In 2014, EIA conducted its first employee engagement survey with TalentMap. The results clearly showed that stresses and change over the previous year had taken their toll on employee engagement, which was 11% below the benchmark average. Less than one year later, a subsequent “pulse” survey showed significant improvement in engagement, and double-digit increases in the key drivers of engagement which were actioned.
2. 2
Topic Agenda
Item Time
(min)
Introduction 2
In the Beginning…the Situation in early 2014 5
EIA Response 15
The TalentMap Process 15
Overall Results and Update 5
Q&A 5
Norm Baillie-David
SVP Engagement – TalentMap
With Special Guest:
Monica Helgoth
VP Business Development –
Western Region
Agenda
Holly Veiner
Manager, Talent and Acquisition
Edmonton International Airport
3. 3
15 years in business
7,000+ employee engagement surveys since
inception
1,000,000+ employees surveyed
500+ employee engagement surveys annually
Only 1 Focus
TalentMap by the Numbers
4. 4
Sample Clients & Benchmark
Award Programs Technology & Engineering Not-for-Profit & Association
Financial Services
Health Sciences
Other
6. Completed expansion in 2012
Shifting focus from “build” to “fill”
End stages of requisite org design
Stability in people resources
New talent strategy
Legacy issues
Situation in 2013
6
7. Complex organization and issues
Needed simplistic practical approach
Deep dive
TalentMap
• Understood complexity
• Recommendations - trusted
• Experienced
• Best practices
• Benchmarks
• Good fit
Why TalentMap was Engaged
7
8. Engagement Survey Revealed Significant Issues
Coefficient Vs. Delta To Benchmark
8
Compensation
Work Environment
Performance Feedback
Professional Growth
Work/Life Balance
Information and
Communication
Teamwork
Innovation
Customer Focus
Immediate Management
Executive Team
Organizational Vision
Strong
Engagement
Driver
Weak
Engagement
Driver
Worse Than
Benchmark
Better Than
Benchmark
• Engagement 11% below
TalentMap Benchmark
• Key issues with teamwork,
communications (silos), and
culture of innovation.
• Change fatigue from
renovations and org.
restructuring.
• Executive Team blamed for
low morale
10. Engagement Survey - Launch
• February – survey distributed
• March - TalentMap compiled results
• April - results shared with EMC
• May – results shared with SMT & all Managers
• June – results shared with all employees
• July – EIS update. Individual SBU & Division results sharing. Approach planning.
• August – consultation with TalentMap, defined approach
• September – SBU Talks & Employee Task Force
• October –Employee Task Force share action plan with CEO
• November – Pulse Survey & action plan
• December / January – Results sharing of Pulse Survey
11. Our Approach
Engagement Drivers Lowest Scores Strengths
Professional Growth
Maintain focus / deliver
Communicate
Employee Task Force – sub
topic
Information & Communication
Employee Task Force
Compensation
Communicate / inform
Innovation
Employee Task Force
Executive Team
Immediate
Forward actions
Performance Feedback
Maintain / enhance
Employee Task Force – sub
topic
Work Environment
Employee Task Force – sub
topic
Teamwork
Employee Task Force
Customer Focus
Communicate
Information sharing
12. Immediate Action
• Leadership visibility – Management led – HR support
– Management by walking around
• Commitment to listening & sharing, spontaneous, random
• Facilitate engagement opportunities & create approachability
• Sharing & receiving information directly from the front line
– Exec profiles
• Personalizing
• Get to know our Executives
– Creating transparency
• Communication – HR led – Comms support–
– People promise
– Communicate often
– Be transparent
– New & existing tools
– What & how?
