SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 11
Download to read offline
Originalarbeiten á Originals                              Holz als Roh- und Werkstoff 57 (1999) 407±417 Ó Springer-Verlag 1999



Use of wood in new Dutch one family dwellings since 1969
        P. J. Fraanje




                                                                                                                                         407
The application of wood for building purposes, especially                                     È           È
                                                                           Holzverwendung fur neue hollandische
when used in constructions, can be seen as a high quality                               È
                                                                            Einfamilienhauser seit 1969
application. As wood is, in contrast with most other              Die Verwendung des Rohstoffs Holz im Bauwesen, vor al-
building materials, a renewable resource, and because the               È
                                                                  lem fur Holzkonstruktionen, kann man als Nutzung von
environmental impact is relatively low, wood is promoted                         È
                                                                  hoher Qualitat ansehen. Holz ist im Gegensatz zu den
by the Dutch government in the ``20% more wood for the            meisten anderen Baumaterialien ein erneuerbarer Rohstoff.
building sector'' programme. In this article an overview is       Weil die Belastung der Umwelt relativ niedrig ist, wird die
given of wood utilization in new one family dwellings                                                   È
                                                                  Holzverwendung durch die niederlandische Regierung im
(OFD's), built in the past three decades. The wood use per        Rahmen des Programms ,,20% mehr Holz im Bau`` gefor-    È
average OFD dropped from 6.2 m3 in 1969 to 3.4 m3 in                                                                 È
                                                                  dert. In diesem Beitrag wird die Holzverwendung fur neue
1996. Most of the wood is currently applied to roof and                          È
                                                                  Einfamilienhauser (EFH) in den letzten dreiûig Jahren
window frames. It appears that there is a decrease in the         analysiert. Fur ein EFH brauchte man im Jahre 1969 6,2 m3
                                                                                È
total wood use for new OFD's and that the amount of wood          Holz, 1996 dagegen nur 3,4 m3. Heute sind Dach und
products per average OFD also shows a declining ten-                                                 È
                                                                  Fenster die wichtigsten Bauteile fur die Holzverwendung.
dency, counterbalanced however by a growing gross ¯oor            Es zeigt sich, daû sowohl die gesamte Holzverwendung als
area and an increasing number of unsubsidized OFD's. For          auch die durchschnittliche pro EFH laufend sinkt, obwohl
1996, a balance of the total amount of wood applied in all                            È
                                                                  die Brutto-Boden¯ache der EFH gestiegen ist. Dies liegt
OFD's with the input and output of wood products is               daran, daû der Anteil nicht subventionierter EFH in den
presented. The total wood stock in all OFD's is estimated                                     È
                                                                  letzten Jahren zunahm. Fur 1996 wird hier eine Bilanz der
to amount 21 ´ 106 tonnes for 1996. This can be seen as a                                  È
                                                                  gesamten Holzmenge fur alle EFH zusammen mit In- und
reservoir out of which wood becomes available every year                                           È
                                                                  Output von Holzprodukten prasentiert. Die gesamte
through renovation and demolition of OFD's. This sec-             Holzmenge in EFH betragt rund 21 ´ 106 t und steht jedes
                                                                                            È
ondary wood (together with wood waste from newly built                   È
                                                                  Jahr fur Abbruch und Renovierung von EFH bereit. Das
OFD's) can be cascaded, so that the resource wood is                                                      È
                                                                  Altholz kann (zusammen mit Holzabfallen von Neubauten)
optimally used. The article concludes with options to in-         wieder verwendet werden (cascade), so daû der Rohstoff
crease the amount of wood used in new OFD's, by ±                                                     È
                                                                  Holz optimal genutzt wird. Eine Moglichkeit zur Steigerung
amongst others ± increasing the market shares of timber                                   È                       È
                                                                  der Holzverwendung fur EFH bietet z.B. die Erhohung des
frame dwellings, wooden ¯ooring and wooden foundation                                                      È           È
                                                                  Marktanteils im Holzskelettbau, bei holzernen Fuûboden
piles.                                                            und Fundamentierungspfahlen.È

