr el& Chai ,P. s, ank et A. Pr dentilCicl .Suie 265- esi a r e t 5 4000 Hol lywood Boul d evar Holl ywood,Fl i 33021 orda p:( 4)894- 043 95 3 f ( 4)89 801 : 95 4- 5 dc ai a eiiaeraw.om * h et sn l c www . si l . ei ngeraw com Confdental v and Prvacv Notce:The if maton c ai ed i t s c i ii t i i n or i ont n n hi omm unia i , icldig if mat n con ai i any c ton n u n n or i o t ned n at tachment i c i ilmaybe s j tt t ator - intprvl mayconsi t isie i or i , and i i ended onl s,s onf a, dent ubec o he t neycl e ii ege, tue n d nf maton t s nt y f t use oft e a ess . I i t e pr edy ofEi n ,Br wn, L s Fr el Chait P. Un h ie us , diclsur or or he h ddr ee t s h op siger o ewi, ank & e , A. aut orz d e s o e copyngoft scomm u cai oranypar t eofi sr typr biedan maybeunlwf . I you hav r v t s communi ton i hi ni ton ther s ti l ohi t c d a ul f e eceied hi ca i i eror plasenoiyu i n r,e tf s mmedit ybyr ur e- l bye- lo rcepi eii er c , and destoyt s comm uniaton ael et n maior mait e ton@ sng l om aw. r hi c i and aI c es t eof i l ng aI a t chment DebtCol i Di osur Pur tt t e Fai Deb Col c i Pr c Ac , I opi her , ncudi I ta s. l on scl e: suan o h ect r t l ton adies t e you ar adv s t tt s L Fim i a de col oratem p ig t c l ta deb , and any if mat o ai d may be us f t t e i ed ha hi aw r s bt l ect t tn o ol ec t n or i bt ne on ed or ha pur e,Tax Advi e Di osur To ensur c pi e wih r ui pos c scl e: e om lanc t eq r ement i p s m osed byt I underCi ar230, we i or y he RS r cul nf m ou t atany wrten advie r atn t Feder t i ues c ai i t scomm u c i , i u ngi an atach ens, snot h it c el ig o alax ss ont ned n hi niaton ncldi n y t m t wa i ended n wrten t be used andcanno beused, an peronf t pur eof 1 av dngtx p ale t t y b nt or it o , t by y s orhe pos ( ) oii a en t s ha ma e i i ed un t lt nalRe mpos derhe ner venueCo or( pr ig, kei orr ommendigt an h p t an tan t nt or de 2) omotn mar tng ec n o oter ary y r saci s) o maters addess b te wrtenadvieconai i t scommu c i i u ngi an atac t t t) r ed y h it c t ned n hi niaton,ncldi n y t hmen . P Please c i t envionm ent bef e prnt ng t s e- ai. ons der he r or i i hi m l
  18. 18. Wid wsLv Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 18 1 /43 215 n o Case t iP itMe s ge ir mal rn s a 1 of 2 1 :7 4/ 2 01 e* * Davi Chai ( h et sn lw.om) d et Dc ai @eiigera c Mon 1 / / 8: AM 2 05 11 20 Tr anBudu eanu( i v@ms c ai j v orona n.om) Icannotagr ee, On DK 4,2011 a 1 25 P Tr an Buj ve <oron l ms c , t 0: M, ai du anu i av n.oml wr e: ot DearM r.Chai et, Thank you agai f yourem ai. n or l Pl ease be ki and under tand t Iw i to be as hel ulas possi e. nd s hat sh pf bl How e l anno a t y deposton s tby y due t t i onveni e ofbei ver ver c t t end our ii e ou, o he nc enc ng y si ck. W e need t r chedul t deposton durn atm et tI l be i good healh a Iha o es e he ii ig i ha wi l n t nd ve a cl m i ass r scan caus m y m i t g c pl el bl , ore t m i em em ber ear nd, t es e nd o o om et y ank ven o sr thi w hi coul dam age yourcause. ngs ch d Onc agai I i e t I ct ng her wi bet s hedul t deposton afert Cour e n, belev he ogi hi e l o c l e he ii t he t w il w eraI pendi m otons and alo a t m y s ger . l ans I ng i , s f er ur y Bes Regar t ds Tr an Bu du anu ai j ve Fr :Dchait ei nqeraw. om e @ si l com To:oronav@ msn.om i c Subed: j Dat Fr,2 Dec 2011 19: 41 +0000 e: i 29: Si r I e notr ei ed c im a i ba f om you r di g yourat enda att hav ec v onfr ton ck r egar n t nce he deposi on. ti Accor ngl lassum e that Iw ils you atthe dat tm e and pl oft deposi on notce di y, l ee e, i ace he ti i at ached. t Have a good w eekend.
