Privatization of School Functions, Gloucester, Virginia
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×
 

Privatization of School Functions, Gloucester, Virginia

on

  • 356 views

A presentation created by Phillip Bazzani, Gloucester,Virginia Board of Supervisor's and presented to county government as well as the public. Posted here for use in a news story on Gloucester, ...

A presentation created by Phillip Bazzani, Gloucester,Virginia Board of Supervisor's and presented to county government as well as the public. Posted here for use in a news story on Gloucester, Virginia Links and News website. Visit us.

Statistics

Views

Total Views
356
Views on SlideShare
323
Embed Views
33

Actions

Likes
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0

1 Embed 33

http://www.gloucestercounty-va.com 33

Accessibility

Categories

Upload Details

Uploaded via as Adobe PDF

Usage Rights

CC Attribution-NoDerivs LicenseCC Attribution-NoDerivs License

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Processing…
Post Comment
Edit your comment

Privatization of School Functions, Gloucester, Virginia Privatization of School Functions, Gloucester, Virginia Presentation Transcript

  • 1 Privatizing Certain SB Functions Phillip N. Bazzani, CPCM, MBA Supervisor – York District Gloucester County, Virginia February 17, 2014
  • 2 Discussion Topics ! Gloucester’s  economic  reality.   ! What  is  priva6za6on?   ! Why  priva6ze?   ! What  can  be  priva6zed?   ! What  are  the  poten6al  savings?   ! What  other  states  have  found.   ! What  other  locali6es  are  doing?   ! What  might  this  mean  for  our  schools?   ! Recommenda6ons  
  • 3 Gloucester’s Economic Reality !  Gloucester  is  at  an  economic  cross  roads,  and  our  current  economy  is   stagnant.   !  Taxpayers  are  being  asked  more  and  more  to  fund  both  the  county  and   school  opera;ons.   !  Household  income  averages  $58,000;  and  with  tax  expenses  and  mortgages,   there  is  less  than  $850/month  of  discre;onary  income.   !  The  number  of  households  in  Gloucester  are  only  half  of  our  neighboring   locali;es,  such  as  York  and  James  City.   !  The  County  and  School  Board  (SB)  must  robustly  find  ways  to  alleviate  the   burden  to  the  taxpayer  and  facilitate  private  sector  growth.   !  The  County  and  the  SB  must  look  introspec;vely  into  their  budgets  and  adjust   where  necessary  much  like  the  ordinary  ci;zen  must  do  when  economic   condi;ons  change.  
  • 4 What is Privatizing? !  Priva;za;on  is  the  transfer  of  government  services  to   the  private  sector.       !  Services  formerly  provided  by  government  may  be   contracted  out.       !  The  objec;ve  is  oPen  to  increase  government  efficiency   and  reduce  opera;ng  costs.  
  • 5 Why Privatize? !  Schools  provide  a  variety  of  services  having  no  rela;on  to   their  fundamental  role  of  educa;ng  students.     !  Such  services  can  be  subject  to  priva;za;on.     !  By  priva;zing  these  non-­‐educa;on  related  func;ons,  we   may  achieve  two  posi;ve  results:         "  Educators  are  allowed  to  focus  on   educa;on.     "  Priva;zing  may  lower  the  cost  and   improve  the  quality  of  those  services   that  have  been  outsourced.    
  • 6 What Can Be Privatized? !  The  following  are  poten;al  “non-­‐academic”  candidates  that   could  be  considered  for  priva;zing  by  the  School  Board  (SB):     "  Transporta;on,     "  Food  services,   "  Cleaning  and  Maintenance  (Custodial)   "  Technology  Management   !  Freeing  up  these  func;ons  to  private  firms  could  poten;ally   allow  school  teachers  to  focus  on  their  core  mission:      
  • 7 What are the Potential Savings? !  Two  statewide  surveys  of  school  districts  in  Illinois  and   Alabama  showed  that  priva;zed  non-­‐academic  services   saved  tax  dollars  to  the  school  system.  *     !  The  systems  were  then  able  to  reallocate  the  savings   into  core  services-­‐teachers'  pay,  new  textbooks  and   computers,  and  other  instruc;onal  ac;vi;es.*   !  Even  the  AASA  states  that  the  most  frequently   contracted  services  include  food  services,  custodial  and   transporta;on  as  the  most  visible  because  these   func;ons  consume  the  greatest  propor;on  of  school   budgets.**       *Source:    Geoffrey  F.  Segal,  The  Reason  Founda6on  and  a  member  of  the  Board  of  Scholars  of  the  Virginia  Ins6tute  for  Public  Policy.   **  American  Associa6on  of  School  Administrators     !  Savings  typically  range  from  12  to  25  percent.*  
  • 8 What Others States Found   !  Gloucester  SB  should  carefully  consider  how  non-­‐core,  non-­‐educa;on   related  services  are  provided.   !  Priva;za;on  can  allow  the  School  Board  to  enhance  the  educa;onal   experience  of  Gloucester’s  youth.     *Source:    Geoffrey  F.  Segal,  The  Reason  Founda6on  and  a  member  of  the  Board  of  Scholars  of  the  Virginia  Ins6tute  for  Public  Policy.   !  Some  of  the  most  important   conclusions  from  the  Alabama  and   Illinois  surveys  showed  that  two-­‐ thirds  of  school  officials  rated   priva;za;on  a  success.*     !  Outsourcing  can  be  used  to  address   budget  challenges  while  direc;ng   more  funds  toward  instruc;onal   programs.*    
  • 9 What Other Localities Are Doing !  Hampton  City  public  schools  were  recently  presented  with  a  Facili6es   op6on  that  showed  a  20%  reduc6on  in  facili6es  and  maintenance  costs.*     !  Richmond  public  schools  is  considering  outsourcing  its  transporta6on  and   facili6es  maintenance  departments.   !  Roanoke  City  Schools  outsourced  its  student  transport  in  2009.     Controversial  at  the  6me,  a  Roanoke  City  Schools  spokesperson  says  the   district  saves  $1.4  million  every  year  because  it  outsources  its   transporta6on.**     !  Norfolk  public  schools  contract  out  for  supplies,  training  and  some   management  services.**     !  Portsmouth  public  schools  outsources  some  maintenance  services  such  as   HVAC.**   !  In  2009,  the  Isle  of  Wight  school  board  voted  to  turn  their  custodians  over   to  a  na6onal  commercial  cleaning  company  saving  about  $500K  in  costs.**   *      Hampton  City  Public  Schools,  School  Board  Mee6ng  2-­‐19-­‐14  Presenta6on   **Source:    PilotOnline;  11-­‐15-­‐13  
  • 10 Recommendations !  Take  a  close,  introspec;ve  look  at  “non-­‐academic”  SB  services  and   iden;fy  which  can  be  candidates  for  outsourcing.   !  Benchmark  locali;es  that  already  have  priva;zed  programs  –  see  what   works  or  does  not  work.   !  Work  with  Central  Purchasing  to  solicit  RFPs  and  have  vendors  present   their  proposals  to  the  SB.   !  Decide  whether  proposals  will  actually  lower  costs.   !  Savings  should  be  returned  to  the  School  System  for:   "  Teacher’s  pay   "  New  Technology   "  Hiring  more  teachers