Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Thanks for flagging this SlideShare!

Oops! An error has occurred.

×
Saving this for later? Get the SlideShare app to save on your phone or tablet. Read anywhere, anytime – even offline.
Text the download link to your phone
Standard text messaging rates apply

Section 1-1-irish-jewish-communities

1,080

Published on

Published in: Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,080
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
3
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
1
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

Report content
Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 1 SECTION 1 The Irish Jewish Communities and the Jewish Home Topic 1.1 The Development of the Irish Jewish Communities Description of Topic Key moments in the history of Irish Jews. Recorded history of Irish Jewry in the Annals of Innisfallen; the incremental establishment of communities in Cork, Dublin, Limerick and Belfast. Irish Jewish participation in the creation of the Free State. Waves of immigration and their participants. The impact of World War II and Irish government policy on immigration. Current patterns of Jewish immigration. A short biography of some Irish Jewish men and women and their contribution to the academic, cultural, economic and political life of Ireland. The contribution one Irish Jewish person made to the religious or secular life of Israel. Trace the historical development of the Irish Jewish community in one Irish town or city. Learning Outcomes Trace key events in the history of the Irish Jewish community. Give a brief account of the Annals of Innisfallen; the incremental establishment of communities in Cork, Dublin, Limerick and Belfast. Irish Jewish participation in the creation of the Irish Free State. Waves of immigration and their participants. The impact of World War II and Irish government policy on immigration. Give an account of current trends of Jewish immigration. Provide examples of the contribution that individual Irish Jews have made to the academic, cultural, economic and political development in Ireland. Discuss the contribution one Jewish person has made to the religious or secular life of Israel. Give an account of the historical development of one Irish Jewish community. Begin by looking at the continental origins of the Jewish community in Ireland by placing them in context. Animoto Clip Show the Animoto clip of the Jewish community in Ireland as an introduction to this topic. Copy and paste the following on to that: http://static.animoto.com/swf/w.swf?w=swf/vp1&e=1322752188&f=zXlO1xlbEOGFKhNcrds4ZQ&d=289&m=a&r=360p &volume=100&start_res=360p&i=m&options=%22%3E%3C/param%3E%3Cparam%20name=%22allowFullScreen%2 2%20value=%22true%22%3E%3C/param%3E%3Cparam%20name=%22allowscriptaccess%22%20value=%22always %22%3E%3C/param%3E%3Cembed%20id=%22vp1zXlO1%22%20src=%22http%3A//static.animoto.com/swf/w.swf? w=swf/vp1&e=1322752188&f=zXlO1xlbEOGFKhNcrds4ZQ&d=289&m=a&r=360p&volume=100&start_res=360p&i=m& options=%22%20type=%22application/x-shockwave- flash%22%20allowscriptaccess=%22always%22%20allowfullscreen=%22true%22%20width=%22432%22%20height =%22240%22%3E%3C/embed%3E%3C/object%3E
  • 2. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 2 Map Locate the movement of the people from mainland Europe – Lithuania, France and Spain - to Ireland Find Normandy and Rouen, the first recorded details of Jews coming to Ireland.
  • 3. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 3 NUMERACY MOMENT Chart the distance by land and by boat from Rouen to Cork or Dublin.
  • 4. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 4 KEY DATE: 1079 The Annals of Innisfallen The earliest reference to the existence of a Jewish community in Ireland is in the Annals of Innisfallen, a chronicle of medieval Irish history, in the year 1079, that states, “five Jews came from over the sea with gifts to Tairdelbach [king of Munster] and then were sent back again over the sea.” It is probable that they came as merchants from Rouen in France. According to Benjamin T. Hudson, this delegation could have come from William the Conqueror, or from England where a Jewish colony was claimed to have been established by William of Malmesbury, or they may have come directly from Normandy where the largest Jewish population was located in northern Europe at that time.1 ‘This terse statement sums up what would be Ireland’s attitude toward Jews for the next 900 years. In fact, so inhospitable was Ireland to the Jews that in 1249 the British King Henry III began penalizing Jews who failed to pay their special ‘Jew Tax’ by sending them there.’2 The word ‘annal’ comes from the Latin ‘annus’ meaning ‘year’. Annals are a concise historical chronology of events that happen as a narrative from year to year. The Annals of Innisfallen give an account of the historical events which occurred in the medieval history of Ireland. There are more than 2,500 entries written between the years between 433 CE and 1450 CE, but it is believed to have been written between the 12th and 15th centuries. They were written by the monks of Innisfallen Abbey, on Innisfallen Island on Lough Lein, near Killarney, Co. Kerry. The island, 21 acres (8.5 hectares) is one mile from Ross Castle and the ruins of the Abbey are still visible today. The monastery was originally founded by St Finian the Leper in the 7th century CE. Diverse events are to be found in these annals including deaths and births of kings, feastdays, battles, tribulations of Irish family clans, new moons, the sightings of comets, to mention but a few entries. They are written in Irish and Latin and the manuscripts are preserved today in the Bodleian Library in Oxford.3 1 Benjamin T Hudson, Viking Pirates and Christian Princes: Dynasty, Religion and Empire in the North Atlantic, New York: OUP, 2005, p. 168.) 2 George E. Berkley, Jews, p. 94 3 A cursory glance at some of the entries provided on the UCC/CELT website, gives the breadth of the course of Irish history in medieval times: The Annals of Inisfallen: CELT, Corpus of Electronic Texts, The Free Digital Humanities Resource for Irish History, Literature and Politics. It brings the wealth of Irish literary and historical culture to you on the Internet, for the use and benefit of everyone worldwide. It has a searchable online textbase consisting of 14.7 million words, in 1161 contemporary and historical documents from many areas, including literature and the other artsCELT, Corpus of Electronic Texts, The Free Digital Humanities Resource for Irish History, Literature and Politics: http://www.ucc.ie/celt/published/T100004/index.html [accessed 8 November 2011].
  • 5. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 5 Exercise 1. Where is this record to be found? 2. Why would the details have been found in Annals? 3. What other historical documents might record such details? 4. Where and when were the Annals written? 5. Why might the Jews have been coming from France? 6. Find out what was going on in Europe at the same time. Visual-verbal Squares Each pair of learners is given a keyword and is asked to draw a square and in corner of it they: Write their own definition Write a sentence using a keyword Give a word that is connected to the keyword Draw a sketch of a word or something related to the word (The image used above from the Annals is from the Bodleian Library where the Annals are kept in the collection of Medieval and Renaissance Manuscripts: http://bodley30.bodley.ox.ac.uk:8180/luna/servlet/detail/ODLodl~1~1~4032~104137:Annals-of- Innisfallen,-from-the-Cre) Student’s Definition Connected Word Key word Sample Sketch Sentence Innisfallen The Annals of Innisfallen give the first record of Jews coming to Ireland in 1079 when they document that the Jews brought gifts to Tairdelbach, King of Munster. Annals
  • 6. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 6 WAVES OF IMMIGRATION In the following map, the waves of immigration can be seen across Europe and the direction and movement of the Jewish communities in the aftermath of persecution from 1100-1600. The following section gives some information about a number of these persecutions and those which occurred into the 19th century. The Jewish communities of Ireland are descendants of those who had to flee these persecutions in Europe. (Map is from http://upload.wikimedia.org/wikipedia/commons/thumb/6/65/Expulsion_judios-en.svg/500px- Expulsion_judios-en.svg.png) What was occurring across Europe which had an impact on the immigration of Jews? Jews were constantly moving to escape pogroms and expulsions in different countries. Below are a number of different waves of immigration which had a significant impact on Jews living in these areas.