  19. 19. Wido Case t iP itMe s g n wsLy Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 19 1 /43 2157 ie mal rn s a e 1 of 2 4/ 2 011 2 It us t Iwilsee you M onday. r t hat l Davi Chai Esquie d et r Ei nger Br si , own,Lew i,Fr el& Chai ,P. s ank et A. Pr dentalCicl * Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Hol lywood Boul d evar Holl ywood,Fl i 33021 orda p:( 4)894- 95 3043 f ( 4)89 801 : 95 4- 5 dchai l ei ngeraw . et si l com www. si l . ei ngeraw com * la e n e t ato rf n? meha c an d. pe s ot h u / na r s h ge Confdental v and Prvac Notce:Th i or i c ai i t s c i ii t i v i e nf maton ont ned n hi omm u ca i ,i u ng if mat ni ton ncldi n or i on c ai i an atachment i con i tal maybesu ec t te at neycl nt ii ont ned n y t s, s fden i , bj t o h tor - i prvl mayc tut i i e ege, onsi e nsde t if mat n, i i en onl f t e us oft addr ee. l i t pr n or i and s nt ded y or h e he o ess t s he opedy ofEii ,Br wn,L wi Fr el s nger o e s, ank & Chai ,P. .Unaut ied u diclsur orc n of hi c munca i orany par t eofi s rc l et A horz se, s o e opyig t s om i ton t her s tit y p ohi t an may be unl ul I y ha r eied t s c munia i i eror pl se not y u i medit y b r bi ed d awf . f ou ve ec v hi om c ton n r , ea i sm f a el y rt r e mal b e malor c t n esn e lw.o a dd sryt i c mmu ia ina daI o iste e f e u n - ior y - it e epi @ iig r c m, n e to hs o nc t n Ic pe h r o , o a o i u n aIa tchment .DebtColec i Di cl e:Pur uantt t Fai DebtCol ct Pr tc Ac , y a e ncldi g I ta s l ton s osur s o he r l i ac ies t ou r e on advied t att s L Fim i a debtco lc oratemptn t c l a debt and any if mat obt n may be s h hi aw r s l t t ig o ol e ed , n or ion aied u ed f t pur os Tax Advi Di osur To ens e c pl n e wih r r s or hat p e. ce scl e: ur om i c t equi a ement i ed byt I un s mpos he RS der Ci ar230, i f m you t anywrten advce r a i t Feder t isuescon ai i t scommuniat n, r cul we nor hat it i eltng o alax s t ned n hi c i o i l ng i an atac ncudi n y t hmen s, no i t ded n wrten t b us , an c tb us b any per on f t t was t n en or i o e ed d anno e ed, y t s or he pur eof( )avoiigt penalest maybei ed un t It nal enueCode or( pr i pos 1 d n ax t hat i mpos der he ner Rev 2) omotng, maretn orr ommendi t anoherpadyanytans tonl)ormaters)addr s b tewrtenadvie k ig ec ng o t r aci s tt es ed y h it c c aied i t sc ont n n hi ommuniaton,icldig i anyat c i nu n n tachmen. t P Pl ease consi the envionm ent bef e pri i thi e-m ai, der r or nt ng s l
  20. 20. Wi Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS ndowsLv Ho maiP itMess ie t l rn age Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 20 of 43 21:6 1 2/ 011 5 4/1 2 M oti f Sum m ar Judgm ent on or y Tr anBuj ai duveanu ( i a oron v@ms c n.om) Tu 11 2 113: PM e / 9/ 20 Davd Chaet(ch e@eiiger c i i d ait sn l om) aw. Re:Moton f Sum mar Judgment, i or y DearMr Chai , . et 1 b i e t s i wh you wan e me t do fom t e i e i n oft s c s . elev hi s at td o r h nc pt o hi a e The ot way ar her ound,ofcour you woul have had t r se, d o evealmany unpl antcrm i ad s c eas i nal omm it by ted t def he endant ,and t coul have I i o a crm i i tgaton by t DeparmentofJus i . s hat d ead nt i nal nves i i he t tce Agai 1do no bame y f p o t ig t e De en t b c e t i i yourj a you a e as pad a îtof n, tl ou or r tvfn h f dans e aus hs s ob nd r lo i o money by t ri ance c pany. hei nsur om W ih my l ied fnanci r our Icoul nothave a f rfght butIf i notf raIt tme. t i t i al es ces, m d ai i , ie s ai I he i Jus make sur t t Justc Depar mentdo notcome aRert , because t have r l gotaway a f t e hat he ie t hem hey ealy ew tmesw ih crmi ads. i t i nal Bes Regar t ds Tr an Buduv anu ai j e
