PROJECT REPORT                ONCOMPETETION IN MICROFINANCE MARKET   IN THE OPERATIONAL AREA OF HIH          SUBMITTED TO ...
AcknowledgementIn my venture of writing this report, I have a long list of people to thank for theirinteraction and help. ...
CERTIFICATEThis is to certify that Mr. Mohammad Azhar, pursuing MBA-Rural management in AmityUniversity-Uttar Pradesh succ...
TABLE OF CONTENTSAcknowledgement--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(i)C...
4.3.7. Quality of customer service----------------------------------------48                               4.3.8. Emotiona...
1.0.INTRODUCTIONJesus says: “man cannot live by the bread alone.” Abraham says “man lives by bread alone whenthere is no b...
1.1. Salient Features of SHGs:1. It is a homogeneous group of people of similar economic status and interest and an affini...
But out of necessity and enterprise, those located out of the banking world have found a wayout. It is called microfinance...
1.5. Research Objectives:The objectives of the study given by organization are:1. To determine the level of penetration of...
1.6.2 Selection of Branches, Staff and Respondents    The following three branches were selected in Kanchipuram district o...
The following categories of staff were selected for responding:-Table-2                               STAFFDESIGNATION    ...
1.7     Significant of the study          This study would be helpful to HIH to adopt new strategy (see page no.40-57) inw...
2.0 HAND IN HAND in brief (as in the organization’s MOA)Hand-in-Hand is a Public Charitable Trust registered in the year 2...
MicrofinanceIn Tamil Nadu, HIH one of the biggest NGO which provide loan on lowest interest rate andbecause of this Intern...
HIH growth and global presence              Public Charitable Trust.              Registered in the year 2002.            ...
Page 16
Overall Growth up to July 2011         •   Jobs created through SHGs – 801,842         •   Child - Friendly Panchayats– 79...
2.1.   Flash progress report of HIH**Resource*http://www.hihindia.org/handinhand/facts_and_figures/reports/annual_report_2...
3.0 Penetration of various competitors:In project area different types of MFI’s are working with full potential. These all...
Findings: - Total 180 SHGs are with Ragini NGO in CHENNA KAANCHIPURAM area.Members join this NGO because of lower interest...
Bandhan (NBFC)Group size                                  ---                   Depend on member availabilityTraining     ...
Gram Vidyal (NBFC)Group size                                  ---                                            15-20Training...
Mahashemam (NBFC)Group size                                ---                                          Up to 30Training  ...
Ashirwaad (NBFC): - On Rs.10,000 Ashirwaad charge Rs.560 for document procedure andtake weekly installment of Rs.225 for 5...
Urban: - In project area different type of MFIs working with full potential. These all are inform of NGOs as well as NBFCs...
NWTWS (NGO)Group size                                ---                                         12 - 15Total SHGs        ...
Mahashemam (NBFC)Group size                                ---                                          Up to 50Training  ...
Gram Vidyal (NBFC)Group size                                ---                                         Up to 25Training  ...
Equitas (NBFC)Group size                                 ---                                         Up to 20Training     ...
Overall view of urban area: More than 25 MFI’s actively working in urban area in this someNGO’s provide only bank linkages...
RuralIn project area different types of NGO & MFI play role as a lender. In village ASEFA, FFASLAshirvadam, & Mahashemam w...
AshirvadamOn Rs.10,000 they charge Rs.160 as document procedure and take Rs.960 as weekly installment.Overall interest is ...
3.1. Choice of getting loan at the time of needs in the villages (three year oldSHG)   •   Jewel loan                     ...
4.0 To assess the factors that help in client retentionCauses of desertion of the HIH can be categorized in five groups, w...
4.1. Why HIH SHGs are inactive? Some of the important reasons are: -      Multiple borrowing;      SHG members migrating t...
Findings: - Multiple borrowing is the main cause of dysfunction in SHGs. In urban areasborrowers do not want huge amount o...
4.2. Why HIH members migrated to other MFIs or NGOs?       Inadequate loan size from HIH;       Delay in providing loan;  ...
Overall view of 4.1 &4.2Four major reasons behind HIH SHGs being inactive are (a) Lack in group coordination,(b) Migration...
4.3. Causes of desertion in HIH;                                        STRUCTURAL                                      DE...
4.3.1 Growing competition:-       In the same target market 5-6 big names create face to face competition. For instance:  ...
4.3.2. Product adequacy: -       The basic credit product proposition, with stepped lending amounts, does not fit with the...
4.3.4 Regional and economic factor: -       Regional economic factor is one of the most influencing factor for desertion. ...
4.3.5 Product image: -       HIH has five types of loan products.       1- Grameen loan           a) first installment of ...
Findings: - In urban area 80% of borrowers not like Grameen loan because of its size and timeperiod. All SHG members did n...
4.3.7. Quality of customer service: -       Though HAND IN HAND still has lots of grounds with respect to improving custom...
My field interviews through up the following patterns in training:-In Rural Areas: -   % of three year old members who did...
Social services: -       HIH is well known for its social services. This is an NGO in Tamil Nadu which provides       a nu...
4.3.8 Emotional involvement: -      Emotional involvement plays a crucial role to coordinate in between both sides. As    ...
Techniques to build emotional involvements: -        1- TAKE CARE                                                 STRATEGY...
•   All borrowers bought sewing machines and they continually earn money and every        month they paid installment on t...
2- ROLE OF OPERATION / HR MANAGER FOR EMPLOYEE RETENTION         Note: - Because of two Credit Officer’s resignation 10 SH...
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Azhar to amity_2
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Azhar to amity_2

1,021
-1

Published on

Internship Report

Published in: Economy & Finance
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,021
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Azhar to amity_2

  1. 1. PROJECT REPORT ONCOMPETETION IN MICROFINANCE MARKET IN THE OPERATIONAL AREA OF HIH SUBMITTED TO Under the guidance of P. JOSEPH RAJ Chief Manager-Operation HAND IN HAND-KANCHEEPURAM S.P. JAKHANWAL, IAS (Retd.) Director General-ASRUM Submitted by Mohammad Azhar MBA-Rural Management (2010-12) Amity School of Rural Management Amity University Uttar Pradesh
  2. 2. AcknowledgementIn my venture of writing this report, I have a long list of people to thank for theirinteraction and help. This includes Mr. Joseph Raj (Chief Manager Operation) & Mr. S.P.Jakhanwal (DG, ASRUM), who really helped and mentored for achieving goals and targetsof the study.I would also like to thank all those staff of HAND IN HAND – Tamil Nadu who helped mein field for arranging meetings with members, group interactions and take care personally.Namely V. Priyasamy (Regional Manager), and his staff Mr. C.Udayaraj (BranchManager), Ms. Jareena Beevi (Credit Officer), Ms. K.Ramani (Credit Officer), Ms.Arockiamany (Credit Officer), Ms. Syamala (Credit Officer), Ms.T.Uma (CreditOfficer),Ms. D.Illamalli (Credit Officer), and Ms. D.Papitha Ponmalar (Branch Manager).Special thanks to all staff of SHG pillars. Personal thanks to Mr. Devaraj, G.Palanivel andmy hearty gratitude to Ms. Mohana for arranging travel; K.Thiyagarajan andN.Rathinasekar for arranging delicious food and thanks to all security staff ,drivers andcleaners.Finally, warm thanks to HAND IN HAND–Tamil Nadu & Amity University Uttar Pradeshfor giving an opportunity to work on challenging objectives.DATE: August 25, 2011 MOHAMMAD AZHARPLACE: Noida, India Page 2
  3. 3. CERTIFICATEThis is to certify that Mr. Mohammad Azhar, pursuing MBA-Rural management in AmityUniversity-Uttar Pradesh successfully completed six weeks of summer assignment under ‘GlobalLeaders’ Internship program with HAND IN HAND INDIA in Tamil Nadu in May – June 2011. . S.P. Jakhanwal – Director General-ASRUM Email - spj@amity.edu Phone India - +91-120-4392228Contacts;Email id; mba.azahar@gmail.com azhar.amity@gmail.comMob; +91-(0)9953151810Blog; http://blogs.siliconindia.com/AZHAR Page 3