  • 7. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 7 KEY DATES: 1290 KEY EVENT: EXPULSIONS FROM ENGLAND Context: There was widespread antisemitic sentiment in England in the 12th and 13th centuries: rumours of blood-libel cases and desecration of Roman Catholic Communion hosts, false accusations of poisoning neighbours and being responsible for the spread of the plague. All of this was in advance of the eventual expulsion of Jews from England in 1290 by Edward I. England was the first European country to expel Jews. (The following material is abridged from http://www.bbc.co.uk/religion/religions/judaism/history/350.shtml) Jews had been living in England since Roman and Anglo-Saxon times, but they did not become an organised community until William the Conqueror arrived in 1066. He encouraged Jewish merchants and artisans to move from northern France to England. In 1144, Jews in Norwich were accused of a ritual murder. A rumour sprung up that a Christian child had been kidnapped by Jews, tied to a cross and stabbed in the head to simulate Jesus' crown of thorns. While the Norwich account did not contain the accusation that the child's blood was drained and was then ritually drunk at Passover, and so does not constitute the full blood libel, it is a story of the same type and is generally seen as the entry point into England of such accusations. The rumour was false - for one thing, the Torah forbids the eating and drinking of any form of blood - but it became the first recorded case in Europe of 'blood libel'. The accusation was enough to get Jewish leaders in the town executed. The other main charge that early 11th-century Christians levelled at Jews was that of host desecration. The host is the wafer used during Christian communion; England was Catholic at this time and to Catholics the host is literally Jesus's flesh, so mistreating it was an incredibly serious thing to do. Jews were variously accused of stabbing the host wafer with pins, stepping on it, stabbing it with a knife until Jesus' blood flowed out and nailing it in a symbolic re-enactment of the crucifixion. Jews were also accused by their Christian neighbours of poisoning wells and spreading the plague. Each fresh claim gave rise to new massacres. Accusations of blood sacrifice continued in the 12th and 13th centuries in Suffolk, Bristol, Winchester, London. In 1247, Pope Innocent IV ordered a study into the charges brought against the Jews. The investigation found no evidence to justify their persecution. The Jewish community was vindicated by four more Popes but accusations, trials
  • 8. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 8 and executions continued to rise. The Jews were banished from England by Edward I. His motivation was partly financial: once they were banished, their possessions became property of the crown. England was short of money and illegal coin-clipping was on the rise. The Jews became Edward's scapegoat. He banned them from usury (money-lending at interest) in 1275. 1278 brought widespread arrests of Jewish men; many were hanged and 600 imprisoned in the Tower of London. In 1290 Edward banished the Jews outright. He issued writs to the sheriffs of all English counties ordering them to enforce his Edict of Expulsion, a decree which required all Jews to be expelled from the country by All Saints' Day (1st November) that year. They were only allowed to carry with them their portable property. Apart from a few exceptions, houses and properties were passed to the king. Some Jews stayed in England by hiding their identity and religion but the majority settled in France and Germany. It wasn't until the 17th century that Jews were allowed back to Britain. KEY DATES: 1492 KEY EVENT: SPANISH EXPULSION Context: In 1492, Queen Isabella and King Ferdinand expelled the entire 200,000 of the Jewish population of Spain in an attempt to isolate conversos (Christian converts) from contact with non-Christians. Eventually, many of the exiles found new homes in North Africa, Italy, the Netherlands, the Americas, and the Ottoman Empire (which at that time included Palestine). Below is an eye- witness testimony to that event. When the dreadful news [of the decree expelling Jews from Spain] reached the people, they [...] wept bitterly. [...] However, they bravely encouraged each other: “Let us cling unflinchingly to our faith [...] If they let us live, we will live; if they kill us, we will perish. But we will not break our Divine Covenant nor shall we turn back. We will go forth in the name of the Lord our God.”
  • 9. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 9 15th century Spanish Jews taking refuge in the Atlas Mountains, Morocco (From http://www.1st-art- gallery.com/thumbnail/325564/1/Spanish-Jews-Taking-Refuge-In-The-Atlas-Mountains-In-The-15th-Century.jpg) In this spirit the people, old and young, women and children [...] went forth on one day, unarmed and afoot. I was among them. They went whithersoever the wind carried them. Some fled to the kingdom of Portugal, others to the kingdom of Navarre. Many chose the way of the sea and were lost, drowned, burnt to death, and sold into slavery. (From Don Isaac Abrabanel (1437-1509), Memoir, from Leo W. Schwarz, Memoirs of My People Through a Thousand Years (New York, Toronto: Farrar and Rinehart, 1943) KEY DATES: 1648-1655 KEY EVENT: THE CHMIELNICKI MASSACRES (Ukraine) Context: In 1648, the prosperous Jewish community in Poland met with catastrophe, as Ukrainian Cossacks and Crimean Tartars went on a rampage. A contemporary author, Nathan of Hanover, describes the bloodshed. There was no cruel device of murder in the whole world that was not perpetrated by the enemies. All the four death penalties: stoning, burning, beheading, and strangling were meted out to the Jews. Many were taken by the Tartars into captivity [...]. They seized comely women as handmaids and house- keepers, some as wives and concubines. Similar atrocities were perpetrated in all the settlements through which they passed. Scrolls of the Law were torn to pieces, and turned into boots and shoes for their feet[...]. Other sacred books served to pave the streets. Some were used for kindling purposes, and others to stuff the barrels of their guns. (From Nathan of Hanover, The Abyss of Despair, Transaction Books: 1982) KEY DATES: 1804, 1825, 1881-1884 KEY EVENTS: FORCED ASSIMILATION AND EXPULSIONS, RUSSIA Context: In the Russian Empire the presence of Jews was not tolerated since the Middle Ages. Jews were considered the enemy of Christ by Orthodox Christianity
  • 10. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 10 and believed to aim at converting Christians to Judaism. The Czars (Supreme monarchs of Slavic regions, also known as Tsars), in their role as Protectors of the Faith, regularly refused permission even for Jewish merchants to enter Russia. From 1825, children as young as 8 were conscripted to military service for 25 years while the official age was meant to have been 12. After the assassination of Czar Alexander II in 1881, Jews were blamed and pogroms were carried out against them. The May Laws of 1882 instigated by Czar Alexander III signified greater persecution of Jews. (The following is abridged from http://www.friends-partners.org/partners/beyond-the-pale/english/29.html [accessed 7 December 2012]) In his "Statute Concerning the Organization of the Jews" from 1804, Alexander I was the first to formulate the dual policy of forced assimilation and expulsion from the villages. With the aim to draw the Jews into the general stream of economic and cultural life, Jews could now enter public schools for the first time. In order to undermine the Jewish village economy, Jewish residence in the villages was prohibited, and expulsions began soon afterward. Jews were also forbidden to distill or sell alcohol to peasants, or continued leasing activities in the villages. Czar Nicholas I (1825-1855) sought to destroy all Jewish life in Russia and his reign constitutes a painful part of European Jewish history. In 1825, he ordered the conscription of Jewish youth into the Russian military beginning at age 12. Many of the youngsters were kidnapped by “snatchers” (“khappers”) in order to get them to spend their formative years in the Russian military. The Jews that were not forced to spend decades in the military were often expelled from their towns and villages. The following gives more detailed information about this: (The following is from http://www.jewishgen.org/infofiles/ru-mil.txt) The men who were a part of it were, unofficially, called by the Russian "lovchiki" or the Yiddish "khapper" which is translated as both "bounty-hunter" or, more colloquially, "one who grabs." And it is with this activity that the stories of Jews avoiding conscription must come under closest scrutiny. This is what appears to have happened. The high quota that was demanded, the brutally severe conditions of service, and the knowledge that conscripts would be forced to contravene Jewish religious precepts and cut themselves off from their homes and families, made those liable for conscription try every means of evading it. The communal leaders who were made personally responsible for implementing the law took the easiest way out and filled the quota from children of the poorest homes. Every community had special officers, khappers, who seized the children, incarcerated them in the communal building and, finally, handed them over to the military authorities. The khappers were not scrupulous about adhering to the minimum age of 12 and frequently impressed children as young as 8. These were
  • 11. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 11 alleged by witnesses on oath to have reached the statutory age. These children were most frequently then spirited away to inaccessible places (cantonist institutions in Kazan, Orenburg [now Chklaov], Perm, and Siberia) from where they could not escape and return home, and where they waited until achieving the age of 12 at which point they were then formally inducted into the army. So it seems that something like half of the inductees would not have been to claim that they were sole supporters of families since this half was no older than 12 and more likely no older than 8. The radical author, A. Herzen, described a meeting in 1835 with a convoy of Jewish cantonists (Jewish children conscripted for military service): ‘The officer who escorted them said, "They have collected a crew of cursed little Jew boys of 8 or 9 years old. Whether they are taking them for the navy or what, I can't say. At first, the orders were to drive them to Perm; then there was a change and we are driving them to Kazan. I took them over a hundred versts farther back.’4 The officer who handed them over said, 'It's dreadful, and that's all about it; a third were left on the way' (and the officer pointed to the earth). 'Not half will reach their destination,' he said.’ ‘They brought the children and formed them into regular ranks: it was one of the most awful sights I have ever seen, those poor, poor children! Boys of 12 or 13 might somehow have survived it, but little fellows of 8 ....’ The May Laws: When Czar Alexander III became monarch, he initiated the ‘Temporary’ May Laws in May 1882 bringing a new period of anti-Jewish discrimination and severe persecution. It lasted until 1917. The area of the Pale of Settlement was reduced by 10%. Jews were once more prohibited from living in villages, buying or renting property outside their prescribed residences, denied jobs in the civil service and forbidden to trade on Sundays and Christian holidays. NUMERACY MOMENT Exercises based on the Waves of Immigration 1. Study the following picture and answer the questions which follow: 4 A verst is an old Russian measurement. The modern equivalent is 1.06 kilometres. Calculate the approximate amount of Jewish people who had to leave England, Spain and Russia.