                                                                    1
                                                                    Introduction
                                                                    The use of timber in dwellings is interesting from an en-
                                                                    vironmental point of view, as wood is, in contrast to most
P.J. Fraanje                                                        other building materials, a renewable resource with rela-
IVAM Environmental Research                                         tively low environmental impact and a positive effect on
University of Amsterdam                                             the indoor environment (Schneider 1986; Fraanje et al.
P.O. Box 18180,                                                     1990; La¯eur and Fraanje 1997). The utilization of the
1001 ZB Amsterdam, The Netherlands
                                                                    resource of wood in the building sector, especially when
I thank Prof. Dr. L. Reijnders of the Interfaculty Department of used for structural purposes, can be seen as a high quality
Environmental Sciences (IDES) of the University of Amsterdam application and therefore is a good start for a cascading
for his comments. I am grateful to Mr. W.J. de Graaf of PRC         strategy (Fraanje 1997; La¯eur and Fraanje 1997). In
Bouwcentrum in Bodegraven, Mr. F.G.M. van Swam and Mr.              general, the use of wood as a building material is envi-
                 È
R.G.A. Bult of Hugli Pollock Read in Utrecht, Mr. A.G. Oskam of ronmentally preferable to application in products with a
Damen Consultants in Rotterdam (now working at Centre for           shorter life time e.g. pallets, as carbon locked up in wood is
Sustainable Building in Utrecht) and Mr. E. Knapper of the
Netherlands Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS), for supplying       stored for a longer period of time (Fraanje and La¯eur
data. The research for this article was ®nancially sponsored by the 1994; Fraanje 1997; Drunen 1997).
NWO-research programme for sustainability and environmental            Against this background, the Dutch Ministry of Hous-
quality.                                                            ing, Physical Planning and Environment (VROM) pub-
lished a report within the framework of its programme for      working in renovation projects. Although being quantita-
      sustainable building in which an effort to increase the        tively less important, this article is limited to newly built
      application of timber and other wood products in the           dwellings. Speci®c data on wood use for renovation of
      building sector by 20% is formulated (Boonekamp 1995).         dwellings are not available as most of the renovation
      Some important institutions in the building and civil en-      activities are not recorded.
      gineering market, like the Ministry of Public Works and           Apart from the new OFD's yearly some 20±30% of all
      Water Management as well as two umbrella organisations         dwellings are new apartments in multi storey blocks. The
      of housing corporations, have committed themselves to          amount of wood products per apartment constitutes a
      this goal. In 1990, the year of reference of the 20% more      fraction of the wood products used for OFD's; in apart-
      wood programme, 2,150,000 m3 of wood products were             ments built after 1968, 2.5 times less wood is applied than
      used in the whole Dutch building sector (residential, non      in an OFD (de Graaf 1996). Therefore, within the section of
408
      residential and civil engineering) (Boonekamp 1995). For       new dwellings only newly built one family houses (without
      1990, the use of sawn wood and sheet material was esti-        sheds) (OFD's) are taken into account.
      mated at an average of 2.8 m3 wood product per new
      dwelling, totalling 280,000 m3 net and 400,000 m3 gross    3
      (excluding wooden foundation piles) for 97,500 new         The use of wood in dwellings
      dwellings built in this year (Boonekamp 1995). In 1980, thebuilt between 1969 and 1982
      average still was 3.8 m3 wood product per new dwelling     There are unfortunately no detailed data covering the use
      (Fraanje et al. 1990).                                     of wood in Dutch new OFD's during the 20th century.
         Within the framework of the 20% more wood pro-          Estimates for the 1900±1945 period suggest that roughly
      gramme, the total amount of wood for the new dwellings     10.4 m3 of timber was applied in new OFD's (Botman
      has to be enlarged by about 100,000 m3 in the year 2000    1979), whereas only about 8.5 m3 were used in the 1945±
      (Boonekamp 1995). The object in view is to double the      1970 period (Botman 1979). It should be noted that earlier
      number of timber frame dwellings and to expand the         mentioned estimates refer to analyses of typical single
