!"#$%&'()$*"&+
,,-$.(&&/0
12/3)'(4$52+$6778

! "#$%&'()*&#
! 9/:(;<")=$!"$<2>>()")=$;/$?/@(A;$;()3@($")$%?@"B2$C
#$%&'(%&')*+,-&.*"%&)'($/0
! %$'(D/&3;"/)2@+$;@2)A";"/)$?@/:$A;2;($;/$>(/>&(
! !2@=(&+$A(&?E'@"D()$F3;$2&A/$>2@;$/?$=&/F2&$;@()'
! -);(=@2&$;/$'(:/B@2;"#2;"/)
! 9&/0$")$%?@"B2$2)'$:2")&+$/BB3@@")=$;<3A$?2@$")
G2A;(@)$H$9/3;<(@)$%?@"B2
! I<($A;/@+$/?$?/@(A;$;()3@($@(?/@:$"A$;<($A;/@+$/?$&2)'
@"=<;A$@(?/@:J$$")$%?@"B24$;<"A$<")=(A$/)$$;<($10*'/!'/
"%*%$"&(.&1$"%(2*+-&,*'3&+!/0%"
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 2

! "#$%&'($%)*#+,-%&#.%/-'$0
K(B(AA2@+$2)'$)/0$3@=();$")$/@'(@$;/$C
! ,(A>(B;$<3:2)$@"=<;A$2A$")$2=@2@"2)$B/);(L;A
! !":";$'(=@2'2;"/)$2)'$B&":2;($B<2)=(
! M3;$:2)2=(:();$/)$2$A3A;2")2F&($?//;")=
! !":";$3)N3A;$");(@EA;2;($@(A/3@B($=@2FF")=
! M@/D"'($;<($?/3)'2;"/)$?/@$2$2(3)+'$?/@(A;$(B/)/:+
! %)'$")$?/@(A;('$A;2;(A$B/);@"F3;($;/$;<($@(B/)A;@3B;"/)$/?
;<($2=@2@"2)$(B/)/:+$/D(@2&&
! %)'$;/$;<($+)1('"%+$1%!('&(.&%0)&"%*%)
! !":";$B/)O"B;$'3($;/$>&3::(;")=$B";"#()$;/&(@2)B($/?
")N3A;"B($2)'$B/@@3>;"/)
! 52P($@(2&$;<($/FD"/3A$(:>/0(@:();4$B2>2B";+$2)'$;<@"D")=
();@(>@()(3@"2&$A>"@";$/?$B/::3)";"(A
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 3

!"#$%&#'($)*+,-.$,'/01$1.'/0',
! M3;$2)$()'$;/$;<($!"#$%&'($)*$+&,-&./0+1(&+$)*'&$)*
%2#&$0/'#&,-&2/3$)&"1!2%'
! I<2;$"A$E$'(2&$0";<$%2#&+$'%&(,+,)1$+&4/#'%1,)
%2#&%"#$%3#)%&,-&567&31++1,)&"/"$+&8-"1($)'&$'
'4/$%%#"'&,)&%2#1"&,9)&+$)*
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 4

1#.)($%,#2).*'*3)%$-+(%-'(%'%.#4)%$#%54'6
7*8
!A(B3@")=$'3($&2)'$@"=<;A$/?$;<($&(=2&&+$0@/)=?3&&+
'"A>/AA(AA('$/?$;<("@$;()3@(
!Q(&>")=$@(A;@3B;3@($=/D(@)2)B($/?$A/B"(;+$;/02@'A
:/@($=()3")(&+$")B&3A"D($2)'$;<()B($F/;;/:$3>
=/D(@)2)B($A+A;(:A
!2)'$<(&>")=$;/$@(A;@3B;3@($'(:/B@2;"B$(B/)/:"B
)/@:A$;/02@'A$2$)(0$R2=@2@"2)$(B/)/:"B$/@'(@S$")
0<"B<$=/D(@):();$2"'A$H$;2L(A4$)/;$/0)A$H$;">A
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 5

!"#$%&'"+,-./012,34-56-6371.3711839.18:;,"1+3<==>/
;1:+,.@
=? 4-66-- 5.-53AB
9:; ;A"+5 !<=%>7447#*
-,A"19"5 "+8"5 +&$3B##&(#)C'
D-+@5 E5,5. F=G===
H545I" 8"JK1:," +&$3B##&(#)C'
H1L5HK"E:- ;A"+5 +&$3B##&(#)C'
?@9A" -0@9, +&$3B##&(#)C'
B>7*<%C<C%D-'E J1.85+ <MG===
D:I5", +&$3B##&(#)C'
E5,5. +&$3B##&(#)C'
65:8"35.5K"5 !=G!!N
61:,A3D1.-5 O?=G===
:5- PN>G===3Q3P=G===
6&($RC%#36('B# :653S9."25,-T F==G===
,5+L5+"5 ;A"+5 P==
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 6

F G#/%H7H%#.H7*'.6%A&.73'*(%4#()
$-)7.%.7,-$(0
-);(=@2&$;/$(2@&+$A;2;($:2P")=4$F/;<$?(3'2&$2)'$B/&/)"2&
TA32&$@();EA((P")=$=@(('$H$'(A"=)('$;/$B2>;3@(
@(A/3@B(A$2;$AB2&(
:1'.,''#''1,)
! UVVW$C$:2P")=$%?@"B2$(4')+,)""
! 5"A3)'(@A;2)'")=$;<($B/);(L;$/?$3A3?@3B;
! -);@/'3B")=$G3@/>(2)$;()3@($@(=":(A
! ,()'(@")=$2&&$3)@(="A;(@('$&2)'$;<($>@/>(@;+$/?$;<(
9;2;(
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 7

