Doc.73

  • 111 views
Uploaded on

 

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads

Views

Total Views
111
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0

Actions

Shares
Downloads
1
Comments
0
Likes
0

Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
    No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 1 of 11 I TH E UNI N TED STATES DI STRI COURT FOR CT E SOI IHERN D I lH P STRI OF R ORD A CT CASE N O . 1 - 20 Cl S : 1 201 - W EnW S> ONTON TRM AN BUD U VEAN U, Pli i antf, FI LED by D. C. VS. lkl : t (t - i:k 7 : 7i1 q! ; 1i d, :- 21 / ,, . : t Dlsm s CH ARI s,I c uANA GISPER T, - N STEVEN M . A RI O rE L M ki Dsl sK n l t om s andAoo s LASH AN DA CLFRK t S Dl T r J S m1 Def nda s. e nt S D. fFL - pl..,L1 o h tqh1 /,r ? . . / G M ORANDUM OF POINTSm AUTHORI ES TI I SIPPOR T OF N J PLAI TI S M O H O N FOR SI M M ARY JUDG M EN T N FF J Pliufs Trin Budu e Pr Se heena r Mo n hee y s b tt s an , aa j v mm, o , ri Re va t rb u mi hi M e or nd Of Poi t a Au ho i s l Su r o hi M oton f r S m a um n s nd t rde n ppo t f s i o umm a y r Judm ent As s . hown bel , a as s red i t accom panyi St em e of ow nd upm t n he ng at nt Fa t ,S a e ntOfM a e i lFa t M To W hih n e e I N o Ge ui e Dip e sa c s t t me t ra c s c r s n n s ut s nd Evi nce,no genui is ofmat ralf exit i t s ac de ne s ue e i act ss n hi ion.M ovo ti enuted t s l o j > e i hi fv a amatrof1w o alCo qoft Ame dCo ant ud nt n s a or s te a n l unt he nde mpli . Ac odi l s c r ngy,mmmayj > e s ul l e ee frM o nt r ud nt ho d x ntrd o va . L PO A ODUCD ON M ovant was s e entnced t s r 35 m ont i f a prs and ttee yea s of o e ve h n eder l ion, lr r sz r i e r lxq , on J me 20, 2 9. f r Co pH c t vi l t t I t r io l nm vs d ee e t * o ns y o o a e he n e na na Em e ge Econox c Pow erAct n e 1 1 Tg ndon Regul r ncy ni - % nnu adon and t Armn he Ex r Co l Ac 1 U. C. 371 M e M o n h d s r e 2 m o t a t e po t nko t 8 S. . r va t a e v d 4 n h t h Co r c i na Ce e ,due t hi m e c l c ne o ,he wa t nK e r d t Dim % r e to l nt r o s a o ns s m fre o s Ch rue ,n , œ a e i Da a Fl rda aha f y ho e i whi h f d r li m a e c n a i sl c. l t d n ni , o i s lwa us n c e e a n t s a s nd t ls sx m on hs of t i s n e e He a rve a D imnq O s i e on pe he a t i t he r e t nc . ri d t K . rt s i 07/ / 28 2010.n es halwa hous ar desi ed t e e t tansNon f e at e f y es e > o mq àe r i or es 9om prs t sœ i y.A prs ion o et ioner m us be ms r ed Com m uniy Cusody by t t si t t he Fe r lBln Ofprs ns G f r hec l a t e prs n t t ba Y a ho e de a l uu io , o e = e ve h i o o he l y us . Folo i a s re ofvi i us a il ga a t a a e ,c m mit d b De e l w ng e i s c o nd le l c s nd bus s o te y f ne t , s Mov ntwa sntba kt Fe l Prsn,FDC Mimifcly,fr75(e nt ) a s e c o deal io s a ii o t sve psve d ys wiho pemiso oft pr ra l iis a wi utd p oc s,i atme a , t ut r s in he ope utmrte , nd lo ue r e s n i whe M o nt wa vey sc a wiho a y c nsde n f r Ms me c l n va s r ik nd t ut n o i ndo o dia condii Def tons. endant cons r t and caus t M ovantf s i prsonmentby s pied o, ed he ale m i usng t c lph i i n a a me n t c us te M o n ic c mto whe i he el one ncde t s a o a e h va ts n are in, n t e % e i f c i wi no l ga . h y w n a tt s te l 1
  • 2. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 2 of 11 Dee a sha ee ga d i De mva n o pr pe t i vilio o t Fo t fnd nt v n ge n p Eo f o ry,n oa n f he nrh A1 dxe:s M alcousPr s c in i viluon o t Fo te t Ame me t = 1.1 , ii t o e uto n oa f he ure nh nd n a Fa rc tng ofe de e a Fa l et k e 9o h r , c Dpr s n a t b0 1 b ia i vi nc , nd iur o e p m a m whih e e t c s t1 wihi a be d t e lm isoft i l wf a t odt o oo c a sa us t n nd yon h i t àer a ul u h y r il tt . Def n nt h ve c mitd a e ofN we i vi l ton of42 U. C.1 ,whi h e da s a om te bus s r n oa i S. 983 c i uded unl wfulact ,i a om ci ca t undert R orofl and cons r ncl a sn n al paciy, he col aw pied t an wilul de rve t M o a ofMsrgh spr tce by t Cons u n or o, d lf ly p i d he v nt i t oe td he dtio U . l i atme whe t M ovantwasi ttzi iw l i vi auon ofFolrhz S. aw, n i n he ns iltonnlg ; n ol tt Fi Ei ta Fo te hAme me t t Co tttonofUnie