      number of wooden carrying inner cavity walls, sloping      OFD's; they are not a result of a representative cross-sec-
      roofs, wooden foundation piles and sheds (Boonekamp        tion. Detailed data are available as to OFD's built between
      1995).                                                     1969 and 1982. In this paragraph, the application of wood
         Exact data on wood applications in new dwellings since  products in new one-family dwellings in the period be-
      1982 in the Netherlands are not available, but experts havetween 1969 and 1982 is analyzed. In the period between
      the impression that timber products lost ground in the     1969 and 1982, the Ministry of Housing and Physical
      residential sector (Eisma 1979) (Boonekamp 1995). Wood     Planning (VRO) documented the use of building materials
      products seem to be more and more replaced by other        in new dwellings, in the Quantitative Material Documen-
      materials like concrete and plastics, so the actual trend of
                                                                 tation (QMD). For a period of fourteen years, a unique
      wood utilization in the building sector tends towards the  documentation was developed, however published only
      opposite direction of the ``20% more wood programme''.     partly and at different places (CBS 1976±1984; Eisma 1973±
         In an effort to trace the actual development of wood use1980 and van derWerff 1980±1985). In 1983, the Dutch
      and to view this against the background of longer term     government decided to stop this documentation, due to
      trends, it is attempted to determine the average amount of cuts in expenditure. Since then some consultants have
      wood in new one family dwellings (OFD) in the Nether-      emerged offering information per building product or
      lands over the last three decades. OFD's in the Netherlandselement for a commercial price, but no overview is given,
      built in this period typically have two ¯oors and an attic.and data are hardly published anymore.
      The attention is focused on which building elements are       For the QMD, the utilized building material according
      usually made of wood and changes therein. Further, the     to 1000±1200 plans for new dwellings was recorded. This
      total amount of wood in all OFD's in the Netherlands is    represented a 1% cross-section of all new dwellings. Such
      estimated and a wood balance for 1996 is presented. Data   recording was possible, as for all new houses authorization
      on the total wood stock and wood ¯ows are relevant for     of the central government on the basis of drawings and
      determining the cascading potential of timber in the Dutch speci®cations was necessary. It should be noted that as
      OFD stock. Finally, some options for an increase in wood   plans for building were used, the data for 1969 are rep-
      utilization for OFD's are given.                           resentative for the dwellings built in 1970, etc. A slight
                                                                 drawback of this method may be that minor differences
      2                                                          between plans and the actual dwellings are possible,
      New one family dwellings                                   especially where ®nishing materials are concerned.
      Most of the timber used annually in the Netherlands is        Based on the primary data of the Quantitative Material
      applied in the residential sector (NEI 1983; NEHEM 1983; Documentation, Table 1 lists the use of wood in different
      Fraanje and La¯eur 1994; Boonekamp 1995). Apart from construction elements and building products for one
      the 400,000 m3 for new dwellings, also about 650,000 m3 family dwellings without shed for the period 1969±1982.
      (gross) of wood and sheet material (boards, plywood etc) The table is divided into the categories foundation, ¯oor,
      was used for renovating dwellings in 1990 (Boonekamp       facade, ceiling, wall, roof, door and staircase. Not included
      1995). Wood is a light weight, strong, ¯exible, easy       in the QMD are skirtings, roof laths, thresholds and indoor
      adaptable and workable (on the building site) building     ®nishings, as well as timber used for shuttering and scaf-
      material which explains its popularity amongst contractors folding. Also excluded from the QMD is the use of wood
Table 1. The use of timber and boarding material in different construction elements and building products are given for one family dwellings without shed for the period 1969±1982
                                                                                                                         È               È
Tabelle 1. Die Verwendung von Schnittholz und Brettmaterial in verschiedenen Konstruktionselementen und Baustoffen fur Einfamilienhauser ohne Schuppen in den Niederlanden
von 1969±1982

