I really enjoyed this collection and found it useful. I can understand the arguments people make that the collection can be contradictory, but that is do to the fact that there are different essays by different people with different roads to success. There is no one sure-fire way to write a good story, if there were we wouldn't need different perspectives. This seems obvious to me. Each writer can only comment on their own particular field of science fiction. Some people love hard science fiction, while others love cyber-punk, space operas, anthropological science fiction, etc etc. All of these sub-genres have niches and ways to go about writing.
In fact, if you read the opening essay by Heinlein, he clearly says that the essay is merely pointing out basic ideas toward interesting pieces that will be sold. So, while there are "guidelines" to follow, the guidelines aren't biblical commandments of writing science fiction/fantasy, and they can be broken.
It also tells you throughout the essays what clearly NOT to do if you don't want to end up with a cliche-ridden story that will get rejected over and over.
It is true that this book deals more toward the process of creating a short story than a novel, but generally that is how science fiction authors break into the field and get noticed, and if you didn't notice the book was compiled by Analog and Asimov's science fiction, which are two of the most famous SHORT STORY publications. That said, I would recommend this to people who want to write speculative fiction stories to sell to magazines like Asimov's, Analog, Science Fiction and Fantasy, etc.
It is not loaded with information on Fantasy or novel-writing, but if you are serious about writing, this book will give you some good weapons to add to your writing arsenal and get you pumped to do some writing. I agree it is not the end-all book on writing, but realistically as an aspiring writer you should read whatever you can find, and this features some of the greatest names in the field writing honestly about what they know.
less
0 comments
Post a comment