  • 12. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 12 Photo is from http://lcweb2.loc.gov/service/pnp/ppmsca/05400/05438r.jpg (a) Describe in detail what you see. (b) In what century do you think this picture would have been painted? Why? (c) Why might that century be important in Jewish immigration? (d) What do you think is being portrayed in this picture? (e) How many figures do you see there? (e) Who is the person bearing the weight? (f) The word ‘OPPRESSION’ is written on the weight being carried by the man. What do you think that means in the context of the Jewish people in Europe from the 13th to the 19th centuries? 2. Imagine that you are a child in Russia in 1825 being conscripted for military service at the age of 12. Describe, in detail, the kind of life you have in Russia at that time and what happens to you and your family when you receive the news of your conscription. LITERACY MOMENT There are many words and phrases highlighted in the texts on the subject of waves of immigration. Explain what they mean and put them in sentences.
  • 13. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 13 3. There are many words and phrases highlighted in the texts on the subject of the waves of immigration. In each of the following give reference to the place and the approximate years which are relevant to the question. (a) Discuss the issues presented in the situations which presented problems for observant Jews. (b) Outline the false accusations brought against Jews in some of the countries mentioned above. (c) What were the punishments inflicted on Jews in some countries? 4. Construct a drama surrounding any of the events outlined above. In your drama, include the facts of the stories, key dates, a description of the place where they occurred, and the different perspectives of the people affected by these events. L-I-N-K-S Many of the ancestors of the present Irish Jewish community had to flee these persecutions in Europe. In the next section, we will focus on the Irish Jewish communities, their origins, where they are, and some facts about members of the Irish Jewish communities who have made significant contributions to Irish life. Powerpoint and Focused Questions on the Jewish Community in Ireland Here, we will focus on the Jewish community in Ireland. It is presumed that some background work would have been covered before doing this exercise. The following photographs are photographs which would be shown in a powerpoint presentation, with one photograph per slide. Here I have used ten pictures. Ten to twelve is sufficient. There are no copyright issues attached to these images since I have taken them myself. (See powerpoint entitled Jewish Ireland with Focused Questions in the Teacher Resource Section) Show the powerpoint first in silence, with enough time in each slide to allow the students time to observe and assimilate some information relating to the pictures.
  • 14. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 14 Exercise: Give students a sheet of questions as follows: 1. If you were to give a title to this powerpoint presentation, what would it be? 2. What can you recognize in these pictures which relate to Jewish life in Ireland? 3. What is the significance of buildings which are photographed here? 4. Do you know of their association with the Irish Jewish communities? 5. When were those buildings founded and for what reason? 6. Where are these buildings located? 7. In the map of Europe which was shown, what parts of Europe might be of particular relevance to Irish Jewish communities? 8. Why might these places be relevant? 9. Where would you expect to find Jewish communities living and congregating today in Ireland? 10. Where is the cemetery which is shown? 11. Who is the person whose name is on the inscription? 12. What was his contribution to Irish Jewish society and internationally? 13. Do you know where he was born? 14. What was the most distinguished position of his career? 15. What are the customs in Jewish law relating to burial? 16. What is the Jewish tradition when one visits a cemetery? 17. What is the significance of the two food-related pictures? 18. Where might one expect to find kosher food in Dublin? 19. What foods are considered kosher? 20. One road sign is given. What is it called? 21. Why is this included here? Consider the following structure for what happens now: THINK Students attempt to answer the questions on their own. PAIR They pair with someone else in the class and focus on the questions together.
  • 15. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 15 SHARE They share the answers. View powerpoint again. Go back over the questions and bring it to the next level focusing on higher order questions. Correct any information which is not accurate. Fill out information which is required. Then move into deeper learning and application by asking them to write an exercise based on the pictures which give us some information about the Irish Jewish communities. Or you could follow it with a text which has information about the Jewish communities. LITERACY MOMENT Word Searches and Crosswords Use to reinforce key words. Grade them in difficulty for differentiation. Write them left to right for those with literacy difficulties. Here is a moderately difficult word search based on information about the Irish Jewish communities. Where two words are on a line in the key below, they are not separated in the word search itself; for example, ‘Adelaide Road’ appears in the word search as ‘Adelaideroad’. L T K B E L F A S T P G U D W A E K C S A L C K N L E G A A L E I R I F K P V I X R L O L A R D C O R O M T G O A O R W N T U A E C E H E S A L U E O S S B E R S U M V N H D I D R H X L W U A T E I E E G S I T A O I E N W N E R L A O L A H T N N I E O E Z R P T L E L R T N A K R K O H V A S D N E O Word searches are easy to do. Prepare your own on any topic. The following is on Jewish Communities in Ireland.
  • 16. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 16 E E W R E G T D C E V B T D A R L O S T M I A H C P E I A D D A V I D M A R C U S R N T L D R O F R E T A W P M G Y U R E O C S I R B T R E B O R S E ADELAIDE ROAD AKMENE ALAN SHATTER BELFAST CHAIM CORK DAVID MARCUS DUBLIN GERALD GOLDBERG GROSVENOR ROAD HERZOG Reading Becoming a successful reader Understand how to locate, retrieve and find evidence in a text Identify techniques for skimming and scanning a text You will see a series of words and pictures. You need to pay attention as you will then need to answer a series of questions on what you have just seen … LEICESTER AVENUE LENNOX STREET LIMERICK LITHUANIA LOUIS LENTIN ROBERT BRISCOE TERENURE WALWORTH ROAD WATERFORD Immigration Ackmene The town was established in the 16th century. It was burnt in 1705 in a war with the Swedes. In 1792, Ackmene received the Magdeburg Rights which were granted by the nobility to Jews and a few other minorities for commerce, trade and money- lending. Jewish settlement in Ackmene began in the beginning of the 18th century. In the first half of the 19th century, Jews numbered approximately two-thirds of the population. The mass immigrations of Jews began after the so-called May Laws were instigated in Tsarist Russia in 1881. These laws were meant to be temporary measures but lasted over thirty years. Ashkenazi
  • 17. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 17 The following exercises are based on the text and image combinations from the page before this. Exercises 1. What is the name of the town which is mentioned in the first text box? 2. When was that town first established? 3. When did Jews begin to settle in that area? 4. What happened that made life difficult for them in the 1800s? 5. What is meant by the word Immigration? 6. What area of the world is indicated by the map? 7. Can you name any countries on that map which have particular significance for the origins of Irish Jews? 8. To what does the word Ashkenazic refer? 9. How did people end up on the shores of Ireland in the waves of immigration? 10. What is illustrated in the photograph from Cork? 11. What are the languages of the inscription on the stone? Answers 1. Ackmene. 2. In the 16th century. 3. In the 18th century. 4. The Russian/Czarist Laws. 5. Immigration is the action of coming to live permanently in a foreign country. 6. Europe. 7. Ireland, Lithuania, Germany, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, France. 8. Originally referred to Jews from northern France and Western Germany, but later including Jews from Poland and Lithuanian regions. People came and settled in different parts of Ireland and created communities. These journeys to Ireland were generally unexpected due to circumstances: sickness, disorientation, lack of kosher food. However, a small number settled and made their homes here in Cork, Limerick, Waterford and Dublin.
