0
Totally Awesome Tuning
In Utah
Dr. Bill Sederburg
Dr. Teddi Safman
5
Administrators on the loose! Coordinated strategy!
Governor’s Education
Excellence Commission
Promises
to
Keep
Utah’s
Future
Department of
Utah’s Job Connection
Florida Plan...
Lumina Funded
Tuning Process
+
State Plan for 2020
7
But first, let’s talk about
Tuning in Utah…
Pre-Tuning, Faculty Style
1992-1999
• Faculty-driven meetings on transfer
• Faculty-driven General Education Task Force
• ...
Faculty Majors’ Meetings
• 32 academic disciplines met
• Clear Transfer and Articulation Policies
• Learning Outcomes (goa...
Kismet
• Association of American Colleges and
Universities (AAC&U)
• Coherence in curriculum
• Assessment models
10
Essential Learning Outcomes
• Many years of dialogue with many colleges
• Analysis of reports from business/industry
• Ana...
Essential Learning Outcomes
• Knowledge of Human Cultures and Physical
and Natural World
• Intellectual and Practical Skil...
Unintended Prescience
• Faculty Driven Process
• Regents’ General Education Task Force
• Annual Faculty Discipline Majors’...
Preparation Meets Opportunity
• Bologna Process
• Essential learning Outcomes
• Lumina
• Tuning
Utah was Prepared!
14
What is Tuning?
• Identify learning outcomes in each academic
discipline
• Identify competencies that support learning
out...
Who Does Tuning?
• Faculty in the academic disciplines
• Student representatives
• Statewide teams represent all system
in...
What Else Happens in Tuning
• Surveys:
– Employers
– Recent graduates
– Current students
– Faculty
17
And?
Data are used to assess and adjust competencies
18
And?
• Faculty agree on outcomes but not how to get
there
• Faculty agree on levels of expectations, not
how to evaluate
•...
Process of Tuning by Academic Degree
20
Prior Faculty-
Led Experience
(in Utah)
Essential
learning
outcomes
incorporated
D...
Tuning History
Three Major Learning Outcomes
• Historical Knowledge
• Historical Thinking
• Historical Skills
21
Ratcheting Up: Tuning History
Historical Knowledge
Surveys, changes over time, causation, influence of
political, economic...
Benefits of Tuning
• Explicit learning
outcomes/competencies
• Shift from inputs to
expectations of what
graduates should ...
Tuning and Common Core
State Standards
• Both identify competencies and learning
expectations
• Both are coherent
• Both a...
Tuning and Common Core
State Standards
Faculty majors reviewing international standards
– Math and developmental math
– Co...
Identification of Learning Outcomes
and Competencies Should be a
Guideline for Education Policy
• Better definition of wha...
So, what about future
planning for higher
education in Utah?
It’s comforting to know that no matter what you do in life,
it may be as awesome as this picture.
Utah’s 2020 Plan for Higher Education -
Timeline
Case Statement
Strategies
Jan. Feb.
2010
March April May June July Aug. S...
AK
AR
DE
GA
HI
IL
IN
IA
KS
LA
ME
MD
MA
MTNE
NV NJ
NY
NC
ND
OH
OK
ORPA
RI
SC
SD
VT
VA
WA
US
AL
CA
CO
CT
FL
ID
KY
MI
MN
MS
M...
Educational Attainment and Income
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Decennial Census’ and American Community Survey
AK
AR
DE
GA
...
Educational Attainment and Income
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Decennial Census’ and American Community Survey
PAAK
AR
DE
G...
Educational Attainment and Income
Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Decennial Census’ and American Community Survey
NM
NC
AK
AZ
...
Educational Attainment and Income
34
• Correlation has increased
dramatically!
• States are differentiating
themselves!
• ...
Basic Argument
To prosper, Utah
needs to increase
the education level
of its workforce.
Georgetown Center on Education and...
Utah
66 % Total
• 55% Associate’s
and Higher
• 11% Certificates
36
Percentage
of Jobs Requiring
Postsecondary
Education by...
