People's Choice Award: Pandora v Spotify
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

Like this? Share it with your network


People's Choice Award: Pandora v Spotify

Uploaded on

Project slide-deck submitted for a Technology Competition and Strategy graduate course taught at the University of California, Davis by Associate Dean Hemant Bhargava. The full analysis can be......

Project slide-deck submitted for a Technology Competition and Strategy graduate course taught at the University of California, Davis by Associate Dean Hemant Bhargava. The full analysis can be found here:

More in: Technology
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads


Total Views
On Slideshare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds



Embeds 2,172 2,147 10 4 3 1 1 1 1 1 1 1 1

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

    No notes for slide


  • 1. Pandora’s Strategy: An AnalysisAsh Alhashim * Lily Ho * Christiana Lee * Jem Nguyen * Christina Santamaria
  • 2. AgendaBackground and ObjectiveNetwork EffectsPricing StrategiesVersioningStrategic AlliancesFinal Recommendation
  • 3. PandoraCompany Background Automated music recommendation service 2012: 150M users, 1M tracks, 100K artistsCompetitive Landscape iTunes, Jango, Playlist, Rhapsody, and SpotifyChallenge High royalty costs, how to monetize user base, lack of strategic leadership
  • 4. Revenue and Profit/Loss: 2012 - Present
  • 5. Pandora v. Spotify: At a Glance PANDORA SPOTIFYMonthly Unique Users 65.6 million 20 millionCompany Facts: Launched: 2000; 180+ Employees Launched: 2008; 300+ EmployeesCommunity Comparisons Available in 3 countries Available in 21 countriesMusic Library Size 1 million songs 20 million songsType; Rating Available? Discovery; Yes Discovery & On-Demand; YesCreate Custom Stations? Yes YesFree Version Available? Yes: limited skips, ads, reduced quality Yes: ads, limited listening time Unlimited: $4.99/mo for desktop &Paid Tiers PandoraOne: $36/year or $3.99/month laptop with no ads; Premium: $9.99/mo for all devices with no ads Custom stations, supported by PandoraStations Custom, unlimited skipping algorithmSocial Media Integration Yes (Limited) Yes iOS, Android, Windows Phone, iOS, Android, Windows Phone &Mobile Apps BlackBerry Mobile, Blackberry, S60 (Symbian)
  • 6. Versioning: Freemium Model Pandora Spotify Free users  Free users • Basic with limited number of skips • Spotify radio version • With advertisements • With advertisements Paying Users  Paying Users • Pandora One • Tier 1: Unlimited  $3.99/month or $36/year  $4.99/month  Ads removed  Ads removed  Increased number of skips  No access on mobile devices  Higher quality  Desktop application • Tier 2: Premium  $9.99/month  Ad-Free Service  Radio access on all devices
  • 7. Network Effects Historically, functioned as a genuine information good • Recently added social features Automated music recommendation service • Selection based on user’s feedback Music Database No direct effect, but creates an indirect, cross-side network effect Pandora Collective Individual Feedback Engagement
  • 8. Network Effects Network Good • Adds value as network size grows • Can create and share playlists New features: “Follow” and “Discover” • Follow friends, musical artists and celebrities • Two-sided network, serving both music industry and consumers.
  • 9. Mobile Monetization Creating revenue from mobile ads Mobile revenue in increased by 86% Focuses on solutions that bring targeting, interactivity and measurability
  • 10. Relationship with Record Labels 2012: Pandora paid out 60% of its revenues to the music industry Royalty remain higher for online radio providers than traditional radio stations Internet Radio Fairness Act • Reduce royalty costs for online radio providers.
  • 11. Alliances: Record LabelsBoth Pandora and Spotify have partnerships with the 3 corporate labels that controls the majorityof the market in the United States: Universal Music Group, Warner Music, and Sony Music. Pandora Spotify  Relationship with music industry and artists  20 MM songs v. 1 MM of Pandora is lukewarm  Exclusive rights w/ smaller labels  Positioned as a friend of artists  Playlists and applications created by artists and influencers
  • 12. Alliances: DistributionAlliances in the music streaming industry is necessary for distribution and productPandora: Car manufacturers, internet TV New cars, X-box, Roku, has Pandora pre-installed Not exclusive alliancesSpotify: Facebook Makes music sharing social and viral Proves to be effective with growth in new subscriptions in short period Recent partnership with Ford and Volvo
  • 13. RecommendationsSocial virality Convert from an information good into a two sided network • Decreases risk of losing users • Creates a higher switching costPricing Create a three tier system Limit their free version Keep current $3.99 for ad free with limited service Add $9.99 for their premium version, for all devicesContinue efforts to pass the Internet Radio Fairness Act Reduces royalty costs
  • 14. RecommendationsAlliances Be social to attract young users Rebuild alliances with music industry to ensure continuity of product Pandora and Spotify should build alliances to bundle its product with othersInternational growth Pandora in 3 countries Spotify in 21 countriesAdditional content category eBooks, comedy, and newsPandora has the advantage of having a larger user base than Spotify, butif they don’t act strategically, that gap will narrow.