13. SBU Specific
• SBU specific – VP led – Talent Map Consult
SBU insight / support
– Individual sessions with each VP - discuss
• Their results
• Implications for their specific SBU
• How to undertake effective action planning with employees
– Series of tailor-made directions on action planning
summarized in brief memo addressed to relevant VP
14. Corporate
• Corporate / cross-functional – HR support – Employee led
– Employee Task Force - Talent Map facilitate Three small (8-10) employee groups
for each identified engagement areas
– Main Topics: Innovation, Teamwork, Information & Communication
– Sub Topics: Professional Growth, Work Environment, Performance Feedback
• Understanding of issue root causes, preliminary idea generation and action planning
to identify quick wins and recommended actions
– Workshop – Talent Map facilitate Jumpstart High Intensity Action Planning
Workshop
• Build upon and expand individual task force action plans
• Develop final action plans (including accountabilities & timelines) to improve
engagement along each of the engagement drivers identified
– Each task force will “own” their action plan and be accountable for its
implementation moving forward
• Present to Tom (CEO) in October
• Share with EMC
16. Three Day Intensive Approach
16
Deep-Dive Focus
Groups
•Cross-functional – Involve Employees from Across the
Organization
•Identify Root Causes for Issues
Senior Leadership
Consultations
•1:1 with Senior Leaders to Discuss Issues
•Guidance, Review and Critique Action Plans
JumpStart
Workshop
•Full-day Workshop with ~ 40 employees. Cross functional.
•Focused Creativity and Idea Generation
•Prioritization, Convergence, Evaluation, Implementation Plan
17. Decisions take a long time to make as
managers don’t want to accept accountability,
resulting in many last-minute rushes and
inability to include all necessary participants in
team efforts.
Shift work and remote sites make face-to-
face collaboration more challenging
Culture of secrecy and lack of transparency
causes lack of trust between business units
People genuinely don’t know each other so
it is easier not to consider them when
planning and executing tasks
Worse still, front-line employees feel they are
rarely, if ever, consulted on areas where
they feel they have experience and expertise,
often resulting in costly “re-dos”.
Some Focus Group Highlights
17
Example of a “Mindmap” Used to Identify Root Causes
Deep-Dive Focus
Groups
19. Creative ideation exercises to help
employees develop 50-75 “action
ideas”
Ideas are prioritized
Most promising evaluated and
more fully developed.
Employee Driven Solution Development
19
JumpStart
Workshop
20. 69 Action Ideas
15 Priority Ideas
Evaluated and with
Action Plans
Workshop Results
20
21. Example Idea
Name your idea: _______________________________________________________
Description (What is it? How does it work? What are the main features?
What area does it focus on…marketing/promotion/display/etc.?)
How Does It Achieve Higher Employee Engagement?
Tours of facility
New employees
Changes to facility
Understanding of our facility and who takes care of what
What our challenges are and who does what and how things
impact other departments
Illustration
Primary Benefits (How does this solve a problem or
deliver a need?)
General – Airport Tours
22. PPCO – Pluses, Potentials, Concerns, Overcoming Concerns
(Airport Tours)Pluses
What do you like about idea right now?
Be direct, honest and specific
• Engagement – feel part of the EIA family
• Educational
• Meet an entire department
• Relaxed/casual environment
• Takes less time/20 people can meet 20 people at once
Potentials
What opportunities might this new idea open
up?
What might be potential spin-offs for future
growth?
• Creates a more efficient environment
• Opens up communication
• Create ideas for process improvement
Concerns
Express your concerns-open-ended questions
that offer a possible direction for future
development:
How to….
How might…
In what was might we….
• Nobody has time for that
• Aligning schedules
• Protective of turf/afraid people would point out deficiencies
Overcome Concerns
Review list of concerns
Choose most important one and create 3-5
ways to overcome
Continue until all concerns have been
addressed
• Keeping tours short
• Organized well in advance
• Share the benefits of the tour so people are less resistant
25. Fully established Engagement Committee
Building trust
• Listening
• Implementing ideas
Commitment from all leaders
• Senior Leadership Team ownership
Ownership of ideas
BoD support
2nd full survey September
Innovation sprouting
What’s Happened Since?
25
26. Event Format Topic Date
TalentMap Webinar Live Webinar The Increase In Popularity Of Pulse
Surveys: Do They Make Sense For
Your Organization?