;/'%$1)1)!&%2#&80/'#
! -)'/B;@")2;('$>/A;E")'(>()'();$=/D(@):();A$@(;2")
;<($)/@:A$C$2)'$")B@(2A")=&+$F3+$");/$;<(:
! I<($A;2;($F(B/:(A$;<($>@":2@+$@();EA((P(@4$:/@(
&2)'&/@'$;<2)$;@3A;(($/?$>3F&"B$&2)'A$X'($?2B;/
Y/D(@):();Z9;2;($!2)'A[
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 8

<=$R3)C#$(%U3#&%VW3/
" T);";&('$</&'(@A$2A$5)+2!""!6)&(11$5*'%"&/)&+$/)
>3F&"B$&2)'$X9;2;(ZY/D(@):();$&2)'[
" )&+$5+(3$1%!6)&$")&XA(;;&(:();$H$?2@:")=[$B2)
A(B3@($;<2;$/BB3>2)B+$2)'$3A($;/$2)+$3A(?3&$'(=@((
" %BB/@'")=&+$B/::3)";+SA$1(,,)1%!6)&*"")%"&X>2A;3@(A4
0(;&2)'A4$?/@(A;AZ0//'&2)'A[$@()'(@('$:/A;$")A(B3@(
" )&+$B/:>()A2;"/)$?/@$</3A(A$H$B@/>A$0<()$;<($A;2;(
@(]3"@('$?/@$/;<(@$3A(
^()+")=$/0)(@A<">$"A$B<(2>$?/@$=/D(@):();A$2)'$(&";(A
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 9

3;(W$&VB%U3XB#'3$C#(%C
$7(22$'!%-&#*")3&"-"%)2&0<(@($@"=<;A$2@($'(_)('$2)'
3><(&'$F+$&/B2&$@3&(A$H$B/)A()A3A4$)/;$)2;"/)2&$&20A4
2)'$/?;()$@//;('$")$&/)=$;@2'";"/)A
`2@"2;"/)A$")$@(=":(A$F3;$:/A;$A<2@($C
# %$D"&&2=(EF2A('$/>(@2;"/)2&$?@2:(0/@P
# `"&&2=(EF2A('$B3A;/'"2&$23;</@";+
# .2:"&+$/0)(@A<">$/?$</3A(A$H$?2@:A$X3A3?@3B;$/@
>(@:2)();$R$B3A;/:2@+$?@((</&'S[
# a/&&(B;"D($/0)(@A<">$/?$@(A/3@B(A$3A('$")$B/::/)
# M@/D"A"/)A$?/@$A(2A/)2&$2)'$/;<(@$A3F/@'")2;($@"=<;A
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 10

I%%%J-).)%%K%-#/%7(%$-)%$.'*(7L#*%#33+..7*,0
<= >2",/!2&1)*1!#),/'&+$)*&(+$13'?
Kb4$%3A;@2&"24$M2>32$K(0$Y3")(24$."N"4$a2)2'24$K/@02+4$,3AA"24$M<"&">>")(A
2)'$UW$!2;")$%:(@"B2)$A;2;(A$F3;$(A>(B"2&&+$c@2#"&4$a/&/:F"24$c/&"D"24
a/&/:F"24$a/A;2$,"B24$M2)2:24$M2@2=32+4$M(@3$$H$c(&"#($XBd$677$5<2$)/0
&(=2&&+$/0)('$)/0$F+$B/::3)";"(A$/)$;<($F2A"A$/?$<"A;/@"B$/BB3>2)B+$")
!2;")$%:(@"B2$2&/)([
" >2",/!2&+#!$+&(2$)!#&1)&'%$%/'&,-&(/'%,3$"@
#
"1!2%'?&:2")&+$%?@"B24$2&A/$52&2+A"2$H$/;<(@A
A= >2",/!2&"#'%1%/%1,)&,-&'%$%#B($.%/"#*&"1!2%'&&%,
."1C$%#&.",.#"%@&(,++#(%1C#'&1)&-,"3#"
)$%1,)$+1'#*&"#!13#'?&a<")24$`"(;)2:4$!2/A4$5/)=/&"24
%#(@F2"N2)4$5(L"B/4$%@:()"24$5/&'2D"24$Y(/@="24$e+@=+#A;2)
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 11

M J-'$%)N'3$46%7(%$-)%$.'*(7L#*Y
! %BP)/0&('=(:();$/?$B3A;/:2@+$&2)'$@"=<;A$2A
!"#$%&'(!")!'"&*("#+,&-(C$2)'$"@@(A>(B;"D($/?$0<(;<(@
C
# Q(&'$F+$")'"D"'32&A4$?2:"&"(A4$B&2)A$/@$B/::3)";"(A
# ,(="A;(@('$/@$)/;
# %F&($;/$F($B3A;/:2@"&+$A/&'$/@$)/;
# ^3($A3>>/@;$")$;<($B/3@;A
# ^3($?3&&$B/:>()A2;"/)$"?$;2P()$?/@$>3F&"B$>3@>/A(
• %)/;<(@$;@2)A";"/)$0<"B<$*#(,!"0)"$RB3A;/:2@+S$@"=<;A
F3;$B/)B@(;(&+$@(>&2B(A$;<(A($0";<$2BP)/0&('=(:();
/?$(L"A;")=$B/::3)";+$F2A('$@"=<;A
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 12