Wood use in new one family dwellings (OFD's) without shed 1969±1982

Number of OFD's                                       85100 91300 98500 112400 109900 100600 88600 93900 84500 81900 73300 68900                                  78375    63950
  Building element                       year            69     70     71     72     73     74     75     76     77     78     79     80                             81       82
Foundation                               pieces      346800 366400 386300 370600 326600 326500 283600 316100 284000 131200 135000 140800                          90700    73400
  Wooden foundation piles
Floor
  Floor beams                            m3            39600    42600    33473    42311    36107    27145    19605    27188    22431    19162    16641    12513     7949     7642
  Wooden ¯ooring                         1000   m2      1484     1858     1936     2062     1482      808      610      687      464      392      331      274      121      111
  Plywood                                1000   m2                                   28        8       17       58      105       48      124       95      151      117      193
  Chipboard                              1000   m2                          14       77      115      138      105      170      200       85       66       44       42       37
  Planks of hardwood                     1000   m2        31        5       10        4       16        0        0       22        0        0        0        0        0        0
  Parquet                                1000   m2         0        0       16       12       13       16       20       16       16       11       14        4        3        0
Facade
  Wooden facade                          1000 m2          11        1        8       23       nb       11       13       15        0       15       21       40       24       20
  Wooden sheatings                       OFD's                            4400     4400     5900     5600     6300     6900     6300     3700     2800     2000     1700     1000
  Coniferous window frames               1000 m2        2712     2790     2746     2958     2641     2123     1478     1178      757      670      751      626      625      435
  Hardwood window frames                 1000 m2         382      422      730     1126     1332     1277     1433     1949     2033     1819     1269     1157     1238     1020
  Parapets wood                          1000 m2         138      133      189      342      422      460      364      441      448      399      288      187      173      174
  Parapets plywood                       1000 m2                   28       31       46       72       79       70       73       65       63       62       38       51       49
  Parapets ®breboard                     1000 m2                    2        2        5        2        0        1        1        0        0        0        0        0        0
  Wooden parapet for balconies           1000 m2          28       42       25       31       14       24       33       30       29       46       16       28       20        9
Ceiling
  Fibreboard ceiling                     1000 m2        1467     1546     1606     1306      783      391      264      156       93       12       46        7        1        0
  Wooden ceiling                         1000 m2         234      250      219      356      759      641      535      605      687      289      211      204      103       55
  Chipboard ceiling                      1000 m2          nb       nb       85       67       71      137       77      100       66       35       17        4       10       10
Wall
  Wooden carrying inner cavity wall      1000 m2                                                                                  nb      108       90       99      101      221
  Non carrying interior wall chipboard   1000 m2           8       13       nb      425      465      374      328      260      197      130      105      112      120       66
Roof
  Beams for roo®ng                       m3            80800    86900    82324 100482 102876        86139    76077    96266    88838 79523 61608 57123 53053               37893
  Boarding spruce                        1000 m2        3371     3215     2303   1880   1410          852      400      258      258     155      118      46      9           8
  Boarding plywood                       1000 m2          21        7       13     83    112          121       69      211      190     189      304     429    521         528
  Boarding woodwool(cement)              1000 m2         239       69      174    156    260          120       60       48       35      45       22       0      1           3
  Boarding chipboard*                    1000 m2                                         137           65      119       83      278   6086     4839     4681   4435        3003
  Reed ¯ax straw boarding                1000 m2        2324     3278     3648   5598   5993         5782     5485     6850     6217 included in chipboard data
  Roo®nsulation woodwool                 1000 m2         119       76      142    136     63           78       18        0       62       0        0       0      0           0
  (Ply)wood for gutters                  m3             1310     1260     1389   1618   1837         1820     1719     2190     2055   2156     1668     1157    713         575
  Wooden dormer                          pieces        11440    10313    14300 12000 12900          10400    13840    15440    14160 17600 16800 12051 11092                8514
  Wooden pivotal window                  pieces         5170    13630    20680 28012 24252          30174    32430    40138    29422 35881 43150 44556 61100               54219
Doors
  Front door coniferous                  pieces       29500 30400 30000 31300 20000 20900 14000 12700          6100   5700   6800   4400   5300   3900
  Front door hardwood                    pieces       40100 37800 46500 52500 59500 50300 48900 58900 59100 64800 54900 48900 53100 44100
  Front door plywood                     pieces       14300 22000 20600 23600 22000 17900 13500 13800          8600 24200 20500     8200 10900    6900
  Kitchen, terrace, balconydoor          pieces      129000 131000 139700 164500 169100 157000 137600 160700 148100 141000 108400 93200 91700 70700
  Outer doors (total)                    pieces      212900 221200 236800 271900 270600 246100 214000 246100 221900 222900 181700 154700 161000 125600
                                                                                                                                                409
for constructions of inner walls and ceilings. Table 1
                                                                                                 582
                                                                                               11100