  21. 21. W i Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS ndowsLi Hot lPrntMes ye mai i sage Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 21/of 201122: 14 1 43 2/ 03 R E:N oti of M oti for Sum m aG Judgm ent ce on Davi Chai ( hait sn lw.om) d et Dc e@eiigera c Mon 11 21 149 PM / /11 : Tr an Bu du eanu ( i v@ms c ai j v orona nxom) Iam nother t educate you on the r es. How ever you ar notentr y cor ec e o ul , e iel r t. The Cour does nothave yourm oti on is books. t on t You cannot sm pl setone,especi l w ihoutcoor nati i w ih ourof i i y aly t di ng t t fce. I y ar welenought dr t fl and s ta motonf s f ou e l o af, ie e i or umm ar j y udgm en , henyoushoul be abl t tt d eo at end a deposton. t ii M y ofi w ilbe r set ng yourdeposi on. fce l e- ti ti Davi d Fr :Tr an Budu ea ( lo: i av ms c om ai j v nu mai oron @ n.om) t Sent:Monday,Novem ber21,2011 1: PM 45 To:Davi Chai d et Sub e :RE:Notc ofMoi f Su j ie ton or mmar J dgment yu DearMr Chai , . et Thi i a Notce ofl entt fl a Moti n f Sum mar Judgment ss i nt o i e o or y . As Iunder and,a notce m ustbe gi t al opposi pari , days i advance. st i ven o I ng tes zl n BestRegar ds, Tr an Bu du anu ai j ve
  22. 22. Wido Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 22 /12/ 122: n wsLy Hot iP itMe s ge ie mal rn s a 1 of 43 4 201 02 (No Subject) Davi Chai ( hait sn lw.om) d et Dc e @eiigera c Tu 1 / 9 11 2: PM e 1 2 / 05 Tr an Budu ean ( i av ms c ai j v u oron @ n.om) Si, r Asyouar welenought fl motons pr edecl a i andat e l oi e i , epar artons temptt ar ahe i (as ume o gue arng 1 s your dc tsor srkngyournotc ofhearng)I ls youMondayf yourdeposton. ea our der tii ie i , wil ee or ii Davi Chai Esquie d et r Eii ,Br n,Lewi Fr snger ow s, ankel& Chai ,P. et A. Pr dentalCicl * Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Hol lywood Boul d evar Holl ywood,Fl ia 33021 ord p:(54)89 30 9 4- 43 f ( 4)8 801 : 95 94- 5 dchai @ eii l com * et snqeraw. www. si l c ei ngeraw.om Confden i iv and Prvacv Notce:The if maton c a n i t s c muniat n, i l ng i or ton con ai i any i talt i i n or i ont i ed n hi om c i ncudi nf ma i o t ned n at tachment i c i ilma b s j tt te at n cl tpr i g maycon iuei de if mat n, i i endedonl s,s onf a , y e ubec o h torey- i i l e, dent en v e st t nsi nor i and s nt t o y f t e us oft addr s . l i t p opery ofEii ,Br wn,L s Fr el Ch et P.A.Unau hor ed u dicosu e or or h e he es ee t s he r t snger o ewi, ank & ai , t i z se, s l r c yi oft i communi ton orany par t er i s r t pr bi and may b unlwf . I y ha r ved t s communiaton op ng hs ca i t h eof s ti l ohi t cy ed e a ul f ou ve ecei hi c i i er , eas noi usi n ror pî e tf mmedkt ybyrt ne- iorbye- lor ept eii lw. anddesryt sc y ael eur mal mait ec ion@ sngera com, to hi ommunc i iaton and aI c es t eof