SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 37
URBAN DESIGN & STREET
TYPOLOGY
Do they matter?
William Riggs, PhD, AICP, LEED AP
Assistant Professor, City & Regional Planning
Tweet questions to @billyriggs
RATIONALE
CONTEXT
OUTCOMES
RATIONALE
6
CONTEXT
CONTEXT 1
Louisville, KY
• Brook and First Streets
– One way multi-lane
parallel streets since
the 1950’s
– Converted to a two
way, single lane street
with a bike lane in
Summer 2011
One way Brook Street: July 2007
Two-way Brook Street August 2011
CONTEXT 2
LONDON
USE OF CARROTS & STICKS TO MEET SUSTAINABILITY GOALS
PUSH PEOPLE OUT OF CARS & PULL PEOPLE TO TRANSIT, BIKES & WALKING
Source: Greater London Authority
Source: Broaddus, 2014
ECON CHANGE 01-11
OUTCOME
CORE QUESTIONS
• Can thinking about street
design increase safety (Riggs
and Gilderbloom, 2015)?
• Can investments in pedestrian /
bike safety bring about more
ecological and economic
resilience (Gilderbloom, Riggs
& Meares, 2014)?
LONDON
OUTCOME 1
SURVEY OF MODE SHIFT
SUCESS
• Push people out of cars with
fiscal stick
• Vehicle traffic volumes
reduced 27%, stable over
time
• 80,000 fewer vehicles per
day
• Pull people into sustainable
modes
• Transit use up 14%, rising
mode share for biking and
walking
2001 to 2011 - 11.3% growth in trips made in Greater London
Source: Broaddus, 2014
TRIP CHANGE 01-11
MODE SHIFT
2001 to 2011 – 6% decline in driving, 6% growth in transit use
LONDON
OUTCOME 2
FUNDING & BUILT
ENVIRONMENT CHANGES
• £150M Annually for Transit, Bike,
& Ped Improve
• Key Projects / Locations
• Exhibition Road
• Shepherd’s Bush Westfield
• Thames Bicycle
Superhighway
• Bike Share
LONDON
OUTCOME 3
LESSONS IN DESIGN
• Experimentation
• Focus on simplicity and existing
assets
• Land use and form parallels
LOUISVILLE
OUTCOME 1
• Decreased
– Collisions:
• -36% on Brook
• -60% on First
• Increased
– Traffic Volumes
– Calmer traffic
– Pedestrian & bike
traffic
Significant decrease in
accidents despite slight
increase in volumes
Speeds up to 50-60 mph were clocked during
the am peak on one-way segments (limit is 35 mph)
LOUISVILLE
OUTCOME 2
• Increased
– Property
Improvements: 2x
• Property Values:
– 39% on Brook
– Tax revenue
Significant increase in
property values
Property Taxes
• Average for one-way streets is: $17,886
• Average for two-way streets is: $42,820
– Increased property taxes could pay for
conversion (value capture)
– >$250,000 lost taxes
– West Louisville: multi-lane one-way
streets lose ~$2 million in taxes
LOUISVILLE
OUTCOME 3
• Decreased
– Crime 23%
• Increased
– Business
revenues
Significant decrease in crime
despite slight increase in
citywide and in an adjacent
neighborhood
Photos tell the story of thriving business on two-way
Abandoned business/vacant structure on one-way segments
KEY LESSIONS & FUTURE WORK
• STREET SUITABILITY / DESIGN OF
SURROUNDS MATTER
• TYPOLOGY / STREET TYPOLOGY ARE
ALSO IMPORTANT & MAY HAVE
TRAFFIC CALMING EFFECT
– Hypothesis 1: Perceived Distance
– Hypothesis 2: Visual Interest
FUTURE WORK
• Longitudinally
track the impact
of numerous
street
conversions
• Evaluate
perceptions on
different streets
with varying
LOS
Q&A
William Riggs
wriggs@calpoly.edu

More Related Content

What's hot

Capitol Hill Cc 12110
Capitol Hill Cc 12110Capitol Hill Cc 12110
Capitol Hill Cc 12110jseattle
 