Degree Requirements for Utah Jobs (2018)
Source: Georgetown University
Center on Education and the
Workforce
Associate’s D...
National
Movement
Lumina Foundation
Gates Foundation
Obama Administration
39
Governor’s Educational
Excellence Commission
...
Regents’ Big Goal
+33,000*
+71,000*
+109,000*
* Numbers are approximate 40
Strategies for Action Plan
1.Pipeline
2.Persistence
3.Expansion
4.Transformation Through
Efficiencies and Technology
5.Eco...
Seeking Public Input
42
www.higheredutah2020.org
• Nearly 100 ideas to vote on,
either “like” or “dislike”
• Contact and c...
Pipeline
• Clearly written
college/workforce
standards
• Build upon K-12 Common
Core by using clear
educational outcomes,
...
Pipeline
• Strengthen K-16 Alliances with specific agendas
• Increase need-based financial aid
• Establish loan program fo...
Persistence
• Funding based on institutional mission with
accountability measures instead of third week
enrollment
• Creat...
• Increased use of “mixed” or
“blended” delivery
• Use 12th grade as first year of
college – fund early college
enrollment...
Transformation Through Efficiencies
and Technology
• Enhance online education opportunities through
coordinated approach t...
Economic Prosperity
• Create a “Mountain Research
Corridor”
– (USU, U of U, BYU, plus outreach
centers)
• Expand the Utah ...
Intersection of Tuning and 2020
• Build upon K-12 Common Core
• Define outcomes & competencies for general
education
• Put...
Quick Demonstration
50
Thank you for your time!
Lumina and Utah's "Tuning" Project
Lumina and Utah's "Tuning" Project
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Lumina and Utah's "Tuning" Project

1,530

Published on

Presentation for 2010 WICHE Conference by Commissioner Sederburg and Teddi Safman from USHE.

Published in: Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,530
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
16
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Transcript of "Lumina and Utah's "Tuning" Project"

  1. 1. Totally Awesome Tuning In Utah Dr. Bill Sederburg Dr. Teddi Safman
  2. 2. 5 Administrators on the loose! Coordinated strategy!
  3. 3. Governor’s Education Excellence Commission Promises to Keep Utah’s Future Department of Utah’s Job Connection Florida Plan Race to the Top 5
  4. 4. Lumina Funded Tuning Process + State Plan for 2020 7
  5. 5. But first, let’s talk about Tuning in Utah…
  6. 6. Pre-Tuning, Faculty Style 1992-1999 • Faculty-driven meetings on transfer • Faculty-driven General Education Task Force • Faculty from all nine institutions began meeting in some academic disciplines • “What is an Educated Person?” Conference 8
  7. 7. Faculty Majors’ Meetings • 32 academic disciplines met • Clear Transfer and Articulation Policies • Learning Outcomes (goals) were identified 9
  8. 8. Kismet • Association of American Colleges and Universities (AAC&U) • Coherence in curriculum • Assessment models 10
  9. 9. Essential Learning Outcomes • Many years of dialogue with many colleges • Analysis of reports from business/industry • Analysis of accreditation requirements for engineering, business, nursing, teacher education 11
  10. 10. Essential Learning Outcomes • Knowledge of Human Cultures and Physical and Natural World • Intellectual and Practical Skills • Personal and Social Responsibility • Integrative and Applied Learning 12
  11. 11. Unintended Prescience • Faculty Driven Process • Regents’ General Education Task Force • Annual Faculty Discipline Majors’ Meetings • Unknowingly Prepared for Tuning 13
  12. 12. Preparation Meets Opportunity • Bologna Process • Essential learning Outcomes • Lumina • Tuning Utah was Prepared! 14
  13. 13. What is Tuning? • Identify learning outcomes in each academic discipline • Identify competencies that support learning outcomes • Identify methods students use to demonstrate mastery of competencies • Make transparent all of the outcomes, competencies and demonstration methods • Tuning clearly states what a student must know and do at every degree level 15
  14. 14. Who Does Tuning? • Faculty in the academic disciplines • Student representatives • Statewide teams represent all system institutions 16
  15. 15. What Else Happens in Tuning • Surveys: – Employers – Recent graduates – Current students – Faculty 17
  16. 16. And? Data are used to assess and adjust competencies 18
  17. 17. And? • Faculty agree on outcomes but not how to get there • Faculty agree on levels of expectations, not how to evaluate • Faculty harmonize but do not sing in unison 19