i cldig aIatach en s. I opi her , n u n I t m t DebtColec i Di osur Pu suan t t Fai Deb Col ct Pr ce Ac , l ton scl e: r t o he r t l i adi s t e on y ar advs t att s L Fim i a deb col ct atem p i t c l ta d t an an i or ton obt n may be us f t t ou e ied h hi aw r s t l or t tng o ol e ec eb , d y nf ma i aied ed or ha pur os Tax Advi e Di osur To ens e compl ce wi r r p e. c scl e: ur i an t equiemen s i h t mpos b t e l underCi ar230, we i or you ed y h RS rcul nf m t tany wr t ad c r atng t Feder t isue con ai i t i co muniaton, i l di i an atac ha ien vie el i o t al ax s s t ned n hs m c i nc u ng n y t hmen s, t was n ot i en norwrten t be u nt ded i o t sed,an c notbe used, byanyper f t p pos of()a digt penalest maybe d an son or he ur e 1 voi n ax t hat i i osedunderte I er lRevenu Codeor( pr i maretngorr ommendigt an herpadyanytans tont)or mp h nt na e 2) omotng, k i ec n o ot r aci s maters addr s byt wrt advc c aied i t sc t t) es ed he ien ie ont n n hi ommuniat n,ncudi i anyatac t c i i l ng n o t hment. P Please consi the envionm ent bef e pri ng t s e- ai. der r or nti hi m l
  23. 23. Wi o Case ot i PitMe s ge nd wsLy H1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 234/ 243 2 : ie mal rn s a 1 of / 011 202 1 2 R E: Tr an Bu duveanu ( i v@ms c ai j orona n.om) Tu 11 2 /112: 3 PM e /9 1 DavdChae ( h et sng lw.om) i it dc ai @eii era c DearM r Chai , . et Thank you f youremai. or l I ver m uch appear t me asyou ar t one qualfed t m ak medi as wel ascour decii i t s t y so e he ii o e cal l t sons n hi Case. As you have c egorcaly r us t pari pat i t dicover pr s and mor t t you have t aly at i l ef ed o tci e n he s y oces e han hat ot l i ed t t r r gnor he hid equestf dicover lsugges t you wai fr f a couo answerand deci on on aI or s y, t hat t ist or si I pendi moti ns. ng o Bes Regar t ds Tr an Budu ean ai j v u Fr Dch e @eii eraw.om om: ait sng l c To:or v@ ms c i ona n.om Subed: j Dat Tue,29 Nov 2011 19: 29 +0000 e: 05: Si, r Asyouar welenought fl motons pr edecaatonsandat e l oi e i , epar lr i temptt ar ahearn ( a s o gue ig 1 s ume y r c tsor srki y notc ofhearng) I ls y Monda f y dep ii ou ead our der ti ng our ie i , wi ee ou l y or our oston. Davi Chai Esquie d et r Ei nger Br si , own,Lewi Fr s, ankel& Chai ,P. et A. Pr dentalCicl . Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Hol wood Boul d l y evar Holl ywood,Fl ia 33021 ord p:( 4)89 30 95 4- 43 f ( 4)8 801 : 95 94- 5 dchai l ei nqeraw . et si l com www. si l , ei ngeraw com Confdentalt and Prvac Notce:The if mai conai i t sc i i iv i v i nor ton t ned n hi ommuniat n,i udi i or ai conai d i any c i ncl ng nf m ton t ne n o atach t i coni talmaybe s j tt t ator -l ntpr i e,maycon ttt isie if maton, i i en onl t mens,s fdeni , ubec o he t neyci i l e v eg siue n d nor i and s nt ded y f t e us oft addr se I i t pr t ofEii ,Br or h e he es e. t s he opery snger own,L s,Fr el Chait P. Unaut orz u diclsur or ewi ank & e , A. h ied se, s o e cop ng oft s comm unca i oran par t eofi s r t pr bt d an may be unlwf .I y hav r eied t s c yi hi i ton y t her s ti l ohiie d cy a ul f ou e ec v hi omm unia i c ton
