Summit 05 Cd Session 09b Presentation - Presentation Transcript
National Angel Organization Annual Summit Terry Matthews October 24th, 2005
Who is Wesley Clover?
Significant investments in:
Next Generation Networks
Real Estate
Leisure and Golf resorts
Founded or funded over 60 hi-tech startups
Not as a ‘pump and dump’ investor
Most major investments are here in Canada
Pretty good run-rate from initial investment to IPO
Investment Philosophy
Investment decisions based upon ideas and people
Innovation is important, but innovation without commercialization is a challenge
Use the success to fuel new investments
Use stock options as a reward for success and encourage employee share ownership
Leverage Government funds where possible
Generate an attractive return to all parties
When Is a Good Time to Invest?
Now is a good time to start a new venture, the talent is available
Technology cycles come in waves
Ottawa is a good example of a technology cluster, critical mass has been established here
Need to stimulate more early stage investor activity
Federal Government must encourage tax breaks for early investors – historically there is evidence of a 6:1 $ benefit to the federal government for every additional dollar invested in R&D intensive companies
Investors will reap benefits
Our portfolio companies will reap benefits
Canadian economy will reap benefits
A Proof Point 604%+ Direct Return Government Investment in Newbridge
Venture Capital (Canada) Source: OCRI $CAN Millions
Concerns
Lack of incentives for startups
Ottawa has great technical skills - leadership and commercial pool needs to be improved
Cost of Canadian innovation versus China and India
In Canada, R&D as a percentage of GDP has declined since 2001 - In Asia (China, Taiwan and India) it is surging
From 1995 to 2001, gross R&D spending in China, South Korea and Taiwan increased by about 140%. In Canada and the US it increased by only 65% and 34% respectively
Chinese patents filed through the World Intellectual Property Organization 38% last year. Canada dropped 7%.
Many new innovations acquired by US Companies - need to maintain a strong base here
Summary
Innovation is our life blood and we must strive for continued improvement
It requires support from Government, Industry and Academia
This is not a time to be complacent!
It is a time for this country to be involved and not just a participant
I continue to be involved and will be for a long time to come
Thank you...
The Telecom Nuclear Winter
Telecom industry is a $150B industry – but came down from a peak of $250B+
It is a global market and Ottawa/Canada is one of the centres of excellence
The market will evolve and new technologies will be adopted – it is a matter of time
Bold investments will return handsomely
Technology change causes churn in Telco and enterprise capital expenditures (typical industry cycles and technology waves)
A Dollar Here versus a Dollar There
Value of a dollar in our economy versus in their economy
Capital gain (tax)
Capital spend
Operational expenditure (rent, professional fees)
Salary base
Consumption taxes
Intellectual capital and our centre of excellence
Knock on effect - $1 invested generates $10 of economic activity
Net Benefits Flowing to Government from Newbridge
$ Billions in exports over the life of the company
$ Hundred Millions invested in R&D
Thousands new high tech jobs in Ottawa alone
New tax revenues of over $Hundreds Millions
Anchor company for high tech cluster (affiliate program)
Development of several hundred local supplier jobs
Strong relationships with local universities
2,000 hrs/employee of training - increasing local skill base
Stimulate R&D Investment through Private Sector (VC/Angel/private equity) Funding Sources
Let’s Encourage Early Stage Investment
Angel community needs encouragement now!!
VC’s are in the process of returning funds to investors (ie. They are NOT investing the money they have today!)
Capital Gain tax holiday for early stage investor cost only 1.5% ($88) of the net-net proceeds of the $5,783 additional taxes reaped from the program
Not in the analysis
A profitable operating company (value to the economy of $30k - $50k per job - based on incentives paid to attract investment)
Economic benefit from wealth creation through employee option plan (beyond salary driven accelerator effect) – Value to economy of a higher ratio of Disposable Income per Job Created?
Wealth creation in the hands of the Angels
Reinvestors in economic Activity!!
Venture Capital (Ottawa) Source: OCRI
Summary
Early stage investment is a significant driver for the economy
We should be investing when the price is low so we can reap when the price is high
Two significant actions:
TCG exemption for early stage investors to get things rolling
ESOP tax exemption to retain our best and brightest
Enterprise gateways and IP Telephony and Applications
Advanced desktop applications
Hosted key systems
Session Border Controllers
XML Routing
Rapid new service creation and deployment
Peer to peer policy management
Carrier class media processing platforms
Digital Video Recording Solutions
Policy Management Solutions
Present Value Impacts on Tax System $1,000 Early Stage + $5,000 Follow-on Investment
Capital gains $528
Early stage $88 ($113 five years out)
Later Stage $440 ($565 three years out)
Salary taxes $1,282
Downstream activities $6,123
Corporate income taxes $389
Transactional taxes $1,947
Salary taxes $3,787
Costs (ITC’s and PV of future loss carry forward) $2,150
Net-Net – Each $1,000 Early stage investment yields $5,783 in Taxes
0 comments
Post a comment