Stt . % l nd urent nd nto he nsiui t aes Defnd nt we ecai i t a ho iy#ve t t m b t Fe mlBur a of e a s r l m ng be ut rt n o he y he de eu Prs ion. Def ndant knowi y and w iluly us af sewrtng ordocum ent u owi t e s ngl lf l ed al ii a ng he u m et cont n am at i l f s fc i o ai eraly ale, i tiousorH udul st e entore r i ent atm nty, n vi a of18U . C.1 1 oluon S. * Defene t COIS H t com m i t aboveoFens agsi tt Unied Stt i or s IPù o t he e nK he t a es n der t d udteUnie Stts a a tn t e t obe oft c ns me i o eH h td ae , nd cig o Fxthe jct he o pi y,n vi aton of 1 U . C . ol i 8 S. 371 De e da swilu l mi r p e e e t Unie S a e o Am e i awiho po ro f n nt lf ly p e r s nt d he t d t t s f rc t ut we f atom ey,i vi aéon 28 U . C.371 t n ol S. V i l uonso t e f er lc i i lsa ut a 1 U . C. a 1 U . C.O Ia e oa f h e s rm na t t es t 8 S. 371 nd 8 S. I r f l es. e oni Dim s.Chartesl i aprvat notf pr cor atonyoper tng 27 haN a s q ii ,nc. s i e or oft por i ai y hous i 18 sat D im xqCha ii hous haslm ied i es n t es. s rtes e i t ndepe ndentdici i y s plnal dicr tow a coul i s e i nd d mpos s i on r denl onl f t m os m i of e anctons esi y or he t nor pr bied act.Any se i s i r m d appr ofCCM ,U SPO and ohi t s rous anctons equi oval Co m u t Sa to r p s nt éve . m niy nc i ns e m e a s Unde iss rnge ntw1 1 be g ve n e t r t r a me t t o rm n 1 tz Dim a Gartesf lt asahal way hous coul notdet n a r dent le s h ii aciiy. f e, d ai esi . Re i n qa e f e t la , o d t % sgn d a s r - uts e . e f c lt c ul sde t r xx o e ve pr vi e h i e i o he t n a iiy o d notbe l ocked downi ordert pm ventm sde qf om l n o i nt r eadng,I sum ,r i nt n esde q c ul l vet fciiya a ytme, ujc o yt t c oue c st tc ul be o d ea he a l t n i sb et nl o he ons n e u o d t i mpos d b t c r sorby t Bl- u ofPrs ns I M o nt e y he ou t àe x i o . f va woul ha l R t d ve e he f lt Di masCharuescoul onl r tt i dentt t CCM and U SPO . aciiy, s i d y epor he nci o he An at orney represenhngt i ur t he ns ance com pany oft def he endant have s ppe r l t i t pi t e asi w msnouc d by t s Cour , o hsa t a a ed a e n he c ur , t e hi t m nt Aer he c ew a il w 11 t Unied So t sCo hous . i ntt oft i ur e as s ed t1 he t e urt e The de iy he ns anc c m pa w a ne rr ve e i f 1 nort r a i ntbe ofe h Def nfs o ny s ve e al d n u1, he e l de i s ac enda lr tna e m i e nam e and l tna e.W he que tone a r qui ed t i s m , ddl , as m n s i d nd e r o r vea t s i i s t r o ons s o t At o ne f t Def nda sw e e e l ho e dentue , he e e f he t r y or he e nt r vague and m i l ng. seadi
  • 3. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 3 of 11 H .STATEG NT O F M ATERI FACTS AL I 20 whie i i o d a FD C M i m i M ov twa di r os d wih He its C n 08, l mprs ne t a , = s a e t pa i I ecions Li Cir i , Di be e , n r nf , ver rhoss a t s omboc o ni As ie , Hypeeennon, yt pe w cts i HyN lpi w Chr c Fa i , a ohe c i demi oni tgue nd t r omplc éonsa s itsw11 He a ii C ia socae t1 p tts I ecton.M ovant condi lm ied hi a lt t engage i phys calactviy, a dnf i s don i t s biiy o n i i t nd ue t t a f c whie i pr s n M o n wm ne rr quie t pe r a wo ki o h t a : l n i o a va t s ve e r d o db m ny r ng dute .Atpr s n tme t is e e t i h= ae 3 pa s o me c ldoc ns is e b tl r * ge f dia ume t s u d y le Fed r l r a Ofp o M e ialS a a mor t 1 0pa so me ia r c r e a Bu e u hs ns dc t ë nd e h= 0 ge f dc l e o ds i s d by M e o i lHos t l Br d Gene l Hos t ,Nova Uni st M edi s ue m ra pia , owar m pial ver iy cal Cent and physi a .Def er ci endant ar fuly awar oft e r dsand have accesst s e l e hes ecor o a1 m edi r ds. 1 cal ecor W hie at Dim n Hous M ovantw as t d t pe f m cl sni s ces by Dc ek l s . q e, ol o r or e ng ervi , n om as,when he kne M sm edi condii ,i or rt l ii e and i lctpaù: w cal tons n de o mm lat nfi s i and m e aldites on t M ovant W he Pl ne r us t pe or t uFerng nt s r s he . n ai ef ed o rf m he ms r ed wor exphi ng t advanced m e ca condii , he w as r oved fom si k, ni be l tons em r Dim n. Hous by t US M ar halagent , and ta port t FDC M i wher he s q e wo s s r ns ed o ami e , wasi cer t f t ee m ont v wihoutany char orhea