  18. 18. Process of Tuning by Academic Degree 20 Prior Faculty- Led Experience (in Utah) Essential learning outcomes incorporated Drilling down into competencies Methods to demonstrate mastery Employee/ student/ faculty surveys Validate and adjust competencies
  19. 19. Tuning History Three Major Learning Outcomes • Historical Knowledge • Historical Thinking • Historical Skills 21
  20. 20. Ratcheting Up: Tuning History Historical Knowledge Surveys, changes over time, causation, influence of political, economic, social, cultural, race, gender, ethnicity Historical Thinking Context of past, complexity/diversity, problematic nature of interpretation Historical Skills Critical thinking/reading, primary sources, research, historical argument Assessment Rubrics and Mastery Scale 22
  21. 21. Benefits of Tuning • Explicit learning outcomes/competencies • Shift from inputs to expectations of what graduates should know and be able to do • Better match between needs of labor market and what graduates know and can do • Facilitates transfer • Coherent and purposeful curriculum • Transparent 23
  22. 22. Tuning and Common Core State Standards • Both identify competencies and learning expectations • Both are coherent • Both are transparent • Both will raise level of performance • Alignment between high school and college is possible 24
  23. 23. Tuning and Common Core State Standards Faculty majors reviewing international standards – Math and developmental math – Composition (new language arts standards) 25
  24. 24. Identification of Learning Outcomes and Competencies Should be a Guideline for Education Policy • Better definition of what higher education does • Built in accountability with assessments • Transparent learning expectations and demonstration of mastery • Coherent curriculum • Closer tie to future employers 26
  25. 25. So, what about future planning for higher education in Utah?
  26. 26. It’s comforting to know that no matter what you do in life, it may be as awesome as this picture.
  27. 27. Utah’s 2020 Plan for Higher Education - Timeline Case Statement Strategies Jan. Feb. 2010 March April May June July Aug. Sept. Oct. Governor’s Call Coalescing documents with institutional and other state-wide plans and initiatives Nov. Delivered to Governor 29
  28. 28. AK AR DE GA HI IL IN IA KS LA ME MD MA MTNE NV NJ NY NC ND OH OK ORPA RI SC SD VT VA WA US AL CA CO CT FL ID KY MI MN MS MO NH NMTN TX UT WV WI WY $15,000 $22,000 $29,000 $36,000 $43,000 $50,000 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 AZ PersonalIncomePerCapita Percent of Adults Age 25-64 with Bachelor’s Degrees 1980 Correlation = 0.64 Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Decennial Census’ and American Community Survey Educational Attainment and Income
  29. 29. Educational Attainment and Income Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Decennial Census’ and American Community Survey AK AR DE GA HI IL IN IA KS LA ME MD MA MT NE NV NJ NY NC ND OH OK OR PA RI SC SD VT VA WA US AL CA CO CT FL IDKY MI MN MS MO NH NM TN TX UT WV WIWY $15,000 $22,000 $29,000 $36,000 $43,000 $50,000 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 AZ 1990 PersonalIncomePerCapita Percent of Adults Age 25-64 with Bachelor’s Degrees Correlation = 0.76
  30. 30. Educational Attainment and Income Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Decennial Census’ and American Community Survey PAAK AR DE GA HI IL IN IA KS LA ME MD MA MT NE NV NJ NY NC ND OH OK OR RI SC SD VT VA WA US AL CA CO CT FL ID KY MI MN MS MO NH NM TN TX UT WV WI $15,000 $22,000 $29,000 $36,000 $43,000 $50,000 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 AZ 2000 PersonalIncomePerCapita Percent of Adults Age 25-64 with Bachelor’s Degrees Correlation = 0.80 WY
  31. 31. Educational Attainment and Income Source: U.S. Census Bureau, Decennial Census’ and American Community Survey NM NC AK AZ AR DE GA HI IL IN IA KS LA ME MD MA MT NE NV NJ NY ND OH OK OR PA RI SC SD VT VA WA US AL CA CO CT FL IDKY MI MN MS MO NH TN TX UT WV WI WY $15,000 $22,000 $29,000 $36,000 $43,000 $50,000 10 15 20 25 30 35 40 45 2005 PersonalIncomePerCapita Percent of Adults Age 25-64 with Bachelor’s Degrees Correlation = 0.83
  32. 32. Educational Attainment and Income 34 • Correlation has increased dramatically! • States are differentiating themselves! • Utah has slipped relative to other states!