M J-6%H#)(%$-7(%>'O).%$#%&#.)($%$)*+.)0
$
# ./@(A;A$2@($2$:2N/@$B/::3)";+$>@/>(@;+
"# )($/?$;<($:/A;$D3&)(@2F&(
%# I<($A/3@B($/?$:/A;$)(0$?2@:&2)'
&# ./@(A;$=/D(@)2)B($"A$2$:"B@/B/A:$/?$F/;<$=//'$2)'$F2'
=/D(@)2)B(
'# ./@(A;A$:"@@/@$B/:>(;")=$");(@(A;A$/?$@"B<$H$>//@
(# I<($?/@(A;$A(B;/@$A</3&'$P)/0$F(;;(@$C$";$<2A$2&@(2'+$:2'(
":>/@;2);$2'D2)B(A$")$'(D/&3;"/)2@+$'(:/B@2;"A2;"/)
)# 5/'(@)$?/@(A;$(B/)/:+$@(]3"@(A$;@2)A?/@:2;"/)$")$?/@(A;
/0)(@A<">
*# 5/'(@)$?/@(A;$=/D(@)2)B($@(]3"@(A$2$@(&2;('$=/D(@)2)B(
;@2)A?/@:2;"/)$?@/:$/0)(@Z:2)2=(@A$;/$@(=3&2;/@A$/?
B";"#()E&('$();(@>@"A(
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 13

M<%J-6%'.)%>#.)%3#+*$.7)(%'3P*#/4)H,7*,
3#>>+*7L)(%#/*%&#.)($%4'*H(0
! .2"&3@($/?$A;2;($2A$B/)A(@D2;/@J$0(2P$>2@2'"=:4$;@2=('+$/?
>3F&"B$&2)'A
! M(@A"A;()B($/?$;<($@3@2&$B/::3)";+ZD"&&2=(A$2A$'($?2B;/
@(A"'();A$2)'$</&'(@A
! Y&/F2&$A<"?;$")$@(B/=)";"/)$/?$0<2;$B/)A;";3;(A$2$<3:2)$@"=<;
X:2)"?(A;$")$-!$Uf8$H$TK$^(B&2@2;"/)$-)'"=d$,"=<;A[
! ^(B&")")=$;/&(@2)B($F+$&/B2&$B";"#()A$/?$$A3>>@(AA"/)$/?
>@/>(@;+$@"=<;A$$E$2)'$;<(+$@(>@(A();$UdWg$F"&&"/)$/?$;<($@3@2&
>//@
! M2")?3&$@(2&";+$;<2;$>(@:"AA"D($@"=<;A$2@($)/;$>@/>(@;+$@"=<;A
0";<$@"A")=$D3&)(@2F"&";+
! ,(A();:();$/?$=/D(@):();$H$B/@>/@2;($=@(('$@($?/@(A;A
! ^(:/B@2;"A2;"/)$/?$;<($A;2;($C$:/@($A2+$")$>/&"B+$H$&20
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 14

Q<%A&.73'R%;S:%'(%T.#5).$6
^(_)";"D(&+4$F+$a/)A;";3;"/) M@/>/A('$")$M/&"B+$/@$^@2?;
HZ/@$!2)'$!20 !20
Ud %)=/&2$X677h[ Uid$52&20"$X67764$677i$'?;$&20[
6d 9/3;<$%?@"B2$XU88f4$677h[ Uhd$!(A/;</$X677i$>/&"B+[
id 5/#2:F"]3($XU88j[ UWd$9"(@@2$!(/)($X677W$>/&"B+[
hd c/;A02)2$XU8fV[ Ufd$c()")$XU88h4$677W$'?;$&20[
Wd T=2)'2$XU88W4$U88V[ Ujd$c3@P")2$.2A/$X677j4$6778$'?;
fd I2)#2)"2$XU888[ &20[
jd Y<2)2$XU8Vf4$U886[ UVd$e()+2$X'@2?;$B/)A;d$H$&2)'
Vd a/;($^S-D/"@($XU88V4$U888[
>/&"B+[
$ 9/3;<(@)$93'2)$X677V[
+#
$ K"=(@$XU88i4$U88j[
$#
" 52&"$XU88f4$6776[
$#
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 15

U<%D7N)H%#.%'>V72'4)*$%5.#27(7#*
Ud b2:F"2$X$677V$>/&"B+[ $#!"F(@"2$XU8h8ZWf4$U8jh[
"
6d 902#"&2)'$X677f[ $#K2:"F"2$X6776[
%
id I<($Y2:F"2$XU887[ $#Y3")(2$a/)2P@+
&
hd I/=/$XU8fh[
Wd c3@P")2$.2A/$XU88f4$U88j[
jd G;<"/>"2$XU88j[
Vd G@";@(2$XU88h[
8d ,02)'2$X677h[
U7d 9()(=2&$XU8j6[
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 16