  4. 4. TABLE OF CONTENTSAcknowledgement--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(i)Certificate-----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(ii)Table of Contents-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------(iii)1.0. INTRODUCTION-----------------------------------------------------------------------------6-12 1.1. Salient Features of SHGs-------------------------------------------------------------6 1.2. Status of Microfinance in India -----------------------------------------------------7 1.3. Statement of Problems----------------------------------------------------------------8 1.4. Introduction on Client Retention ---------------------------------------------------8 1.5. Research Objectives------------------------------------------------------------------9 1.6. Research Methodology---------------------------------------------------------------9 1.6.1. Research design-----------------------------------------------------9 1.6.2. Selection of Branches, Staff and Respondents----------------10 1.6.3. Duration of the study----------------------------------------------11 1.7.Significance of the study------------------------------------------------------------12 1.8.Limitations of the study--------------------------------------------------------------122.0. Introduction about the organization------------------------------------------------------13-18 2.1 Flash progress Report of HIH------------------------------------------------------183.0. Penetration of Various Competitors------------------------------------------------------19-33 3.1.Choice of getting loan at the time of needs in villages ------------------------33 3.2.Level of HIH penetration in village----------------------------------------------33 4.0. To assess the factors that help in client retention-------------------------------------34-55 4.1. Why are HIH SHGs inactive? ---------------------------------------------------34 4.2. Why did HIH member migrated to other MFI’s or NGO’s? -----------------37 4.3.Causes of desertion on HIH--------------------------------------------------------39 4.3.1. Growing competition-----------------------------------------------40 4.3.2. Product adequacy----------------------------------------------------41 4.3.3. Market adequacy----------------------------------------------------41 4.3.4. Regional and economic factor-------------------------------------42 4.3.5. Product image--------------------------------------------------------43 4.3.6. HIH image------------------------------------------------------------44 Page 4
  5. 5. 4.3.7. Quality of customer service----------------------------------------48 4.3.8. Emotional involvement---------------------------------------------52 4.3.9. Segmentation variables---------------------------------------------525. Customer Retention------------------------------------------------------------------------------55-586. Against social perspective---------------------------------------------------------------------------577. Frame work on Retention Improvement-----------------------------------------------------58-608. Response sheet from best SHG Interviews---------------------------------------------------61-68 8.1. Best SHG in Rural area----------------------------------------------------------61 8.2. Best SHG in Urban area---------------------------------------------------------659. Conclusion----------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------6910. Annexure-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------70-75 Annexure 1.0 (Gram Vidyal Loan card)---------------------------------------------------------70 Annexure 1.1 (Mahashemam Loan card)--------------------------------------------------------73 Annexure 1.2 (Samastha Microfinance Loan card)--------------------------------------------75 References-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------------7611. Opportunity with HIH--------------------------------------------------------------------------------7612. Suggestions page--------------------------------------------------------------------------------------7713. Reader comments-------------------------------------------------------------------------------------78 Page 5
  6. 6. 1.0.INTRODUCTIONJesus says: “man cannot live by the bread alone.” Abraham says “man lives by bread alone whenthere is no bread.” If a person is starving only food occupies his mind. He needs the bread. Itmay be not enough he needs many more things, but that many more things come only later on;first comes the bread. It is but natural that as soon as one need is satisfied, a second needbecomes apparent. The person forgets that he or she was starving and now starts to be concernedabout a need which was formerly of less significance. People are never completely satisfied onany need level, but a reasonable amount of gratification of first priority needs man beforthcoming if they are to perceive a lower priority need. However, it has to be noted that theprimary goal of both “poverty lending approach” and “financial systems approach” is providingfinancial services to the poor people. “A poor person has not known what riches are, he is not frustrated. How can he go beyond richesif he is not frustrated with them? A poor man also sometimes comes to me, but then he comes to me forsomething that I cannot supply. HE ASKS FOR SUCCESS.” (Rajneesh: The Guru of Self-help Movement)*What is Microfinance?The Microcredit Summit 2007*** defines microcredit as the extension of small loans toentrepreneurs too poor to qualify for traditional bank loan. It has proven as an effective andpopular measure in the ongoing struggles against poverty, enabling those without access tolending institutions to borrow at affordable interest rates and start small business. The keyimplication of microcredit is in its name itself ‘micro’. A number of issues come to mind when‘micro’ is considered: The small size of loans, small size of savings, the smaller frequency ofloans, shorter repayment periods and amounts, the micro/local level of activities, the community-based proximity of microcredit, etc.The Bangladesh experience has shown that programmes that empower women at the bottom canmake a real difference to the quality of life of the poor even under conditions of massdeprivation. This is reflected in the steady progress front. In a way, this represents a culminationof the growing recognition of micro-credit as an instrument of poverty alleviation, the worldover. Thirty years ago, the concept of micro-credit was unknown. Since then, its role in povertyalleviation and empowerment of the weaker sections has gained recognition in many developingcountries and even in a few developed ones. Today, it is active in more than 100 countries and issaid to have helped more than 125 million people take their steps to reduce poverty.**The biggest challenge to any civilized society is the economic deprivation of its bucolic part. Themost potent tool against human deprivation is building human capital among the deprived,through the sustainable development initiative which is taken by the deprived themselves. “Self-realization and self initiative are the two most powerful weapons to wash poverty from the worldmap” this dynamic quotation of world’s greatest economist Chanakya was translated to one wordthat is SHG.*** Page 6
  7. 7. 1.1. Salient Features of SHGs:1. It is a homogeneous group of people of similar economic status and interest and an affinitygroup.2. It is small in size and membership of one SHG is in the range from 10-20 people.3. Non-political and voluntary and follows democratic culture.4. SHGs have the transparency among themselves and they have the collective accountability offinancial transaction in the group.Mohammad Yunus (2004) stated that loners from the experience of other developing countrieslike Bangladesh, Indonesia, Bolivia and Philippines motivated India too to start experiencinginnovative scheme of SHGs which are also called as “thrift and credit groups”http://www.asienkunde.de/content/zeitschrift_asien/archiv/pdf/Schrader94.pdf. The SHG is a brain child of GrameenBank of Bangladesh which was founded by Prof. Mohammad Yunus of Chittagong University inthe year 1975. In India NABARD initiated it in 1986-87, but the perceptible progress was madeafter 1991-92 from the linkage of SHGs with the banks.Of late, some of the leading commercial banks such as ICICI bank, HDFC bank, UTI bank andthe State Bank of India, have begun focusing on this sector rather aggressively, may be, underthe pressure from the RBI and governments. Even some of the multinational banks operating inIndia, such as ABN Amro, Standard Chartered, HSBC and Citi- bank, have moved into thesector. Not to be outdone, the old generation banks located in south India, particularly Keralabased, Dhanalakshmi Bank have taken a great stride in meeting the aspirations of the poor andhave carried the mantle of microfinance across the state of Kerala. In Tamil Nadu, Indian Bankplays a very vital role in financing SHGs.1.2. Status of Microfinance in India.India has one of the largest networks of bank branches in the world, but the hundreds of millionsof poor in the country are largely out of it. Banks were nationalized three and half decades agowith the hope and promise that their products and services would reach the poor. But that goal isnot even close to being met today with 52,000 commercial bank branches, 14,522 branches ofRegional rural banks and 1, 00,000 Cooperative bank branches. The country is teaming withinstitutions that should be able to meet the credit needs of the people. But if you are poor, youare also probably out of luck with the banks; it is tough persuading them to ever let you open abank account. The consequences have been devastating. Consider these numbers; 75 millionhouseholds in India depend on moneylenders to meet financial needs; almost 90% of people inrural India have no access to insurance; 50 million households are landless and need small creditto start some economic activity. And even families earning Rs 5000-6000 a month in urban areasspends huge portions of their earnings to service their never ending debt.***** Page 7
