News via Voldemort: The role of parody and satire in topical discussions on Twitter

  • 312 views
Uploaded on

Paper presented at IR14, Denver, CO. 24 October 2013.

Paper presented at IR14, Denver, CO. 24 October 2013.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads

Views

Total Views
312
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1

Actions

Shares
Downloads
1
Comments
0
Likes
0

Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
    No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. News via Voldemort: The role of parody and satire in topical discussions on Twitter Tim Highfield ARC Centre of Excellence for Creative Industries and Innovation Queensland University of Technology | Curtin University Brisbane, Australia | Perth, Australia t.highfield @ qut.edu.au @timhighfield http://mappingonlinepublics.net/ | http://socialmedia.qut.edu.au
  • 2. GUIDING QUESTIONS • What is the role of parody/gimmick/humour accounts in discussion of news? • Do they act as bridges or form separated, disconnected takes on news? • Are the same roles carried out across multiple topics? • How does topical content relate to these accounts‟ „usual‟ tweets?
  • 3. #OVERLYHONESTMETHODS • This research is a by-product of accumulated studies into discussions on Twitter about politics, popular culture, live broadcasts, sport, crises… – An accidental paper, with impetus provided by serendipity – Also a very exploratory paper, providing some initial comments on some of the questions raised and ideas for further exploration…
  • 4. #OVERLYHONESTMETHODS
  • 5. OVERVIEW • Parody accounts and their ilk are “part of the fabric” of Twitter (Vis, 2013) – Three of 25 most-mentioned accounts discussing 2011 UK riots on Twitter were fake/spoof accounts • Neither new nor Twitter-specific, though – Creation of MySpace accounts „as‟ fictional characters, mixing the personal and the original text (Booth, 2010) – Gimmick accounts prevalent on message boards, fora, comments sections
  • 6. OVERVIEW • Cultural context – Creation of fake/parody accounts as a memetic practice on Twitter • Memetic: “extensive user engagement by way of creative derivatives” (Shifman, 2012) – Breaking news, cultural phenomena, gaffes, quickly followed by accounts spoofing events • Meta-meme/trope of Twitter? • Not limited to any one field – Political parodies well-established, but not the only fake contributors to discussions on Twitter
  • 7. (INITIAL) TYPOLOGY • Character-specific – e.g. Lord_Voldemort7 • Public figure-specific – Queen_UK, YourMateColin • Parodying an idea/stereotype of a type of person – NotTildaSwinton, MatureAge • Organisation/non-human – DeathStarPR, SarcasticRover, https://twitter.com/Exciting_Perth • Topic-specific (including character/figure/thing) – more short-lived? – Subiaco_Cat, Hoyts_Mouse, PerthMillipede, numerous Obama chair accounts… • Hoax – deliberately malicious • Role-playing • …
  • 8. METHODS • Exploratory study, for further development • A mixture of manual and automated data collection and analysis, covering multiple datasets since 2011 • For automated collection and analysis: – yourTwapperKeeper – Gawk scripts, Gephi (see Mapping Online Publics) • Augmented by manual capture
  • 9. GENERAL AND TOPICAL
  • 10. GENERAL AND TOPICAL • Eurovision – the reach of @queen_uk: red nodes are those directly linked to @queen_uk; blue: @planet_jedward; green: @bbceurovision; yellow: @loreen_talhaoui; pink: @eurovision
  • 11. GENERAL AND TOPICAL • Armstrong (keyword dataset) (25-26 August) – some Lance Armstrong, death of Neil Armstrong: – red (@lord_voldemort7) – green (@nbcnightly)
  • 12. GENERAL AND TOPICAL • Tour de France – Presence of parody accounts for (Australian) presenters – Fostered by familiarity with broadcast – Tropes of the coverage, captive audience (three weeks of racing) – Topic-specific; limited non-cycling/sport coverage?
  • 13. TOPICALITY OF PARODY ACCOUNTS • Five months of tweets (May-October 2013) from @queen_uk, @lord_voldemort7, @deathstarpr
  • 14. TOPICALITY OF PARODY ACCOUNTS Lord_Voldemort7 Queen_UK DeathStarPR Original tweets 165 605 146 RTs of others 2 2 9 Replies 0 1 43 Total 167 608 198 Tweets per day 1.07 3.90 1.27
  • 15. TOPICALITY OF PARODY ACCOUNTS lord_voldemort7 queen_uk Topical HP Character-specific Trending Topical Self-promotion (web content) Sponsored Other self-promotion (shop) RT sponsored Promo deathstarpr RT StarWars reply Topical Self-promotion (web content) RT Trending MT Self-promotion (purchase)