                                                                                                                52200
                                                                                                                54358
                                                                                                                                                                                                    shows dramatic decrease in wooden foundation piles, ¯oor
                                                                                                                                                                                                    beams, wooden ¯ooring and spruce boarding of roofs.
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Especially for window frames, inner door frames and front
                                                                                                 743
                                                                                               13600

                                                                                                                68000
                                                                                                                66619
                                                                                                                                                                                                    doors, hardwood gained market shares at the cost of co-
                                                                                                                                                                                                    niferous wood in the period 1969±1982.
                                                                                                 663




                                                                                                                                                                                                    4
                                                                                               19600

                                                                                                                57600
                                                                                                                58565


                                                                                                                                                                                                    Estimation of the wood use in one-family
                                                                                                                                                                                                    dwellings (OFD's) in 1996
                                                                                                                                                                                                    For the period after 1982, hardly any detailed information
                                                                                                 729
                                                                                               22830

                                                                                                                59800
                                                                                                                62305




410                                                                                                                                                                                                 on wood use in new dwellings is available. There are,
                                                                                                                                                                                                    however, reports with estimates of wood product market
                                                                                                                                                                                                    shares (Dielen 1985; de Graaf 1988; Boonekamp 1995; de
                                                                                                 822
                                                                                               37410

                                                                                                                66200
                                                                                                                69615




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Graaf 1996). For 1996, there are also informations available
                                                                                                                                                                                                                                        È
                                                                                                                                                                                                    from BuildsightÒ (produced by Hugli Pollock Read, Ut-
                                                                                                                                                                                                    recht 1997), a software programme for producers in the
                                                                                                 847
                                                                                               29000

                                                                                                                68500
                                                                                                                71825




                                                                                                                                                                                                    building market. Buildsight is based on about 1400 inter-
                                                                                                                                                                                                    views on building sites in combination with statistical
                                                                                                                                                                                                    information on total area's of roofs, walls etc. of newly
                                                                                                 953
                                                                                               36200

                                                                                                                74400
                                                                                                                79815




                                                                                                                                                                                                    built OFD's. As the interviews take place on the building
                                                                                                                                                                                                    sites, the data gathered are representative for the same
                                                                                                                                                                                                    year, so in contrast to the QMD, the data for 1996 refer to
                                                                                                 904
                                                                                               30600

                                                                                                                73500
                                                                                                                76000




                                                                                                                                                                                                    the OFD's built in 1996.
                                                                                                                                                                                                       In the following the wood use for 1996 in new OFD's is
                                                                                                                                                                                                    estimated. In 1996, 61,007 OFD's were realized, of which
                                                                                                1033
                                                                                               41300

                                                                                                                86900
                                                                                                                83200




