Fake Your
Research
In April 2012, Czech TV launched a new logo. They ran a last-minute research. The purpose was
clear – prove that the new l...
Imagine you are taking a survey and you see this picture of a TV screen and they ask you „which
TV channel is on?“
Now you show you this picture and ask you „What does this remind you of?“ Hands up those
who think of TV
More than half associate this with a TV (hoorray!)
The survey reported that more than half people answered „TV“. More than...
I will give you a set of useful tools to manipulate the results of your research
Some will directly influence the results,...
Framing
Take advantage of the fact that question order and wording influence the way subjects answer
Answer this…
● Do you think it is easier to find work in a city?
● Is the average salary higher in a city than in the
coun...
Now tell me… Would you like to
live in a city?
Then answer this…
● Is the air in cities polluted?
● Do you think there is too much technology in
our lives?
● Are city st...
Now tell me again… Would you like
to live in a city?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=G0ZZJXw4MTA#t=30
Learn framing from Sir Humphrey
Lesson 1
Randomize questions in surveys
Ask open-ended questions
Ask What If
The anwer people choose doesn't have any real consequences, just like in a computer game
Ask people how they w...
Are you racist?
Let me ask you this: Are you racist?
Now let me ask you another question: Imagine you see a white guy cutt...
http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=ge7i60GuNRg#t=32
Lesson 2
Ask people about past behavior. The
answer will not be 100% accurate, but
it will be much more precise than
askin...
Mention Interface Elements in Wording
Now add this item into cart
When giving tasks, mention parts of the interface to mak...
Look at this page.
1) Find maps
2) Imagine you want to find something about Mick Jagger. Where do you click?
3) Compare ho...
Lesson 3
Never use interface elements in
task wording
Ask about the Unknown
Great TerribleAverage
Imagine you are taking a survey and they ask you to rate a bank
Great TerribleAverage
And another one
Great TerribleAverage
And another one… Most of which you have no experience with. Imagine how useful the answers
from such...
Lesson 4
Ask people what they know first
and then about their experience
with it
Ask Irrelevant Questions
Just like this picture is totally irrelevant to this talk 
Imagine they show you a page. Like this one…
And then they ask you to select the emotions you had when looking at the page. From 41
emotion altogether! Sorted on a mys...
Anothe popular type of survey. Look at sets of photos and select brands (banks in this case) and
select the ones that go t...
Ask People What They Want
Saying yes costs nothing. It‘s like taking children to a toy store. Participants will say yes to...
In 1985 Coca Cola released „New Coke“. They ran a set of focus groups asking people what kind
of coke would they want. Sin...
Home Simpson‘s brother asked him to help engineers develop a new car. So Homer went and
told the engineers about all the f...
Summary
Randomize questions
Ask about past behavior
Avoid irrelevant questions
@adlo
www.adamfendrych.cz
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

Fake Your Research

1,052 views

Published on

Bias in user reserach is a nasty thing that can render the whole project useless. I will go through all phases of research - planning, data collection and analysis - and show examples of habits you really should avoid unless you wanna fake your own research.

Published in: Technology, Business
0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total views
1,052
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
112
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
8
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Fake Your Research