  8. 8. But out of necessity and enterprise, those located out of the banking world have found a wayout. It is called microfinance- the enterprise of small loans to individuals who are too poor toqualify for traditional bank loans, as they have no assets to be offered as guarantee. In Indiamicrofinance has been working largely through SHGs. Predominated by women, these areformed with simple rules---save, accumulate and give loans to each other and also get loans fromfinancial institutions.India’s demand for microfinance is Rs.500 billion, and only Rs.31 billion of this amount hasbeen generated so far; these is still a long way to go. Nearly 7.5 million poor households in Indiadesperately want access to financial services to meet immediate needs. Almost 36% of thecountry’s rural households have to look for credit outside the formal sector. A World Bank studyof over 6000 families in Andhra Pradesh and Uttar Pradesh, two of India’s largest states, showsthat 87% of them have no access to credit, 85% had no access to insurance and 56% borrow frommoneylenders. For addressing this problem NABARD and lot of NBFC’s, NGO’s, and voluntaryorganization come to address it.******Top NBFC’s in India are as under: Top NGO’s in India are as under:SKS Microfinance Ltd (SKSMPL) HAND IN HAND Tamil NaduSpandana Sphoorty Financial Ltd (SSFL) MIMO Microfinance DehradunBandhan PRADANGrama Vidiyal Micro Finance Pvt Ltd (GVMFL)1.3. Statement of ProblemExcessive competition in market creates multiple borrowing, huge cash flow, over dues, excesspressure on members to repay loan, wrong practices in lending money and making over SHGsgroups are mainly causes of competition in between microfinance companies. Unfortunately themicrofinance industry is losing customers, mainly as a result of the MFI’s approach andstrategies. In many cases focus on credit sale, expansive marketing and bottom line results losescustomer preferences. In Microfinance, credit is only a means to satisfy their goals and not anend in and of it.1.4. Introduction on Client RetentionThe study of client retention provides insight into how to improve products and services offeredto the targeted market by developing effective retention programs and consequently creating longterm relationships between MFI’s and their clients. But why is relation so important? It is notonly because retaining a customer is less expensive than acquiring a new one or because of thenecessity of retaining customer until they are profitable? Rather, client retention is improvedbecause it is a value generation strategy for the MFI; that is the MFI’s value is not only related tobottom line of its financial statements but also to the present value of its future revenues.Guaranteeing the MFI’s future revenues greatly depends upon strengthening its customer’sloyalty. For this reason, two MFI’s with the same number of customers may have differentrevenue-streams. As such, customer retention is not only necessary for MFI sustainability but itis also a value generation strategy of the organization and shareholders. Page 8
  9. 9. 1.5. Research Objectives:The objectives of the study given by organization are:1. To determine the level of penetration of various competitors in the study area.2. To assess the main factors that help in client retention.3. To identify the problems that excessive competition may lead to like multiple borrowing, overindebtedness.4. To identify the unmet needs of clients.5. To suggest strategies to retain and increase current client base/market share.1.6. Research Methodology;Components of research methodology used in the present study are given below:1.6.1. Research Design • Desk research – It was undertaken to explore the current status of international microfinance market and also to collect information about technologies available for client retention. Desk research aims at searching for information from the available sources such as press, internet, analytical reports, and statistical publications. • Observation – It was undertaken to know the study area, culture of study area, time table of village respondents, suitability of urban respondent, CO’s availability etc. • Prepare questionnaire – Four type of questionnaire prepared for HIH staff members, three year old HIH SHGs, migrated drop out, inactive, dysfunction SHG of HIH and other MFI’s members. • Personal interviews – It was for three year old SHGs and dropout members, personal interview of staff as well as some other NGO’s founder. • Group discussions – This was adopted for knowing common problem of three year old SHG members. • Hypothesis tested: Does training help in client retention? Page 9
  10. 10. 1.6.2 Selection of Branches, Staff and Respondents The following three branches were selected in Kanchipuram district of Tamil Nadu toreceive the response of clients: - • S.V Chatram • Chinna Kanchipuram • St. Thomas MountTable-1 Category of Respondents Branch selected 3- year Migrated, Other MFI Total for old SHG’s Dropout & members respondent research members Inactive covered selected covered covered for research (Nos) (Nos) (Nos) (Nos) S.V CHATRAM 20 10 7 37 CHINNA 20 20 5 45 KAANCHIPURAM St. THOMAS MOUNT 20 20 10 50 (CHENNAI) TOTAL 60 50 22 132Source- field survey • Internship period 16th May– 24th June 2011 (6-Weeks) Page 10
  11. 11. The following categories of staff were selected for responding:-Table-2 STAFFDESIGNATION TOTAL RESPONDENTS TOTAL COVEREDCredit Officer 13 13Branch Accountant 2 2Branch Manager 4 4Regional Manager 2 2Chief Operating Officer 1 1Training Department 3 3Chief Manager 1 1Legal Advisor 1 1Credit Monitoring Manager 1 1Management Information 1 1DepartmentHR Manager 1 1Project Developer 1 1HO 1 1TOTAL 32 32 nd thNote: - On 2 & 6 June 2011, gave midterm presentation in Kanchipuram head office.Note: - May 23rd, 24th, 25th & 26th 2011 I observed field, members and did some auditing workon field with my mentor. Started field work on 27th with translator and one field staff like CreditOfficer, Branch managers etc.1 – We started field work from (27-05-11)2 – Total fifteen day we worked on field.3 – Total 164 respondent covered. [Members+Staff]4 – Average 11 respondents covered per day.5 – Last four days we spend in making report.Note: - Taken interview of VEED NGO founder at her home.1.6.3. Duration of the studyThe period of study was from 16th May 2011 to 24th June 2011. Page 11
  12. 12. 1.7 Significant of the study This study would be helpful to HIH to adopt new strategy (see page no.40-57) inworking area. This study also brings out the level of penetration of other MFI’s, NGO’s andother individual lenders with impact in working area. This study also helps to develop new MISand monitoring system because in this report mainly focuses on problems of clients and criticalevaluation of these problems. The hypothesis shows the importance of training and internal loanin working area because this report is totally based on primary data. The suggestions are made onthe basis of market needs.1.8. Limitations of the Study; Time was not enough for working and making report. Only three branches selected for field study. Small number of respondents chosen because of time limitation.References*“Microfinance redefining the future” book written by V.S. Somanath and published by Excel publication in 2009.**Sam Dalley- Haris (2007) “State of the Micro Credit Summit Campaign Report – 2007”***“Microfinance through SHGs: A Boon for the Rural Poor” a research paper written by Rimjhim Mousumi Dasand published by DEEP & DEEP Publications Pvt. Ltd. in 2009.****“Microfinance redefining the future” book written by V.S. Somanath and published by Excel publication in2009*****“Microfinance redefining the future” book written by V.S. Somanath and published by Excel publication in2009.******“Microfinance redefining the future” book written by V.S. Somanath and published by Excel publication in2009.. Page 12
  13. 13. 2.0 HAND IN HAND in brief (as in the organization’s MOA)Hand-in-Hand is a Public Charitable Trust registered in the year 2002 with an initial focus oneducation and the elimination of child labor. HIH worked for economic and social empowermentof women and thus of society by creating enterprises and job. In 2005 more than 115,000 womenhave been organized into, over 7,336 SHGs in 5 district of Tamil Nadu.* It is recalled that year2005 was observed as the International Microfinance Year (IMY) with the objective ofeliminating poverty by creating enterprises and jobs. ObjectiveTo eliminate poverty by creating enterprises and jobs. VisionTo alleviate poverty through job creation and integrated community development. MissionTo work for the economic and social empowerment of women, and thus of society, by creatingenterprises and jobs. To follow with this an integrated development programmed that createssustainable communities. Five year goal ending 2013-14To create 1.3 million jobs. Strategy adopted to fulfil objectiveIntroduce five-pillar activities for holistic development of poor people especially women. Thisfive-pillar activity is follow:1. Job creation 2. Education 3. Health 4. Environment 5. Citizen centers. Apart from these fivepillar activities, HIH has village uplift program.Out of these five only jobs creation is discussed below because during my research I workedwith SHG-pillar, mainly focus on Job creation.Job creationHIH is the only NGO in Tamil Nadu to create job with follow up and take care of SHGmembers. HIH provides training to all its members the most famous training by HIH is skilltraining like computer class, tailoring, glass paintings, embroiling and many more. Throughtraining women learn accounting, saving, borrowing & group coordination etc. Page 13
  14. 14. MicrofinanceIn Tamil Nadu, HIH one of the biggest NGO which provide loan on lowest interest rate andbecause of this International Financial Cooperation (IFC)*** invests more in Hand in Hand. HIHlend to only women and ensures that the loan is used only for investment and creatingenterprises, not for consumption.HIH five-pillar model has been successfully replicated in South Africa, Afghanistan and Brazil.Encouraged by these success stories, Prof. Kasturi Rangan, a leading academic at HarvardBusiness School, who also chairs the HBS-ACCION microfinance program is leading a courseon HAND IN HAND Social Entrepreneurship Program on the pattern of HBS.Village Uplift Program (VUP)****The Village Uplift Programmed is an integrated project in which HIH has adopted all five - pillarprogram simultaneously in one village. Each village is supported by one exclusive donor, whoadopts the village for two years for $ 35000. The village uplift program symbolizes practicalapplication of HIH integrated development approach in one village at a time.Note: Up to June 2011 more than 674,432 women have been organized into over 46,923 SHGs in TamilNadu.***** Page 14