                                                                                                                                                                                                    36% were detached, while the other 64% of OFD's were
                                                                                                                                                                                                    built in a row (Buildsight 1997). Table 2 summarizes the
                                                                                                                                                                                                    wood use in new OFD's in 1996. These elements are the
                                                                                                1158
                                                                                               59700

                                                                                                                90200
                                                                                                                92800




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Table 2. The estimated amount of wood products (in m3) ap-
                                                                                                1230
                                                                                               67800

                                                                                                                99300
                                                                                                                91100




                                                                                                                                                                                                    plied in one family dwellings (without shed) built in 1996
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Tabelle 2. Geschatzte Menge an Holzprodukten (m3) in Einfa-
                                                                                                                                                                                                                     È
                                                                                                                                                                                                            È
                                                                                                                                                                                                    milienhausern (ohne Schuppen), die 1996 gebaut wurden
                                                                                                1129
                                                                                               67200

                                                                                                                93100
                                                                                                                81048




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Building element                             m3 (1996)

                                                                                                                                                                                                    Foundation
                         Wood use in new one family dwellings (OFD's) without shed 1969±1982

                                                                                                1082
                                                                                               71600

                                                                                                                80993
                                                                                                                76158




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden foundation piles                      5630
                                                                                                                                 * documentation modi®ed in 1978 (accounts for a sudden increase)




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Floor
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Floorbeams                                   7240
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Plywood/OSB ¯ooring                          4935
                                                                                                1016
                                                                                               72200

                                                                                                                78204
                                                                                                                67905




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Facade
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden facade                                2800
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Coniferous window frames (spruce, pine)      2310
                                                                                               1000 pieces




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Hardwood window frames                      19940
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Ceiling                                      no estimation
                                                                                               OFD's




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Wall
                                                                                                                pieces
                                                                                                                pieces




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Carrying inner cavity wall                   2860
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Roof
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Beams for roo®ng                            58230
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Boarding plywood/chipboard/OSB              66175
                                                                                                                                 ** after 1975 data are extrapolated




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Plywood for gutters                          1095
                                                                                                 Wooden staircase to ®rst ¯oor




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden dormers                               1315
                                                                                                 Wooden staircase to attic**
                                                                                                 Wooden inner door frames




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden pivotal windowÃ)                      2865
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Doors
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden outer doors                           5320
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Inner doors of wood                          5490
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden inner door frames                     2040
      Table 1. (cont.)




                                                                                                                                                                                                    Staircases
                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden staircase to the ®rst ¯oor            9900
                                                                                                 Staircases
                                                                                               Inner doors




                                                                                                                                                                                                     Wooden staircase to the attic                6000
                                                                                                                                                                                                    Total                                          204.145
                                                                                                                                                                                                    * wood for window frames of dormers
same as the ones covered by the QMD (Table 1), with the         hardwood to coniferous wood was about 90:10 in 1990 but
exception of parapets. In order to outline the underlying       changed to 85:15 in 1993 (Boonekamp 1994). Probably,
data and assumptions for 1996, the speci®c building ele-        this has to do with campaigns against the use of tropical
ments of OFD's built in 1996 in which wood is applied are       hardwood in combination with the emergence of techni-
reviewed:                                                       cally well-constructed coniferous window frames.