i . n i when Dim as Ch ncar aed or hr h t ges rngs s R artes had acce t mor t 3* pages of M ovants m edi r ds âom t ii ss o e hsn cal ecor he Fede alBur OfPrsons a d ne e a ty t e W o ki g Re ti io oft e Pl n i r eau i , n w x cl h r n s rc ns h ai tE A c p ofM o nts me c lr c r wms l c t d i t M ov nts Pe s na Re or oy va di a e o ds o a e n he a r o l c ds Fie,atDi masChartes. l s ii W hie a Dim a Ho e a ltro Home Conlne nt Def l t s s us , nd ae n me endanl de ed t ni he m ov t a t r lgi s r ie att Orho x Chur h, l ed w ihi 16 ant o tend ei ous e vc s he t do c ocat t n m i esf om Di asHous , i nut r sm e nvoki t reason ofFeder Gui i . ng he al delnes Such G ui lne do no e s F l l Gove nm ent r m ai ne a i r ga ds t a 1 de i s t xit ede a r e ns ue l n e r o l aspe> ofr i on pr ces ordi ancest orf a halw ay house. elgi aY st o rom f W hie atD im s. hous and aAer whe i Hom e Conlnm e ,whih was out i of l s q e , n n nt c sde dicridsito oftr haf y hous,Dee nst trl h lae sn e o t j dcin he lwa he u e fnds t orue umiit, igl ut M s m i e agai ace. et c orgi col a m ce. a e a l a s d t e nst nst hni i m or nd bus , nd mr . e h q o n wiho a y c nsde a n f hi m e i a c ndii ns va t t ut n o i r :o or s d c l o to . M ert M ovantwas s il l t FDC M i , a F oup off D im asChlrtes he ent legaly o ami our s ii e o es v st d t M o n i Prs a d pr s n e hi w11 a one pa hom e mpl ye i ie he va t n ion n e e t d m t1 ge m nde f m abes ng t na e ofUS Fe alPrs cha ge ofGr at tVi a i , Code 108 or ri he m der i on r e es ol ton , sr e by Der k n om ms, t j b y t i e li ion nt n i wa f t i d e o us he l ga mprs me . s s or he f l > m e vi aion appled t ce i t pas on di ol i wi n he t fe= t f m s, wi out due pr s or i oces w hi r ule i s l ch es t d n ancéonsappled per onaly by Der n om % , atDi mmsCharies, i s l ek s i , nc. W hie i cer ed a FDC M i i M o n di noth ve a y c r s l vi d a i K l ncar at t am , va t d a n ha ge e e gâ n t hi by any DH O,BOP, o a o he l g a h iy,a hi c t d r m a n d a m r ny t r e al ut ort nd s us o y e i e s Com muniy Cusody,untlbi r eas on 01/ 2011. M ovantwasnoti t f m l t t i s el e 03/ n he ede
  • 4. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 4 of 11r prson f any cri es t he comm it He was i t f der prs ( e t il i or m hat ted- n he e al ion hz o legal act agsi thi com m it by t def s nq m ted he endant s. M e pl ye s of FDC M i m i t t c me i c t c w1 t s cas i udi m o e a 9 ha a n on a t d1 hi e, ncl ng Co ms l rM c ,W a de a d a 1DHO Om c r ,sa d a y 9om Di m as Cl ées t eo e r n n 1 e s t ye wa s mri ast f l t i cer hey et he ncar auon washi y il .Cot orPrce atempt t c ac , ghl legal msel i t ed o ont t on s al oc i ever cu ons, by t ephone, e ai a t ef x, CcM Diect Caros el m l nd el a r or l Ro i e ,wh woul be r s nsbl f rr t m i g a p io rt f de a p i o t n drgu z o d e N i e o eu n r s ne o e r l r s n. o o a l USPO s aed t t y f m d out a vai. t t hat he ot boutt M ovant i ce afon i J he ncar r n anuar y 201 wh n t y ha e r c i e a c py o n e M o i n Fo t Re l n Ofp o ry,s n 1 e he v e e v d o f to r he tl r r pe t e t t t m by t e M ov nt Eve t da BOP doe n r co i e a y c r e lvi d o he h a . n o y, s ot e gn z n ha g s e e ag i tTrinBudu mm, a onewhiea Dima Ch rée ,nc,o a rhewa ans aa j ve by ny l t s . ai s I . r Re q s r oved 9om Dim msCharii and i ce at atM i iFDC wihoutany r ds em s tes, ncar r ed am t egar f hi m edi condii and untlt end ofhi s e or s cal tons, i he s entnce. Att t m et i i ntt ok pl c , e e rng t t t l he i he nc de o a e r f r i o he e ephone f ound i t gl ve n he o com pmo entoft vehi e,t Pl ntf w asi Hom eConhnem ent out de of he cl he ai i n si t j ididon of hehalwa hous andhewaspr s nta Dima Cha i sf he urs c t f y e, e e t s s rde or hi wee y r pol Co to And Te mROfHo eCo e e tdo no c t i o s kl e t ndii ns r m nln m n t on s n r s f t ephonesi t gl compsM entoft drven vehi e.l f tl t m s peciy el n he ove he i cl n act le er and condii do notm enéon anyt ng a% utce l art e tons bi lul elphones orany ki of , nd phone,bei us asaweapon ore se ofaphonei t gl com ps entofa ng ed xit nce n he ove M vehi epar out i cl ked