Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
0
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Thanks for flagging this SlideShare!

Oops! An error has occurred.

×
Saving this for later? Get the SlideShare app to save on your phone or tablet. Read anywhere, anytime – even offline.
Text the download link to your phone
Standard text messaging rates apply

A future without mediation? Online access, archivists, and the future of archival research

1,047

Published on

Presentation by Sigrid McCausland at RAILS7, 10 May 2011

Presentation by Sigrid McCausland at RAILS7, 10 May 2011

Published in: Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,047
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
0
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

Report content
Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. A future without mediation? Online access, archivists and the future of archival researchSigrid McCausland RAILS 10 May 2011
  • 2. Users of archives are increasingly physically remote, but we still tend to measure success primarily in terms of personal visits to an archive repository. This is not surprising, as our profession is generally focused on the physicality of documents and the secure accommodation that we need to provide for them, and the understanding and interpretation of physical archives is crucial to many areas of research.
    Jane Stevenson (2008) ‘The Online Archivist: A Positive Approach to the Digital Age’, p.91
  • 3. Outline
    Introduction
    Definitions
    Online access and archival research
    Mediation and archival reference practice
    A new paradigm?
    Conclusion
  • 4. Online access
    In archives today, this usually means either or both:
    • access to information about records
    • 5. access to digitised surrogates of paper records
  • Mediation (OED)
    Agency or action as an intermediary; the state or fact of serving as an intermediate agent, a means of action, or a medium of transmission; instrumentality
  • 6. Disintermediate (Macquarie)
    to connect directly to the primary source of a commercial product, thus cutting out distributers, retailers, wholesalers and all other intermediaries. –disintermediation, noun
  • 7. Archival research
    Archival research means accessing and using original records, created by organisations or individuals and placed under archival control, as sources for intellectual enquiry.
  • 8. Archives user types
    • Family historians
    • 9. Professional researchers
    • 10. Local area historians
    • 11. Academics
    • 12. University students
    • 13. Secondary school students
    • 14. Other – inc architects, journalists, visual artists
    (CAARA/ASA (2007) Archives Survey 2007, pp. 46-48)
  • 15. Archives users
  • 16. ‘Inherent’ and institutional factors
    • Lack coherence making retrieval more difficult
    • 17. Inadequacy of finding aids – coverage and comprehensibility
    • 18. Organised according to provenance not subject
    • 19. Limitation of ready reference tools
    • 20. Closed stacks, no browsing possible
  • Human factors (1)
    • Inferential methods of searching based on archivists’ knowledge
    • 21. Users don’t know how to research primary materials
    • 22. Users have less experience with using archives than libraries
  • Human factors (2)
    • Interaction between archivists and users is more intense than between librarians and users
    • 23. Archivists have often processed the materials and bring deep knowledge of content
    (adapted from Duff 2010, p.118)
  • 24. Online access – one view
    Digitised records available online are … accessible to all, irrespective of location, and at a time to suit individual convenience and preference rather than reading room hours of opening.
    (Macpherson, P. (2010) Building a better horse and buggy: The privileging of access in reading rooms over online access, p. 64)
  • 25. Online access – another view
    On a broader, more philosophic level, the notion of digitisation as an agent of equality needs a bit of scrutiny. Contrary to the rhetoric, it is not really value-free. Databases are like maps, they are representations of reality and similarly a model set of relationships…which means that selection is always involved.
    (Susan Crean, (2011) National Archives Blues : Is a precious Canadian asset being digitized to death?)
  • 26. A new paradigm?
    • Digital access should come first and archival practice should be shaped by this imperative
    • 27. ‘a philosophy that privileges the user and promotes an ethos of sharing, collaboration and openness’ (Joy Palmer, 2009)
  • Conclusion
    • Archival notions of uniqueness and control are being challenged
    • 28. Mediation has a future but not in its traditional form
    • 29. Archival institutions and archivists need to embrace user engagement on many fronts, not just reference services

×