Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Harriet Orr
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Thanks for flagging this SlideShare!

Oops! An error has occurred.

×
Saving this for later? Get the SlideShare app to save on your phone or tablet. Read anywhere, anytime – even offline.
Text the download link to your phone
Standard text messaging rates apply

Harriet Orr

712

Published on

Published in: Education, Technology, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
712
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
3
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
1
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

Report content
Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. WFD and Upland management:a regulatory perspectiveHarriet OrrResearch Expert, Climate Change, Evidence Directorate9th May 2012Input from: Robert Brotherton, Zoe Frogbrook, Stacey Roe, Kate Gamble, Simon Hildon
  • 2. Introduction Good Ecological Status: reasons for failure Pressures, impacts and measures How we’re addressing issues and evidence gaps
  • 3. Reasons for Failure
  • 4. Water BodyFailures due toagriculture and landmanagementNorthern England
  • 5. Wales Reasons For WFD Failures - Wales 19% Unknown (investigation to be completed) 3% 1% Agricultural pollution 1% Artificial barriers to fish migration 2% Abandoned mines and contaminated land2% 16% Forestry 3% Acidification4% Sewage discharges Impoundments7% Flood protection & land drainage Urban & transport development 11% Surface water abstraction 7% Natural conditions Industrial discharges 7% 10% Septic tanks 7% Other
  • 6. Reasons for Failure Wales Agricultural Pollution 132 of Wales’ water bodies (16% of failures) fail Good Status because of pollution from agricultural activities Abandoned mines & contaminated land 84 of Wales’ water bodies (10% of failures) fail Good Status because of diffuse and point source pollution from abandoned mines and contaminated land
  • 7. Reasons for Failure Forestry 60 of Wales’ water bodies (7% of failures) fail Good Status because of forestry activities This may drop to around 20 with further investigations Map of surface water failures for forestry
  • 8. Reasons for Failure Wales Acidification in Wales 59 water bodies (7% of failures) fail Good Status because of the deposition of acidifying pollutants from combustion on sensitive environments. Map of surface water failures due to acidification
  • 9. Upland issues Failures due to upland condition are few Looking for cost effective multiple benefits from measures Holistic approach in uplands e.g. riparian management to reduce sediment and nutrient delivery
  • 10. Evidence gaps for pressure/impacts Risks of deterioration Efficacy of measures Value for money of measures esp. sediment/morphology lag time between implementation and ecological recovery.
  • 11. Existing mechanisms Voluntary agreements e.g. safeguard zones for drinking water Pilot studies: learning by doing NE, moorland condition and fish (non SSSI) 13 water bodies to be improved through moorland restoration (> 900 water bodies in the region) Effectiveness of catchment sensitive farming methods “Taking a quality rather than quantity approach”
  • 12. Implementing measures: Safeguard zones Drinking Water Protected Areas for water supply – designated in WFD DrWPAs provide safe drinking water (Drinking Water Directive) Protected from deterioration in quality (reduce treatment) Key variables colour, pesticides, algae and nitrate. In England, DrWPAs protected through defining Safeguard Zones. Voluntary Safeguard Zone Action Plans – to focus actions. Safeguard Zone action plan can link PR09/PR14 programmes.
  • 13. Drinking Water Protected Areas at risk of failure due tocolour 25 DrWPAs at risk in NW feeding into 10 Safeguard Zone action plans 18 DrWPAs at risk inYorkshire & North East Region, feeding into 5 Safe guard Zone action plans WPZ/ product restrictions Water Company catchment Safeguard zones schemes CoGAP/cross compliance/NVZs/CFE
  • 14. Significant Water Management Issues Addressing national scale issues in post 2015 Consultation: opportunity to raise issues Inform evidence development
  • 15. Conclusions Upland condition not big reason for failure Future deterioration unclear (incl peat) Evidence about measures needed Channel issues/evidence through SWMI and UHGImproving the evidence base “learning from doing”

×