=<%% ?$'$)%.)$'7*(%3#4#*7'4%#.%#$-).%
H7(5#(()((#.6%$)*+.)$*#.>(
Ud 523@";2)"2$$XU8Vi[ K/;$()/3=<$")?/@:2;"/)
6d a<2'$X$U8fj[ Y3")(2$c"AA23
G]32;/@"2&$Y3")(2
id ^,a$XU8fj4$U8ji4$U8V7
677f[ a();@2&$%?@"B2)$,(>d
a/)=/$c@2##2D"&&($XU8Vi$K(0
hd a2:(@//)$XU8jh[
&20k[
Wd G=+>;$XU886[ Y2F/)$XU8fi4$U8V64$U8Vj$K(0
fd K"=(@"2 &20k[
jd b":F2F0($XU8V6[
Vd 93'2)$X677W[
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 17

W<% X'.7'L#*%7*%/-'$%.)3#,*7L#*%#&%
3+($#>'.6%5.#5).$6%>)'*(%7*%5.'3L3)
$ ^(>()'A$/)$'(&"D(@+$C$D(@+$:"L('$>"B;3@($/?$2'/>;"/)$/?
#
)(0$&(=2&$>@/D"A"/)A$3>$2)'$'/0)$;<($B/);")();
" K/@:A$D2@+$C$'(>()'A$3>/)$0<(;<(@$$B3A;/:2@+
#
/0)(@A<">$"A$)(A;('$")$A;2;($&2)'$X(d=d$!"F(@"2[4$)(A;('
F3;$0";</3;$@(2&$(l(B;$X(d=d$I2)#2)"2$0<(@($*,,$&2)'$"A
>3F&"B$&2)'[$/@$23;/)/:/3A$X(d=d$a<")2[
id *<(;<(@$B3A;/:2@+$@"=<;A$:2+$/)&+$F($2B;"D2;('$F+
+)/!"%+*%!('&XB?d$I2)#2)"2$H$T=2)'2$0";<$a/;($^S-D/"@($H
52&"4$H$D"@;32&&+$2&&$&2)'$B&2":$A;2;(A[
18
& *<(;<(@$B&(2@$>@/D"A"/)$"A$:2'($?/@$@(;2")")=$>@/>(@;+
#

& *<(;<(@$B3A;/:2@+$@"=<;A$@(B/=)";"/)$(L;()'A$;/
#
B/&&(B;"D($$&2)'$@(A/3@B(A$XB?d$K2:"F"2$0";<$9/3;<
93'2)[
' Q/0$?2@$:")(@2&A4$;":F(@4$H$0"&'&"?($2@($@(B/=)"A('$2A
#
>2@;$/?$;<($>2BP2=($/@$)/;$2)'$</0$?2@$/D(@&2>>")=
B/)B(AA"/)A$2@($>(@:";;('$X2)$"AA3($")$:/A;$!2;")
%:(@"B2)$A;2;(A[
( ,(&2;('4$</0$?2@$+)/$,*%!('&*'3&*32!'!"%+*%!('&/D(@
#
@(A/3@B(A$/)$B/::3)";+$&2)'$'(@"D($?@/:$'"l(@();$&20A
2)'$/mB(A4$>@/'3B")=$B/);@2'"B;"/)A$X(d=d$9((
B/::/)&+$")$@(=2@'$;/$0"&'&"?(4$@"=<;A$/D(@$0<"B<
B/);@2'"B;$B/::3)";+$?/@(A;$@"=<;A4$A(($")$/"&4$;":F(@4
:")")=4$2)'$(D()$@2)B<")=$@"=<;A$")$A/:($!2;")
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa
%:(@"B2)$A;2;(A[ 19

jd Q/0$?2@$B/::3)";+$@"=<;A$;2P($>@(B('()B($/D(@
")D(A;:();$");(@(A;A$")$;<($A2:($&2)'$X(d=d$")
5/#2:F"]3($B/::3)";"(A$F2;;&($?/@$@"=<;A$0";<
=/D(@):();$A3>>/@;('$")D(A;/@AJ$A2:($")$:2)+$!2;")
%:(@"B2)$A;2;(A[
Vd Q/0$:2)+$&2)'$2@(2A$H$B&2AA(A$/?$</&'")=$2@($(LB&3'('
?@/:$B3A;/:2@+$>@/>(@;+$X:/A;$B/::/)&+$(LB&3'('$2@(
M2@PA$H$,(A(@D(A[$X(d=d$M<"&">>")(A4$-)'/)(A"24$!2;")
%:(@"B2)$2)'$%)=/&2$(LB&3'($F(A;$@(A/3@B($2@(2A$?@/:
B/::3)";+$F2A('$;()3@([
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa
20

, *<(;<(@$$;<($F2A"A$/?$;<($B/::3)";+$&2)'$2@(2$"A$;<(
#
D"&&2=(ZD"&&2=($B&3A;(@$/@$;@"F2&$/@$;(@@";/@"2&$2@(2$C$AB2&(
'/(A$:2;;(@$$2)'$A:2&&$"A$2&:/A;$2&02+A$F(A;
$ *<(;<(@$;<($&2)'$"A$D(A;('$'"@(B;&+$")$;<($B/::3)";+4
+#
2)$(&(B;('$F/'+$/?$;<($B/::3)";+4$2$B<"(?4$/@$2$@(:/;(@
B/3)B"&$/@$/;<(@$F/'+$X(d=d$:2)+$=/D(@):();A$D(A;
B/::3)";+$@"=<;A$")$@(:/;(@$'"A;@"B;ZB/3);+ZB/::3)(
=/D(@):();A$/@$2':")"A;@2;"/)A$2A$;@3A;((Ad$Q2A$B@(2;('
2$B/)A;";3;"/)2&$"AA3($")$9/3;<$%?@"B2[
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 21