  15. 15. HIH growth and global presence Public Charitable Trust. Registered in the year 2002. Focus on child labor elimination, education, and the empowerment of women. Kalpana Shankar is Chief Executive Officer for HIH. In India, HIH currently active in 17 districts in Tamil Nadu, 6 districts in Madhya Pradesh, 3 in Karnataka, Orissa, Maharashtra, as well as in the Union Territory of Pondicherry. Hand in Hand is also a consultant for the Inter American Development Bank and a partner with World Vision. HIH Growth http://www.hihindia.org/handinhand/facts_and_figures/annual_report/Year 2004-05 2005-06 2006-07 2007-08 2008-09 2009-10 2010-11Women 10,000 115,000 206,664 304,000 450,000 609,027 6,74,732organizedSHGs 500 7336 13,962 21,184 42,169 46,923New 300 60,779 161,000 248,000 539,094 685,316Enterprises Page 15
  16. 16. Page 16
  17. 17. Overall Growth up to July 2011 • Jobs created through SHGs – 801,842 • Child - Friendly Panchayats– 798 • NRM Projects – 14 • Medical camps held - 1913 • Camp beneficiaries - 178,860 • Children enrolled in the school - 97,280 • Village Upliftment Programs– 64 • Waste collection (house hold) - 219,580 • Trained in Job Oriented IT – 5,458 • Total number of CCE’s - 2,883HIH Global Presence Page 17
  18. 18. 2.1. Flash progress report of HIH**Resource*http://www.hihindia.org/handinhand/facts_and_figures/reports/annual_report_2005-2006/**http://www.hihindia.org/handinhand/facts_and_figures/annual_report/***http://www.indiaprwire.com/pressrelease/financial-services/2009111237457.htm****http://www.hihinternational.org/what-we-do/programmes/village-uplift-programme/*****http://www.hihindia.org/handinhand/facts_and_figures/monthly_report/ Page 18
  19. 19. 3.0 Penetration of various competitors:In project area different types of MFI’s are working with full potential. These all are in the formof Non Government Organization’s (NGO) as well as Non Banking Financial Companies(NBFC).NGO’s & NBFC’s were studied in three categories.Semi-urban – NGO (1) + NBFC (5) = 6Urban area – NGO (2) + NBFC (5) = 7Rural area – NBFC (4) = 4Semi-urban: In this area mainly one NGO’s and five NBFC’s are working with differentattractive strategies. The details of these MFI’s are mentioned below: -Ragini NGO.Average group size --- 15Training --- NoProduct --- loan (Only bank linkage)Credit Officer --- One man NGOMeetings --- Twice in a monthGroup coordination --- Very strongLoan period --- First loan is provided after six month and next loan after the repayment of first loanInstallment --- MonthlyAverage Interest rate --- Depend on BankDocument charges --- Rs.1500-Rs.2500 per SHGMember getting loan --- All members of SHG getting equallyMoney collection --- By SHG leaderInternal savings --- Rs.100 per member SHG per month Page 19
  20. 20. Findings: - Total 180 SHGs are with Ragini NGO in CHENNA KAANCHIPURAM area.Members join this NGO because of lower interest rate; easy maintenance of books of accountsand not forcing anyone to attend meetings. This NGO provides loan to its members throughCentral Cooperative Bank. Group gets Rs.60,000+Rs.1,00,000+Rs.2,00,000 in four and halfyears. The most attractive strategy in Ragini which is missing in HIH is that all loans aredistributed equally to all members. Members of this group indulge in multiple borrowing becauseof huge demand in market, as respect of demand they borrow loan from Gram Vidyal and paidRs. 270 per week installment for 50 weeks on Rs 10,000 to Gram Vidyal. Page 20
  21. 21. Bandhan (NBFC)Group size --- Depend on member availabilityTraining --- NoLoan size --- loan up to Rs 20,000 minimum is Rs 6,000Credit Officer --- Only for collection moneyMeetings --- NoGroup coordination --- No, very weakLoan period --- 50 weeks, and depend on suitability of Borrowers or loan will provide after completion of first loanInstallment --- Weekly Rs.(225+25)* on Rs 10,000Interest rate --- 25%Document charge --- Yes, taken but not clarifyMember getting loan --- All member getting loanMoney collection --- By CO’sInternal savings --- NoFindings: - Majority of members in this group is above 60 years of age & they all are having selfenterprises. Bandhan has no restriction on age in giving loan. It gives loans to those memberswho already have enterprise. Bandhan attracts borrowers by adopting following strategy “if yourepay Rs 10,000 within 10 weeks then we shall give Rs 6,000 on weekly installments of Rs.(132+18) installment for 50 weeks.” Bandhan give up to Rs 15,000 to its SHGs for educationpurpose. In CHENNA KAANCHEEPURAM 5% of borrowers belongs to BandhanMicrofinance.* Rs. (225+25) in this Rs. 25 is security money which will be given back to borrowers aftercompletion of loan. Page 21
  22. 22. Gram Vidyal (NBFC)Group size --- 15-20Training --- yes, depend on member demandLoan size --- loan up to Rs.25,000 minimum is Rs. 9,000CO’s --- Only for collection moneyMeetings --- NoGroup coordination --- No, very weakLoan period --- 50 weeks, and depends on suitability of Borrowers or loan will provide after completion of first loanInstallment --- Weekly Rs.225 on Rs.9,000Interest rate --- approximately 18%Document charge --- Rs.500 on Rs.9000Member getting loan --- All member getting loanMoney collection --- By Credit Officer (CO)Internal savings --- NoFindings: - Gram Vidyal provide social services to their client and in every 10th week provisionto less Rs.9 from interest, one of the most positive points of Gram Vidyal is that, not chargingany money in the name of security. GV has provision to give Rs.12,000 to their members aseducation loan. For attracting borrowers GV approach members by giving extra loan “if yourepaid Rs.9,000 in 10 weeks then GV gives Rs.3000 for 20 weeks on the installment of Rs.75 perweek. GV target those borrowers who already have small enterprises and those who willing tostart new small enterprises. Members like GV because of easy suitability of getting loan and noforce to attend meetings. In CHENNA KANCHIPURAM lot of members having loan by GV,approximately 20% of total borrowers in particular area. 20%-30% HIH members having loanfrom GV (Gram Vidyal).Note: For Gram Vidyal loan card see annexure 1.0. Page 22
  23. 23. Mahashemam (NBFC)Group size --- Up to 30Training --- NoLoan size --- loan up to Rs.25,000 minimum is Rs.10,000CO’s --- Only for collection moneyMeetings --- NoGroup coordination --- very strongLoan period --- 50 weeks, and depend on suitability of Borrowers or Loan will provide after completion of first loanInstallment --- Weekly Rs.459 on Rs.20,000Interest rate --- approximately 18%Document charge --- Rs.1000 on Rs.20,000Member getting loan --- All member getting loanMoney collection --- By CO’sInternal savings --- NoFindings: - In every 5 week provision is to reduce Rs.5 from interest and collect Rs.10 withweekly installment for insurance. Mahashemam said to borrowers that we will give backinsurance amount to members after cylinder or dysfunction of groups. They charge Rs.1 everyweek in the name of trust. The maximum members of Mahashemam are not indulging inmultiple borrowing because Mahashemam take care of customer needs. As compare to othersMFIs Mahashemam members having less overdue in group because of good group coordinationand selection of members. All members of this group have enterprises like Embroiling andgrocery, fruit, flower shops. Approximately 5%-10% borrowers belong to MahashemamMicrofinance from total borrowers of this particular area. Approximately 20% of HIH borrowershave loan from this NBFC in this particular area.Note: For Mahashemam loan card see annexure 1.1 Page 23
  24. 24. Ashirwaad (NBFC): - On Rs.10,000 Ashirwaad charge Rs.560 for document procedure andtake weekly installment of Rs.225 for 50 weeks.Samastha Microfinance an NBFC: - On Rs.15000 they charge Rs.500 to Rs.700 fordocument procedure and charge 13% interest on loan amount.Overall view of semi urban area: -The impact of HIH in semi urban area is very strong. However, heavy demand of loans, wrongselection of clients, lack of HIH awareness in SHGs and undue emphasis on attendingmeetings/training are main causes of borrowers joining other MFI’s. Borrowers generalperception is that these organizations are liberal than HIH in the requirement of training andmeetings.Chart-1.0 Peneteration of MFIs in Semi-Urban areas HIH GRAM VIDYAL MAHASHEMAM BANDHAN OthersHIH- 55%.Gram Vidyal-21%Mahashemam- 9%Bandhan- 8% and Others-7% Page 24
  25. 25. Urban: - In project area different type of MFIs working with full potential. These all are inform of NGOs as well as NBFCs. In urban area mainly two NGOs & five NBFCs working withdifferent attractive strategies. The full details of these MFIs are mention below.Swathi Vaazga Valamudan Welfare Association (P. Leelavathi) (NGO)Group size --- 15Total SHGs --- 400Training --- Yes, on demand mainly skill trainingProduct --- loan through Bank linkageDifferent in loan period --- In 2008 Rs.1.5L, in 2009 Rs.3L, in 2011 Rs.4.5LMeetings --- Monthly one meeting (80% attendances)Group coordination --- Very strong (only one SHG dysfunction)Loan period --- Depend on loan amount and bankInstallment --- MonthlyInterest rate --- depends on bankDocument charge --- 2% on loan amountMember getting loan --- All members getting loanMoney collection --- By leader & representativesInternal savings --- Yes, strongly believe on this Rs. 110 per monthFindings: - This is a one man NGO managed by P. Leelavati (founder) and her daughter. Total400 SHGs are managed by this NGO mainly in Kanchipuram and St. Thomas Mount. Memberslike to join because of lower interest rate, cooperative style of P.Leelawati, only one meeting in amonth, P.Leelavati’s helping nature, more emphasis on internal savings and segmentation. At thetime of migration, death or late repayment, the responsibility of clearing overdue falls on theshoulders of all members not only on the group leader. It adopts strategy to provide small loan ofRs.4000 to each of 15 members at initial level for learning “how to manage?” At initial levelP.Leelavati focuses on learning, group coordination, increasing internal savings, leadership andbook maintaining. Page 25