  24. 24. Wi d wsLy Ho1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 24 of/201122:2 n o Case t i PitMes a ie mal rn s ge 1 1 43 4/ 2 0 i eror plasenotyusi n r,e i mmedi el b r u ne- l bye- lo r epi eii er w.om, d desr t scommu c i f at y y etr maior mait ec ton@ sng l c an toy hi a niaton an a1c i t er ,icl ng a1atachmen s.DebtCol i Di osur Pur uan t t Fai DebtCol ton Pr ces Ac , d I opes h eof n udi I t t l on scl e: s t o he r ect l i ec adi t you ar advied t tt s La Fim i a deb c l t atemptn t col ta debt and any i or i obt ned m a be us f t at e s ha hi w r s t ol or t ig o l ec ec , nf maton ai y ed or h p pos Tax Advi Di osur To ensur c ur e. ce scl e: e ompl e wih r r i anc t equi emen s i t mpos by t e l underCiculr23 we i or y ed h RS r a 0, nf m ou t tan wr t advce r atn t Feder t i ues c ai i t s c ha y i en i el i g o t alax ss ont ned n hi omm unia i i l ng i any atac c ton, ncudi n t hment ,was not s i en norwrt t b us andcann be u b anyperonf te puroseof( av di tx p alist tma b nt ded ien o e ed, t ot sed, y s or h p 1) oi ng a en te ha y e i edundert It nalRe mpos he ner venueCo or( pomoi maretn orr ommen ngt anoterp t an tans tons)or de 2) r tng, k ig ec di o h ary y r aci t mat addr sedbytewrtenadvieconai i t sc teqs) es h it c t ned n hi ommuniai i l ngi anyatac c ton,ncudi n t hment. P Please consi t envi onm ent bef e pr nt ng t s e- ai. der he r or i i hi m l
  25. 25. Wi Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 254/1 43 122: ndowsLi Hot aiPrntMess ye m l i age 1 of 2 2/ 01 01 R E:R E: Davi Chai ( hait snger c d et Dc e@eii l om) awa Tue 11 29 112:6 P / / 2 M Tr anBuduv anu( i av n.om) ai j e oron @ms c It ustIw ils you M onday. r l ee W e have resetdeposii f you t i . ton or w ce Fr :Tr an Buduv nu ( lo: i av ms c om ai j ea mai oron @ n.omj t Sent:Tuesday,Novem ber29,2011 2: PM 14 To:Davi Chai d et Sub ec :RE: j t DearMr Chai , . et Thankyou f yourem ai. or l I ver m uch appear t me asyou ar t one qualfed t mak m edi as wel as cour decii i t s t y so e he ii o e cal l t sons n hi Case, Asyou have cat ial r us t par i pat i t dicover pr egorc l ef ed o tci e n he s y y ocessand m or t t you have t aly e han hat ot l i ed t t r r gnor he hid eques f di t or scover Isuggestt you wai fr tf a c tans and deci on on aI y, hat t is or our wer si 1 pendi motons. ng i Bes Regar t ds Tr an Buduv u ai j ean Fr :Dchai @ ei ngeraw. om et si l com To:oronav@ msn. i com
  26. 26. Wido Case t i P itMe s g i 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 26 of 43 12 01 n wsLyeHo ma l rn s a e 1 1 201 2: 4/ 2/ Subed: j Dat Tue,29 Nov 2011 19: 29 +0000 e: 05: Si, r Asyou a ewelen gh t fl mo i ,pr par de l aton an atemp t ar e a he ig ( a s y r l ou o i tons e e car i s d t t o gu e arn 1 s ume ou radc tsor srkn yourn ieofh ig) Iwi sey Mon f y d ston. e our der tiig otc earn , l e ou day or our epo ii l Davi Chai Esqui e d et r Ei nger Br si , own,L s,Fr ewi ankel& Chai ,P. et A. Pr dentalCicl * Suie 265- esi i r e t 5 4000 Hol wood Boul d l y evar Holl ywood,Fl i 33021 orda p:( )89 30 954 4- 43 f ( 4)894- 5 : 95 801 dchai a ei ngerawa * et si l com www. si l .om ei nqeraw c Confdentalt and Prvacv Notc Th if maton c aied i t s c munia in, i l ng i or a i c t n i any i i iv i i e: e n or i ont n n hi om c to ncudi nf m ton on aied n a t hment i c i