July 23rd, 2015
12:00pm EST
TalentMap Webinar Live Webinar Engaging Your Employees Through
A Compelling Organizational Vision
Aug 13th, 2015
12:00 PM EST
TalentMap Webinar Live Webinar Managing Employee Engagement
During Major Organizational
Change
Sep 24th, 2015
12:00 PM EST
TalentMap Webinar Live Webinar How To Improve Engagement
Through Better Teamwork (And It’s
Not Through “Team-building”
Exercises)
Oct 29, 2015
12:00 PM EST
Upcoming TalentMap Learning Sessions
Register: www.talentmap.con/events
27. THANK YOU!
QUESTIONS AND DISCUSSION
27
Monica Helgoth
VP Engagement – TalentMap West
mhelgoth@talentmap.com
1-888-641-1113, x515
Norm Baillie-David
SVP Engagement
nbaillie-david@talentmap.com
1-888-641-1113, x504
Holly Veiner
Manager, Talent and Acquisition
Edmonton International Airport
hveiner@flyeia.com
Now we know what to focus on….how does that translate to actions?
Holly speak to slide and invite Tom to speak directly about the Executive Team
Go over each item briefly and explain how we will be approaching each individual dimension. See example of each below:
For those things that we’re doing well we’re going to make sure we keep doing well and don’t let our foot off the gas.
We’re thrilled to hear our performance feedback process is starting to come together. That doesn’t mean, since it’s one of our strengths, that we’re going to stop all efforts. It means that we’re going to keep on listening, take every opportunity, and be better and better at it. We’re passionate about giving feedback, and know that we need it to continue to grow and be better at what we do.
Professional growth is our number one driver of engagement. Our career development planning initiative was aimed specifically at drawing out what areas you want to develop in. We’ll be asking more about that…such as what worked well in our development planning process? Did it meet your expectations? What can we do different/better?
Executive Team was one of our lowest scores. We’ve begun to take immediate action in this area, restructuring to provide more opportunities and time to connect with employees.
What will happen with those other areas? – the medium/low priority dimensions? – What we’re heard through the survey is that we’re doing “ok” in these areas. These play an important role in our values and our success, we’ll continue to keep moving forward and strive for improvement as in everything we do. They just won’t be part of the initial action planning.
Tom to speak to Leadership Visibility – pass over to Holly for Communication
Tom’s speaking notes:
For those items that are most important to us (and we’re not doing so great at) we need to take immediate action. And where that immediate action is specifically driven from a certain area or group, e.g. Executive Team or Information and Communication, we’ve been working behind the scenes to address those gaps.
Our Executive Team has committed to being more available for you, and we’re asking that you be more available to your teams. We all need to commit to getting to know our employees, their goals, their stressors, what excites them and how they each define success. All that happens by talking to people. We need to ask our employees how we're doing in their eyes.
I know it can be difficult to request employee feedback, and it can be equally if not more challenging for an employee to give an honest response. Something that I’ve done that gets the conversation started is to say "It's one of my goals to constantly improve myself as a manager. What would you like to see me do differently? What could I be doing to make your job easier?”
It’s also great to personalize people, get to know them. It can make them more approachable. We’re going to start this by sharing more about our executive team. What makes them laugh? What stories of success or moments they would rather not share?
Tom
We have continued to engage the services of Talent Map’s while we build on internal skills, and understand what the engagement survey is telling us. As part of that support from Talent Map we will be holding one-on-one sessions with Talent Map and each VP.
Ask more from your VP. Ask how you can get involved.
Holly
Where we need your help we’re making a call out to you. We will be running a series of Task Forces the end of September. These Task Forces will discuss those topics / dimensions that we need your help with (read off slide).
They will be comprised of a cross section of employees who are interested in making a difference. While we have a few folks who have come forward and signed up, we still need more.
What does being involved mean?
Actively participating in discussions and providing insight
Represent their team and being their voice
Being involved first hand in planning for improvements
Reporting back and being part of the actions
Being part of shaping the culture that we aspire to be
Time involved?
1.5 days end of Sept
.5 day in Oct to present to EMC
Monthly meetings (approx 1 hr) to check in
Please let Holly or Heather know who from your team is interested in participating in one of these Task Forces.