  1. 1. Fake Your Research
  2. 2. In April 2012, Czech TV launched a new logo. They ran a last-minute research. The purpose was clear – prove that the new logo (already scheduled to launch) is good. And they succeeded! They used several cool tricks to do that. I‘m gonna show you two of them.
  3. 3. Imagine you are taking a survey and you see this picture of a TV screen and they ask you „which TV channel is on?“
  4. 4. Now you show you this picture and ask you „What does this remind you of?“ Hands up those who think of TV
  5. 5. More than half associate this with a TV (hoorray!) The survey reported that more than half people answered „TV“. More than half! What a beautiful intepretation. What if I take the same data and say – almost half of the people didn‘t associate the logo with a tv screen. Even after they had just seen one!
  6. 6. I will give you a set of useful tools to manipulate the results of your research Some will directly influence the results, others will simply spread chaos (useful for covering the former) And for the good guys… This is a list of things you should never do And fire your research agency if they do them
  7. 7. Framing Take advantage of the fact that question order and wording influence the way subjects answer
  8. 8. Answer this… ● Do you think it is easier to find work in a city? ● Is the average salary higher in a city than in the country? ● Is it nature-friendly to use public transport to get to work? ● Is it good to have many cultural events to choose from? ● Do you want to be able to choose from high- quality schools for your children to go to? ● Do you enjoy meeting new people?
  9. 9. Now tell me… Would you like to live in a city?
  10. 10. Then answer this… ● Is the air in cities polluted? ● Do you think there is too much technology in our lives? ● Are city streets safe for children to play? ● Do you like the nature? ● Are the people in the country more open and friendly? ● Would you like to have a network or neighbors you know and you can count on?
  11. 11. Now tell me again… Would you like to live in a city?
  12. 12. http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=G0ZZJXw4MTA#t=30 Learn framing from Sir Humphrey
  13. 13. Lesson 1 Randomize questions in surveys Ask open-ended questions
  14. 14. Ask What If The anwer people choose doesn't have any real consequences, just like in a computer game Ask people how they would behave if they were rich, how would they react if they got a discount etc. The answer will be very inaccurate.
  15. 15. Are you racist? Let me ask you this: Are you racist? Now let me ask you another question: Imagine you see a white guy cutting the lock of a bike in a park. Think what you do. Keep the answer to yourselves and let me show you this video.
  16. 16. http://www.youtube.com/watch?feature=player_detailpage&v=ge7i60GuNRg#t=32
  17. 17. Lesson 2 Ask people about past behavior. The answer will not be 100% accurate, but it will be much more precise than asking about future
  18. 18. Mention Interface Elements in Wording Now add this item into cart When giving tasks, mention parts of the interface to make it really easy for the participants to find the information. This will help you prove that your design is good 
  19. 19. Look at this page. 1) Find maps 2) Imagine you want to find something about Mick Jagger. Where do you click? 3) Compare how much time each task took
  20. 20. Lesson 3 Never use interface elements in task wording
  21. 21. Ask about the Unknown
  22. 22. Great TerribleAverage Imagine you are taking a survey and they ask you to rate a bank
  23. 23. Great TerribleAverage And another one
  24. 24. Great TerribleAverage And another one… Most of which you have no experience with. Imagine how useful the answers from such survey must be.
  25. 25. Lesson 4 Ask people what they know first and then about their experience with it
  26. 26. Ask Irrelevant Questions Just like this picture is totally irrelevant to this talk 
  27. 27. Imagine they show you a page. Like this one…
  28. 28. And then they ask you to select the emotions you had when looking at the page. From 41 emotion altogether! Sorted on a mysterious scale! Does that really allow you to express you experience with the design? I doubt it.
  29. 29. Anothe popular type of survey. Look at sets of photos and select brands (banks in this case) and select the ones that go together with the photos. My answer? None!
  30. 30. Ask People What They Want Saying yes costs nothing. It‘s like taking children to a toy store. Participants will say yes to a lot of stuff they would never actually want. Ask „do you want a newsletter“ or „do you want 28 new features“ to get yourself something to work on „because people want it“
  31. 31. In 1985 Coca Cola released „New Coke“. They ran a set of focus groups asking people what kind of coke would they want. Since they were asked (and paid to reply) people said they wanted a different kind of coke. A new one. The product was a failure. It turned out that people didn‘t want a new one, the like the good old coke just fine.
  32. 32. Home Simpson‘s brother asked him to help engineers develop a new car. So Homer went and told the engineers about all the features his dream car should have. And they built it…
  33. 33. Summary Randomize questions Ask about past behavior Avoid irrelevant questions
  34. 34. @adlo www.adamfendrych.cz

×