• Share
  • Email
  • Embed
  • Like
  • Save
  • Private Content
Hv consortium tl_seminar_011714
 

Hv consortium tl_seminar_011714

on

  • 622 views

This is the presentation used throughout the first seminar of a three part series about teaching and learning for the SUNY hudson Valley Consortium instructors with Dr. William Sheldon and Hope ...

This is the presentation used throughout the first seminar of a three part series about teaching and learning for the SUNY hudson Valley Consortium instructors with Dr. William Sheldon and Hope Windle.

Statistics

Views

Total Views
622
Views on SlideShare
370
Embed Views
252

Actions

Likes
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0

3 Embeds 252

http://teachinginthehudsonvalley.blogspot.com 213
https://teachinginthehudsonvalley.blogspot.com 37
https://www.blogger.com 2

Accessibility

Categories

Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Processing…
Post Comment
Edit your comment

    Hv consortium tl_seminar_011714 Hv consortium tl_seminar_011714 Presentation Transcript

    • SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 1
    •       OUR STRUCTURE AS NEW COMMUNITY COLLEGE INSTRUCTORS MY OWN EXPERIENCE MY INTENT NOTHING IS MANDATED -- OPEN TO IDEAS, EACH PERSON’S OWN CREATIVITY HORIZONTAL GROWTH –OUR CRAFT I AM STILL LEARNING SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 2
    •   REFLECTION: WHO WAS A MEMORABLE TEACHER IN YOUR OWN EDUCATIONAL EXPERIENCE? IS THERE SOMEONE, A CLASS, YOU REMEMBER FOR YEARS THAT CHANGED OR MOVED YOU? WRITE A LITTLE BIT ABOUT WHO THAT PERSON WAS AND WHAT THE EXPERIENCE OF LEARNING WAS? WHAT DID THEY DO THAT WAS MEMORABLE? SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 3
    •   TALK ABOUT YOUR REFLECTION WITH ONE OTHER PERSON…. ARE THERE ANY SIMILARITIES? SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 4
    •  RANK THE FOLLOWING IN HOW EFFECTIVE EACH PRACTICE IS IN YOUR OWN LEARNING. GIVE A NUMBER 7 FOR HIGHEST 1 FOR LOWEST ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ ◦ READING DISCUSSION GROUP PRACTICE BY DOING LECTURE AUDIO VISUAL TEACHING OTHERS DEMONSTRATION SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 5
    • SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 6
    •   AT THE VERY BEGINNING OF THE BAIN READING, HE RELATES TWO EPISODES THAT SUPPORT A NATIONAL DEBATE ON WHETHER THE LECTURE DEAD AS AN EFFECTIVE WAY OF COLLEGE INSTRUCTION YOUR TASK, IN THE NEXT 15 MINUTES, USING BOTH YOUR ANSWERS TO THE BAIN QUESTIONS AND THE EXERCISE/DATA JUST PRESENTED, IS TO PUT FORTH AN ARGUMENT FOR BOTH SIDES OF THAT QUESTION. REFER TO YOUR BAIN ANSWERS, SHARE THOSE WITH EACH OTHER, AND BE PREPARED TO QUOTE AT LEAST ONE PASSAGE FROM THE READING TO SUPPORT EITHER SIDE OF YOUR RESPONSE SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 7
    •   YOUR ARGUMENTS? YOUR LEVEL OF ENGAGEMENT? SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 8
    •   CRITICAL THINKING OR A ―NATURAL CRITICAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT‖ TEAM LEARNING SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 9
    •     ―DON’T BE A MOTHER BIRD‖ SOCCER ANALOGY TEACHING STUDENTS TO THINK BY SPENDING MOST OF THE TIME HAVING THEM THINK RICHARD PAUL – TWO THINGS THINKING ABOUT ON DRIVE IN --- CONTENT AND THINKING EXERCISES SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 10
    • Business Ethical Application Case—In-Class Thinking and Writing In the 50’s, 60’s 70’s and 80’s average CEO pay was approximately 40 times that of the lowest worker. Now it is approximately 400 times that of the lowest worker. Comment on whether John Rawls would consider this ethical and a practice that conforms with justice in terms of the distribution of resources in our society. Include at least two quotes from the reading to support your comments and conclusions. Using at least one, each, of our former ethical frameworks: ◦ Defend the change in the CEO pay….why it is ethical and in your company with you as CEO should it be allowed and encouraged. ◦ Criticize the change in CEO pay…why is it unethical and in your company with you as CEO should it be addressed and brought back in line with previous levels… SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 11
    •  HANDOUTS 12
    •     Reading through these posts is inspiring. It's interesting to see how the techniques discussed in JOT and WTBCTD, which overlap a bit, but emphasize important goals and approaches, can be applied to teaching so many subjects, and how they add so much interest when applied. I've found the readings quite useful, and they've actually helped me rethink my own 'mental models' considerably, so much so that I'm now beginning to think of the entire classroom situation in a different way. It occurred to me that what was being described in these chapters about structuring and getting the most out of class time has a lot of affinities with the structure of a story. it helps me to think about a day's class using this lesson-as-story metaphor. It has all the essential elements of a story: a beginning, a middle, and an end. But most crucially, the 'begin with a question' idea creates the conflict which needs to be resolved, the backbone of many a