I Thought My Soul Would Fly / 0-590-84913-1
Of all the Dear America books, I believe that this one is the most historically accurate, well-written account to date. While I recommend all Dear America books to adults (these aren't just for children!), I especially recommend this book as a superb insight into the plight of "ex"-slaves immediately following the Civil War - this fictional diary shows clearly that the "free" slaves were - in many ways - no more free than before.
The Good: Everything. The diary format is believable and well-written here - where the other Dear America slave book ("Picture of Freedom") falters slightly over a believable excuse for a slave to have access to writing materials and privacy, "I Thought My Soul" provides excellent reasoning for this Herculean feat on the part of the author. Young Patsy quietly and aptly describes life on the plantation in the wake of the Civil War - the rising hopes and dreams (freedom! families! education!) and the disappointing crescendo when it becomes clear that their masters intend to treat them the same as before. The slaves are quiet, firm, resolute - calmly demanding legal marriages, proper wages, fair education, and the right to raise their own children as they see fit.
The challenges the ex-slaves face are legion, from Southern gangs harassing freemen found off the plantations, to former Masters and Mistresses who force illiterate men and women to sign "contracts" which aren't worth the paper they are written on, to Northern 'liberators' who help round up freemen and force them to work off their lodgings before being allowed to leave the plantation - a new, indentured slavery that is indistinguishable from the old slavery.
Patsy slowly, painstakingly, teaches herself to read and write, not unlike the real Phyllis Wheatley. And - when the masters refuse to provide a teacher for the young children, despite their "contract" which states otherwise - Patsy quietly teaches the young children herself. The love of learning here is tangible, and serves as a reminder that our privilege of literacy is a privilege indeed.
The Bad: There is none. This book is simply superb, and I cannot think of anything in here which could be frightening or difficult for a small child. There is no violence or slave beatings, and there is no real romance featured here.
less
0 comments
Post a comment