UUd I<($&(D(&$/?$>@/;(B;"/)$H$@(B/3@A($B3A;/:2@+
/0)(@A$<2D($2=2")A;$A;2;($2)'$>@"D2;($A(B;/@
B//>;"/)$?/@$>3F&"B$>3@>/A($2)'$(A>(B"2&&+$</0
R>3F&"B$>3@>/A(S$"A$'(_)('$X:2+$")B&3'('$>@"D2;(
")D(A;:();$2A$2$>3F&"B$A(@D"B([
U6d %&A/$'(>()'A$/)$</0$)*"-&&20$2)'
2':")"A;@2;"/)$:2P(A$";$;/$:2P($B/::3)";+
;()3@($2$@(2&";+d$$52)+$3)3A2F&($>2@2'"=:A$<2D(
F(()$>@/l(@('$2&:/A;$2A$0";<$;<($");();$;/$?2"&d
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 22

CY< Z.)*H(%7*%23&#1(%$)*+.)
Ud -);(=@2&$;/$'(D/&3;"/)2@+$?/@(A;$=/D(@)2)B($/D(@2&&
6d %A$0";<$;()3@($=()(@2&&+$C$F/;<$>@"D2;"#2;"/)$H$;/
B/::3)";"(A
id I<($(D/&3;"/)$/?$;<($A;2;($;/$B/::3)";"(An$E
?@/:$>(;;+$2BB(AA$;/$:/@($2BB(AA$;/$:2)2=(:();$A<2@(4
:2)2=(:();$B/);@/&$;/$/0)(@A<">$XA(($)(L;$A&"'([
hd 9;"&&$3)'(@02+n$#-&.*+&%0)&2*8(+!%-&(.&+!/0%"&3),!6)+-&"A$;<(
@"=<;$;/$3A($2)'$:2)2=($/)&+
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 23

?$',)(%7*%H)2#427*,%$)*+.)
! ,"=<;$;/$'@+$?3(&0//'
! )E?2@:$;@(($>&2);")=$C$R;3@)$+/3@$(+(A$?@/:$;<($?/@(A;S
! c3l(@$#/)(A$E$$</>(?3&$B/:>@/:"A(A
! ^(_)('$2BB(AA$H$3A($@"=<;A$C$")$@(;3@)$?/@$@(>/@;")=
! o/");$?/@(A;$:2)2=(:();$C$2&&$0/@P4$)/$>/0(@
! 5")/@$?/@(A;A$2A$B/::3)";+$?/@(A;A$C$;/P()$=(A;3@(
! ,(D()3($A<2@")=$C$>2"'$;/$B//>(@2;(
! a/::(@B"2&$3A(@$@"=<;A$")$B/::3)";+$B/)B(AA"/)A
! a/::3)";+$;()3@($C$=/D(@):();$2"'A4$02;B<(A$C$2)'
;2L(A
! E$/@$B/::3)";+$&(2A(A$/3;4$(D()$F2BP$;/$Y/D(@):();
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 24

CC< J-#%#/*(%$-)%&#.)($(%#&%$-)%/#.4H0
Ud 5/A;$"A$1(22$'!%-&5+(5)+%-&#-&(+!/!'*,&+!/0%
" cTI$:/A;$"A$)2;"/)2&Z=/D(@):();$>@/>(@;+$F+
#
)2;"/)2&$&20$XR>3F&"B$?/@(A;S[
! jWp$/?$2&&$?/@(A;A$")$;<($0/@&'
! @$fWp$/?$i7$;@/>"B2&$B/3);@"(A$X,,-$677V[
%# %)'$2;$&(2A;$jjp$"A$Y/D(@):();$a/);@/&&('
&
# cTI$A;(2'+$'(D/&3;"/)2@+$;@()'$0(&&$3)'(@02+n
>@/>/@;"/)$/?$>@"D2;($H$B/::3)";+$/0)('$?/@(A;$<2A
@"A()$F+$jp$2)'$ip$A")B($6776
L. 25

1#.)($%[/*).(-75%7*%!YY=
?#+.3)R%::%!YY=]%::%K%ZZ[%!YYW
DEFG8E A7&>HFIJK8E&;>8>L;
Y/D(@):(); jWp Y/D(@):(); fWp
M@"D2;( Uhp M@"D2;( Uip
a/::3)";+ 8p a/::3)";+ UVp
a/::3)";+$3A( 6p a/::3)";+$3A( Wp
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 26

C!< J-#%#/*(%A&.73'^(%&#.)($(0
./@$Vhp$/?$;@/>"B2&$?/@(A;A$")$677V$E
MN=MO Y/D(@):();$/0)('$X'($?2B;/$/@$'($N3@([
7dUp M@"D2;(&+$/0)('$X")'"D"'32&A$H$_@:A[
7dhp a/::3)";+$/0)('
Udhp ^(A"=)2;('$?/@$B/::3)";+$3A(
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 27