sde. The deci on t send t Pl nti bac t t f si o he ai F k o he ederalpri w as not m ade by son USPO,CCM a or Communiy S nY o Ce e .l f c USPO ha sat d t t nd/ t a n nt r n a t s t e ha Def nd= t f l t advie U SPO w ibi 48 houm,of t M ova i ce atony as e s aied o s tn he nt ncar r i r r by Fede al Blrx l of M s r aion. USPO f md out a equied r le ons egul ot bout t he i a c r to i J nua y 2 1 whe t y r c i d a c y o t M oio For n e nc r e a i n n a r 01 , n he e e ve op f he n Re ur OfPr t 9om t M ova . t n opery, he nt Today t ear no e s r port i her e xidng e s, nvesugatonsorc gesby t US Fedel i har he la Bur a Ofprs ns U S M x l U S Co muniy S nc i nsCe t ro a y o he eu io , mha h PO, m t a to ne r n t r l gale iy,a none oft e agenci ur whatt geti ved orhearanyt ng e ntt nd hes eo eaus o nvol hi aboutDim nqfTsrdesort Def s i h be endmm ,a1 dx um e spoi i t t f that 1 nt ntng o he ac Def endant act al n os ac sand om isi r pr entver r aveil act s ed one. e t s ons e es y legal s whi ar a nn t Consiuéon Ofhe Unie St esofAm erca.W hatt ch e gni t he tt I t at i he Def nda shave on ha ar onl t rwor butnota suppor ofBOP,USPO , e nt nda e y hei ds ny t US M ar hal,orany l a hortes. s l egal ut ii 1 .CT, R W ON W H I Jl GC N IS SO UGH T H ATM CH m f A .pl no h entted t Sum m ary Judgm ent@n Cl m 1:Ri t be f e f al il o ai ght o re rom unl uls H reofpropert or pers awf e y on. 1 Bur e ofpr ofa e e e s . dn o nd l m nt : 4
  • 5. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 5 of 11 n e Pl nt scl m ofVi akon ofhi Fourh Am endm entrght t t Consut i ai x si ol s t i s o he uton ofUnie S a e ,a hi Fi Am e dm e t t Co ut ton ofUnie St t s t d t t s nd s % n nt o he ns u i td a e . An il g ls a c wa c ndu t d o t e v hi l t tM o n dr vea p ope t w m le a e r h s o c e f h e c e ha va t o nd r ry s r oved 9om t vehi ew ihoutt u owl em he cl t he edge oft M ovanta w ihoutt he nd t he M ovantbei pr ntatt se ch.Dat and e dence &om t s eil e ng ese he ar a vi he uw lance -mer as wm de i r t l d s e by t De e a s s lbe a ey e koy d he f nd nt . n eFonrb Am endm e t t U . Constt i pr e spe e 9om - t eas t nt o he S. iuton ot ct opl mr onabl e s a c sa s i r sb r quh ng t tt go m m e tGr ts c ea w s n ba ed o e r he nd enle y e i ha he ve n s e ur - t s n probabl caus e e. Havi a celul t ephone i t ca does notrv ese a vi aton f prs son ng l ar el n he r, nt ol i or ioner hom e cone em e as Hal way Hous Rul and Regul nt f e es auons a e not t O m e as r he Hom e Conlnem ent Rul a Regul i . n e i de w as a m oive f t es nd atons nci nt or he de e a s t c e t a ho tl e r m e m e t a uib pa n, ml lng, a f nd nt o r a e s ie nvion nt n al ng s m i eei nd hn qs ent A s ch woul notbe vald wi outa s c warsntf e pl i a m m . ear d i l ear h r or xam e, f cel phone was f l ound i t car and t owne oft carwasnotpmsent How evc n he , he r he none of t a he bove apples her due t t f t t M ovant w as on hom e i e o he act hat he conlne enta t tm eand nota r i ntofDim a.halway hous m t he i esde s q f e. I i w e l e t b i h d t t a pe s n whos pr pe t i be ng f r e t d i e éte t t s l sa ls e ha ro e o ry s i o f ie s n l d o notce,r onabl calll ed unde a1 t cicumKtnces t apprs i er t psrtes i exq y czat r l he r a ,o ie nt esed i ont pe e ofalg la uona a o rn t t pesntt i o jc he nd nc y e a c nd n ppo tniy o r e her be ion. Go -lsGon ne ,25 3 a 3 (ii M ulnev.Ce .Hu o rBs & Tnzt nz e - m ls 7F. d. t 5 ctng a q nt ve nk s Co. 3 U. 3 31 7 Ct65 9 , FZ 8 5 ( 9 ) Se as Mah ws v. , 39 S. 06, 4, 0S. . 2, 41. 6 1 50. e lo te El i , 4 U. 31 3 ,965.Ct 89 47 Ed. 1 ( 9 (l e u c o d drge 42 S. 9, 48 . 3, L. 2d. 8 1 76) xe s e f ue po e si terq ie n ta ag ro i jo ad o sro sls b gv nn t eo r c s s h e urme t h t es n n e p ry f eiu o s e ie oi f c tec s a ai thi a op rl t t me ti.) h ae g ns m nd po t y o e t ml venK dec son pr des dsm s f yi atons of Fede al Cons i ton Fourt Bi ii ovi ges or ol i r tm i s h Ame me .2m ,U. )1 9LEd 2d. 8,1 SCt2 9. nd nt(( S. 5 - 71 24 . 