  33. 33. Basic Argument To prosper, Utah needs to increase the education level of its workforce. Georgetown Center on Education and the Workforce 35
  34. 34. Utah 66 % Total • 55% Associate’s and Higher • 11% Certificates 36 Percentage of Jobs Requiring Postsecondary Education by 2018
  35. 35. Degree Requirements for Utah Jobs (2018) Source: Georgetown University Center on Education and the Workforce Associate’s Degrees 27% Bachelor’s Degrees 20% Graduate Degrees 8% Certificates 11% Currently, only 39% of Utahns have a college degree. 16% gap to cover in 10 years! 38
  36. 36. National Movement Lumina Foundation Gates Foundation Obama Administration 39 Governor’s Educational Excellence Commission Supported By : Board of Regents State Superintendent SLC Chamber of Commerce Utah’s 66% Goal by 2020
  37. 37. Regents’ Big Goal +33,000* +71,000* +109,000* * Numbers are approximate 40
  38. 38. Strategies for Action Plan 1.Pipeline 2.Persistence 3.Expansion 4.Transformation Through Efficiencies and Technology 5.Economic Prosperity 41
  39. 39. Seeking Public Input 42 www.higheredutah2020.org • Nearly 100 ideas to vote on, either “like” or “dislike” • Contact and comment to the Commissioner • Interactive wikis for Case Statement and Action Plan
  40. 40. Pipeline • Clearly written college/workforce standards • Build upon K-12 Common Core by using clear educational outcomes, instead of seat time, in general education • Change concurrent enrollment to focus on general education 43
  41. 41. Pipeline • Strengthen K-16 Alliances with specific agendas • Increase need-based financial aid • Establish loan program for part-time students • Expand outreach and marketing of UESP • Increase number of early college high schools 44
  42. 42. Persistence • Funding based on institutional mission with accountability measures instead of third week enrollment • Create innovation fund for retention initiatives • Publish data on retention and degree completion by program • Transform remediation practices • Mandatory attendance for freshmen in selected courses 45
  43. 43. • Increased use of “mixed” or “blended” delivery • Use 12th grade as first year of college – fund early college enrollment • Create community college centers within 4-year institutions • Improve articulation with ATC institutions and programs • Support branch campuses Expansion 46
  44. 44. Transformation Through Efficiencies and Technology • Enhance online education opportunities through coordinated approach targeted for general education courses • More efficient use of campus; reduce time to completion • Use open courseware to reduce book costs 47
  45. 45. Economic Prosperity • Create a “Mountain Research Corridor” – (USU, U of U, BYU, plus outreach centers) • Expand the Utah Cluster Acceleration Program (UCAP) • Double size of USTAR • Provide special assistance to students in STEM fields 48
  46. 46. Intersection of Tuning and 2020 • Build upon K-12 Common Core • Define outcomes & competencies for general education • Put general education in online/hybrid formats, and offered by many providers • Shifts concurrent enrollment to early college 49
  47. 47. Quick Demonstration 50
  48. 48. Thank you for your time!
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×