_@Z%'4(#%'%($)'H6%.7()%7*%3#>>+*7$6%K%5.72'$)
#/*).(-75%(7*3)%!YY!
,"A($")$B/::3)";+$/0)('$?/@(A;A$q$?/3@E?/&'$A")B($6776
;/$6d7W$5<2
,"A($")$>@"D2;(&+$/0)('$?/@(A;A$")B@(2A('$?@/:$7$5<2$;/
7d6h$5<2
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 28

1A[%($+H6%#&%CU%3#+*$.7)(%7*34+H7*,
/##H4'*H%3#+*$.7)(%B!YY=E
PFHL;>&FQRLH PFHL;>&S;LTUD>
Y`G,K5GKI 8W
K2;"/)2&$Y/D; Vip M@/;(B;('$)/$3A( Ufp
M@/D")B"2&4$'"A;@"B; ip a3A;/:2@+$3A( fUp
53)"B">2&";+4$D"&&2=( ip o.5$?/@$&/B2&$3A( ip
;<(@$>3F&"B$F/'"(A fp a/)B(AA"/)AZ&"B()B(A hp
M,-`%IG a/)B(AA"/)AZ&(2A(A Uip
-)'3A;@"(AZ_@:A 7p a/::3)";+$B/)B(AA"/)A
-)'"D"'32&A ip H$&"B()B(A$H$&(2A(A 6p
;<(@$>@"D2;($/0)(@A Up
a55TK-I1 Up
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 29

CF<% S)((#*(%&.#>%H)2#42)H%&#.)($%$)*+.)
<= K,33/)1%@&-,"#'%&,9)#"'21.&1'&!,,*&-,"&C
! a/)A(@D2;"/)$ XR"?$";$"A$/3@A$0($0"&&$&//P$2?;(@$";S[
! 52)2=(:();$ X/)EA";(4$P)/0$0</$"A$3A")=$0<2;4
B<(2>$ ;<(@(?/@($A3A;2")2F&([
! a";"#()$(:>/0(@:();$ X<(&>A$@3@2&$>//@$=(;$/@=2)"#('[
! Y/D(@)2)B($")$=()(@2&$$ X()B/3@2=(A$$")B&3A"D($=/D(@)2)B([
! 9;2;($@(B/)A;@3B;"/) X<(&>A$.^$@(A;@3B;3@($@/&(A$;/$F($:/@(
'(:/B@2;"B$2)'$:/@($2'D"A/@+$;<2)
@();EA((P")=[
! M/D(@;+$@('3B;"/)$ X2A$/0)(@A$<2D($:/@($B/);@/&$/D(@
F()(_;A[
! 9/B"2&$@(&2;"/)A$ X0/:()$>&2+$2$P(+$@/&($")$?/@(A;$
B/::";;((A$2)'$()A3@($A3FA"A;()B($H
?2:"&+$");(@(A;Ad$a&2AA$@(&2;"/)A$2@($2&A/
2&;(@('$E$2)$")B&3A"D($;()3@($2>>@/2B<
B2)$")B&3'($;<($:/A;$>//@
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 30

6d$94'!'/&;<($?/@(A;4$@2;<(@$;<2)$<2D")=$2BB(AA$;/$;<(
?/@(A;$/@$:2)2=(:();$@(A>/)A"F"&";"(A$"A$3A32&&+$;<(
%!55!'/&5(!'%&#)%4))'&"$"%*!'*#,)&:*'3&10)*5;
1('")+6*%!('&*'3&'(%&$")&(+&2*'*/)2)'%&5(4)+"
:7(22$'!%-&*'3&5+!6*%)&.(+)"%"&!'&<)5*,=&>'3(')"!*=&70!'*&*'3&?*'@*'!*&!,,$"%+*%)&%0)&1*");
"d(d TA($@"=<;A$2@($'(%&()/3=<
"d(d 52)2=(:();$23;</@";+$"A$'(%$()/3=<
"d(d c3l(@$#/)(A4$F()(_;EA<2@")=$"A$'(;$()/3=<
"d(d o/");$?/@(A;$:2)2=(:();$"A$'(%$()/3=<
0)(@A<">$>@/;(B;A$");(@(A;A4$>@/D"'(A$2&&$@"=<;A$/?$/0)(@A<">$X(d=d$;/
&"B()B($2)'$_)($H$'(B"'($3A($")$;<($_@A;$>&2B([4$;/$F($>@":2@+
F()(_B"2@+4$;/$F($B/:>()A2;('$>@/>(@&+$0<()$&2)'$;2P()$?/@$>3F&"B
>3@>/A([d
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 31

% 0)(@A<">$/?$?/@(A;$&2)'$4!%0($%&%0)&%+))"&"A$?3;"&(
#
X!"F(@"24$a2:(@//)[$d$^(A"=)('$;/$>@(E(:>;$&/B2&
B/);@/&$2)'$@(D()3(d$ %&A/$>@/'3B(A$3)0/@P2F&(
/D(@&2>>")=$@"=<;A$F+$=/D(@):();Z;":F(@$&/==")=
B/)B(@)A$H$B/::3)";+$@"=<;Ad
hd 0)(@A<">$4!%0($%&%0)&1('%+(,,!'/&5(4)+"&(.
(4')+"0!5$"A$2&A/$")(l(B;"D($2)'$2)$2F3A($/?$@"=<;AJ
;<"A$'/(A$)/;$:(2)$/0)(@A$A</3&'$)/;$F($A3FN(B;$;/
B/)A(@D2;"/)4$'"A;@"F3;"/)$2)'$/;<(@$@(=3&2;"/)$F3;$;<2;
;<($?/3)'")=$>/0(@$/?$:2)2=(:();$:3A;$@(A"'($0";<
;<($B/::3)";+$2A$/0)(@$X)/;$;<($B2A($")$Y<2)24$!"F(@"24
a2:(@//)[
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 32