talmaybesube t t ator - in prvlge,mayc tt ei i if mai andi it tac s,s onfdeni , jcto he t neycl t ii e e onsi nsde nor ton, s nendedonl ut y f t u oft e addr s . Ii t pr or he se h es ee ts he opedyofEii ,Br snger own,L s,Fr el& Chai ,P. Unauhor edus di l ur or ewi ank et A. t iz e, scos e c yi oft s communi ton oran par t er i s rc l pr bi and may b unlwf . I y ha r ved t s c op ng hi ca i y t h eof s tit ohi t y ed e a ul f ou ve ecei hi ommuniatonc i i eror pl e n i usi edit yb r ur e- lorb e- lor ent eii lw.com,and des r y t s c n r , eas otf mm ael y et n mai y mait ec i y ona snnera to hi omm unca i i ton and aIcopis t e ,i l ng aI a t chment , DebtCol i Di osur Pur tan t t Fai DebtCol ton Pr ces Ac , I e her of ncudi I ta s l on scl e: s l t o he r ect l i ec adi t you ar ad s t t i L Fim i a de col t atem p i t c l ta d , a a i o ma i obt i ed ma be us f t t e vied hat hs aw r s bt l or t tng o ol ec ec ebt nd ny nf r ton a n y ed or ha pur ose. Advi e Di osur To ens e c p Tax c scl e: ur ompl ce wi r r ian t equiemen s i ed b t l underCi ar230, we i f m you h t mpos y he RS rcul n or t tan wrten advce r atn t Feder t i ues c aied i t s c munia i , i l ng i any atac ha y i t i el ig o alax ss ont n n hi om c ton ncudi n t hmens,was not t i t ed norwr t t b us and canno be us , byan peronf te puroseof 1) oi ngtxpenalestat y b n end i en o e ed, t t ed y s or h p ( av di a t h ma e i i ed und t I er alRev mpos erhe nt n enue Codeor( pr tng,maretn orr ommendigt an h p t an tans tonl)or 2) omoi k ig ec n o oter ary y r aci s mat t)addr sedbytewrtenadvieconai i t sc ters es h it c t ned n hi ommuniai icl n i anyat c ton,n udig n tachment . P Please consi the envionm ent bef e prnti thi e- ai. der r or i ng s m l
  27. 27. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 27 of 43 N o Sol ase Uni m iy va dhe t rn ve t Cole ofO so pat eM e e e lge t hi di l 3200 S U ni iy D ri ven t ve (oL audeM alaFl333:8 it e ( ) 4 954262-371 PatentN sm e: i Bu d v a u Tr in j u e n , aa D. B. O. : 12- 54 11- Enc mtr#: ot e 1 31 7 4 M R#: 1626 Ph i i . yscmr HitDO,Gar l y Da e ofSer c t vi e: 6-21-11 Exxm i i naton; LEFT NVGU DVA L U LTR ASO U ND I c ton: ndiai Pin M ul e c s we e ob a ne n e e t i don r vea sa l gem offui c l c i n t i dpl ut r t i d. xzm na e l ar O l d ole to h+ s orgi i nadng &om G e abdom en ext ndi dow m vr d t t s ot . Tle Gndi s y l be e ng o he cr um l ng h u d c i ca l co r a e w ih a iese a ng do lni ly r el t d t t xl nai xmw ar i o a l sde hl na h n t te c s d nt eh i gui l e e ha xt nd rm i o 1 s r t . I a ton t t s t e ar sm al biat alhyœ ocel . Tbe r ghtl tcl nt he c q um n ddii o hi . hc e l lc es i es i e m eas es 3. x 2. . The l t cl m eas w 3.1x2.= .W eel si t omi nce o t ur 4 2œ eA ee e tul 1 r s ll pr ne f he l R e di ri l tm ea u= 1.7 .Not g elei no e . e pi dyrts ha s cm hm s s t I PRESSI : M ON n e e i a l r e qui colm ton t text r s ag d l i ha ends ilo t) s r um a t f di s d be r le c ot nd he m ngg houl t clni l co w l t d w ih as ie &om 1 a o e e e ng t ougbouta l f i i lbe i i Y y t a e t ct s he M m n xt ndi br v t ngu na nnm C lni lconvl Eon t t sobs r ton. Pe àapsa CT s a e i ca a o hi e va i r c n xnmi i oft ew l e e ng nnton .h ds xtndi downwa i ot s rtlamai rcomme d f f t re uat d nt he coa se ùde or urhe val i on . % 1 ! G Uz 1 f ï t h ! l (, - ! k t R> d by:G nron M endez,Jr M . - . D t t . D : 6/ 1 11 2/ i . t g T: 6/ l 1 2 zl GNlj - as T i rp r wJ ee o ial sg e yGm w! eK J.. M D. b s c ot l drn c l in db s y M ee r z YZ -