73 . Four cicuis have hel t t a prvat pa y f alact m ay be la e i a Bi r t d ha i e rt eder or ibl n ven acton.Re r v.U nied St es,242 U . App.D. 370,750,F,2d.1039, i ube t at S. C. 1053-57 ( C.Ci. 1 4) Do ns v.E- se ,1c. 7 F. 2 11 9 ( h Ci. 1 2) D. r 98 ; by sy tms , 66 d 21 5t r 98 Yimou n sv.Che ca Abs c 5- .9 F.2d 1 92 ( t Ci. 1 75 , c r. a ys ni mi l % t ,521 3 6h r 9 ) e t de e v439U. 983 5 1. 2 65 99 Ct 5 3(97 nid S. , 8 ,Ed. d 4, 5. . 7 1 8) s ch i l galy deG ed msan i i ofan i vi l tmat expecauon of ear s e l A nvœs on ndi duals egii e t prvac See Kat v.Unied St es 389 U . 347, 9L Ed-2d 576,88 S,Ct 507 i y. z t at , S. 1 . (96 .Thi rq rsta a i vamlh veas betv e pe tto ofprvay a 1 7) s e uie h t n ndii a uj cie x cain i c nd t tte e cain b obetvey rao bl o ,memi o t ts i i ha h xpetto e jci l e sna e ne a ng ne ha ocdy s pr pnr. t ac e ed o ceptasrAqonabl e e. n> ofpr Sei opert œ cur when a gover m e om ci m emi uly,i erer wih y s n nt al l ngf l nt f es t a per on pos s y i er ti t tpr t SeeUnied St esv.Jac en,466 U . s s ses or nt es n ha opery. t at obs S. 1 8 Ed. d85 1 S. .1 52(98 .npli Engls ii as ineo prpet 09, L. 2 , M Ct 6 1 4)I an ih,ts ez r f o ry when t polce t t bag,i m d t c ,orvouchert pur e. he i ake he mpot he ar he s
  • 6. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 6 of 11 B.Pli i se ldt Summar l antFi ndte o y udgme t enm 2: eares a ntm ll Fe r t nd i pri@nm ent m s 1.Bur ofpr and tl e den oof em n? n e Pl ntY scl m ofV i aéon ofM sFi ,Si h,Ei and Fourt h ai i m ol M xt ght eent Am endmentt t Cons iuton ofUnied St t . o he tt i t a es Defendant havecons r t ca ed t ares oft M ovant by US M a hal,f a a pied o us he r t he a rs l or mi vi a w t a e n i tu , sno r q r = s a d ic me n. Wnga nor oldo h t ve f r e dœ t e uie t n n a mdo Ha celul t e l ar elphonedoesnotr se avi aion f prs o on Home Conf em e . epre nt ol or ione m nt n ei i ntwa a mouve f t d f n n st c e t a h tl e io e t m e a nc de s or he e e da t o r a e os ie nv r nm n nt l anguih,pai K s w nlehng,and hm qsment. Fal e a est a f i ton of e dence: n e Fonrt Am endm ent of t U . s rr nd abrcai vi h he S. Cons i i guqant t rght agnnR A e onabl s ches or s z es A 1 tmton x ees he i i t mrxq e ear ei ur . aw e o c m e oo c a usng a ho iy pr vi d u rtl co o of1 w i a l d t so nf r e nt i l i ut rt o de nde le l r a s lowe o t p idi d l aA u rc ran cr mRa c s t s a c t a dr t n t i pr pe t n viuas I nde e ti ioz tn e ,o e r h h* n eni her o ry. l i i t a e oft dicr t s n he bus hat s eéonar power y --such asan ull uldet i oril lawf enton legal c nssainofpo ry ta avi ainofapes scvirl t ma ocur o c to rm t- h t olto ron i l i s y c . Fa rc tng e i n e a i torf le y are tng a i i d la s W ol t s t e c o b i a i v de c gans a s l r s i n nd vi ua lo a e h ol r of 1w s a ut t ng aw a t per on rght of due pr s and ung onabl a t t e, nki y he s s i s oces eas e s z r .I t e c s of de rva i n of p ope t t e c o of 1 w s a t wou d be ei n e n h a e p i to r ry, h ol r a t m e l vi at by t lw f l obt ni or mai ni ng a pe on pr t w hi over t ol ed m a uly si ng nt ni rs s opery, ch seps orm iapplest om ci aut iy. s i he als hort The Fouree h Am e e s es t rghtt due pr t nt ndm nt ecur he i o ocess t Ei h A mendm e ; he ght nt pr bist useofcm eland unus pm ihm ent nlrng a a r tordet ohi t he ual K . li n r es endon,t hese rght can be vi at by t tse of f ce a ol tng t punihment n e per on i s ol ed he l or m m i o s . s accus ofa crm e mus be alow e t opport t t have a t1 and smul notbe ed i t l d he uniy o ra1 l d sbe td t pu si ntwih ha i 1 1 a r d t op t t o t lg l u jce o nilme tout vng xe1 Fode he port y f he e a mi PI CCSS -O . C. a no i e ildt s m j gm e on Cll 3:Rl t t duepr e s Pli s ntte o umm ud nt am gh s o oc s . 1 Bur e o p oo = d ee e t . dn f r f lm n s n e Pl i i sc m o Vi a n o h sFO ,Ei hta Fo t e Am e a ntm hi f ol do f i g nd ure n ndme r g t nt i h s t he Cons ton ofUnie St es. o ém i t d at Pl ne wmsgi n t vi atons on di entdat ,f t O m e lci ntt has ai ve h- ol i , Fer es or âe de hat oc ure i t O me da tm ea pl c , t utdu pr e sofl w a d he wa s n c r d n he y, i nd a e wiho e oc s a n s et t f alprs by Def nt wihoutDue Pr sofLa . o eder ion enda s, t oces w eCCC Co r t ,ferrwl ro omeCoAne n,.lldevlpas tmf n ntacor A t Wc fh n me t çJ/ eo yse or / handlng vi adonso/ o = m l , c meeste z o e.ci rao Fof i ol . /r gr eçwhih t h T epr c - rt i f / #l ç ç e v Mc al an icu sprviins ord aln wi mi rï#lcfa.o o a . Don d d n lde o so f e ig t no a /o çfprgr m h 6