Sustainable Cities: Sustainable Transportation
Sustainable Cities: Sustainable TransportationSustainable Cities: Sustainable Transportation
Sustainable Cities: Sustainable TransportationAnuradha Mukherji
 
Delivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner Expressway
Delivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner ExpresswayDelivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner Expressway
Delivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner ExpresswayToronto Public Consultation Unit
 
Urban Form and Design - Course Review
Urban Form and Design - Course ReviewUrban Form and Design - Course Review
Urban Form and Design - Course ReviewAnuradha Mukherji
 
NJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets Cotter
NJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets CotterNJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets Cotter
NJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets CotterNew Jersey Future
 
Reimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panels
Reimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panelsReimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panels
Reimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panelsknelischer
 
Urban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & ResilienceUrban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & ResilienceAnuradha Mukherji
 
Urban Design: Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Design: Sustainability & ResilienceUrban Design: Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Design: Sustainability & ResilienceAnuradha Mukherji
 
Manor Park Neighborhood Urban Park
Manor Park Neighborhood Urban ParkManor Park Neighborhood Urban Park
Manor Park Neighborhood Urban ParkJose Carlos Ayala
 
Urban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical Precedents
Urban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical PrecedentsUrban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical Precedents
Urban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical PrecedentsAnuradha Mukherji
 
Clifton Avenue Streetscape Design - Posters
Clifton Avenue Streetscape Design - PostersClifton Avenue Streetscape Design - Posters
Clifton Avenue Streetscape Design - PostersJake Henderson
 
Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010
Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010
Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010City of Geneva
 
Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)
Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)
Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)knelischer
 
Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1
Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1
Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1Toronto Public Consultation Unit
 
Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010
Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010
Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010Daniel X. O'Neil
 
Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)
Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)
Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)Toronto Public Consultation Unit
 

What's hot (20)

Capitol Hill Cc 12110
Capitol Hill Cc 12110Capitol Hill Cc 12110
Capitol Hill Cc 12110
 
Sustainable Cities: Sustainable Transportation
Sustainable Cities: Sustainable TransportationSustainable Cities: Sustainable Transportation
Sustainable Cities: Sustainable Transportation
 
Delivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner Expressway
Delivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner ExpresswayDelivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner Expressway
Delivering the Rehabilitation of the F.G. Gardiner Expressway
 
Urban Form and Design - Course Review
Urban Form and Design - Course ReviewUrban Form and Design - Course Review
Urban Form and Design - Course Review
 
NJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets Cotter
NJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets CotterNJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets Cotter
NJ Future Forum 2012 Complete Streets Cotter
 
Reimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panels
Reimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panelsReimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panels
Reimagining yonge_street__pic_3_display_panels
 
The Cermak/Blue Island Sustainable Streetscape
The Cermak/Blue Island Sustainable StreetscapeThe Cermak/Blue Island Sustainable Streetscape
The Cermak/Blue Island Sustainable Streetscape
 
Urban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & ResilienceUrban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Form and Design - Urban Sustainability & Resilience
 
What if 280 came down
What if 280 came downWhat if 280 came down
What if 280 came down
 
Urban Design: Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Design: Sustainability & ResilienceUrban Design: Sustainability & Resilience
Urban Design: Sustainability & Resilience
 
Manor Park Neighborhood Urban Park
Manor Park Neighborhood Urban ParkManor Park Neighborhood Urban Park
Manor Park Neighborhood Urban Park
 
Urban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical Precedents
Urban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical PrecedentsUrban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical Precedents
Urban Form and Design - Key Concepts & Historical Precedents
 
Clifton Avenue Streetscape Design - Posters
Clifton Avenue Streetscape Design - PostersClifton Avenue Streetscape Design - Posters
Clifton Avenue Streetscape Design - Posters
 
Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010
Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010
Kane County 529 PACE Route Study Presentation 2010
 
Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)
Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)
Emery village pic #1 boards v4 (reduced)
 
Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1
Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1
Glen Road Pedestrian Bridge Environmental Assessment Study - PIC #1
 
Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010
Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010
Congress Parkway Construction Overview, January 2010
 
041916-HBP-Media Packet-Complete
041916-HBP-Media Packet-Complete041916-HBP-Media Packet-Complete
041916-HBP-Media Packet-Complete
 
Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)
Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)
Six Points Reconfiguration - Community Update June, 2013 (Poster Boards)
 
King Street Pilot Public Meeting
King Street Pilot Public MeetingKing Street Pilot Public Meeting
King Street Pilot Public Meeting
 

Viewers also liked

What's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADI
What's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADIWhat's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADI
What's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADIaalliance
 
Elements of urban design
Elements of urban designElements of urban design
Elements of urban designNeo Angala
 
Road Design Session
Road Design SessionRoad Design Session
Road Design SessionPraja
 
Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)
Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)
Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)SJ Ohi
 
Pili abis input2012
Pili abis   input2012Pili abis   input2012
Pili abis input2012INPUT 2012
 
Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...
Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...
Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...agungwah
 
Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...
Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...
Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...moscowuforum
 
Historical network research
Historical network researchHistorical network research
Historical network researchMaria Bostenaru
 
Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"
Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"
Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"Placefocus
 
Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)
Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)
Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)SJ Ohi
 
Who needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street network
Who needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street networkWho needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street network
Who needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street networkurbanbairam
 
Mock Revitalization Project
Mock Revitalization ProjectMock Revitalization Project
Mock Revitalization Projectlasleym
 
Kolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post soviet
Kolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post sovietKolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post soviet
Kolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post sovietIryna Sobetska
 
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brandsChallenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brandsVasily Dubeykovskiy
 

Viewers also liked (20)

2.25.15
2.25.152.25.15
2.25.15
 
What's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADI
What's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADIWhat's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADI
What's different between urban planning, urban design, architecture, AADI
 
Elements of urban design
Elements of urban designElements of urban design
Elements of urban design
 
Road Design Session
Road Design SessionRoad Design Session
Road Design Session
 
Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)
Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)
Urban street segments (Pedestrian modes)
 
Pili abis input2012
Pili abis   input2012Pili abis   input2012
Pili abis input2012
 
Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...
Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...
Modelling the spatial decisions of private developers: A case study of Jakart...
 
Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...
Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...
Markus Stebich. Tourism & the Urban environment: elements of a mature city ho...
 
Market Research on Russian cities _ MLA+
Market Research on Russian cities _ MLA+Market Research on Russian cities _ MLA+
Market Research on Russian cities _ MLA+
 
Historical network research
Historical network researchHistorical network research
Historical network research
 
Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"
Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"
Place Typology: section 4 "intro to urban design and placemaking"
 
Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)
Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)
Traffic flow and Capacity (Pedestrian Mode)
 
Who needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street network
Who needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street networkWho needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street network
Who needs giant roads? Donwgrade of big infrastructures and Ufa street network
 
Mock Revitalization Project
Mock Revitalization ProjectMock Revitalization Project
Mock Revitalization Project
 
New Urban Topologies
New Urban TopologiesNew Urban Topologies
New Urban Topologies
 
Kolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post soviet
Kolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post sovietKolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post soviet
Kolomak evolution of the spatial proportions in the post soviet
 
Morse Road Design Study
Morse Road Design StudyMorse Road Design Study
Morse Road Design Study
 
John Massengale, Street Design
John Massengale, Street Design John Massengale, Street Design
John Massengale, Street Design
 
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brandsChallenges and opportunities for russian city brands
Challenges and opportunities for russian city brands
 
Lect 2 typology (1)
Lect 2   typology (1)Lect 2   typology (1)
Lect 2 typology (1)
 

Similar to Urban Design and Street Typology: Do They Matter?

