Finding & Evaluating OER - SCORE Workshop Activity by Non Scantlebury
SCORE Fellows Open Educational Resources (OER) WorkshopWhat are they?"Digitised materials offered freely and openly for educators, students and self learners touse and reuse for teaching, learning and research" (OECD, 2007).Why use them? • Quality can be improved and the cost of content development reduced by sharing and reusing. • Theres a need to look for new models of module production and presentation. • They can speed up the development of new learning resources, stimulate internal improvement, innovation and reuse. • Because of the flexibility of OER materials, you can make them relevant to your needs.The JISC Open Educational Resources infoKit1 gives more information about thebenefits of using OERs.OER Handbook for Educators2 is also a useful starting point. Where can I find them?General ‘Repositories’ or Collections • Cloudworks: Links to OER repositories 3 • OpenLearn (labspace)4 • Jorum5 • OER Commons6 • 100 Best Open Educational Resources on the Web7Open Educational Resources Search EnginesJISC Infonet OER toolkit lists links to specialist search engines8and the UNESCO OER toolkit which lists specialist search engines, and generalrepositories9 Another useful resource is the OER Recommender101 https://openeducationalresources.pbworks.com/w/page/24836480/Home2 http://wikieducator.org/OER_Handbook/educator_version_one3 http://cloudworks.ac.uk/cloud/view/2318/links#contribute4 http://labspace.open.ac.uk/5 http://www.jorum.ac.uk/6 http://www.oercommons.org/7 http://www.mastersdegreeonline.net/blog/2009/the-100-best-open-education-resources-on-the-web/8 https://openeducationalresources.pbworks.com/w/page/27045418/Finding-OERs9 http://oerwiki.iiep-unesco.org/index.php?title=UNESCO_OER_Toolkit/Finding_and_Using_Open_Educational_Resources#Searching_for_and_finding_OER10 http://oerrecommender.org/
How do I evaluate them?Important attributes of quality OERs include:- • Accuracy • Reputation of author/institution • Standard of technical production • Accessibility • Fitness for purpose • Clear rights declarations e.g. Creative CommonsIf you would like to explore more issues around quality visit the JISC Open EducationalResources infoKit quality considerations11 web page.The accompanying checklist at the end of this document is provided to prompt you toconsider some key issues to think about when evaluating OERs. The checklist coverspotential areas to consider particularly when selecting OERs for reuse.Examples of good practiceIf you want to quickly view some good examples here are links to the recent top threewinning entries for the JORUM Learning and Teaching Competition 2010:1st Place: The molecular basis of photosynthesis.Submitted by Katy Jordan, University of Cambridge.http://open.jorum.ac.uk/xmlui/handle/123456789/70232nd Place: The Open Dementia E-Learning Programme: Living with dementia.Submitted by Colin Paton, Social Care Institute for Excellencehttp://open.jorum.ac.uk/xmlui/handle/123456789/70223rd Place: Making the creative process visible.Submitted by Dr Natasha Mayo, University Wales Institute, Cardiffhttp://open.jorum.ac.uk/xmlui/handle/123456789/2027 How can I use them?OER projects make use of open licenses in which the author retains copyright but canspecify clearly which rights he or she is prepared to share with users of the work.Creative Commons are the most common type of licenses which all require that a usergive credit to the original author and allow use and distribution of the resource. SomeCreative Commons licenses are more restrictive and, for example, do not allowmodification of a work to create a derivative work, or commercial use. Licenses thatinclude a "Share Alike" condition require that any derivative works are licensed under thesame open license.Want to know more?11 https://openeducationalresources.pbworks.com/w/page/24838164/Quality-considerations
You may find this series of tutorials from OER Commons12 useful.This short Information Literacy activity13 on ‘Finding images and copyright’, provides anoverview of issues relating to finding and incorporating images within academic work, aswell as providing some pointers for finding copyright cleared images online.Workshop Activity:1) Choose at least two of the OER search engines listed on the JISC OER InfoKit to locate an OER on a subject or topic of your own choosing.2) Apply the checklist below to record your evaluation of your chosen OER?3) Discuss with workshop participants how easy and pragmatic your chosen OER would be to adapt and reuse for your own teaching and learning contexts.Content for this resource was repurposed from material originally developed by TheOpen University Library Services used to promote the potential use of OER in moduledevelopment within the organization.This resource is licensed for reuse under Creative Commons Share AlikeNon ScantleburyThe Open University Library Services6th December 201012 http://wiki.oercommons.org/mediawiki/index.php/Tutorial13 http://learn.open.ac.uk/mod/oucontent/view.php?id=444918
Quality checklist for Open Educational ResourcesHere are some things you might want to consider when selecting Open Educational Resources for reuse. You can use this form torecord your findings. Comments Score 1 – 5 (1=low 5=high)Content- Relevant, accurate, appropriate level of detail, objective, current, jargon-free- Good provenance (consider reputation of author/institution), list of references if appropriate- Free of advertisingPedagogy- Learning outcomes stated and match with learner’s needs- Engaging, interactive- Appropriate level, any prerequisite skills / understandings stated- Time required to study is stated and equates to importance of learning outcomes achieved
Usability / Accessibility- Easy to use, well presented, clear navigation- Accessible for users with disabilities and conforms to accessibility guidanceReuse- Standalone resource that can be reused in different contexts- Robust, functional, works on different browsers/platforms- Rights are fully documented (Creative Commons or other rights statement) Is it OK to reuse it? Are there any conditions?