  28. 28. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 28 of 43 , %x jjz *.v a kj/ . & ( t n m ; : , t . .. .. SO U T H E A ST ER N k * / . - U N 1 N. E R S l T 3: ) , . -* 7 . .è ê ttF ofost opat 1 M ed- ne : ;) , , e h- c 1 ci N SU Davi I er M edi ne e nt nal ci 3200 S U ni siy Drve ver t i D avi FL 33328- e, . 2018 Phone :954) 4100 ( 262- Fax :954) 3285 ( 262- PAT i N T: E Tr an Bu duveanu ai j DATE 0 F Bl RTH : 12/ 1/ 1 1954 DATE: 09/ 2011 10: AM 28/ 30 V I 6F IY P E: S- - O fi V i t fce siShifCot ai / son f vi t tt npl ntRea or si:lhi 51 yearol mal pr s 3 d e esent wih check- . s t upFit 1,of r se Ines s- . f e nt l s o$ - l1. C h(ck- p 3 U56 y/ Romani mal wih a hi of ofHepati C compl i and Di esType 2 pr t a an e t st y is t i ons cat abet esent her as a f l - s e olowtp bi tfum 3 mont ago.He has nothad any hospialadm i ons orER vi t He had a CT scan oft 1 r si hs t ssi sis heabeorl donewhi showed Massi Acii sugges ie ofcir s aswelasspl yen ch ve tes tv rosi l enomegal Hi onl com pl nt . y s y aii a m or lg f i t seem st alevi e t oughoutt dayt has been ongoi f aboutt past5 mottsF! ni atgue hat l o l at hr he hat ng or he nhs e ias no f l everorchil,t e i no nausea,vom ii ordi r l her s s tng, areah.Ther have been no epi e sodes ofshorness of tbr h ordyspnea. eatFO PIRecot I ded by:Gar HilDO y l lui anu, aa DOB:1 1 / 954 Pa l4 l duve Tr in 2/ 1 1 ge: /
  29. 29. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 29 of 43 EXH I T 2 BI
  30. 30. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 86 Entered on FLSD Docket 12/22/2011 Page 30 of 43 DI AGNOSTI RADI OLO9Y CONSULTANTS OG RAPHY C RADI Y- PUTERI TOM OLOG COM ZED 21 AcR AGCREDI MAMOGRAPHY* TEP UVTRASOUND* MRI 0 SOUTH FEDERALHI TE GHWAY *SECONP FLOOR *HOL YWOOD, ORI 3 0 L FL DA 3 20 L( . 1776* ( - 0069 954/927- FM 954)927- Vl mi Gr a,M. ,Boar Cerii Radi ogi adi r nj D. d tfed ol st PatentNam e: i TRAI BUJDUVEANU AN Account#: 170321 Ref rng Physi an DR .GARY R HI eri ci . LL Dat ofBit e rh: 12/ 1954 11/ Dat ofSer ce: e vi 06/ 3/ 1 1 201 CT SCAN O F THE ABD O M EN: TEC HNI UE:CT oft abdom en was peror ed usi 16 det orCT t Q he f m ng ed echnol w ih 5 m m . ogy t spaci aferor contast. ng t al r FI NGS: er i s ie a ct sn td s rou dn t e l er ss ee Th l eri n NDI Tà e sma sv s i oe u r n ij h i an pl n. e i s ot e v v enar d. la pe st s o l ult s ra e, ih l c a il wl da o i o l ge t p ar o h w ob aej u fc whc s omp tbe t ign ss f h cir s. The spl i enl ged. The adr s ar unr r hosi een s ar enal e emar e. The ki kabl dneys dem onst at r e j odc dialhc n s .No r al s s.Noh d on p o i.No kdn yson s Th a t o o c t ik e s en mas e y r e hrss i e t e . e ora I cal sed and no aneuls . No par aori adenopat y. No bowel senton. s ci m a- t c h dit i I PRESSI N: M O M ASSI ASCI VE TES. RELATI VELY SM ALL LO BULATED SURFAC E O F THE LI VER SUGGESTI OF CI VE RRHOSI M I SPLENOM EGAL S. LD Y. > . . # . . VLADI I G RNJ ,M . M R A D. VG/gr 6/ 2011 1: 20 PM 13/ 22:

×