  • 18. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 18 9. Because they came on ships and sometimes they were not sure of their destinations, or else they were sick, or if they were observant Jews they needed to stock up on their kosher foods. 10. The Curraghkippane Cemetery in Cork. 11. English and Hebrew. L-I-N-K-S In Ireland there are Jews who are Sephardic and Ashkenazic. Sephardic means that they are descendants of the Jews of the Iberian Peninsula (Spain and Portugal), North Africa and the Middle East. The Hebrew word Sepharad was a name associated with Spain. Sephardic Jews (Sephardim) are often subdivided into Sephardim, from Spain and Portugal, and Mizrachim, from the Northern Africa and the Middle East. The word "Mizrachi" comes from the Hebrew word for Eastern. Ladino is the traditional language associated with the Sephardim. Sephardim have tended to live in Islamic environments and have Arabic and Greek influences. Ashkenaz was the name given to the area of settlement of the Jews of North western Europe, initially on the banks of the Rhine. The term became associated with Germany, and German Jews and their descendants living in other countries. Many of the Jews of the Irish Jewish communities are Ashkenazi in origin. Yiddish is the traditional language associated with the Ashkenazic Jews (Ashkenazim). Ashkenazim tended to live in more Christian environments. There are differences between the groupings, culturally, in their observations of laws, choice of foods, holiday customs, liturgies, music, and some Hebrew word pronunciations. LITERACY MOMENT Example of a QuAD: Based on the sources from this initial exercise using texts, words and images. QuADs help you to look at a text and explore it in more detail, taking account of important information in the process.
  • 19. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 19 Complete the following columns? Questions Answers Details Sources 1. What is the name of the town which is mentioned in the first text box? 2. When was that town first established? 3. When did Jews begin to settle in that area? 4. What happened that made life difficult for them in the 1800s? 5. What is meant by the word Immigration? 6. What area of the world is indicated by the map? 7. Can you name any countries on that map which have particular significance for the origins of Irish Jews? 8. To what does the word Ashkenazic refer? 9. How did people end up on the shores of Ireland in the waves of immigration? 10. What is illustrated in the photograph from Cork? 11. What are the languages of the inscription on the stone? 1. Ackmene. 2. In the 16th century. 3. In the 18th century. 4. The Russian/Tsarist Laws. 5. Immigration is the action of coming to live permanently in a foreign country. 6. Europe. 7. Ireland, Lithuania, Germany, Poland, Czech Republic, Slovakia, France. 8. Eastern European Jewish tradition. 9. Because they came on ships and sometimes they were not sure of their destinations, or else they were sick, or if they were observant Jews they needed to stock up on their kosher foods. 10. The Curraghkippane Cemetery in Cork. 11. English and Hebrew. THE IRISH JEWISH COMMUNITIES5 5 A one-hour documentary is available online which gives some insights into the Jewish community in Ireland and how they contributed to the development of Ireland and Israel: http://www.shalomireland.com/ The material in this section about the Irish Jewish communities is abridged from Ray Rivlin, Jewish Ireland: A Social History (Dublin: The History Press Ireland, 2011; updated version of Shalom Ireland published in 2003)
  • 20. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 20 Dublin6 In 1660, the earliest recorded synagogue was established, consisting of a prayer room in Crane Lane, opposite Dublin Castle. The oldest Jewish cemetery dates from the early 1700s, and is situated near Ballybough Bridge, Clontarf, Dublin 3. Anglicised Jews who lived in Dublin before the Russian immigrants arrived had been designated the Dublin Hebrew Congregation in 1839. Their synagogue or shul was in 12 Mary’s Abbey on the northside of the city. It was established in 1836 with seating capacity of 90-220. The Russian Chevra (religious group) opened two small prayer houses in vicinity of Lower Clanbrassil Street and South Circular Road, an initiative resented by the established Dublin Hebrew Congregation. In 1889, a representative group from the Russian Chevra approached Mary’s Abbey to discuss the prospect of amalgamation. A year later, £100 was contributed by Sir Julian Goldsmid ‘to the building fund of the new synagogue ... at Dublin’. The building was completed in 1892 in Adelaide Road and it was Ireland’s first purpose-built synagogue. It was consecrated by Dr Adler, Chief Rabbi of the United Hebrew Congregations in the British Empire on 9 December 1892. It seated 450 people with overflow accommodation in the basement and it was easily accessible by foot from South Circular Road. It did not unite the Dublin Jewish community and was perceived to attract those who were less Orthodox and better educated. 6 There is a lovely article worth reading entitled ‘A Stroll Through Jewish Dublin’ and is available at the following URL: <http://www.theirishstory.com/2012/02/27/a-stroll-through-jewish- dublin/#.UMRh6Y5hra4>
  • 21. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 21 Synagogues in 7 St Kevin’s Parade and 32 Lennox Street continued to function. By 1912 others in Lombard Street West, 1 / 2 Oakfield Place, Heytsbury Street, 52 Camden Street and 3 Walworth Road were also in existence. The Lithuanian Jews settled south of the centre in an area that was eventually dubbed “Little Jerusalem.” Many of the immigrants became peddlers, petty traders and moneylenders. The second-generation would eventually go on to become a major force in the manufacture of clothing and furniture. Even with this amount of places, the flow of immigrants continued and premises were inadequate to accommodate them. Representatives of four different synagogues met in Longwood Avenue on 10 October 1909 to discuss the situation. They became the founders of the Dublin United Hebrew Congregation and eventually a site, Greenville House, Dolphin’s Barn, on the southside of the city, was purchased in 1913 for £625. It was officially opened in 1916. In 1922, a new Building Committee raised a loan of £5,000 to erect the long-awaited synagogue. Greenville Hall Synagogue was consecrated in 1925. Dr Isaac Herzog was appointed Chief Rabbi of Dublin from 1919 but his status changed in 1926 to Chief Rabbi of the Irish Free State, encompassing the Jewish communities of Cork, Limerick and Waterford, in addition to Dublin. Rabbi Herzog had a significant influence on the relationships between the Jewish and non-Jewish communities. He had an affable personality, and was gentle, humble, and highly respected. De Valera said of him, ‘From the moment I met him, I felt in the presence of a good and holy man.’ Rabbi Herzog was appointed Chief Rabbi of Palestine from 1936 which left the post vacant in Ireland for almost thirteen years. The Rathmines Hebrew Congregation, catering for the Jewish communities of Rathmines, Rathgar and Terenure, had their synagogue in 6 Grosvenor Place. By 1940, with increased numbers they moved to 52 Grosvenor Road. Later again, they ecided to erect a purpose-built synagogue in Terenure. ‘Leoville’ on 32a Rathfarnham Road was bought for £1,490. When the renamed Terenure Hebrew Congregation opened Terenure Synagogue in 1953, its seating capacity of 600 made it the largest synagogue to be built in Ireland in the thirty-five years. The prospect of amalgamating the Dublin synagogues was again discussed but no consensus achieved. A new Chief Rabbi for Ireland was appointed in February 1949: Rabbi Immanuel Jakobovits. Jewish population in Ireland had dropped from 3,907 in 1946 to 3,255 in 1961, which meant that they now had more capacity in the combined existing synagogues than was actually necessary. A number of factors contributed to this decrease: emigration, intermarriage, and smaller Jewish families. Community debts were increasing. The founding of the first
  • 22. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 22 Progressive synagogue was another factor which impinged on the Orthodox population. The Progressive strand of Judaism are more liberal in their approach to Judaism compared to the Orthodox. According to Rabbi Jakobovits it was a ‘new and potentially growing splinter group’ pioneered by Larry Elyan, its first chairman. In the early 1960s, Lombard Street Synagogue closed and St Kevin’s Parade Synagogue relocated to 77 Terenure Road North (now Machzeikei Hadas Hebrew Congregation). Greenville Hall’s population had halved in ten years due to migration away from the South Circular Road vicinity. In 1959 another Chief Rabbi was appointed to Ireland: Dr Isaac Cohen. He was glad to be able to uphold ‘the great traditions of Irish Jewry’ which he defined as Jewish education, the maintenance of facilities for fulfilling religious obligations and care of the sick and needy. Ireland Fourth Chief Rabbi David Rosen took up office in 1979. He had estalished the Council for Christians and Jews in Ireland and set up a programme in Christian-Jewish relations at the Irish School of Ecumenics. In the 1980s, the Lennox Street and Walworth Road synagogues finally closed, followed by Greenville Hall. Ephraim Mirvis came to Ireland from Israel in 1982 on Rosen’s recommendation to fill the post of communal rabbi at Adelaide Road. In 1984 he became the fifth Chief Rabbi of Ireland. He shared Lithuanian ancestry with many of the Jewish community in Dublin at that time. He was anxious to make Judaism ‘relevant, meaningful and exciting’. Changes in the Jewish population in Dublin left only a few who were strictly Observant. Driving to synaguge for Sabbath, eating non-kosher food in public places were becoming more common practices. With Jewish (and Christian) society moving towards greater secularisation, the number of regular shul (synagogue) attenders continued to decline. With the attachments to both the Adelaide Road and Terenure Synagogues being strong, it meant that the decision to have to close one again was more painful. The Adelaide Road site was sold in 1999 for approximately £6,000,000. Progressive Jewish membership remained steady with converted non-Jewish spouses and occasional defectors from the Orthodox communities replacing members who emigrated or died.
