You just lost money! Though the exit was successful the investor lost money
Ways VC’s protect their capital
The Agenda:
Types of Securities
Ways to Protect the Down Side
Vesting
Other Rights
The typical types of securities
If you had bought convertible preferred shares: This time the investor gets their money back
If you had bought participating preferred shares:
We call this:
Having your cake and eating it too!
Down rounds are bad
Definition: When another round of investment is necessary, and the company is valued at a lower price than the previous round.
An example: A VC offers to invest, but thinks the company is only worth $3M
This implies that our 49% stake is only worth $1.5M
Our ownership will be diluted badly
Two common dilution protection methods:
Full ratchet anti dilution
The investors percentage ownership before the new round remains the same
Example: If the value for the first round was $2 a share, and the new round is $1 a share, then the number of shares the investor owns would be doubled so that their ownership would still be 49%
Weighted average is kinder to the entrepreneur
Weighted average ratchet anti dilution
Less harsh for the entrepreneur, this method takes into account the ratio of the amount of money diluting the original investment
The actual formula can be simple or complex
Liquidation preferences
Another way to protect down side risk
Receive a multiple on the investment if preferred stock is not converted
Example:
You invest $2M into FastSell with 1.5x liquidation preference
If you had bought with a 1.5x liquidation preference: This time the investor gets nothing
How to use vesting to solve the problem
Many times the entrepreneurs shares will vest over time
Each month the entrepreneur earns more shares
For instance: The entrepreneur would have 75% of their stock vesting over the next 3 years (25% a year)
If you had bought common with vesting: This time the entrepreneur get’s $750K
Other rights
Board seats
VC’s will almost always request a board seat
Number of seats should be pro rata with ownership
Sale Rights
A majority of preferred must vote to allow the company to sell
Other rights (cont.)
Dividends
Preferred shares can have accruing in-kind dividends
Has the effect of transferring ownership to preferred
There are many others that attempt to align the investors with the management
What did we learn?
In VC the lingo is much more difficult than the concepts
There are a few common scenarios that one should be familiar with
There are many uncommon scenarios that ones lawyers should be familiar with
Make sure you understand what will happen in down round
0 comments
Post a comment