  • 7. >@ , Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 7 of 11 nde f prs nesi HomeCon e af( pto zfc) ( deal ra Of s or io r n /a -e .De ./yl fe, Fe r Bue u x PrsnsPr io opam Sttme Nu r 7 01 ae nt mbe: 320. ) Prort t Unie St t sSup e eCo t de ii n i G o e e g v. l 39 U . 25 9 S. i o he t d a e rm ur c so n l r Kel s y. 7 S. 4, 0 Ct 1 1( 9 ) t r weenoc nsiuina s f . 01 1 70, hee r o ttto l ae prtc g piones&o abimy oee rs r m r t and ca i ouspuaibm e . prci s nt l Kel t S r me Cour e tnd d t Due Pr es ca e o t Unt d S ae n l he up e y. t xe e he oc s lus f he ie t ts Co tm to hol i t t be o e a we f r cpi ntc d b de i d o a g a a c rs n nsi i w d ng ha f r lre e i e oul e prve f r nt e t i prc d a sfgu rs wee dz hm o he. n e i l e:noie of t c res, o e url ae ad r le i r r y ncud tc he hag t) c O on a i o c os - xa na i o a e s w i e s s a d t rgh t r p e e a i b o t ton r r s e mi ton f dv r e m s e n âe i t o e r s nt ton y c t s lb f r a i pa t he rng o ce . om e e o e n m ri n i m r al n e epr e u a s f g r we e t 0 e pr s l e t nde t i l prs ne f c ng s oc d r l a e ua ds r h x e sy x e d o ncude io m a i di cplna y pr c e n by t e U . S e e Co r de ii n i W ol v. si i r o e di gs h S. upr m uts c so n F Mc nnel428U. 5 9 S.Ct296 (97 .Prs nc i Ne Jre weeas Do l. S. 39, 4 . 3 1 4) io n w esy r lo accor e ensve rgbt by t New Je se Supr e Courts r i i Avant v. ded xt i i s he r y em ulng n Cllbrx6 N..496( 97 . n e sa r a pr e r t taeo l d hee il d 7 J 1 5) tndads nd ocdues ha r uthe r sem diecty âom t et dec sons. t r l hes wo i i n e rght and pr d= lprot i .s oce ecéonsofprs sf ci dici i pr ui wer i oner a ng s plnmy oceelngs e r ce l e m r e a d r i o e y t e N .. pr me Co t n t de ii , c na d e nty a m d n e nf m db h J Su e r ur i wo c sons M Do l v. n hn ( 2-4 , N.. ( 9 )a Jc bsv.Se he ,A--4)- N.. (99 . Pic k,A- 9 ) - J 1 95 nd a o tp ns ( 19 , J 1 5) I Mc n l teCo rcai da dmo i ds meo teDOCdsil ayh s g n Do ai h u t lrW n dse o fh s icpi r evn n pr i o fl he ens e t tDOC pr l i em ent bot t sandar a actces trt r ur ha t opery mpl s h he t ds nnounced i n Avantand t X C own r a i . he s egul tons ih r pectt t r e ofBi t es W o he ul vensv.Si U nkmown N a e Age off dn lBm e x m d nl e au ofNac s ( 971 403 US 388,2 Ed 2 61 91 Et 1 - h alwe a r oic 1 ) 9L D 9, 5 999 wMc lo d n i i d c us o a to f r d m n s a i ti v du l f d r l o c a s f c ra n mple a e f c i n o l ge glnq ndi i a e e a m i l or e t i viltonsoffdea c ns uto lrg st Unie SttsSu e Co tha () oai e rl o ét ina iht-he td ae prme ur s 1 he l a r c gn z d ge e a l t ta l ge vi l ions of t d pr e s clus of e s nd e o i e n r ly ha le d o a he ue oc s a e Feder Cons uton Fi Am endmentm ay gi rse t an i ple ca ofacion al dt i s M ve i o m i d use f d m s s . or n ge .. n Da sv.Pm s n ( 9 )44 US 2 60 Ed 2 8 995 Ct2 4, Sup e vi I sma 1 79 2 28, L d 46, 26 t he r me Co tn e t tBie de ii n a d h l t t( )a ca e o a to a a da ge ur otd ha v ns cso n ed ha 1 lus f cin nd ma r m e c ul be i i d r c l t e t f de al ns iu i whe t d pr c s e dy o d mpled ie ty md r he e r Co tt ton n he ue o e s cl e oft Consiuton Fi Am e entw asvi at . aus he tt i s % ndm ol ed-. n e Unie Stts Sup e Cou thœ h l t tfde a o cas who ha alg dl td ae r me r s ed ha e rl m il s le e y vi a e rgh st de t Fe r lConsi to s Ei Ame ol t d i t m r he de a tm i n ght ndme we e a l a tun r nt r , t e s de t crlmKa e ofapatc a c ,sb ett d mn e u e tl nzeo Bie v. he icl tncs riulr ue ujc o n g s nd r le l f v ns Si Unk wnNa dAg nt ofFe ea Bura ofNac uc (971 403US38 29 x no me e s d rl eu ro s 1 ) 8, L Ed 24 61 91 S Ct 1 99,whi h a l d a i ple c us o a ton f r ds a e 9, 9 c lowe n m i d a e f c i o m g s agai t i vi l f al om ci s f cerai vi a i of f r cons itdonal ns ndi dlsl eder al or t n ol tons ede al ttz 6XY e nsJ.on dbySoue, e ran Gi bugJ.disne g, x esdt ve .jie St trBrye, d ns r J, se e prse he 7