  26. 26. NWTWS (NGO)Group size --- 12 - 15Total SHGs --- More than 200Training --- NoProduct --- loan through Bank linkageDifferent in loan period --- In 2009 amid get Rs.1.5L, in 2011 get Rs.4.5LMeetings --- Every SundayGroup coordination --- Very strongLoan period --- Depends on loan amount and bankInstallment --- MonthlyInterest rate --- depends on bankDocument charge --- 2% on loan amountMember getting loan --- All members getting loanMoney collection --- By leader & representativesInternal savings --- Yes, strong commitment, Rs. 210 per monthFindings: - Through bank linkage, members get more loans from bank and equally distributeamongst all members. The most noticeable part of this organization is that members haveadequate knowledge about NWTWS, majority of group members go to branch office weekly.Internal savings are one of the strong reasons for group coordination. Because of this theyaccumulate and deposit large amounts of money in Bank and distribute to every members on thebasis of priority. Members recieve internal loan up to Rs.5000 in a month. According tomembers of NWTWS, staff did not charge any fees or bribe. Credit Officers attends meetingsregularly. Page 26
  27. 27. Mahashemam (NBFC)Group size --- Up to 50Training --- NoLoan size --- Loan up to Rs 25,000 minimum is Rs. 5,000CO’s --- Only for collection moneyMeetings --- NoGroup coordination --- very strongLoan period --- 50 weeks, and depends on suitability of Borrowers or Loan will provide after completion of first loanInstallment --- Weekly Rs 459 on Rs 20,000Interest rate --- approximately 18%Document charge --- Rs.1000 on Rs. 20,000, Rs. 700 on 10,000 Rs.380 on Rs. 5,000Member getting loan --- All member getting loanMoney collection --- By CO’sInternal savings --- NoFindings: - Members like lending process and after the death of husband member get Rs. 2000.Every year give Sari & Calendar to members and provide scholarship to those memberschildren’s who hold first position in board exam (Rs. 5,000), second position (Rs. 3,000) andthird position (Rs. 2,000). In every 5 week the provision is to reduce Rs.5 from interest andcollects Rs.10 every week for insurance and said give back insurance amount to all membersafter cylinder or dysfunction of group. Mahashemam charge Rs.1 on the behalf of trust. HIHshould be consider ‘How Mahashemam retain his client?’ Mahashemam retain clients throughbusiness of ‘take care’ of his client needs. No overdue in group because of good groupcooperation and selection of members at the time of building SHGs. All members of this grouphave small enterprises. Approximately 15%–20% is Mahashemam borrowers from totalborrowers of this particular area. Approximately 20% of HIH borrowers have loan from this MFIin this particular area. Page 27
  28. 28. Gram Vidyal (NBFC)Group size --- Up to 25Training --- Yes, on demand. Handloom, bag and tailoringLoan size --- Loan up to Rs 25,000 minimum is Rs. 75, 00Credit officer --- Only for collection moneyMeetings --- NoGroup coordination --- ModeratorLoan period --- 50 weeks, and depend on suitability of Borrowers or Loan will provide after completion of first loanInstallment --- Weekly Rs 250 on Rs 10,000Interest rate --- approximately 18%Document charge --- Rs. 570 on Rs. 10,000Member getting loan --- All member getting loanMoney collection --- On Saturday in home By CO’sInternal savings --- NoFindings: - On the loan lending day all borrowers get day meal in office. Members get loan inthe order Rs.75, 00+10,000+10,000+25,000 in one year by GV. Majority borrowers of GV aremicro entrepreneur and they have flower shops, Tiffin, Vegetable shops and Sari business. GVloan disbursement strategies are on the basis of need and requirement of borrowers. GV alwaysconfirmed that borrowers have ability to repay the loan amount or not, when GV satisfied thenthey continually provide loan up to Rs.25000. More than 50 active groups of GV in St. ThomasMount but majority are not satisfied. Page 28
  29. 29. Equitas (NBFC)Group size --- Up to 20Training --- NoLoan size --- Loan up to Rs 20,000 minimum is Rs.10, 000CO’s --- Only for collection moneyMeetings --- NoGroup coordination --- moderatorLoan period --- After two year and depend on suitability of Borrowers or Loan will provide after completion of first loanInstallment --- 48 times, half monthly Rs 400 on Rs 15,000Interest rate --- approximately 28%Document charge --- Rs. 250 on Rs. 15,000Member getting loan --- All member getting loanMoney collection --- In home By CO’sInternal savings --- NoFindings: - Equitas is an MFI, charge highest interest rate in Tamil Nadu. Equitas members getloan in order to Rs.10,000, Rs.15, 000 and Rs.20, 000 in one year. Its target members are notpoor. Equitas provide money to those persons who already have a self micro business. In urbanarea people need more money because they have good earning and that’s why borrowers do notworry on interest rates. One misunderstanding is in between borrowers that Equitas charge 10%of interest but in actual they approximately charge 28%. How Equitas approach it should beconsider for HIH. Page 29
  30. 30. Overall view of urban area: More than 25 MFI’s actively working in urban area in this someNGO’s provide only bank linkages and some are provide only self credit amount. HIH is farbetter than these NBFC’s & NGO’s by providing both with credit plus activity. Heavy demandof loan and enterprise size attracts MFI’s in urban area. Urban client did not want any trainingand credit plus activity, this is the main reason behind to inter all MFI’s in urban area becauseoperational cost is less. They demand only money and market linkage. The regional economydepend on Sari business, vegetable shop, flower shop, hand looming, leather product, perfumecover, show ribbon, tailoring, fish merchant, Tiffin business & ice-cream shop.Chart-1.1 Share of MFIs HIH GRAM VIDYAL MAHASHEMAM EQUITAS OthersIn urban area mainly in St. Thomas Mount Mahashemam impact is very strong. People areattracted towards Mahashemam because they give gifts and scholarship to their group members.They target the psychology of the borrowers, maximum borrowers attract because of its loaninstallment process. In the case of Gram Vidyal; good loan size, easily availability of loan and nointerest in last week on capital attract borrowers. Provision of insurance is also one of thestrategies in making sound brand of products by NBFC’s.HIH impact in urban area is good. The only reason to take loan from other companies isexcessive demands of loan, lack of awareness about HIH and gap between first loans to secondloan.In urban area 50% of total borrowers belong to HIH, in this 30%-40% members involve inmultiple borrowing. The most interesting part is multiple borrowers have full trust on HIH. Theyall are not like other MFI’s because of high interest but high demand of money and for survivalin the market attracts members to borrow loan from other MFI. Page 30
  31. 31. RuralIn project area different types of NGO & MFI play role as a lender. In village ASEFA, FFASLAshirvadam, & Mahashemam working with different attractive strategies which is mentionbelow:ASEFAGroup size --- Up to 20Training --- Provide to good SHG’s & on demandProduct --- Bank loan, group loan & individual loanCO’s --- Different CO’s for individual loan & group loanMeetings --- Monthly once (member not attended)Group coordination --- Moderator (One SHG inactive out of total two)Loan period --- After completion of loanInstallment --- Monthly for group loan & weekly for Individual loanInterest rate --- On 10,000 they provide 9,500 and charge 12.5%Document charge --- Rs. 30-200 on Rs. 10,000Member getting loan --- All member getting loanMoney collection --- Leader collects and pays inofficeInternal savings --- Yes, Rs. 100 per monthFindings: - Members attract towards ASEFA because it provide both group loan and individualloan in the same time period. ASEFA still in this area because of its group leader. Group leaderand group members knows staff with name, it shows staff actively involved in group. Group loandistributed equally among all members. ASEFA approach group members to join training butmember did not like to go for training because of good enterprises.Reason for continue: - Members replied that, ASEFA did not force to attend meeting and in otherhand HIH force to attend all meetings. According to leader “we know ASEFA charge more rateof interest but we all are not worry about rate of interest” because we all are having goodearning.Note: - Total 14 SHG of HIH and only one SHG of ASEFA in particular area. Page 31
  32. 32. AshirvadamOn Rs.10,000 they charge Rs.160 as document procedure and take Rs.960 as weekly installment.Overall interest is 16.8%.FFASL:On Rs.10,000 they charge Rs.1000 as security and adopt weekly installment payment system.12.5% interest rate charge on 10,000 except security.Mahashemam: On Rs.10,000 they charge Rs.700 as document procedure and have 50 weekinstallment payment system. They charge Rs.15,00 interests on Rs.10, 000.Note: Kaveri Finance also active in village area of Kaancheepuram.Overall view of rural area: - In rural area HIH impact & image is very strong but because ofless awareness and more demand especially ‘education loan’, people like to borrow loan fromother MFI.Chart-1.3 Share of other MFI HIH AHRUWALI ASEFA MAHASHEMAM OthersAhruwali (the State Government initiative scheme) having good impact in rural area. Peoplebelieve on this scheme but lack of follow up create members migration to other MFI and mostlymembers are joined or willing to join HIH. In the name of competition no MFI exist in rural area.Members borrow loan from other MFI just because of buying cow and for submitting educationfees. Page 32