A(4)+"&(.&(4')+B2*'*/)2)'%&2$"%&!'1,$3)&.$,,
+)/$,*%(+-&5(4)+C$;/$&"B()B(4$;/$&(2A(4$;/$2>>@(<()'$H
_)($X/@$A()'$;/$B/3@;$?/@$&2@=($/l()B(A[$C$2=2")$'/(A
)/;$:(2)$)(('$)/;$F($A3FN(B;$;/$/D(@@"'")=$@(=3&2;"/)
/)$P(+$2A>(B;A4$F3;$:3A;$<2D($@(2A/)2F&($>/0(@Ad
! D)%%!'/&%0)&!'"%!%$%!('*,&#*"!"&+!/0%&!"&*,"(&E)-n$0($<2D(
"
A(()$2$&/;$/?$:3''&('$;<")P")=$B/)?3A")=$3A($");(@(A;A
0";<$/0)(@A<">$");(@(A;AJ$?/@(A;$3A(@$=@/3>A$/@$();(@>@"A(
=@/3>A$2@($_)($F3;$A</3&'$F($&"B()A('$?@/:$;<($/0)(@$C
;<($B/::3)";+d$a2)$A(;$3>$B/:>(;")=$");(@(A;A$;<($3A(@
=@/3>$2)'$;<($B/::3)";+$"?$;<(A($=@/3>A$/>(@2;($/3;A"'(
/?$2$@(B/=)"A('$B/::3)";+$;()3@($?@2:(0/@Pd$%&A/$:2P(A
;<($;@2)A";"/)$?@/:$3A(@$@"=<;A$;/$/0)(@A<">$;@"BP+d
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 33

fd I<($6!,,*/)&1(22$'!%-&C$)/;$2$;@3A;(($'"A;@"B;$B/3)B"&4
=/D(@):();$(+&%+!#*,&10!).&:3A;$F($;<($/0)(@J
2)+;<")=$/3;A"'($;<($D"&&2=($"A$;//$@(:/D('$;/$F(
:(2)")=?3&$2A$R/0)(@S$r(d=d$c/;A02)24$K2:"F"24$e()+24
c3@P")2$.2A/4$K3F2Z93'2)sd
jd D)%%!'/&%0)&"(1!(F"5*%!*,&.+*2)4(+E&+!/0%&!"&*'&!'%)/+*,
+)G$!+)2)'%H&a3A;/:2@+$/0)(@A<">$/?$A<2@('$2AA(;A$"A
F(A;$'(_)('$/)$;<($&/="B2&$/>(@2;"/)2&$2@(2$/?$;<(
B/::3)";+$&2)'$2@(24$)/;$2$>2@;$/?$";4$)/@$3>$;/$;@"F2&
&(D(&d$./@$>@2B;"B2&$@(2A/)A$2&A/$P)/0$;<2;$$R;<($A:2&&(@
;<($F(;;(@$C$;@"F2&$/0)(@A<">$"A$)/;$:3B<$'"l(@();
?@/:$=/D(@):();$/0)(@A<">S$C$;//$@(:/D('$?@/:$;<(
B/::3)";+d
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 34

* I<($)(('$;/$'"A;")=3"A<$F(;0(()$3A(@A$2)'
#
/0)(@Z:2)2=(@An$3A(@$=@/3>A$/@$();(@>@"A($=@/3>A
A</3&'$F($@(=3&2;('$F+$;<($/0)(@$C$;<($B/::3)";+
/@$";A$2':")"A;@2;"D($F/'+d
%&;</3=<$:2)+$B2A(A$<2D($/)($A;@/)=$&(=4$F(A;$>@2B;"B($B2A(A$;()'
;/$F3"&'$/)$;<@(($&(=A$/?$;<($A;//&$X(d=d$5(L"B/4$I2)#2)"24$92F2<$H
92@202P4$I<($Y2:F"2[
<= H#(,!)1V#&)./'"-,#!&$'&%2#&-,/)*$%1,)
W= G/1+*&,)&#X1'%1)!T)#9&*#3,("$%1(&0)112/#&*(#/-&#&2&#)/-
34 5266*('1!).'"&%2#&(,33/)1%@&$'&3$)$!#"&1)(+/*1)!&"1!2%&%,
1''/#'&(,33#"(1$+&/'#&+1(#)(#'Y&Z)#&,[#)*#"'Y&#)%#"&(,)%"$(%'
$)*&($)&+131%&(,)(#''1,)&1)%#"#'%'=&K$)&$+',&+#$'#&,/%&%2#
-,"#'%&,"&.$"%&,-&1%&&#C#)&0$(]&%,&!,C#")3#)%=
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 35