  • 8. - , Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 8 of 11 ve tmta Bi nsds ge r me y ou tt ha ebe n a ia e t tl imse,a a iw l ve ma s e d gh o v e valbl o le n t s c si ina vi ain wa alge t ha ebe n c mmi e byafde a a n t ti, on tmto l olto s le d o v e o t d t e r l ge t ha s aprv t c po a i e o d b t BOP t pe f r f nc nst twoul ot m ie i a e or r ton mpl ye y he o ro m u io ha d he s ha e be n pe f r e by i di i nn e pl ye soft Fe e lGo m m e t v e ro m d n v d l m o e he d m ve n a s e t r c ul be aBi e c s a s nc t s um he e o d 1 v ns a e g i t he ma g m e toft ho ei a na e n he us f c dt éo lvi l to o c r dv v n t s ausofDi msqHous a a e r l e t ons u na o a i n c u e gi e he t t s . e s de a ag n f byr uon o isc nta twib t Bm e u ofPrs . eM c nv. re tons e s f t o r c t :e a ions Se cha Co r ci Cor ofAmeiw 1 7U. DitLEM S260 ( Kha 1 ) p. rc 99 S. s. 6 D. n. 997. D. antli e il *,Summar udg ntoncnm 4:M al o pr scutom Pli l s ntte t yj me ll kius o e i 1. de ofpr and elm ent Bur n oof e s n ePli i sca m o Vil nofMsFo t Fi , xt Ei ta d Fo te t antm li f oauo urb, M 5i h, gh n ure nh Am e dm e tt t e Co émto o u t d S a e . n n o h ns i n f nie t t s De e da l h ve e a d i Co or o I Abus s M i c ndu ta d D e i éo of f n n a ng ge n l f Aw e, s o c n prva n l i h sU n r t Co o oft St mt ,W iluly Fa l d t Ke p an I v dua f o t g t de he l r aw a e lf l ie o e ndi i l r m Har whi i ude a sca red outby Def ma ch ncl ct r i endu t oper i b0t wibi and be s atng h t n yond t lm isoft rl he i t hei awfula hort t bei i vi a oft col of1 s amt ut iy, hus ng n olion he or aw t e. I a f dem lcnm e f anyone aci under Rcol of l wiluly t deprve or ts e or tng or aw lf l o i cons r t de i a pe son of a rght pr ect by t Consiuton or U . l . pie o prve r i ot ed he tt i S. aw X olroflwsmpl me nst ttl pesni usnga tort Sv nt bi orhe by o a i y a ba le ro s i uh iy e o m r a l al sat orf algover enta oc , t e, edel nm gency. l t e Unie S a e lw , s at adori ape s who i a tng on be l ofa nb td tt s a a t e s r on s ci ha f go r me al d a dteeoesbe tt rguainun rt Unie SttsBilof ven nt bo y, n h rfr u jc o e lto de he td ae l Ri t , n udi g t e Fis , % a Fou te h Am e dm e s whi h pr hi tt e gh s I cl n h r tFi nd re nt n nt , c o bi h f d a a sa e g e me sf o v ol e g c rni rg sa f e o s e ml nd t t ov m nt r m i a e f n i ht nd r ed m . E.Pl i i e il dt Summ a yj ano s ntte o r udgme ( cll 5 Ri htt bef e f om nt m am : g o r e r c- e and unusualpullhm ent l s v 1.Bur ofpr a eem ent den oof nd l s n ePlitc scam ofr pe t dvilio byt De e nt ofli Vi a ofli an i li e at o a n he fndn s ts olion ls 51 t a Ei htAm e h nd g ndme , o t Co tti on ofUnie St t s c u la d t us l nt t he ns it t d a e , r e n m ua punihm e . s nt W hie a Dimm Ho e a d ltr o h l t s s us , n ae n ome c nfne n M ov ntwa c nsa l o me t a s o tnty t r o i e i tm i t d a h ii t d w i e r rz da n i da e nd um la e louta y r g x Kf rhi m e i a c nd io . n e x o s d c l o i ns d Hewa fre t doce nngjbswhe i fc hewasno alwe b hi d tr.n s oc d o ls i o n n at t lo d y s ocos I t end,asa lnalpt s ent t M ovantwas s bac t f der prson f am i he mihm , he ent k o e al i or nor i i e wiho due pr c s ,f c r e ,tmte n i % e d no r q r a r s a nc d nt t ut o e s or ha g s l ve f , o t e uie r e t nd i ar aton. nc cer i 8
  • 9. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 9 of 11e1 M o nts m e i a c ndi ns a c e a m o t a 1 lf a uvii s ha ng t d wih va d c l o éo le t d l s 1 ie c te vi o o t d t ,i ldig t mao l e a t ée ofwalig sti a san ng. Hi moi ncu n he jr i ci s on f vi kn , itng, nd t di s oc o sr c m m e d r src i s o fe ue G i tn a d be n , tr e o nde e ti ton n r q nt si g n ndi g pefr ng a w or actvi s. Thus ro mi ny k i he lRigo jcs or i n be t, , Dim as Cha i es accom m ndsuons w e e s rt i r unr onabl eas e. W hie a Di mash s , De e ds sha e de i e a e y i e f r d w ih t M o nts l t s ou e f n nt v lb r t l nt r e e t he va m e c lte t nti o de t hn q hi , h z ii t hi , r a epa n a s rng di a r a me n r r o m s m lm la e m c e t i nd ufe i . S e e i no io mlt i dr wn be we n t Consiu i n a t pr s oft s ç r s r n ra n a n t e he tt to nd he i ons hi c mty