  33. 33. 3.1. Choice of getting loan at the time of needs in the villages (three year oldSHG) • Jewel loan --- 6% • Individual loan --- 40% • Other MFI loan --- 3% • Internal loan --- 99% • Bank --- 10% • Member know other MFI --- 30%Reason: -Borrowers bound to take loan because of children education, marriage, medical,maintenance of house etc.Note: - Government allotted houses in rural area is not in good condition. In every year at thetime of rainy season borrowers invest more in house maintenance.Impact: - Multiple borrowing increases, overdue in between group members, pressure of excessloan and group coordination. Internal loan demand increases because of paying overdue and thisis the main reason for group inactive.3.2. Level of HIH penetration in village • % of three year old SHG members know HIH vision & mission --- 60% • % of Staff know HIH mission & vision --- 50% • % of three year old SHG members know about product of HIH --- 65% • % of three year old SHG members went to branch office --- 70%Findings: - Majority of respondent belong to 5 year old SHG but 40% are totally unknown aboutHIH vision & mission and other side HIH staff statement was ‘we discuss mission and vision inevery group meeting.’ Only Credit Officers going to attend group meetings and other hand only40% of Credit Officers know exactly HIH mission & vision.At the time of interview with some staff members use dairy to reply HIH mission & vision. HIHis famous for its products and social services but this is also one of the fact is that 35% of threeyear old SHG members did not know about HIH all products. If we talk about social servicesthen only 40% of three year old SHG members know HIH social services. One of the mainreasons of dysfunction SHG’s is Credit Officer resignation and after Credit Officer resignationparticular SHG members face problem in running SHG’s. This problem exist because ofmembers are unknown the address of branch offices and staff names. In this point of view 30%members did not visit branch office. Page 33
  34. 34. 4.0 To assess the factors that help in client retentionCauses of desertion of the HIH can be categorized in five groups, which in combinationdetermine customer satisfaction levels: • Satisfaction with the product • Quality of customer service • HIH image • Emotional involvement and • The profile of customer.Careful analysis of each of these factors reveals major dissatisfaction with product features.Quality of customer service is a complementary source of dissatisfaction, but to a lesser extent,emotional connection the customer possesses with the HIH mitigates most weaknesses incustomer services.Competition and the pressure of growth goals make the HIH define a broader market anddevelop more credit products, with little differentiation among them, diluting its market focusand complicating the administration with limited retention results. Similarly, HIH emphasizesimproving customer service, to gain a competitive edge; yet, this does not necessarily diminishattrition, given the limited window the HIH has for innovation. Page 34
  35. 35. 4.1. Why HIH SHGs are inactive? Some of the important reasons are: - Multiple borrowing; SHG members migrating to any other area; SHG members leave the place after borrowing HIH loan; SHG members leave the area after borrowing internal loan; After leaving members from SHG all responsibility is on leader; Loan amount is not distributed equally; Out of 12-15 group members only nine members get first Grameen loan; Members have overdue; Lack of leadership quality group; Leaders and representatives do not rotate their position in group ; Lack of group coordination; Leaders and representative get more internal loan; In maximum cases leader and representative of a group get first loan, second loan& third loan; loan size; Illiteracy among members; Marriage of leaders and representatives; When SHGs Leader getting better job; Problem not solved in meetings and Meetings are not arranged properly. Page 35
  36. 36. Findings: - Multiple borrowing is the main cause of dysfunction in SHGs. In urban areasborrowers do not want huge amount of money in one installment, they want amount in a fewinstallments. For example; a borrower has an ice-cream shop. In Tamil Nadu demand ofice-cream depends on seasons (consumption rate of ice-cream is high in May and June) So,in the month of March demand of loan is almost nil but in April it increases, in Maydemand increases further, June is the peak month for ice-cream business so the shopkeepers want loan to fulfill the demand and this is the time to earn more.Migration of SHG members is one of the main causes of SHGs becoming inactive. Sometimesmembers migrate from one place to another because of her husband’s job, relatives call,member’s marriage, family migration, and for son’s or daughter’s education etc; after migrationthe whole calculation of internal savings and the loan amount is affected negatively. If leadersand representatives migrate, probability for group becoming inactive is very high.99% chance to group will become inactive when members leave the place after getting loan. Inthis condition all responsibility would come on the shoulder of leaders. Leader is only memberwho has to pay all over dues of migrated members.Group coordination or less coordination is also one of the major factors which force group tobecome inactive at the time of loan distribution. Main reason in lacking group coordination isHIH not providing loan to all members. Leaders & Representatives want to tag more loans. So,the ego problems between them creates problem in group coordination.Illiteracy is one of the major problem in all SHGs, most of the SHGs are inactive because of onlyone member is educated in the group; and when she dies, migrates, gets job or because of anyother reason she leaves the group, then the whole group becomes inactive. All information andcalculation will go with migrated member who manages all books of account. Uneducated SHGmembers are totally blank about their internal savings & how much they get bank loan or HIHloan.Problems of group member are not sorted out easily because of improper arrangement ofmeetings. Members have problem like 1) overdue, 2) who will be going to branch office to payinstallment? 3) Internal loan distribution and; 4) Book keeping. Because of these four problemslot of SHGs deactivate.Last and valid reason of group becoming inactive is:-Credit Officers resignation or non availability of Credit Officers. Page 36
  37. 37. 4.2. Why HIH members migrated to other MFIs or NGOs? Inadequate loan size from HIH; Delay in providing loan; Demand of money; For education loan; Wrong selection of members; Monthly installments; Misunderstanding between members at the time of loan distribution; Multiple borrowing by clients; When groups called inactive, then inactive group members migrate to borrow loan; In HIH, members gets Grameen loan after six month of joining not on emergency time; HIH inspect that member start business or not and Members did not get services and training. After area migration, all responsibility of overdue comes on the leader shoulder.Findings: - The main reason of migration is loan size; near about 70% of weightage of allproblems is loan size of HIH. In urban area borrowers want current loan because they have dailybusiness activity and they earn on the basis of daily business that’s why borrowers choose otherMFIs because maximum of NBFCs provide loan on current demand and on weekly payment ofinstallment. The time gap between HIH first loan to second loan also affects borrowers. Forexample: a borrower having tea business (supplies tea in offices) and her daily expense inmaking tea is Rs.1,000 means Rs.26,000 is the total expenditure in a month. In tea businessborrowers get money from offices in the form of cheque at the end of every month. In thissituation borrowers need to get urgent loan and this time Gram Vidyal, Mahashemam &Equitas stand outside the doors of borrowers with money.Majority of members in villages work on daily basis that is why they refer to pay weeklypayment. Page 37
  38. 38. Overall view of 4.1 &4.2Four major reasons behind HIH SHGs being inactive are (a) Lack in group coordination,(b) Migration of members, (c) Illiteracy among group members and delay in loan disbursement.Graph-1.0 45 40 35 30 25 Group coordination 20 Members migrated illiteracy 15 loan delay 10 5 0 Group Members Illiteracy loan delay cordination migrationFindings: - Above graph shows that 40% of group migrated or became inactive because of nothaving sound group coordination. 25% of SHGs became inactive and migrated because ofmigration of other group members from one place to another place. 20% of group migrated orbecame inactive because they did not have any criteria or management to follow those SHGswho have only one educated women and 10% of HIH SHGs migrated in any other MFIs justbecause of delay in loan disbursement.Note: - Loan size of HIH should be taken into consideration because in both, rural as well asurban areas borrowers dislike loan size. Page 38
  39. 39. 4.3. Causes of desertion in HIH; STRUCTURAL DESERTION CUSTOMER SEGMENTATION SATISFACTION CUSTOMER STRUCTURAL SEGMENTATION SATISFACTION Geogr- Growing Product HIH Customer competetion adequacy Product image profile phical image factor Psychogr- Market Regional Economic Customer Emotional Self Behaviour phic Life style adequacy factor factor service value esteem patterns segmenta- tionTo improve retention, HIH needs to review the causes of desertion. Causes of desertion arenumerous and sometimes inter-related, as below: - Page 39
