The impact of microfinance on  education in sub-Saharan Africa: A partnership projectwith the Institute of EducationINSTIT...
From http://www.developmenthorizons.com/2011_03_01_archive.html                                                           2
Increase                             income Access to      Invest in                Lift out ofmicrofinance   the future  ...
EspeciallyInvest in the   if available   Improvement   future       to women        in education                          ...
DFID-funded systematic reviewReview question     given                             Paper or                             pl...
Peer-reviewed published protocol                                   6
Extensive searching & 2-staged screening              6 000         Microfinance              336               69        ...
Coding         8
From http://www.zazzle.co.uk/worlds_bestest_appraiser_tshirt-235669736717655238                                           ...
From http://www.verylol.com/extraction-1241/Data extraction                                                               ...
Synthesis            11
development               From http://copyprints.blogspot.com/Causal chain                                                ...
Peer-reviewed  published   reportAvailable athttp://www.dfid.gov.uk/r4d/PDF/Outputs/SystematicReviews/MicroFinance_FOR+WEB...
From http://www.verylol.com/for-small-cars-1231/                                              14
Details of our 15 included  studies• 4 RCTs  2 quasi-experimental studies  9 with/without studies• 11 = microcredit, 2 = s...
Scope of the evidence-base                 RCTs   Quasi-exp   With/withoutMicro-savings     2         -            -Micro-...
Hierarchy of evidence?
Findings – how does microfinance      impact on education?      Credit             Combined          Savings              ...
Specific    paper   findings* High quality studies   19
Photo from http://vishwasaha.wordpress.com/category/yoga/  There is some evidence for positive impacts but worryingly ther...
Savings provision to AIDS-orphanedyoung people in Uganda has beenshown to increase their intention to                     ...
Evidence for micro-credit’s impact on  household’s expenditure on education is                 contradictory: (1) two stud...
On school attendance two studies found reduced attendance amongst micro-credit                  clientsData from Malawi sh...
But micro-credit does not appear to increasechild labour, so we presume children are notbeing taken out of school to work,...
From http://indieintertube.tv/static/episode-length-how-long-should-you-go/#axzz1gSMCYo00Length of time withinmicro-credit...
26
“Credit is like a fire: it is useful to cook your sadza but if you are careless, it will burn your hut.”                  ...
Figure from http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/156359/can-microfinance-                                                     s...
Causal pathway analysis                               Source: Per Herbertsson                          29
What we now think is happening                                  Use other MFI                                             ...
What we now think is happening                                  Use other MFI                                             ...
What we now think is happening                                               Social cohesionMicro-credit                  ...
What we now think is happening                                  Use other MFI                                             ...
Given to individuals or groups                                                                     Long-term              ...
What we now think is happening                                  Use other MFI                                             ...
Able to repay                           Given to indivDefault on loan,                              Able to lose collatera...
Use other MFI      Use same        MFI                                                      Micro-                        ...
What we now think is happening                                  Use other MFI                                             ...
Some of our recommendations              Microfinance not to be              promoted as means of            improving edu...
More (especially on micro-savings) andbetter impact evaluations of microfinance                                           ...
Your thoughts?
Contact us:cvanrooyen@uj.ac.za                                          Source: Per Herbertssonr.stewart@ioe.ac.ukPresenta...
Acknowledgements   Photos acknowledged on slidesThe impact of microfinance on education in SSA by  Van Rooyen C et al is l...
Impact of microfinance on education in sub-Saharan Africa
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Impact of microfinance on education in sub-Saharan Africa

1,293 views
1,183 views

Published on

Presentation to the IOE symposium on 14 December 2011

0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
1,293
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
11
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
17
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide
  • Photo of Africa from
  • Searched in three specialist systematic review libraries, 18 electronic online databases, the websites of 24 organisations and an online directory of books. We also contacted 23 key organisations and individuals requesting relevant evidence, conducted citation searches for two key publications and searched the reference lists of initially included papers.Searches provided over 6 000 hits; reduced to 383 ‘probably relevant’ reports based on their abstracts. Full texts sought & 336 were collected & screened for second time. Identified 69 studies on SSA which evaluate impact of microcredit and/or micro-savings on poor. Then down to 35 which had comparison group.Explicit & justified criteria for inclusion or exclusion of any study.
  • Add pick from EPPI Reviewer 4
  • Had 35 studies when started; ended with 15 included studies of high and medium quality (20 excluded either dueto poor reporting, poor methodology or both).
  • According to income outcomes, other wealth indicators, and other outcomes for the poor.
