The decorative media trap

  • 596 views
Uploaded on

Presented at CNIE, 2012, Canmore AB, May 2012 …

Presented at CNIE, 2012, Canmore AB, May 2012

This is a concept I devised some years ago. It provides a name for a very common phenomenon: the mistaken belief that something that looks good IS good. Educators fall into this trap ALL THE TIME when looking at online media but especially digital games.

It is also a BIG problem for organizations that fund the design and development of serious games - often times, they never bother to look beyond the still images.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads

Views

Total Views
596
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2

Actions

Shares
Downloads
3
Comments
0
Likes
0

Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
    No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. THE DECORATIVE MEDIA TRAP And how to avoid it. Katrin Becker, Ph.D.CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 1
  • 2. WHAT AM I PLAYING NOW?CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 2
  • 3. FIRST IMPRESSIONS Do they matter?CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 3
  • 4. FIRST IMPRESSION S You never get a second chance to make a first impression.CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 4
  • 5. A bad design with a good presentation is doomed eventually. A good design with a bad presentation is doomed immediately. Source: Akin’s Laws of Spacecraft Design (#20)CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 5
  • 6. DECORATIVE MEDIA PRINCIPLE • Promotes: • Scaffolding • Interest • Cues (mnemonics) • Mental Model FormationCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 6
  • 7. LINEAR VS. INTERACTIVE MEDIA • VIDEO : all about visual • Games : about interactionCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 7
  • 8. DECORATIVE MEDIA TRAP Attractive = GoodCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 8
  • 9. DECORATIVE MEDIA TRAPCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 9
  • 10. WRAPPERCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 10
  • 11. FUNCTIONALITY We reviewed each of these games to make sure that they provide students with skill development and critical thinking sequences.CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 11
  • 12. CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 12
  • 13. WRAPPERCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 13
  • 14. DIFFERENT WRAPPERCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 14
  • 15. GAMECNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 15
  • 16. SPLIT BRAINCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 16
  • 17. DNA GAMECNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 17
  • 18. CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 18
  • 19. CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 19
  • 20. CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 20
  • 21. CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 21
  • 22. SUDOKUCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 22
  • 23. DOING IT RIGHT…CNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 23
  • 24. THANKSCNIE 2012 © 2012 K.Becker Thursday, May-10-12 24