W o f v. c nn l, 8 U .S. 39 5 56( 97 . ot l l M Do e l 41 5 , 5* 1 4) F.Pl ntF i entted t Sum m ary Judgm enton CI m :6:U nl f Di ai l s il e *I aw ul stri i i bas on Race,N atonalO ri n,Et m naton ed i gi hnk Groupsand Ancestw l Revers Di en l e s m nae n unde t col ofs at l Di ri hm t H aras ent r he or t e aw sc m ory sm . , l.Bur ofpr a elm ent den oof nd e s Pli i c ai dic i ton u rTil W 1oft Ci lRi t Act 42 U .a ntf l m s nm na i nde te he vi gh s , S. j2 ) e s q.a ai tnaina o i n, etmi bac oundacolr and r i on. C. 0( t e , g ns to l rgi l c kgr 0e o, elgi M ovant was dicrm i ed and hsr sed consanty, by t Def s i nat œq t l he endanl b c us he wa s ea e a f e > e ,s ke Engls wih a a c n p a tc d Gr e -œ t , Relgi or i r po ih t n c e t r c i e e k hodox i on and hewasw hie.Ot r i satDi œ hous wer notk e e i t s wa t her esdent Km q e e Til VH pr bisr di m i i agni tal pe ons i l at d Ca c s a te ohi t ace e naton nm l a n he ame y. , ncuding u a ins . Defendant have a ba ol d i dicri i ton and a cl s ckv m n s m na i e ha c ve a pater Howeve tl r l n. r ley t dicover iil rnuhn ts e nta a yt ri e md i o m asa d i s r quesed i he sa e rcnl if s d o m e a nd o hec n ott nt o:vei n whe s t go a y e e y vok g m q r ve l n ba kv xi e nf r to n s ue e t n s m n , . M s ne sa ep o e t d t d rt e Eq l ot c i Clus oft eFoureent A o r r r t c e m e h ua Pr e ton a e h t h m e dm e t9om i d ousd svi i to b s d o r c . fee v.W as ngt n n nvi i i c m na i n a e n a e hi on, 3 0 U. S. 33 ( 9 3 1 60. 9 E Pl no i entted t Sum m ar Judgm entln CI m 7:H ght t f G. ai s il o y R1 s o reedom of xpres b n s 1.Bur ofpr and elm ent den oof e s TheM ov ntsc a m r pe t d vi a a l i e a e ol :onsb t e De e n so M s constt y h f ndn t f iuéonal A g t,ei u ds r n t na drtl to t e 4 U.S. 1 Fi t r hs rl s ici xi n eai in md r 2 C. 983, rs i /o mi o a m endm entrght .t t cons iuton ofUnied St es t rghtt feedom of i s o he tt i t at he i o , r i on a feedom ofexpr son. elgi nd r es i Def endat have c ed t M ovant hsr and hum ii i b s aus he m laton atend Chur h Ser c on Sunday t c vi es y not alowi hi t l ng m o m i e 9om t D im a Ch ii hatwa ho e chur h on Sundays l at d 1 , a a Orhodox t c he s s artes l y us , t% viltng t eM o oceFis , 6 A nut s f h oai h va ts rt n m endm entRi s. ght 9
  • 10. Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 10 of 11 n eBilofRi sguar nt t t gove m e can neverde i peopl i t l ght a ees hat he m nt prve e n he U . ofcerai f S. t n undam e a rght i udi t rghtt feedom ofr lgi and t nt l i s ncl ng he i o r ei on o 9ee speech and t due pr sofl . he oces aw 1 Pl nt i e ldt Sxmmm l gme o cal 8:I entonalI c nof . ai e s ndte o l ud nt n l m nt i nfie M ent Dit and Abus ofProces . al s r- e s 1.Bur n ofpr a el de oof nd ement s n e Plie s cnm of Vi ai o hi Fi z Si h, Ei and Foureent an li olton f s fh xt ght t h Am endm entt t consiuton ofUnied St t . o he tt i t a es De e a sha e a us d t e rp ra tng i t na e oft S a e a Fe er G f nd nt v b e h i owe c i n he m he t t nd d al ov- m ent. J. a ntl i e lld t Summ a yj me on cam 9:Ne i nc . Pll i s ntte o r udg nt l l glge e 1.Bur n pfpr fand el e s dv m em nt D e e da qc m m it d t s il ga a sa i tt M ov nt whe t y we e f l f n nt o te he e le l ct gs nR he a n he r uly awar oft m e calcondii oft M ovant e he di ton he . K.Pli i i e ildt Summar j me o csl 1 Gr sNe l nt by ants s ntte o y udg nt n l m :: os glge e f lng t as >i t m edk alcondii oft M ovantcom pl t off i il aii o cert n àe ton :e e s eelng l. Da e N o mbc 22, 1 t d: ve 201 Re pe t u l s s c f l ubmit y tedm e... e . , / / mo TRM AN BUm wJx,.z? , U Pro Se z< AN e , 10
  • 11. :+ aF JD : c z 3 -r -J C- Case 1:11-cv-20120-PAS Document 73 Entered on FLSD Docket 11/29/2011 Page 11 of 11 M* ( . *: G> œ rt .* c a Qw - k Kr tm o 31 I 1f . z !. *, ,N êf l. k. . z x, t 9. :. l -u < / x p t s r . , N# . . . . .. Y =. ,. . . ;> o % p 11 k. .i; = l J . ., 1 x c < vD v V k g* ! = # / # % . V/ > z , < k < A - A * * + . % W J > XQ sn . r - - m m % G . - r w )l t X k X O œ M c * r F - * - O . 4 - * *. - . M - .. .. N< . r 1 - w - K * >> mr =œ N> oN $ = mx mm $. - Q - x &-=* 2> * m