Gardiner short briefing package
Gardiner   short briefing packageGardiner   short briefing package
Gardiner short briefing packageWaterfrontTO
 
RV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan Gallagher
RV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan GallagherRV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan Gallagher
RV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan GallagherRail~Volution
 
Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)
Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)
Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)GardinerEast
 
The New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant Communities
The New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant CommunitiesThe New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant Communities
The New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant CommunitiesVierbicher
 
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David PetersonThe Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David PetersonTrailnet
 
Oxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm Strategy
Oxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm StrategyOxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm Strategy
Oxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm StrategyOxfordshireCC
 
Arlington, Virginia's Transportation Future
Arlington, Virginia's Transportation FutureArlington, Virginia's Transportation Future
Arlington, Virginia's Transportation FutureMobility Lab
 
DMURS - DIT November 2014
DMURS - DIT November 2014 DMURS - DIT November 2014
DMURS - DIT November 2014 Jason Taylor
 
Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010
Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010
Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010Joe Zaccaria
 
02 cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.12
02   cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.1202   cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.12
02 cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.12cityofevanston
 
Designing for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim Pheby
Designing for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim PhebyDesigning for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim Pheby
Designing for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim PhebyTim Pheby
 

Similar to Urban Design and Street Typology: Do They Matter? (20)

Gardiner short briefing package
Gardiner   short briefing packageGardiner   short briefing package
Gardiner short briefing package
 
RV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan Gallagher
RV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan GallagherRV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan Gallagher
RV 2014: Can We Get There from Here? First and Last Miles by Dan Gallagher
 
Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)
Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)
Public Forum 3 - Presentation (Feb 6_2014)
 
Pic 2 panels june 23 2015
Pic 2 panels june 23 2015Pic 2 panels june 23 2015
Pic 2 panels june 23 2015
 
Public Meeting #2 Information Materials
Public Meeting #2 Information MaterialsPublic Meeting #2 Information Materials
Public Meeting #2 Information Materials
 
The New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant Communities
The New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant CommunitiesThe New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant Communities
The New Urbanism: Design Principles for Vibrant Communities
 
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David PetersonThe Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
The Minneapolis Bicycle Story David Peterson
 
Oxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm Strategy
Oxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm StrategyOxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm Strategy
Oxford City Centre Movement and Public Realm Strategy
 
Arlington, Virginia's Transportation Future
Arlington, Virginia's Transportation FutureArlington, Virginia's Transportation Future
Arlington, Virginia's Transportation Future
 
Waterfront Transit Reset Phase 2 Display Panels
Waterfront Transit Reset Phase 2 Display PanelsWaterfront Transit Reset Phase 2 Display Panels
Waterfront Transit Reset Phase 2 Display Panels
 
Placemaking through complete streets
Placemaking through complete streetsPlacemaking through complete streets
Placemaking through complete streets
 
King Street Phase 2 Slide Deck
King Street Phase 2 Slide Deck King Street Phase 2 Slide Deck
King Street Phase 2 Slide Deck
 
DMURS - DIT November 2014
DMURS - DIT November 2014 DMURS - DIT November 2014
DMURS - DIT November 2014
 
CDOT South Loop Chicago Overview
CDOT South Loop Chicago OverviewCDOT South Loop Chicago Overview
CDOT South Loop Chicago Overview
 
2 cip infuse-ottawa-bennett
2 cip infuse-ottawa-bennett2 cip infuse-ottawa-bennett
2 cip infuse-ottawa-bennett
 
Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010
Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010
Nwep sfot presentation_nov_9_2010
 
Paul Buchanan
Paul BuchananPaul Buchanan
Paul Buchanan
 
02 cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.12
02   cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.1202   cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.12
02 cta yellow line station evanston cc 04.16.12
 
F2 Restoring Vibrant Downtowns
F2 Restoring Vibrant DowntownsF2 Restoring Vibrant Downtowns
F2 Restoring Vibrant Downtowns
 
Designing for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim Pheby
Designing for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim PhebyDesigning for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim Pheby
Designing for Cycling RTPI 15.6.16 Tim Pheby
 

More from William Riggs

Invest Bavaria Maifest Keynote
Invest Bavaria Maifest KeynoteInvest Bavaria Maifest Keynote
Invest Bavaria Maifest KeynoteWilliam Riggs
 
Autonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the Street
Autonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the StreetAutonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the Street
Autonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the StreetWilliam Riggs
 
ReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America Summit
ReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America SummitReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America Summit
ReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America SummitWilliam Riggs
 
Complexity Transport Housing & Future Cities
Complexity Transport Housing & Future CitiesComplexity Transport Housing & Future Cities
Complexity Transport Housing & Future CitiesWilliam Riggs
 
Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...
Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...
Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...William Riggs
 
Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.
Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.
Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.William Riggs
 
TESTING SOCIAL NORMS AS AN INCENTIVE TO ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIOR
TESTING SOCIAL NORMS  AS AN INCENTIVE TO  ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIORTESTING SOCIAL NORMS  AS AN INCENTIVE TO  ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIOR
TESTING SOCIAL NORMS AS AN INCENTIVE TO ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIORWilliam Riggs
 
Smart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of Los Angeles
Smart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of  Los AngelesSmart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of  Los Angeles
Smart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of Los AngelesWilliam Riggs
 
APA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning Technology
APA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning TechnologyAPA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning Technology
APA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning TechnologyWilliam Riggs
 
Estimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentives
Estimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentivesEstimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentives
Estimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentivesWilliam Riggs
 
GIS for Research and Data Management
GIS for Research and Data ManagementGIS for Research and Data Management
GIS for Research and Data ManagementWilliam Riggs
 
Cargo Bikes & Travel Decisions
Cargo Bikes & Travel DecisionsCargo Bikes & Travel Decisions
Cargo Bikes & Travel DecisionsWilliam Riggs
 

More from William Riggs (12)

Invest Bavaria Maifest Keynote
Invest Bavaria Maifest KeynoteInvest Bavaria Maifest Keynote
Invest Bavaria Maifest Keynote
 
Autonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the Street
Autonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the StreetAutonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the Street
Autonomous Cities: Reinventing the City Starting with the Street
 
ReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America Summit
ReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America SummitReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America Summit
ReStreet :: StreetPlan Presentation at the 2016 Code for America Summit
 
Complexity Transport Housing & Future Cities
Complexity Transport Housing & Future CitiesComplexity Transport Housing & Future Cities
Complexity Transport Housing & Future Cities
 
Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...
Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...
Hampered by Hardcoreness? On Availability Bias and How Group Cycling Events F...
 
Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.
Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.
Research Informing Practice: Opportunities for Transportation Partnerships.
 
TESTING SOCIAL NORMS AS AN INCENTIVE TO ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIOR
TESTING SOCIAL NORMS  AS AN INCENTIVE TO  ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIORTESTING SOCIAL NORMS  AS AN INCENTIVE TO  ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIOR
TESTING SOCIAL NORMS AS AN INCENTIVE TO ACTIVE TRANSPORTION BEHAVIOR
 
Smart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of Los Angeles
Smart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of  Los AngelesSmart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of  Los Angeles
Smart Growth, Displacement and Environmental Justice: The Case of Los Angeles
 
APA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning Technology
APA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning TechnologyAPA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning Technology
APA Tech Toolkit: Establishing your Roots in Planning Technology
 
Estimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentives
Estimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentivesEstimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentives
Estimating the potential for mode shift based on price and incentives
 
GIS for Research and Data Management
GIS for Research and Data ManagementGIS for Research and Data Management
GIS for Research and Data Management
 
Cargo Bikes & Travel Decisions
Cargo Bikes & Travel DecisionsCargo Bikes & Travel Decisions
Cargo Bikes & Travel Decisions
 

Recently uploaded

Call Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full NightCall Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Nightssuser7cb4ff
 
毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree 毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree ttt fff
 
办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一diploma 1
 
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdfgroup_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdfneelspinoy
 
8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCR
8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCR8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCR
8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCRdollysharma2066
 
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025Rndexperts
 
韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作
韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作
韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作7tz4rjpd
 
昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档208367051
 
'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,
'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,
'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,Aginakm1
 
原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档208367051
 
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...Rishabh Aryan
 
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025Rndexperts
 
2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degreeyuu sss
 
FiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdf
FiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdfFiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdf
FiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdfShivakumar Viswanathan
 
shot list for my tv series two steps back
shot list for my tv series two steps backshot list for my tv series two steps back
shot list for my tv series two steps back17lcow074
 
Iconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing services
Iconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing servicesIconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing services
Iconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing servicesIconic global solution
 
PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024
PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024
PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024CristobalHeraud
 
Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...
Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...
Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...mrchrns005
 
ARt app | UX Case Study
ARt app | UX Case StudyARt app | UX Case Study
ARt app | UX Case StudySophia Viganò
 
办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一Fi L
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Call Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full NightCall Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
Call Girls Aslali 7397865700 Ridhima Hire Me Full Night
 
毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree 毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree澳洲弗林德斯大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
 
办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理(USYD毕业证书)澳洲悉尼大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdfgroup_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
group_15_empirya_p1projectIndustrial.pdf
 
8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCR
8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCR8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCR
8377877756 Full Enjoy @24/7 Call Girls in Nirman Vihar Delhi NCR
 
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
 
韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作
韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作
韩国SKKU学位证,成均馆大学毕业证书1:1制作
 
昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
昆士兰大学毕业证(UQ毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
 
'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,
'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,
'CASE STUDY OF INDIRA PARYAVARAN BHAVAN DELHI ,
 
原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
原版1:1定制堪培拉大学毕业证(UC毕业证)#文凭成绩单#真实留信学历认证永久存档
 
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
DAKSHIN BIHAR GRAMIN BANK: REDEFINING THE DIGITAL BANKING EXPERIENCE WITH A U...
 
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
Top 10 Modern Web Design Trends for 2025
 
2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
2024新版美国旧金山州立大学毕业证成绩单pdf电子版制作修改#毕业文凭制作#回国入职#diploma#degree
 
FiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdf
FiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdfFiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdf
FiveHypotheses_UIDMasterclass_18April2024.pdf
 
shot list for my tv series two steps back
shot list for my tv series two steps backshot list for my tv series two steps back
shot list for my tv series two steps back
 
Iconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing services
Iconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing servicesIconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing services
Iconic Global Solution - web design, Digital Marketing services
 
PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024
PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024
PORTFOLIO DE ARQUITECTURA CRISTOBAL HERAUD 2024
 
Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...
Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...
Business research proposal mcdo.pptxBusiness research proposal mcdo.pptxBusin...
 
ARt app | UX Case Study
ARt app | UX Case StudyARt app | UX Case Study
ARt app | UX Case Study
 
办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
办理学位证(TheAuckland证书)新西兰奥克兰大学毕业证成绩单原版一比一
 

Urban Design and Street Typology: Do They Matter?