  • 23. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 23 Today, there are three synagogues in Dublin: Machzekei Hadass (Terenure) Dublin Hebrew Congregation (Rathfarnham Road, Terenure), and the Dublin Jewish Progressive Congregation (Kenilworth). Exercise 1. Where did the Jewish communities in Dublin come from originally? 2. What were the factors contributing to the growth of the Jewish communities in Dublin? 3. What parts of Dublin were the Jewish shuls to be found? 4. In present-day Dublin, where are the synagogues of Dublin to be found? 5. How does the population of Jews in Dublin differ from the 1880s? 6. How many Jewish congregations are in Dublin and where are they located? Exercise In the following map of Dublin City Centre, locate the following and insert an X in the map below:  Mary’s Lane (St Mary’s Abbey is near this)  Adelaide Road  South Circular Road  Kevin Street  Camden Street  Clanbrassil Street From http://www.dublincitymap.com/
  • 24. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 24 2. Create an Animoto Clip to present information about the Jewish community in Dublin including photographs, maps, short text headings and information which would give the viewer some idea of the history of the history of Dublin Jewish communities. (Details of making Animoto Clips are in the Teacher Resource Section) THE IRISH JEWISH COMMUNITIES Cork Cork’s Jewish community was thought to have originated with Sephardic Jews from Portugal. Two centuries before, the Jews of Spain (1492) and Portugal (1496) were expelled. The first Jewish mayor of Youghal, William Annyas, was elected Mayor of Youghal in 1555. William Annyas From http://media1.picsearch.com/is?eVhmY4e7b-dA_DY_drvAIwr49kr6l_F2cc6nffQRy10 His descendants were from Portugal. Many of those who arrived from the Iberian Peninsula to Ireland were known as Marrano Jews, those who were forced to convert to Christianity but continued to observe their religious practices in secret. The community which arrived to Cork in 1772 was from Portugal. There was a synagogue at Cork also in the first half of the eighteenth century, with its own Shochet7 and its burial-ground in Kemp Street, Cork, behind the present synagogue in No. 10 South Terrace; it was founded apparently between 1731 and 1747, but was no longer in use by 1796. This community faded through assimilation and intermarriage with local Protestant families. Records show that from 1891, a second community emerged in Cork but this community was Ashkenazi originating from the town Yakmyan in Kovno (former White Russia, present-day Lithuania, also known as Kaunas), in a very 7 A Shochet is a person who is trained and licenced to slaughter and inspect animals and birds in accordance with Jewish law so that what is to be consumed is kosher.
  • 25. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 25 Catholic country where persecution of Jews was rife. It is unlikely that those fleeing persecution in a Catholic country would choose to live in another Catholic country. The Cork Hebrew Congregation’s website gives the following explanations: Among various explanations proposed, it may have been the case that an unscrupulous ship-captain advised the Jews to disembark and row to America to save money. Possibly they confused ‘Cork’ for New York (the Jews spoke only Yiddish, and the words are – slightly – cognate). From Cobh (then Queenstown), where they disembarked, the Jews made their way into Cork City, and specifically settled in an area known as Hibernian Buildings, in the City Centre, soon to be known as ‘Jewtown’ by the locals. Their employment was usually in peddling materials and as door-to-door salesmen. Among themselves, they were known as vicklemen (vickle means weekly in Yiddish, and their door-to-door rounds took roughly a week). They would travel around Cork City and its surrounding areas knocking on doors and selling various things to the local Catholic farming community. When they discovered that Ireland was hospitable towards Jews, they decided to bring their families, so that the population of the Cork community peaked at the turn of the 20th century. Originally, this community prayed in a small room in Eastville, and subsequently renting a property in Marlboro Street. Later again, they transferred to where the present synagogue is located at 10 South Terrace. A cemetery was acquired in the outskirts of the city at Curraghkippane. The Commissioners of National Education oversaw the establishment of the first Jewish school, South Terrace National Schools, in 1891. At its peak of about 450-500 people in 1939, the Jewish community was very active. Before the decline in numbers, there were two football clubs, a table tennis clubs, a debating club, a branch of the Bnei Akiva (Zionist Youth Movement), as well as, of course, an officiating ‘Reverend’, a butcher, a doctor and a Chevra Kedushsa (burial society). The sons and the grandsons of the peddlers and vicklemen had qualified as professionals in University College Cork and wanted to leave for a place with greater Jewish life and professional opportunities. There was also emigration to the State of Israel, established in 1948. The combination of emigration to Israel and the U.S. (among other destinations) resulted in a steady decline in number which persisted from the late 1930s until the 1980s, by which stage only 15 to 20 Jews remained in Cork, Ireland. At present there are only two families left, as well as a scattering of Jews in the surrounding country, as well as occasional visitors and business-people who may come to pray at the shul. Because of the decline in numbers, services are now only conducted every fourth Friday night, and during the High Holidays. Even during the High Holidays, Rabbis have to be ‘imported’ from the UK to make a Jewish religious quorum (Minyan) of ten men in order to be able to conduct a service.