  • Analysed data using two approaches: identification of whether micro-credit or micro-savings were having positive, negative, varied or no effects on the lives of poor people; and narrative synthesis of qualitative findings.
  • Expect questions re selection/placement biases in the 9 simple comparison studies.Details of the included studies 35 studies which compare the impact of having a loan or a savings account with not having either. 11 studies were medium quality and 4 high quality. These 15 studies were considered ‘good enough’ quality and included in the in-depth review.
  • 3ie’s quality standards for inclusion in its impact evaluation database: “Quality evaluations employ either experimental or quasi-experimental approaches.”EPPI-Centre is one of specialist methodology centres around the world exploring and extending SR methods to consider other types of evidence to address complex questions, interventions and outcomes.
  • 9 studies dealt with impact on MF on education outcomes of the poor. Over simplified: Actually some studies include both credit and savings (lost subtlety) Different levels of impacts – on households, business and individual
  • As early as the 1960s, when inaugurated the credit union movement to provide loans to the poor in Zimbabwe, he acknowledged “Credit is like a fire: it is useful to cook your sadza but if you are careless, it will burn your hut.” (Brother Waddelove in Raftopolous & Lacoste 2001:35).
  • Reminder of conditions of micro-credit – high interest rates and frequent repayments = need to make a profit and quicklyRe micro-savings – encouraged to save, but often at a cost (fees to withdraw money)
  • Could also add behaviour to purple box as an external factor shaping outcomes
  • “I think an honest appraisal of the current state of the evidence is that we simply do not know whether microcredit raises incomes and consumption. If the case for microfinance depended on whether it was lifting people out of poverty, then the appropriate response right now would probably be to declare a moratorium on support for microfinance until further research clarifies this question more.” ~ Rosenburg 2009 on CGAP website
  • Impact of microfinance on education in sub-Saharan Africa

    1. 1. The impact of microfinance on education in sub-Saharan Africa: A partnership projectwith the Institute of EducationINSTITUTE OF EDUCATION SYMPOSIUM ON EDUCATION AND DEVELOPMENT, 14 December 2011 Source: Per Herbertsson Carina van Rooyen, Ruth Stewart and Thea de Wet
    2. 2. From http://www.developmenthorizons.com/2011_03_01_archive.html 2
    3. 3. Increase income Access to Invest in Lift out ofmicrofinance the future poverty Increase education, health, etc. 3
    4. 4. EspeciallyInvest in the if available Improvement future to women in education 4
    5. 5. DFID-funded systematic reviewReview question given Paper or plastic?
    6. 6. Peer-reviewed published protocol 6
    7. 7. Extensive searching & 2-staged screening 6 000 Microfinance 336 69 35 ComparativeSub-Saharan evaluationsAfrica of the impact on the poor 15 7
    8. 8. Coding 8
    9. 9. From http://www.zazzle.co.uk/worlds_bestest_appraiser_tshirt-235669736717655238 9 Quality appraisal From http://runningagile.com/category/esther-derby/
    10. 10. From http://www.verylol.com/extraction-1241/Data extraction 10
    11. 11. Synthesis 11
    12. 12. development From http://copyprints.blogspot.com/Causal chain 12
    13. 13. Peer-reviewed published reportAvailable athttp://www.dfid.gov.uk/r4d/PDF/Outputs/SystematicReviews/MicroFinance_FOR+WEB%5B1%5D.pdf 13
    14. 14. From http://www.verylol.com/for-small-cars-1231/ 14
    15. 15. Details of our 15 included studies• 4 RCTs 2 quasi-experimental studies 9 with/without studies• 11 = microcredit, 2 = savings, 2 = combined credit & savings• Ethiopia, Ghana, Kenya, Malawi, Madagascar, Rwanda, South Source: Per Herbertsson Africa, Tanzania (Zanzibar), Uganda & Zimbabwe• Rural & urban initiatives
    16. 16. Scope of the evidence-base RCTs Quasi-exp With/withoutMicro-savings 2 - -Micro-credit 2 1 8Micro-credit & - 1 1savings 16
    17. 17. Hierarchy of evidence?