  • 1. URBAN DESIGN & STREET TYPOLOGY Do they matter? William Riggs, PhD, AICP, LEED AP Assistant Professor, City & Regional Planning Tweet questions to @billyriggs
  • 4.
  • 5.
  • 6. 6
  • 8. CONTEXT 1 Louisville, KY • Brook and First Streets – One way multi-lane parallel streets since the 1950’s – Converted to a two way, single lane street with a bike lane in Summer 2011
  • 9. One way Brook Street: July 2007
  • 10. Two-way Brook Street August 2011
  • 11. CONTEXT 2 LONDON USE OF CARROTS & STICKS TO MEET SUSTAINABILITY GOALS PUSH PEOPLE OUT OF CARS & PULL PEOPLE TO TRANSIT, BIKES & WALKING Source: Greater London Authority
  • 14. CORE QUESTIONS • Can thinking about street design increase safety (Riggs and Gilderbloom, 2015)? • Can investments in pedestrian / bike safety bring about more ecological and economic resilience (Gilderbloom, Riggs & Meares, 2014)?
  • 15. LONDON OUTCOME 1 SURVEY OF MODE SHIFT SUCESS • Push people out of cars with fiscal stick • Vehicle traffic volumes reduced 27%, stable over time • 80,000 fewer vehicles per day • Pull people into sustainable modes • Transit use up 14%, rising mode share for biking and walking
  • 16. 2001 to 2011 - 11.3% growth in trips made in Greater London Source: Broaddus, 2014 TRIP CHANGE 01-11
  • 17. MODE SHIFT 2001 to 2011 – 6% decline in driving, 6% growth in transit use
  • 18. LONDON OUTCOME 2 FUNDING & BUILT ENVIRONMENT CHANGES • £150M Annually for Transit, Bike, & Ped Improve • Key Projects / Locations • Exhibition Road • Shepherd’s Bush Westfield • Thames Bicycle Superhighway • Bike Share
  • 19.
  • 20.
  • 21.
  • 22.
  • 23. LONDON OUTCOME 3 LESSONS IN DESIGN • Experimentation • Focus on simplicity and existing assets • Land use and form parallels
  • 24.
  • 25.
  • 26.
  • 27.
  • 28. LOUISVILLE OUTCOME 1 • Decreased – Collisions: • -36% on Brook • -60% on First • Increased – Traffic Volumes – Calmer traffic – Pedestrian & bike traffic Significant decrease in accidents despite slight increase in volumes Speeds up to 50-60 mph were clocked during the am peak on one-way segments (limit is 35 mph)
  • 29. LOUISVILLE OUTCOME 2 • Increased – Property Improvements: 2x • Property Values: – 39% on Brook – Tax revenue Significant increase in property values
  • 30. Property Taxes • Average for one-way streets is: $17,886 • Average for two-way streets is: $42,820 – Increased property taxes could pay for conversion (value capture) – >$250,000 lost taxes – West Louisville: multi-lane one-way streets lose ~$2 million in taxes
  • 31. LOUISVILLE OUTCOME 3 • Decreased – Crime 23% • Increased – Business revenues Significant decrease in crime despite slight increase in citywide and in an adjacent neighborhood
  • 32. Photos tell the story of thriving business on two-way
  • 33. Abandoned business/vacant structure on one-way segments
  • 34.
  • 35. KEY LESSIONS & FUTURE WORK • STREET SUITABILITY / DESIGN OF SURROUNDS MATTER • TYPOLOGY / STREET TYPOLOGY ARE ALSO IMPORTANT & MAY HAVE TRAFFIC CALMING EFFECT – Hypothesis 1: Perceived Distance – Hypothesis 2: Visual Interest
  • 36. FUTURE WORK • Longitudinally track the impact of numerous street conversions • Evaluate perceptions on different streets with varying LOS

Editor's Notes

  1. BAN DESIGN & STREET TYPOLOGY Do they matter for the safety of bicyclists and pedestrians?
  2. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  3. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  4. But we haven’t been building nearly enough housing near our job centers. As a result, workers have to endure long commutes and use a lot of gas driving between their jobs and their houses…
  5. - Comparatively, the Bay Area is leading the US in terms of both investigating and thinking about resilience, and adopting sustainable design strategies. - But, there are others who are exceeding us in reducing our 20 MTCO2 emission per person per annum,
  6. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  7. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another. Meeting sustainability goals requires strategies to reduce vehicle miles travelled (VMT) There are dozens of transportation demand management (TDM) policies aimed at a variety of scales, implemented by variety of actors London has implemented an aggressive combination of carrot and stick measures over the past ten years to reduce car use and increase transit and bicycle use This study considers the impacts of these measures as a package, with a particular focus on congestion charging
  8. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  9. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  10. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  11. Estimated number of daily trips, 7 day week. Millions.
  12. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  13. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  14. - Comparatively, the Bay Area is leading the US in terms of both investigating and thinking about resilience, and adopting sustainable design strategies. - But, there are others who are exceeding us in reducing our 20 MTCO2 emission per person per annum,
  15. …and they live in communities where, as you can see, everybody needs a car to get from one place to another.
  16. - Comparatively, the Bay Area is leading the US in terms of both investigating and thinking about resilience, and adopting sustainable design strategies. - But, there are others who are exceeding us in reducing our 20 MTCO2 emission per person per annum,
  17. - Comparatively, the Bay Area is leading the US in terms of both investigating and thinking about resilience, and adopting sustainable design strategies. - But, there are others who are exceeding us in reducing our 20 MTCO2 emission per person per annum,