  • 26. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 26 Exercise 1. True or False (a) The first Jewish Community in Cork originated in Russia. (b) William Annyas was the first Lord Mayor of Cork city. (c) Chevra Kedusha is the Jewish burial society. (d) The second Jewish community in Cork was Sephardic. (e) The area in which they settled in Cork was known as the Hibernian Buildings and ‘Jewtown’ by the locals. (f) Shochet is food which is ritually slaughtered. (g) The Jewish community in Cork peaked to a population of almost 500 in 1939. (h) The present Jewish community in Cork is located at 10 North Terrace. (i) Bnei Akiva is a Zionist Youth Movement. (j) A minyan is the ten men required in order to conduct an Orthodox service. 2. Compare the Dublin and Cork Jewish communities in their growth and development through the years. THE IRISH JEWISH COMMUNITIES Limerick In the 1870 a small group of families from Lithuania settled in the Collooney Street and Lord Edward Street areas of Limerick. In 1871 there were only two Jews recorded as living in Limerick but waves of immigration began to come from Czarist Russia and augment the city’s population. Prayers were said in a private house in Emmet Place (Wolfe Tone Street) until a regular place of worship was opened in 18 Collooney Street in 1889. The census of 1901 said that there were 168 Jews in Limerick. In 1902 a cemetery had been established in Kilmurray, Newcastle, Limerick. Such was the relationship between the Jews and their surrounding neighbours that they used to contribute to one another’s charitable causes. The following account from Gerald Goldberg’s sister, Fanny, gives an indication of the lengths some families went to, in order to keep a Sabbath: Buba [Grandmother] always did the cooking and serving, my mother looking after us children, and helping my father in the shop [a drapery shop on Henry Street, Limerick]. The table was always beautifully laid with a white tablecloth, sometimes
  • 27. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 27 lace-trimmed, with the candles lighting in the shining brass candlesticks. These candlesticks were brought over from Russia by Buba. The cutlery cleaned and a cruet stand was in the centre of the table with the various condiments in the cut glass bottles. The stand was old Sheffield plate polished to the gleam of silver. Wine was in a lovely cut glass decanter, a very lovely one as I remember it. According to family folklore, Louis Goldberg was conscripted to the army at the age of 14 in Akmene in Lithuania. Louis fled, going to Riga where the authorities sent back some boys who were seeking to emigrate to the US. Gerald Goldberg suggested that because of his fair colouring, he was allowed to proceed and found his way to Ireland on a timber ship. This was meant to be the first part of his journey to the US. It was 1882. Having spent sojourns in Cork, and Dublin, he settled in Limerick in 1883. According to the census the Jewish population in the developing community was cited as follows: 1861, 1 Jew; 1871, 2 Jews; 1881, 4 Jews; 1888, 35 Jews; 1892, 90; 1896, 130 Jews; 1901, 168 Jews. The increase in numbers reflected the migrations from Russia after the May Laws were instigated. Anti-Jewish incidents were noted in 1884 or 1892. In 1884, a Jew had slaughtered a chicken in ritual fashion on Good Friday and, in protest, some locals threw stones in through the windows of Lieb Siev’s house injuring Siev’s wife and children. Fanny Goldberg remembered how Jewish pedlars were jeered by local children chanting the following words: ‘A pitchie [picture]man, a tallyman, a Jew, Jew, Jew.’ Following the pogrom in Limerick in 1904, Louis Goldberg and his family moved to Cork. A Redemptorist priest, Fr John Creagh, formed in very conservative French Catholicism of the time, launched a vicious verbal attack against the Jewish community, inciting the Roman Catholic community to boycott Jewish traders.8 This boycott was manifested economically, socially, and often in violent attacks. He said that Jews were ‘sucking the blood of other nations, and must not be allowed to do the same in Ireland’. He pleaded with his congregation ‘not to prove false to Ireland, false to your country and false to your religion, by continuing to deal with the Jews’. Six days after that, Elias Bere Levin reported that the Jews of Limerick were ‘insulted, assaulted and threatened with the most menacing language’. Newspaper correspondence exchanged prevalent views of the time and some distanced themselves from such ‘narrow-minded bigotry’. Some were in support of the Jewish communities. O’Grady stated ‘These Limerick Jews seem to be a very harmless body, neither money-lenders nor extortioners; just traders trading in clothes and selling the same at no more profit than is permitted’. The boycott lasted almost two years and resulted in the reduction of the Jewish community to approximately forty people. The Jewish community of Limerick was irreparably and irrevocably damaged. After that, they dispersed mainly to Cork, Dublin or travelled further afield to the US. 8 If you are seeking further information on this topic, look at this website from Limerick City Council: http://www.limerickcity.ie/media/jews%20of%20limerick%2038.pdf
  • 28. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 28 Exercise (a) From where did the Jewish community of Limerick originate? (b) Give four facts about their place of origin. (c) Why did they settle in Limerick? (d) What parts of the city were home to the Jewish community? (e) What evidence do we have of the community trying to maintain its traditions? (f) Why was there such an increase in the city’s Jewish population over the late 1800s? (g) What was a pogrom? (h) Why was a progrom organised against the city’s Jews? (i) What were the direct affects of this pogrom for the Jewish residents and for those of the city? 2. Write an newspaper account of the history of the Jews in Limerick 3. Imagine you have just arrived into Limerick in the early part of the 19th century. Describe life for you at that time and where you had come from in order to get there. THE IRISH JEWISH COMMUNITIES Belfast Dr Alexander Carlebach, rabbi to the Belfast community from 1959-1967 said that Belfast had a synagogue in Great Victoria Street, with its own minister and choir since the 1870s when the Russian immigrants began to arrive. German- born Daniel Joseph Jaffe had founded the first community there in 1871. He had a linen business and this was a major source of exports from the city to the continent of Europe. Between 1871 and 1903 this congregation increased from 55 to over 1,000 members. Otto Jaffe (1846-1949), son of Daniel Joseph Jaffe, the twice-elected Mayor of Belfast and member of this congregation, paid most of the £4,000 cost of
  • 29. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 29 building the synagogue in Annesley Street, near Carlisle Circus, which was opened in 1904. This was an attempt to unite the German-born Jews and Russian immigrants of which the community was comprised. Three years later with his wife, Paula, they set up the 'Jaffe School for the Jewish Children of Belfast' on the Cliftonville Road. A new synagogue was opened in 1965 at Sommerton Road, Belfast to replace the other building; this is an aerial photograph of the synagogue (Google). Now there are only about 100 members left in this community.9 Exercise 1. When was the first Jewish community established in Belfast? 2. Where was the original location? 3. Who were the key people mentioned in this text above? 4. What difficulties might have been presented by Jews of German and Russian origin being part of one congregation in the 1800s? 5. What contributed to the increase in the congregation’s size between 1871- 1903? 6. What do you notice about the design on the roof of the Sommerton Road synagogue as illustrated in the photograph above? Important Dates in Irish Jewish History: Summary Sheet Fill in the missing dates below 1. Legends (a) Tuatha de Danann – thought to be part of the tribe of Dan (b) Lia Fáil at Tara – thought to be stone used by Jacob as the pillow when he dreamt of the ladder (c) Legend that an Ark of treasures of the Temple are buried at Tara (d) Ten Lost Tribes came to Ireland (e) Name of Kippure mountain (South Dublin/Wicklow) derived from Yom Kippur. 2. Early References (a) Annals of Innisfallen (Insert date) (b) 1170 – Strongbow’s invasion of Ireland, part-financed by Jews from Gloucester (c) 1232 – Viceroy of Ireland given custody of Jews in Ireland (d) First Jewish Mayor of Youghal: William Annyas (Insert date) 3. Foundation of Community (Dublin) (a) c.1660 – founding of shul (another word for synagogue) in Crane Lane by three Conversos (b) 1718 – land for Ballybough Cemetery acquired (c) 1746 – record of shul in Marlborough Street (in reality, Lower Abbey Street – 1762- 1790) (d) 1822 – founding of Stafford Street Shul – 1835 (e) Mary’s Abbey Shul (Insert date) 4. Modern Community (a) Adelaide Road Shul (Insert date) (b) Greenville Hall Shul (Insert date) 9 Interview with Adrian Levy, member of the Jewish Community in Belfast: <http://www.jewishbelfast.com/index.php?cmd=viewsong&viid=12>