    18. 18. Findings – how does microfinance impact on education? Credit Combined Savings credit and savings MAYBE NO YES gender difference negative (1) positive (1) no effect (1) positive (2) mixed (2) negative (1) no effect (1) 18
    19. 19. Specific paper findings* High quality studies 19
    20. 20. Photo from http://vishwasaha.wordpress.com/category/yoga/ There is some evidence for positive impacts but worryingly there is also evidence that microfinancedoes harm by negatively impacting on the education of clients’ children, especially girls 20
    21. 21. Savings provision to AIDS-orphanedyoung people in Uganda has beenshown to increase their intention to Photo by Martin Godwin, http://www.guardian.co.uk/katine/katine-chronicles-attend secondary schooling, & theircertainty that these plans will come tofruition. These young people also didsignificantly better in Uganda’sPrimary Leaving Examinations thancontrol group (Ssewamala et al 2010) blog/2010/aug/19/katine-finance-saving 21
    22. 22. Evidence for micro-credit’s impact on household’s expenditure on education is contradictory: (1) two studies show increased household’s expenditure on children’s education; (2) two studies find no such effect;(3) one study finds mixed results with varied positive & negative impacts on expenditure on education depending on the region 22
    23. 23. On school attendance two studies found reduced attendance amongst micro-credit clientsData from Malawi shows that micro-credit significantlydecreases primary school attendance amongstborrowers’ children Noteworthy gendered impact: repetition of primary grades in young boys & delayed or lack of enrolment for young girlsIn Uganda (high quality study) client households weresignificantly more likely to have been unable to payschool charges for one or more household members forat least one term during previous two years, hencechildren had to drop out of school 23
    24. 24. But micro-credit does not appear to increasechild labour, so we presume children are notbeing taken out of school to work, but becauseclients have difficulties paying school expenses 24
    25. 25. From http://indieintertube.tv/static/episode-length-how-long-should-you-go/#axzz1gSMCYo00Length of time withinmicro-credit programmedecreases children’senrolment• Gendered impact: in Zimbabwe on-going borrowing reduced children’s enrolment in school; proportion of household’s girls aged 6 to 16 in school decreasing more for continuing clients than for departing clients & non-clients 25
    26. 26. 26
    27. 27. “Credit is like a fire: it is useful to cook your sadza but if you are careless, it will burn your hut.” 27
    28. 28. Figure from http://www.deathandtaxesmag.com/156359/can-microfinance- save-the-world/
    29. 29. Causal pathway analysis Source: Per Herbertsson 29
    30. 30. What we now think is happening Use other MFI Social cohesion Use same MFI Micro-credit Micro-savings Women’s empowerment Given to individuals or groups Able to repay loanDefault on loan, Able to and avoid increase lose collateral save Long-term in debtand/or forced to Spend money differently benefits borrow more 1. Actual decreased Actual increased Invest in income income immediate 2. Consumptive 3. future: spending with Invest in long- scope for term future: 4. Consumptive a. Business spending (non- productivity: b. Productive a. Children’s productive): Determined by external assets a. Add on education factors: housing Assets which do c. Adult b. Children’s not retain value Entrepreneurial ability education b. Assets which health and d. Workers’ retain value nutrition Appropriateness of business in context health & nutrition Competition from other MFI clients Scope for increased income via business Gender and power FOR CREDIT CLIENTS ONLY or employment Improved capabilities relations Inability to repay loan Better able to deal with shocks 30
    31. 31. What we now think is happening Use other MFI Social cohesion Use same MFI Micro-credit Micro-savings Women’s empowerment Given to individuals or groups Able to repay loanDefault on loan, Able to and avoid increase lose collateral save Long-term in debtand/or forced to Spend money differently benefits borrow more 1. Actual decreased Actual increased Invest in income income immediate 2. Consumptive 3. future: spending with Invest in long- scope for term future: 4. Consumptive a. Business spending (non- productivity: b. Productive a. Children’s productive): Determined by external assets a. Add on education factors: housing Assets which do c. Adult b. Children’s not retain value Entrepreneurial ability education b. Assets which health and d. Workers’ retain value nutrition Appropriateness of business in context health & nutrition Competition from other MFI clients Scope for increased income via business Gender and power FOR CREDIT CLIENTS ONLY or employment Improved capabilities relations Inability to repay loan Better able to deal with shocks 31
    32. 32. What we now think is happening Social cohesionMicro-credit Micro-savings Women’s empowerment Given to individuals or groups Spend money differently 32