  40. 40. 4.3.1 Growing competition:- In the same target market 5-6 big names create face to face competition. For instance: Mahashemam, Spandana, Gram Vidyal, ASEFA, Equitas and lot of ‘one man NGO’s. In general, all these MFIs & NGOs operate in fragmented market, in which diverse participants in nature and size compete; as a result, the market share of HIH is diluted. Even the leader of the market (like HIH) will fail to reach to 30% market participation. The small MFIs & NGOs compete with large NGOs (like HIH). For example: some places in St. Thomas Mount, an NGO named Swathi Vaazga Valamudan Welfare Association did microfinance business with clients and this small NGO reduced the positional advantage of HIH.Human Resources: - Moreover, having a credit evolution methodology is not an entry barrier fornew competitors since it is based on the expertise of its human recourses, which can be capturedby a new entrant by hiring away the competing MFI’s and NGO’s staff. Indeed, this aggressivecompetitive strategy is taking place, evidence by high levels of loan officer turnover in themicrofinance industry.Impact of growing competition: - 1- Attractive offers by other MFI’s easily attract consumer & HIH members. 2- People easily understand difference between two MFI’s, this may create problem or may increase the trust level of HIH. The loan size of HIH is less than the other MFI’s, according to this point of view borrowers make negative perception in mind and on other hand HIH provides trainings & social services, this should make positive perception in the mind of borrowers. 3- Multiple borrowing, because of increasing competition, members easily borrow loan from other MFI’s. 4- Overdue, by increasing multiple borrowing overdue also create problems for borrowers. 5- 30%-40% group coordination is affected by increasing competition.Note: - see 3.0 for knowing the penetration of other MFI’s & NGO’s in working field. Page 40
  41. 41. 4.3.2. Product adequacy: - The basic credit product proposition, with stepped lending amounts, does not fit with the client that has already learned and evolved in members credit needs, where microcredit is not necessarily the most adequate product, resulting in high attrition levels due to the lack of sustainability that small loans produce or due to the vulnerability of customers being approached. For expansion of credit portfolio or for credit renewal HIH will adopt Consumer Confidence Index (CCI). CCI measures how optimistic or pessimistic consumers are with respect to the economy in the near future.Note: - HIH does not have any study on product adequacy and this is the main reason behind thegap between the first loan to second loan and size of loan.By field: -% of three year old SHGs know HIH products --- 35%% of staff know about HIH products (CO’s & BM’s) --- 100%% of staff believe that the HIH loan size is good --- 80%% of SHGs inactive and migrated because of only loan size --- 10%4.3.3 Market adequacy: - The basic microfinance model assumes, a market that has to be developed and HIH develops market with positive impact in urban as well as in rural areas. Lot of potential customers who took loan from individual person on high interest rate, now maximum of them have become HIH’s good clients. This type of clients are continuing with HIH and because of these clients market expands like anything, up to June total 6,43,633 number of enterprises have been created so far. HIH start SHGs with training without charging cost, this is a very attractive part to catch market. HIH follows the famous quotation “First impression is the last impression” that’s why at the time of introducing SHGs they provide training to group members on ‘how to manage internal savings and loan.’Note: - HIH does not have any study on market adequacy and this is the main reason of agap between the loan period, loan size and CO’s resignation. Page 41
  42. 42. 4.3.4 Regional and economic factor: - Regional economic factor is one of the most influencing factor for desertion. On the basis of regional economy micro entrepreneurs project the future sale. The regional economy is an essential consideration in the decision to renew credit, regardless of the quality of credit offer. In HIH working area 80%-90% of regional economy is based on milk business, embroiling, zarf, silk sari production, leather made products, flower shop, agriculture, aquaculture, Tiffin business, tailoring, small grocery shop, tea business, ice-cream sale and vegetable shops. If, HIH focuses to promote these business by providing loan then client will find it easy to repay the loan amount and then no overdue on group members, no training would be necessary only follow up and take care of product will be required .In rural area; mainly milk business, agriculture and embroiling work is done by microentrepreneurs and these three micro business shares approximately 90% of regional economy.In urban area; zarf work, sari sales, leather, flower shop, Tiffin business, tailoring, small groceryshop, tea business, ice-cream shops and vegetable shops share 80% of borrower’s regionaleconomy.Note: - Regional economy study provides to learn client unmet needs. HIH does not have anystudy on client unmet needs.% of three year old HIH borrowers has own enterprise ---70%% of borrowers spend money in their family business ---20%% of HIH members has multiple borrowing because of expansion in regional business ---20%Findings: - Total 70% of HIH borrowers have own small enterprises and 20% is spent in theirfamily business. HIH has to maintain this pattern and take care. HIH needs strategy to provideloan at the time of emergency otherwise these borrowers will be indulging in multipleborrowing. Page 42
  43. 43. 4.3.5 Product image: - HIH has five types of loan products. 1- Grameen loan a) first installment of Rs.7500 b) Second installment of Rs.10,000 c) Third installment of Rs.15,000 SHG members will receive first installment loan after six month of formation, then second and third installment loan will get after the completion of first and second loan simultaneously. % of minimum three year old SHGs member get third loan --- 63% % of three year old SHGs member unlike Grameen loan in urban area --- 80% % of staff believe that loan size is main cause of multiple borrowing --- 30% % of CO’s have problem in approaching client because of loan size --- 40% % of SHGs inactive and migrated because of loan size --- 10% 2- Through Bank linkage member receive loan up to Rs.5,00,000 and minimum is Rs.60,000. % of minimum three year old HIH SHGs members like bank linkage --- 80% % of minimum three year old HIH SHGs member satisfied --- 80% 3- Educational loan Rs.7,500 to Rs.12, 000 per member. (all for three year old SHG) % of three year old HIH SHGs want education loan --- 50% % of HIH SHGs member already have education loan from other MFIs--- 15% % of HIH SHGs members using internal loan for education purpose --- 85% 4- Water loan --- Rs.3000 in rural area and Rs.6000 in urban area 5- Toilet loan --- Rs.7500 in both areaInterest rate: - 15% per annum excluding bank linkage.HIH SHGs members who are worried about interest rate --- 12% Page 43
  44. 44. Findings: - In urban area 80% of borrowers not like Grameen loan because of its size and timeperiod. All SHG members did not get first loan (only 9/15 get) and if member having Grameenloan then they will not apply for bank linkage. Education loan is one of the most demandingproducts in between HIH SHG members because mostly members depend on daily wages, that’swhy at the time of school reopen demand of education loan increases.4.3.6. HIH image: - Depend on follow up No doubt is being made on HIH image, but this image needs to be converted into trust. The main reason of migration is losing trust, whether from the side of staff or by products. HIH is famous for its social services. This is one of the most eminent Trusts in Tamil Nadu which provides lot of social services as credit plus activity like health camp, eye camp, environmental camp provide education to SHGs member children etc. % of 3 year old HIH SHGs member knows about social services --- 64% % of 3 year old HIH SHGs members benefited --- 29% % of HIH inactive & migrated SHGs members knows social service --- 50% HIH image also depends upon Credit Officers (CO) behavior on field and the way she approach, solve disputes in meetings, attend meetings, politeness at the time of overdue and help in book maintaining etc. Note: - One of the branch manager told in interview that CO’s approaching style is not good some time it hurts and give suggestion to HIH for build up new strategy on CO’s. % of CO’s attend group meetings (as per the CO’s) --- 100% % of CO’s behavior change after overdue --- 50% % of groups inactive because of lacking weekly meeting --- 30% % of three year old SHGs member like their CO’s --- 100% % of 3 year old SHGs members knows BM & RM --- 20% % of 3 year old SHGs member visited branch office (except leaders) --- 20% % of migrated, inactive member’s disputes not solved by staff --- 0% % of inactive members want to become active if problem solved --- 60% Note: - 100% member like CO’s but after overdue 50% members not like CO’s Page 44