K/;$A3@>@"A")=$;<2;$;<($A")=&($:/A;$A3BB(AA?3&$B2A($/?
B/::3)";+$/0)('$?/@(A;@+$"A$I2)#2)"24$0<(@($@//;('
")$C
! 9/B"/EA>2;"2&&+4$;<($D"&&2=($X)/;$;<($02@'4$/@$'"A;@"B;$/@$B<"(?'/:[
! a/::3)";+$?/@(A;$2@(2A$2@($)(A;('$0";<")$;<($'(_)('$B/::3)";+
&2)'$2@(2
! ./@(A;$:2)2=(:();$A;(:A$?@/:$;<($?3&&+$(&(B;('$B/::3)";+
=/D(@):();$B/3)B"&4$)/;$/)($>2@;$/?$;<($B/::3)";+
! Q2A$B/:>&(;($>/0(@A$/?$:2)2=(:();$(D()$;/$(L;();$/?$F(")=$2F&($;/
'(;(@:")($/0)$(AA();"2&$@(A(@D('$A>(B"(A
! -)$B<2@=($/?$&"B()A")=$C$2)'$B/3&'$"?$)(('$F($&(2A($;<($&2)'$2&;</3=<
)(('A$=/D(@):();$>(@:"AA"/)$?/@$;<"A
! ^/(A$)/;$B/)?3A($3A(@$=@/3>A$0";<$/0)(@AJ$;<(+$2@($&"B()A('$F+$;<(
B/::3)";+$X";A$.a[$)/;$23;/)/:/3A$/?$";
! Q2A$2$A":>&($2)'$2&:/A;$B/A;E?@(($:(;</'/&/=+$/?$@(B/=)"A")=$;<($a.
K/0$:/@($;<2)$U4h77$a.$(:F@2B")=$6$5<2
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 36

Z-)%`+)(L#*(%&'37*,%$-)%.),7#*
Ud -A$";$>/AA"F&($?/@$2&:/A;$2&&$;<($?/@(A;$@(A/3@B($;/$F(
/0)('$F+$/@'")2@+$B";"#()A$F+$67W7$C$2)'$:/A;$/?$";
<(&'$B/&&(B;"D(&+$F+$B/::3)";"(Ak
" -A$";$>/AA"F&($;<2;$A;2;($?/@(A;$>/0(@A$B2)$F(
#
@(A;@3B;3@('$;/02@'A$;<($;(B<)"B2&$2'D"A/@+4$@(=3&2;/@+
H$02;B<'/=$?3)B;"/)A$;<2;$2@($A3>>/A('$;/$F($;<(
?3)B;"/)A$/?$'(:/B@2;"B$=/D(@):();k
-A$c/;A02)2$;/$@(:2")$;<($/)&+$%?@"B2)$A;2;($;/$=(;$";A$A;2;(Z=/D(@):();$&2)'A
'/0)$;/$Wp$2)'$)(2@&+$2&&$/?$;<"A$")$;<($3@F2)$2@(2k$I/$F($?2"@$T=2)'2$2)'
I2)#2)"2$<2D($;@"('$F+$'(B&2@")=$2&&$B3A;/:2@+$&2)'A$)/)EY/D(@):();$&2)'Ad
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 37

% *</$"A$;<($@"=<;?3&$&(AA/@n$=/D(@):();$/@$B/::3)";+k$-A$";
#
>/AA"F&($;<2;$/@'")2@+$B";"#()A$B/3&'$F($;<($"0*+)0(,3)+"$/?
B/&&(B;"D($B/::(@B"2&$?/@(A;$();(@>@"A(4$=/D(@):();A
=2")")=$;<("@$@(D()3($A<2@($;<@/3=<$;<($>@/>(@$B<2))(&$C
;2L2;"/)k
& %)'$"A$";$>/AA"F&($;<2;$4!%0($%$;@2)A?/@:2;"/)$")$?/@(A;
#
;()3@($;<2;$B/)O"B;$F(;0(()$A;2;($2)'$>(/>&($0"&&$0"'()$2A
>3##&('$'"AB/);();$;3@)A$");/$/3;@2=($2;$A3A;2")('
'"A>/AA(AA"/)k
%)'$")$2$0/@A;$B2A($AB()2@"/$")$;<2;$")A;2)B(4$A<2&&$0($A((
:"&";"2A$<"@('$F+$B/)B(AA"/)$B/:>2)"(A$=32@'")=$;<("@$"&&E
=/;;()$B/)B(AA"/)A4$/@$=/D(@):();$2&&+")=$0";<$;<(:
2=2")A;$;<("@$/0)$>(/>&(k
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 38

' %)'$?/@$</0$&/)=$B2)$0($'()+$@"=<;?3&$>@/>(@;+k
#
%@($0($A;"&&$=/")=$;/$F($")$;<($UVVW$:/'($/?$;<(
c(@&")$a/)?(@()B($2;$0<"B<$)2;"D($/0)(@A<">$/?
&2)'A$02A$'()"('k$Q2D($0($(D(@$2B;32&&+$B/:(
/3;$/?$";k$@$0"&&$0($@(:2")$?/@$2)/;<(@$<2&?
B();3@+$0";<$;<($&2A;$B/&/)"2&$]3(A;"/)
3)@(A/&D('k
( %)'$0<(@($0"&&$;<"A$@(="/)$F(k$$I":($;/$&(2'k
#
L. Alden Wily, May 2009 Forest Tenure in Africa 39