  • 16. TOPICALITY OF PARODY ACCOUNTS Lord_Voldemort7 Queen_UK DeathStarPR n RTs (mean) Faves (mean) n RTs (mean) Faves (mean) n Topical 35 3982.71 1864.14 392 794.05 220.93 41 949.88 248.98 RT 2 2315.50 1611.50 2 139.00 53.50 9 733.67 128.00 Character-specific 66 2907.68 1595.73 143 554.74 168.45 88 609.00 234.61 Trending 41 2164.93 1114.71 2 335.50 140.50 1 95.00 55.00 MT Self-promo (web) 1 76.00 155.00 RTs (mean) Faves (mean) 109.45 42.37 13 27.31 34.46 17 97.71 50.41 1 14.00 13.00 17.00 Self-promo (shop) 49 23.00 43 5.28 10.09 703.20 168.20 Reply Sponsored 16 93.19 103.19 Other 6 2251.67 924.50 5
  • 17. TOPICALITY OF PARODY ACCOUNTS • Cross-over: – Celebrity and gossip: • Kim Kardashian and Kanye West named their child "North West". It's like you WANT us to destroy your planet. [1541 | 377] • One can confirm that the new Royal baby will not be called North West. This is mainly because William and Catherine are not morons. [4036 | 1061] • So I'm assuming that North West won't be a One Direction fan? [28424 | 11276] • If Prince William and Kate Middleton have a daughter and DON'T call her Princess Leia, they're wasting everybody's time. #RoyalBaby [1626 | 380]
  • 18. TOPICALITY OF PARODY ACCOUNTS • Cross-over: – Breaking news: • Text from Ed Miliband: "Delighted Catherine has joined labour. Together we will rebuild Britain" Absolute idiot. [8135 | 2057] • The half-blood prince has been born as the seventh month dies. #RoyalBaby [6464 | 2909] • Due to our govt shutdown, the following non-essential depts are closed: education, health, welfare. Planet exploding to continue as normal. [893 | 257] • American Government started to shut down. Not sure what the fuss is. Italian Government shut down about 40 years ago and no one's noticed. [2406 | 714] • Clearly this whole "shut down" is just the US government's way of hiding the dementor attacks. [5133 | 2089]
  • 19. TOPICALITY OF PARODY ACCOUNTS • Cross-over: – Geek and tech culture: • Just upgraded to #iOS7 and now our exhaust port force field is on the fritz. Oh well, what are the chances of Rebels attacking us n [636 | 222] • Dear most of the world, there will be a short break in leadership whilst one downloads iOS 7. This will take approximate seven years. EIIR [1610 | 503] • George R. R. Martin is avada kedavraing more people? He's about three deaths away from being called a Dark Lord. [2524 | 1102] • George R. R. Martin kills more people than the Death Star. #GameofThrones [1174 | 323] • One is not the next Dr Who. [1099 | 299] • Ben Affleck as Batman will be the opposite of "movie magic." That is "movie muggles.“ [1485 | 595]
  • 20. INITIAL POINTS/FURTHER DIRECTIONS • Topical coverage attracts more RTs/favourites than other comments – Extends audience? Appeals to more users than account‟s usual comments? • Thematic framing around subject of interest provides original take on news – encourages RTing in addition to/in place of news organisations? • Importance of humour to news coverage – type of event important, although an audience for humour/satire/black humour – see also comedians, for instance • Types of event vs. types of account – celebrity news (and trending topics) more common fodder than politics?
  • 21. INITIAL POINTS/FURTHER DIRECTIONS • Limited engagement with other accounts? – DeathStarPR the exception here, with 40+ @replies over the five months – This applies too to other parody accounts – despite there being accounts for other royals/HP characters, the Queen and Voldemort do not engage with them • DeathStarPR mentions/RTs @JerkSuperman, but this account is by the same people? – Parody operates in a bubble? • Participating in social discussions (e.g. #eurovision) and attracting/encouraging RTs, but not responding to audience or surroundings?
  • 22. INITIAL POINTS/FURTHER DIRECTIONS • Parody as meta-commentary – Established parody accounts dismissing the inevitable influx of new parody accounts in response to breaking news (staying in character as the „real‟ (fake) subject?) • Impact of reporting on Twitter activity by news outlets – Drives spikes in RTing/favouriting? – Aggregating humorous tweets in response to news stories may lead to increased audience for these tweets/accounts • Getting more coverage and reaction in this way may encourage further topical commentary? (albeit brief engagement with topics)
  • 23. http://mappingonlinepublics.net/ http://socialmedia.qut.edu.au/ @snurb_dot_info @jeanburgess @_StephenH @DrTNitins @timhighfield @cdtavijit @lena_sauter @dpwoodford @tsadkowsky @socialmediaQUT