  45. 45. 4.3.7. Quality of customer service: - Though HAND IN HAND still has lots of grounds with respect to improving customer services, since HIH customers have lower expectation about service, except training, this makes it less important cause for desertion. In addition, the personalization and emotional involvement of the customer frequently replaces the service weakness of the HIH. Quality of customer service based on three types; 1- Training; 2- Social services; and 3- Follow up.Training: - Issue: Does training help for client retention?HIH provide four types of training to SHGs members namely; a) Animator & Representative training: - This training is for animators, leaders & representatives. Branch Managers and Credit Officers give A&R training at the time of starting SHGs. The objective of this training is to provide full knowledge on book keeping and account maintaining. b) M-1 training: - This training is for all group members. The objective of this training is to maintain group coordination among SHG members. M-1 training is compulsory for every group member after one month of starting of the group. c) M-2 training: - This training is compulsory for every member. The main objective of M-2 training is to provide basic concept of micro business or micro enterprises. d) M-3 training: - This is not compulsory, it is given on demand of members. The main objective of this training is to develop skills in group members for starting enterprises. The main component of this training is tailoring classes, computer classes, and hand loom product making techniques, glass paintings and many more. Page 45
  46. 46. My field interviews through up the following patterns in training:-In Rural Areas: - % of three year old members who did not get skill training --- 50% % of members who want skill training --- 60% % of members “like” skill training --- 80% % of SHGs inactive because of not getting skill training --- 0% % of members who got skill training but not using it --- 25% % of inactive members who did not get skill training --- 40%In Urban Areas: - % of members who did not get skill training --- 85% % of members who got skill training but not using it --- 20% % of three year members who want skill training --- 23% % of members “like” skill training --- 80% % of SHGs inactive because of not getting training --- 0% % of inactive members needs training --- 10% % of inactive members who did not get training --- 20% In both areas: - % of staff who thinks training is very useful for client retention --- 50% % of other MFIs & NGOs like HIH training (total 10 members know HIH) --- 50%Findings: - No group migrated to other NBFC’s or NGO’s & became inactive because of notgetting training. HIH services are very active in rural area. 60% rural SHGs member wants skilltraining. HIH training and services are liked by majorly all borrowers where as other MFI’smembers also like HIH training. In short training does not play very important role to stop groupor members migration. Page 46
  47. 47. Social services: - HIH is well known for its social services. This is an NGO in Tamil Nadu which provides a number of social services like health camp, eye camp, and environmental camp. HIH provides education to children of SHG members and many more. % of CO’s and Branch Manager (BM) who are aware of social services --- 100% % of three year old SHG members who are aware of social services --- 62% % of three year old SHG members benefited by social service --- 33% % of inactive & migrated SHG members who are aware of social service --- 50%Findings: - All Credit officers (CO), have knowledge on social services but they do not like toshare it. Social service is a type of weapon which can be use only for sound not for shoot. WhenI was takin interview of Mahashemam, I saw her eyes full of emotional attachment withMahashemam because every year Mahashemam provide her a sari and give scholarship to thechildren of SHGs members.Follow up: - Group follow up is very important to know a) client needs, b) client problems, c) special issues, d) problem in distributing internal savings, e) building trust and proper group coordination. This work should be done properly by Credit Officers & Branch Managers. After CO’s resignation SHGs members do not know the staff and liable to be inactive, follow up is only the solution to this problem. 60% of inactive SHGs will become active if group coordination is maintained and they solve their internal group problems. Note: -1 - In St. Thomas Mount 10 HIH SHGs are inactive because of two Credit Officer resignation. Note: -2 - HIH needs to provide training to CO’s and Branch Managers on ‘how to follow groups? Only attending meeting is not enough, must share & care with SHGs. This is the sure way to build trust. Note: - 3 - % of three year old SHGs members know mission and vision of HIH --- 50% Page 47
  48. 48. 4.3.8 Emotional involvement: - Emotional involvement plays a crucial role to coordinate in between both sides. As Shown in the diagram below, this is not a one way approach. Staff Staff Lower Upper Staff staff SHGs Staff member Staff HIH Emotional involvement in between Staff & SHGs builds trust. Sometimes client’s expectation is high from the side of staff, wants to indulge in between them and wants a relation. Client knows very well that only staff will help in providing loan and help us at bad time. HIH is internationally famous for its five-pillar activity and on the basis of this Dr. Ranjan started programme on social entrepreneur. “Credit Plus” program is totally based on five-pillar activity so, it’s very necessary to maintain good coordination between all pillar staff. HR manager plays very crucial role for doing this job. HIH Credit Officers have inhibition to discuss the problem with Regional Managers and RM’s have inhibition to discuss with the COO. To address this problem, first kill fear and make friendly atmosphere in working place. For instance; Play Rajnikant movie and invite higher as well as lower staff of all pillars in Kanchipuram head office. Page 48
  49. 49. Techniques to build emotional involvements: - 1- TAKE CARE STRATEGY MAKERS TRAINING TEAM HIH SHG members: - Through example the above diagram should be clear. • HIH plan to disburse loan for buying Sewing Machines because of heavy demand and regional economic factor. This information is sent to all branches of HIH. Regional Managers and Branch Managers provide information to Credit Officer and set target of giving loan to 100 members. Credit Officer collects all information and application of 100 members. After analyzing all the factors of 100 applicants, strategy makers found that 50 applicants did not know tailoring. Strategy maker passed order to training department to provide training on tailoring. Borrowers were so happy because they got training as well as loan. In the eye of borrowers HIH is called as “parent” (HIH builds attachment here) and Credit Officers are very good according to borrowers. Cont….. Page 49
  50. 50. • All borrowers bought sewing machines and they continually earn money and every month they paid installment on time. After 6 months HIH found that 20 borrowers did not pay the 7th installment. Credit Officers found that these 20 borrowers sewing machine did not worked properly. At the beginning stage machine performance and output was very good but after 6 months machine performance decreased in absence of maintenance care. Borrowers did not know as to, when machine required servicing, after how many days handle should be greased and all small-small factors which were directly responsible to decrease the performance of sewing machine. Out of these 20 borrowers, 10 borrower’s machine stopped working and they spent Rs.1000 in repairing sewing machine, means, an amount equal to two installments. At last borrowers were not able to pay the loan installment.Effects: - a) Overdue on borrowers; b) Increasing pressure to pay overdue on borrowers; c) Because of overdue Credit Officer got pressure from RM’s and BM’s; d) Resignation of Credit Officer; e) Credit Officers behavior and attitude changed at the time of approaching borrowers after over dues; and Note: - 50% Credit Officer’s behavior change after overdue f) Lacking group coordination in between group members.Results: - a) Multiple borrowing b) If 20 members belong from five different SHGs, it means 4 members per SHG have this problem. So, may be out of this five SHGs two SHGs will become inactive. c) In short, out of 100 members 8 members will face trouble and because of these 8 members 2 SHG will become inactive and two SHG inactive means 24- 32 members will not be empowered.Overall: - 24% to 32% of members out of 100 are inactive just because of HIH did not haveappropriate strategies to take care of borrower asset (sewing machine).Solution: - a) At the time of giving M-3 training, HIH must provide training on how to take care of borrower assets. b) Introduce COMMUNITY RADIO http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Community_radio in village area. This is 100% subsidy scheme announced by Central Government. Page 50
  51. 51. 2- ROLE OF OPERATION / HR MANAGER FOR EMPLOYEE RETENTION Note: - Because of two Credit Officer’s resignation 10 SHGs migrated and became inactive. A) Review meetings must be arranged in proper management with certain objective and should adopt strong MIS for analyzing performance of staff, particularly Credit Officers, Branch Managers & Regional Managers. B) Find the factors & solutions of releasing the target on the staff. C) Motivational activities should be organized at the work place with certain objectives. D) Right recruitment, because some Credit Officers do not have the extent level of understanding and cannot solve the dispute among members. Dispute is one of the biggest factors responsible for the lack in group coordination.Findings:- 1) 40% of SHGs became inactive and migrated because of inadequacy in group coordination. 2) According to HIH Human Resource Manager; employee retention is directly proportional to client retention & SHGs are inactive mostly because of lack of monitoring and lack of staff participation with groups. 3) HIH SHG operation department does not have any training on client retention. Interaction between staff is not sound. Page 51

×