    33. 33. What we now think is happening Use other MFI Social cohesion Use same MFI Micro-credit Micro-savings Women’s empowerment Given to individuals or groups Able to repay loanDefault on loan, Able to and avoid increase lose collateral save Long-term in debtand/or forced to Spend money differently benefits borrow more 1. Actual decreased Actual increased Invest in income income immediate 2. Consumptive 3. future: spending with Invest in long- scope for term future: 4. Consumptive a. Business spending (non- productivity: b. Productive a. Children’s productive): Determined by external assets a. Add on education factors: housing Assets which do c. Adult b. Children’s not retain value Entrepreneurial ability education b. Assets which health and d. Workers’ retain value nutrition Appropriateness of business in context health & nutrition Competition from other MFI clients Scope for increased income via business Gender and power FOR CREDIT CLIENTS ONLY or employment Improved capabilities relations Inability to repay loan Better able to deal with shocks 33
    34. 34. Given to individuals or groups Long-term Spend money differently benefits 1. Invest in immediate 2. Consumptive 3. future: spending with Invest in long- scope for term future: 4. Consumptive a. Business productivity: spending (non- b. Productive a. Children’s productive): assets a. Add on education housing Assets which do c. Adult b. Children’s not retain value education b. Assets which health and d. Workers’ retain value nutrition health & nutritionds FOR CREDIT CLIENTS ONLY Improved capabilities Inability to repay loan Better able to deal with shocks 34
    35. 35. What we now think is happening Use other MFI Social cohesion Use same MFI Micro-credit Micro-savings Women’s empowerment Given to individuals or groups Able to repay loanDefault on loan, Able to and avoid increase lose collateral save Long-term in debtand/or forced to Spend money differently benefits borrow more 1. Actual decreased Actual increased Invest in income income immediate 2. Consumptive 3. future: spending with Invest in long- scope for term future: 4. Consumptive a. Business spending (non- productivity: b. Productive a. Children’s productive): Determined by external assets a. Add on education factors: housing Assets which do c. Adult b. Children’s not retain value Entrepreneurial ability education b. Assets which health and d. Workers’ retain value nutrition Appropriateness of business in context health & nutrition Competition from other MFI clients Scope for increased income via business Gender and power FOR CREDIT CLIENTS ONLY or employment Improved capabilities relations Inability to repay loan Better able to deal with shocks 35
    36. 36. Able to repay Given to indivDefault on loan, Able to lose collateral loan and avoid saveand/or forced to increase in debt Spend mon borrow more 1. Actual decreased Actual increased Invest in immediate Co income income s future: w a. Business b. Productive pro Determined by external assets factors: a c. Adult Entrepreneurial ability education Appropriateness of b d. Workers’ business in context wh health & Scope for Competition from nutrition increased income other MFI clients via business or Gender and power Improved capabi employment relations Better able to deal wi 36
    37. 37. Use other MFI Use same MFI Micro- Mic credit sav Given to individuals or groups Default on Able to repay loan, lose Able to loan and avoid collateral save increase in debtand/or forced Spend money differently to borrow more Actual Actual increased 1. decreased 2. 37 income Invest in income Consumptiv
    38. 38. What we now think is happening Use other MFI Social cohesion Use same MFI Micro-credit Micro-savings Women’s empowerment Given to individuals or groups Able to repay loanDefault on loan, Able to and avoid increase lose collateral save Long-term in debtand/or forced to Spend money differently benefits borrow more 1. Actual decreased Actual increased Invest in income income immediate 2. Consumptive 3. future: spending with Invest in long- scope for term future: 4. Consumptive a. Business spending (non- productivity: b. Productive a. Children’s productive): Determined by external assets a. Add on education factors: housing Assets which do c. Adult b. Children’s not retain value Entrepreneurial ability education b. Assets which health and d. Workers’ retain value nutrition Appropriateness of business in context health & nutrition Competition from other MFI clients Scope for increased income via business Gender and power FOR CREDIT CLIENTS ONLY or employment Improved capabilities relations Inability to repay loan Better able to deal with shocks 38
    39. 39. Some of our recommendations Microfinance not to be promoted as means of improving education in SSA Microcredit rolled out with caution & focussed carefully on those most likely to benefit The rhetoric to be scaled back & wild claims challenged
    40. 40. More (especially on micro-savings) andbetter impact evaluations of microfinance From http://www.verylol.com/wash-when-dirty-1218/ Ongoing discussion of how to deliver pragmatic systematic reviews for international development 41
    41. 41. Your thoughts?
    42. 42. Contact us:cvanrooyen@uj.ac.za Source: Per Herbertssonr.stewart@ioe.ac.ukPresentation online athttp://www.slideshare.net/carinavr 43
    43. 43. Acknowledgements Photos acknowledged on slidesThe impact of microfinance on education in SSA by Van Rooyen C et al is licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike 3.0 Unported License

    ×