  • 30. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 30 (c) Shtibblach (House of worship for a Hasidic group) – St Kevin’s Parade, Lombard Street West, Lennox Street, Walworth Road, Lower Ormond Quay. (d) 1918 – creation of Chief Rabbinate. First incumbent Rabbi Isaac Herzog (1937) (e) 1934 – Talmud Torah moved to Bloomfield Avenue and re-opened as Zion Schools (f) 1889 – creation of Board of Guardians (g) 1935 – Jewish representative Council set up 5. Belfast (a) First record of Jews in the city (Insert date) (b) Great Victoria Street Shul opened (Insert date) (c) 1898 – National school where Jewich children had religious education opened (d) Sir Otto Jaffe (1836-1939) elected Lord Mayor (Insert date) 6. Limerick (a) c.1880 – Jewish presence established (b) c.1920s – formal shul in Colooney Street (c) The Limerick Pogrom (Insert date) 7. Cork (a) c.18th century – scant evidence of community (b) c.1860s – establishment of modern communities Exercise Interview/Survey: Finding out about one Jewish Community in Ireland. Select a Jewish community and survey the community by finding answers to some of the following questions: (a) What branch of Judaism is represented by this community? (b) What is its history and origins? (c) How many people does this community serve? (d) What are the roles and functions of the Jewish Representative Council? (e) What is the Board of Guardians? (f) Who is the rabbi for this community? (g) What is the name of the synagogue where this community gathers? (h) What happens in the synagogue? (i) What is the symbolism of the different parts of the synagogue in relation to the Jewish community? (j) Who conducts and attends the services within the synagogue? (k) How are people involved in the educational activities of the Jewish community? (l) What are the community’s charitable commitments? When students have completed their research each is asked to make a presentation of their findings to the rest of the class i.e. through project, photos, creation of a video, podcast, powerpoint, write-up of interview. L-I-N-K-S
  • 31. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 31 Jews from different parts of Ireland have made an important contribution to Irish society. Here we present a list of Jews who have made a contribution and there is a creative way of investigating some of these in the form of a WebQuest which follows below. List of Irish Jews who have made a Significant Contribution Nationally and Internationally Lenny Abrahamson Irish Film Director Leonard Abrahamson (1920s-1961), Gaelic scholar, who switched to medicine and became a professor, was born in Russia, grew up in Newry where he attended the local Christian Brothers school and lodged with the Nurock family in Dublin while studying at Trinity College, Dublin. William Annyas (Ãnes), Mayor of Youghal (1555) a Marrano merchant. Francis Annyas (Ãnes), Mayor of Youghal in 1569, 1576 and 1581, Youghal garrison commander and a spy for Francis Drake. Justice Henry Barron, Irish Supreme Court judge 1997-2003. Leopold Bloom, fictional protagonist of Ulysses. Louis Bookman (1890–1943), Irish international soccer and cricket player. Michael Noyk Irish Republican and solicitor during the Irish War of Independence. Robert Briscoe, member of the Irish Republican Army during the Anglo- Irish War and twice Lord Mayor of Dublin (1956 and 1961). Ben Briscoe (son of Robert Briscoe), former Fianna Fáil T.D. and Lord Mayor of Dublin (1988). Joe Briscoe (son of Robert Briscoe), member of the Jewish Representative Council (predating Israeli Embassy) and Commandant in the Irish Army[40] Michelle Citron, feminist film, video and multimedia producer, scholar and author. Max Eager (son of George Eager), first Chief Rabbi of Ireland. Daniel Day-Lewis, actor. Maurice Freeman (1875–1951), Mayor of Johannesburg 1934/35. Gerald Goldberg, Lord Mayor of Cork in 1977. Rabbi Yitzhak HaLevi Herzog, Chief Rabbi of Ireland from 1919 to 1937, later of Palestine and Israel. Chaim Herzog, sixth President of Israel and British World War II veteran. During and after his service in the British Army, he was also known as "Vivian Herzog" ("Vivian" being the English equivalent of the Hebrew name "Chaim".) Sir Otto Jaffe, Lord Mayor of Belfast (1899 and 1904). Immanuel Jakobovits, Chief Rabbi of Ireland between 1949 and 1958, later British Chief Rabbi.
  • 32. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 32 Harry Kernoff, painter (1900–1974) Louis Lentin, director (documentary films, television, theatre). Ronit Lentin, Head of Sociology, the director of the M Phil in Race, Ethnicity, Conflict, Department of Sociology and founder member of the Trinity Immigration Initiative, Trinity College, Dublin. June Levine, feminist, journalist and writer. Maurice Levitas (1917–2001) (born Dublin) was an anti-fascist who took part in the Battle of Cable Street and fought in the International Brigades during the Spanish Civil War. He is the father of Ruth Levitas. David Marcus (1924–2009), author, editor, broadcaster and lifelong supporter of Irish-language fiction. David Marcus, author and professor of Bible and ancient languages at The Jewish Theological Seminary. Max Nurock, Israeli Consul-General to Australia, subsequently Israel's first Ambassador to Australia. Yaakov Pearlman, Ireland's Chief Rabbi. Alan Shatter, Fine Gael TD for Dublin South and currently Minister for Justice and Equality and Minister for Defence. Bethal Solomons (1885–1965), medical Doctor, Master of the Rotunda, Irish Rugby International. Estella Solomons (1882–1968), landscape and portrait artist and member of Cumann na mBan. Stella Steyn (1907–1987), Dublin-born artist. Mervyn Taylor, former Labour Party TD and Minister for Equality and Law Reform. Abraham Weeks (or Abraham Wix) was the first person killed during 1916 Easter Rising A Jewish comrade who joined on Easter Monday and died in action. He joined the Irish Citizen Army and assigned to the GPO. Gustav Wilhelm Wolff, founder of Harland and Wolff shipbuilders, MP for East Belfast for 18 years. District Judge Hubert Wine, family court judge and prominent member of Dublin's Jewish community WebQuest Jews and their Contribution to Irish Life This material is adapted from a website entitled ‘A Woman’s Place: A WebQuest about Jewish Women in Jewish History’ from the Lookstein Centre for Jewish Education at the following address: http://www.lookstein.org/webquests/jewishwomeninjewishhistory.htm The following is a template for exploring, through the use of web materials, the contribution of members of the Jewish community to the cultural, educational, artistic, political and sporting life of Ireland. For the purposes of the exercise here, three members have been selected. The web resources used are limited but it will be possible for you to look at different websites and choose what you
  • 33. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 33 consider appropriate. It will be imperative to choose sites with care, discernment and appropriateness in mind. Introduction The Jewish Chronicle has decided to run a feature on members of the Jewish community who have contributed to the cultural, educational, artistic, political and sporting life of Ireland. They have asked a panel of historians to nominate the Jewish people of their choice from these categories. The historians have narrowed down the list to the following people (in no particular order): Louis Lentin (Film Producer and Member of Aosdana) Alan Shatter (Minister for Justice and member of Fine Gael) David Marcus (Author, broadcaster, life-long supporter of Irish language fiction) Other famous Irish Jewish people whom you could invesigate include the following: Ben Briscoe (Lord Mayor of Dublin in 1988 and former member of Fianna Fail); Ruth Romney (Sculptor); Ronit Lentin (Head of Sociology and Director of the M Phil in Racism and Ethnicity; Leonard Abrahamson (Professor of Pharmocology, and later of Medicine, at Royal College of Surgeons of Ireland, Gaelic scholar); June Levine (Journalist, Novelist and Feminist) or any other Irish Jewish figures of your choice. Now the readers of The Jewish Chronicle will vote for the person whom they consider to have made the greatest impact in Irish Jewish history. You, as a journalist at The Jewish Chronicle, have been asked to write the biography of one of the personalities. In your biography, you must convince readers why they should vote for this personality. Task You are one of the journalists assigned to this story. Each journalist will take one of the people from the list above (either the one that you can most identify with and most interests you or that is allocated to you by the editor) and write a series of biographical features on him/her, in order to convince the readers of The Jewish Chronicle to vote for this personality. Process In order to do this, you must follow the following format (as requested by the editor!) and complete the tasks in each stage. Your editor will be checking your work at each stage, so remember to keep your work organized! The resulting article in its finished state will be printed in a specially constructed edition of The Jewish Chronicle (or perhaps your school newspaper or website). Stage One - Research You must carry out an in-depth research on the personality that you have been assigned (using the online resources suggested below as well as any other resources that your editor can recommend to you). Make sure to include the following information: Full name