great story. In this way, I try to help students see a conflict that needs resolution by posing an interesting question (not always easy), and it becomes their job to develop a suitable ending. In essence, they, and more particularly, their learning, becomes the vehicle which drives the story to its conclusion. I think, as Bain says, it's just as important to end with a question as it is to begin with one, as this is also an element of some of the best stories, e.g. Hamlet. So now before each class, instead of my old punch-lists, I take time to create an outline, imagining it as a kind of story arc. An example: Upon self-examination, I realized I've often taught cause-and-effect writing and thinking as a series of conventions to be learned (this is inductive reasoning, this is deductive reasoning, avoid ergo propter hoc, etc) but this last time, I began by posing a question from a famous Bob Dylan song: Who killed Davey Moore? I played the students the song, and had them develop an opinion in writing about who they thought killed him. Then I handed out an article by Norman Cousins that argues one answer to that question as it pertains to the real case the Dylan song is based on, the third fight between Emile Griffith and Benny Paret, in which Paret is killed in the twelfth round. The writer argues that the crowd killed him, a response few from the class had provided. Many of their responses blamed Paret himself, which I thought was quite astute indeed, but also allowed for lots of scrutiny... So then I had them think and write about the evidence they used and compare it to the evidence Cousins uses. Before they knew it, they were exploring the really valuable terrain of cause-andeffect: the highly complex nature of causation, in which the answer is usually "it's a lot of things," and the critical thing is to determine the relative importance of those things. They engaged in both induction and deduction without my prompting them. This allowed me merely to label ways they'd come up with their own ideas. It was quite exciting. I showed footage from the fight (brutal and engaging) which made many of them reevaluate their thinking once again, as it shows Griffith pummeling an unconscous Paret as his limp body droops off the ropes. And then I showed them a heartbreaking video of Griffith meeting Paret's son for the first time. I ended the class asking them to continue wondering about who killed him, and to consider what it is about boxing that appeals to us, and if you would consider yourself complicit if you paid to get into a sporting event in which someone was badly hurt. This was easily one of my best experiences in the classroom. So overall I've derived some really meaningful and useful approaches from this reading and I'm looking forward to applying these techniques to future class stories. 13
    •       HETEROGENEOUS SEMESTER LONG -- COHORT GROUPS 5-7 MEMBERS PREPARATION OUTSIDE OF CLASS -- INCENTIVE FOR ASSIGNMENTS (NEGATIVE CREDIT -―EVERYONE STARTS WITH A PERFECT 10‖ SHARING/COMPARING ANSWERS OF ASSIGNMENTS APPLICATIONS IN PROBLEM SOLVING ◦ SUPPLY DEMAND GRAPHS ON BOARD ◦ PREPARE DEBATES WITH OTHER TEAMS ◦ SOLVE APPLICATIONS QUESTIONS  TEAM QUIZZES SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 14
    • WHAT THE BEST COLLEGE TEACHERS DO AND JOY OFTEACHING SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 15
    • 1. NATURAL CRITICAL LEARNING ENVIRONMENT ◦ INTRIGUING QUESTION OR PROBLEM ◦ GUIDANCE N HELPING THE STUDENT UNDERSTAND SIGNIFICANCE ◦ ENGAGES STUDENTS IN HIGHER LEVEL INTELLECTUAL ACTIVITY ◦ HELPS STUDENTS ANSWER THE QUESTION ◦ LEAVES THEM WITH A QUESTION..WHAT’S THE NEXT QUESTION SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 16
    • 2. 3. 4. 5. 6. GET THEIR ATTENTION AND KEEP IT START WITH THE STUDENTS RATHER THAN THE DISCIPLINE. SIGNIFICANT TO THEM. SEEK COMMITMENTS –APPROACH EACH CLASS AS IF EXPECT STUDENTS TO LISTEN, THINK, RESPOND ENGAGE STUDENTS IN DISCIPLINARY THINKING, PROBLEM SOLVING, EVIDENCE, ARGUMEMENTS CREATE DIVERSE LEARNING EXPERIENCES— VISUAL, AUDITORY, ALLOW STUDENTS TO THINK, PROBLEM SOLVE, INDEPENDENTLY, WITH EACH OTHER ETC. SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 17
    • 1. 2. 3. 4. 5. POSE A QUESTION CREATE CONTEXT—WHY IS IT SIGNIFICANT? ―I FIND TODAY’S TOPIC INTERESTING BECAUSE….‖ TALK TO STUDENTS IN A WAY THAT HAS THEM ANALYZE AND WORK WITH EVIDENCE OFER YOUR ANSWER TO QUESTION COMPLETE WITH EVIDENCE AND CONCLUSIONS LEAVE STUDENTS WITH A QUESTOIN. SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 18
    •      GRAPPLE WITH IMPORTANT ISSUES OPORTUNITY TO CONSTRUCT THEIR UNDERSTANDING RAISING IMPORTANT AND CRITICAL QUESTIONS ASKING STUDENTS WHAT THEY THINKABOUT IMPORTANT ISSUES AND WHY PRESS FOR EVIDENCE, ALLOW STUDENTS TO CHALLEGE EACH OTHER SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 19
    •     EXPLORATORY QUESTION PROVOKE IMAGINATION ―ARE THERE ANY GOOD SOLUTIONS?‖ ―WHAT ARE THE POSSIBILITIES?‖ STUDENTS LAY THEIR THINKING ON TABLE STIMULATE EVALUATION OF THOSE IDEAS..WHAT ARE IMPLICATIONS OF ALTERNATE SOLUTIONS, INTERPRETATIONS, APPROACHES ? CONCLUDING QUESTION..WHAT HAVE WE LEARNED HERE? SUNY HV Consortium T&L Seminar with Dr. Sheldon 1/17 & 2/7 & 3/7/2014 20