  • 34. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 34 Place of birth When he/she lived (Dates of birth, and death where relevant) Historical Context Childhood experiences Educational Background Life experiences Skills/talents Personality Greatest influences he/she had (role models, etc.) His/Her impact on Irish Jewish history Stage Two - Biography Now you have carried out your research, you must write the biographical piece. Use all the information asked of you in stage one and any other interesting facts to compile a comprehensive biography of the person from Irish Jewish history that you have been allocated. Remember, you are trying to convince your readers that this is the person that has made the most important impact on Irish Jewish history, so make your biography exciting! Stage Three - In an Irish Jewish Historical Perspective You must now write a few paragraphs explaining to your readers exactly why you think that this personality has made the greatest impact on Irish Jewish History. Include why he has had a great impact on YOUR life. In this article you must build a convincing argument as to why the readers should vote for this person. Stage Four - A Day in the Life As a secondary feature, compose a “day in the life of” feature on the personality. This can either take the form of a diary entry in the fictitious diary of the personality (you may wish to choose an important or special day in his life or an important date in Irish Jewish history where he played a part) or you may just wish to capture his life by taking an average day from his life and writing his schedule. This is a creative writing piece (you should try to keep to the facts but will not have enough information from you research alone to do this) and your editor will be noting your creativity. Stage Five - Interview As a secondary feature, write a fictitious interview with the personality. You must first think of interesting and probing questions about his life and experiences and his impact on Irish Jewish history. You must then decide how you think he would answer those questions. You must try and express his personality through his answers, and at the same The Jewish Chronicle portray an insight into the events that shaped his life and his contribution to Irish Jewish history. This is creative writing (you should try to keep to the facts but will not have enough information from you research alone to do this) and your editor will be noting your creativity. Stage Six – Presentation
  • 35. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 35 You have now completed your research and writing on the personality. All you have to do now is present it in an attractive way to your readers (or more importantly to your editor!). If you have knowledge of desktop publisher software then use that, but if not, you can still do a good exercise using a word processor. If you can find pictures to include in the feature, all the better. After putting it together in an attractive and organized manner, hand it in to your editor. Resources General Jewish Virtual Library, The Virtual Jewish History Tour: Ireland http://www.jewishvirtuallibrary.org/jsource/vjw/Ireland.html The Jews of Ireland, Robert Tracy http://www.ucc.ie/icms/irishmigrationpolicy/Judaism%20The%20Jews%20of %20Ireland.htm Ireland’s Jews: A Fading Tribe on the Emerald Isle http://www.isjm.org/jhr/IInos1-2/ireland.htm Louis Lentin (Film Producer and Member of Aosdana) Aosdana: http://aosdana.artscouncil.ie/Members/Literature/Lentin.aspx?Cnuas=1 [accessed 23 November 2011] Grandpa… speak to me in Russian, Louis Lentin http://www.imrstr.dcu.ie/currentissue/Vol_3_Issue_1_Louis_Lentin.pdf Lentin’s works as director, producer and writer http://www.imdb.com/name/nm2310417/ Alan Shatter (Minister for Justice, Equality and Defence, and member of Fine Gael) Political Profile http://www.oireachtas.ie/members- hist/default.asp?housetype=0&HouseNum=30&MemberID=1028&ConstID=90 Some important issues which the Minister has to deal with on any day http://www.kildarestreet.com/search/?pid=6&s=section%3Awrans&pop=1 David Marcus (Author, broadcaster, life-long supporter of Irish language fiction)
  • 36. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 36 David Marcus dies, RTE news http://www.rte.ie/news/2009/0509/marcusd.html Obituary from The Guardian newspaper http://www.guardian.co.uk/books/2009/jun/12/obituary-david-marcus Information from the Munster Literature Centre http://www.munsterlit.ie/Writer%20pages/Marcus,%20David.html Conclusion Congratulations! You have written an important article on the contribution of Irish Jews to society. By completing this WebQuest, you have helped keep their memories alive. We all look forward to seeing your article published in The Jewish Chronicle! Evaluation This plan suggests possible grading standards for your WebQuest. Task Beginning Developing Accomplished Exemplary Stage 1 Research 1-5 Little evidence of research. Questions addressed inaccurately. 6-10 Evidence of some research. Most questions addressed accurately. No additional information provided. 11-15 Evidence of good research (use of resources listed here). All questions asked addressed accurately. Further information found. 15-20 (Max. 20) Evidence of extensive research (beyond the resources listed here). All questions asked addressed accurately. Further information found. Stage 2 Biography of first choice 1-5 Incomplete biography. Details are inaccurate. Poorly written. Organization and presentation is poor. 6-10 Complete biography. Details are accurate. Fairly written. No interesting further facts. Organization and presentation is poor. 11-15 All details are accurate. Thorough biography. Some interesting facts given. Well written. Organization and presentation is poor. 15-20 (Max. 20) Accurate details, thorough biography, interesting further facts included. Well written. Organization and presentation is good. Stage 3 Rationalizati on for choice as “Greatest Woman of Jewish History” 1-5 Legitimate justification for choice given. No further analysis shown. 6-10 Evidence of some analysis of character. Legitimate justification for choice given. 11-15 Evidence of extensive analysis of character and character’s achievements. Legitimate justification for choice given. Presentation poor. 15-20 (Max. 20) Evidence of extensive analysis of character and character’s achievements. Legitimate justification for choice given. Presentation good. Stage 4 1-3 4-7 8-11 12-15 (Max. 15)
  • 37. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 37 A “Day in the life” feature Attempts made to be creative. Personality is character not accurately captured. No references made to achievements and impact on Jewish history. Evidence of some creative thinking and writing. Attempts made to capture personality’s character, and some references made to achievements and impact on Jewish history. Evidence of creative thinking and writing. Successfully captures personality’s character. References made to achievements and impacts on Jewish history. Presentation poor. Well written, creative. Successfully captures personality’s character. References made to achievements and impacts on Jewish history. Presentation good. Stage 5 Interview of personality 1-3 Attempts made to be creative. Personality is not accurately captured. No references made to achievements and impact on Jewish history. 4-7 Evidence of some creative thinking and writing. Attempts made to capture personality’s character, and some references made to achievements and impact on Jewish history. 8-11 Evidence of creative thinking and writing. Successfully captures personality’s character. References made to achievements and impacts on Jewish history. Presentation poor. 12-15 (Max. 15) Well written, creative. Successfully captures personalities character. References made to achievements and impacts on Jewish history. Presentation good. Stage 6 Final presentation 1-3 Inaccurate spelling and grammar. Presentation lacks creativity and imagination, without clarity and neatness. 4-7 Inaccurate spelling and grammar. Presented creatively and with imagination, though without clarity and neatness. 8-11 Inaccurate spelling and grammar. Presented neatly and clearly. Presented creatively and with imagination. Professionally laid out. 12-15 (Max.15) Spelling and grammar accurate. Presented neatly and clearly. Presented creatively and with imagination. Professionally laid out. FACT FILE EXERCISE Complete the following fact files. Create your own fact files on other Jewish figures. FACT FILE CHAIM HERZOG Date and Place of Birth: __________________________________ Immigration to Palestine:__________ Role in Palestine:_________________ Ambassador to UN: _________________ Member of Knesset (Israeli Parliament): ______________________ President of Israel: _____________
  • 38. Jewish Studies, DWEC, NCCA, DES 38 Date and place of Death: __________________________________ FACT FILE MERVYN TAYLOR Date and Place of Birth: _____________________________________ Occupation:_________________________ Labour Party Membership: ______________________________________ Constituency: _______________________ Ministerial Roles: ______________________________________ Anti-Discrimination Bills: _________________________________________________________ _________________________________________________________ L-I-N-K-S We have been looking at the Jewish community in Ireland. Now let us take a look at the Jewish home, its distinctive features and observances. There are homes which are Jewish and not observant. There are other homes which are Jewish and very observant. Let us look at what follows.

×