4.1                                                             4.4
Foundation                                                      Ceiling
Most wooden foundation piles are made of spruce (about          Wood does not play a role anymore in this building element
75%), the other 25% are larch and douglas (de Graaf 1988).      except as a construction for ®xing gypsum board. This
According to (Beukema 1997) 1±5% of all dwellings built in      application was not recorded in the QMD. For all 110,000
                                                                                                                               411
1995 by housing corporations is built on wooden piles.          dwellings in 1987 de Graaf (1988) estimated a total wood use
Another estimate for 1996 arrives at 1% (Swam 1997). In         of over 8,000 m3, mainly used in about 5,500 timber frame
this article, the assumption is made that the market share of   houses. For 1996, no data are available, and in accordance
wooden piles amounts 2% of all OFD's, and that every house      with Eisma (1979), no estimate is given in Table 2.
is founded on 18 piles. This is less than the percentages of
all new dwellings in 1987 (9%), 1990 (7%), and 1995 (8%)        4.5
(see Boonekamp 1994; de Graaf 1988; de Graaf 1996).             Wall
                                                                Wooden load carrying inner cavity walls seem to be quite
4.2                                                             popular in new residential buildings. Their market share
Floor                                                           was estimated at 20% of all dwellings built by housing
Wooden ground ¯oors have completely disappeared from            corporations in 1995 (Beukema 1997). According to in-
the OFD market (Eisma 1979e) and wooden ®rst ¯oors are          formation of Buildsight however, the market share
rare in newly built houses. Excluding timber frame              amounts to only 5% of the total area load-bearing inner
buildings, the market share of wooden ®rst ¯oors in 1990        walls in all new OFD's; this equals 57,000 m2 in 1996
is estimated at 1 to 2% (Boonekamp 1994). This is in ac-        (Buildsight 1997).
cordance with the share of 1% which can be derived from            It is unknown, how much wood is used for inner non-
(Beukema 1997). In 1996, there was a total surface of           bearing walls. A relatively small amount of timber, mostly
329,000 m2 of wooden ¯oors in all new OFD's (3% of the          spruce, is used in combination with gypsumboards
total ¯oorarca in OFD's). The amount of beams necessary         (Boonekamp 1994). For 1996 there are no data on wood
is calculated from the ratio ¯oorarea ¯oorbeams in 1982.        use in inner walls. In line with Eisma (1979) and
Far out most popular for ¯ooring is sheet material like         Boonekamp (1994) this wood use is neglected.
oriented strand board, underlayment and plywood. It is
assumed that the average thickness of the ¯ooring material 4.6
is 15 mm and that the area of wooden (spruce) ¯ooring is Roof
nil (see Table 2).                                           From Buildsight (1997), it can be derived that the total
                                                             surface of sloping roofs of OFD's in 1996 was 5,882,000 m2.
4.3                                                          With the ratio of wooden beams to roof area, the total
Facade                                                       amount of beams can be calculated. The 1996 market share
Buildsight lists 140,000 m2 of wooden facades, corre-        of beams in sloping roofs is estimated at 90%.
sponding to a market share for OFD's of 1.5%. Pre-fabri-        For boarding of roofs, it is assumed that 75% of the total
cated facades often have wooden parapets. Buildsight gives sloping roof area of OFD's is boarded with plywood and
no information on parapets; no estimate is given in          chipboard, with a thickness of 15 mm. The wood use in
Table 2, as the total surface is not known. In the period ¯at roofs in OFD's (504,000 m2 in 1996) is neglected.
1980±1982 about 3,000 m3 of wood were used for parapets         In 1996, 32% of all OFD's had a gutter boarded with
related to window frames. In line with the data for 1987 wood products (Buildsight 1997), most of it plywood (de
and 1990, indicating a market share of 50% for wooden        Graaf 1988). Detached houses had a facade of 9.82 in
parapets related to window frames in facades for all         width, while an OFD in a row had a facade of 5.43 m in
dwellings (de Graaf 1988; Boonekamp 1995), the market width (Buildsight 1997). If the assumption is made that the
share of wooden parapets for 1996 is estimated at 50%.       length of gutters is twice the width of the facade, an esti-
   Wood is market leader in window frames for new            mate can be derived of the wood use for gutters in 1996.
OFD's. According to (Buildsight 1997), the total window         In 1996, 20.5% of all new OFD's had a dormer. The
frame surface in facades of OFD's built in 1996 was          market share of wood is put at 50% (see Table 2). This
1,246,000 m2, 92% of which was wood. The total market means an increase compared with the estimated 35%
shares of wood for window frames in all dwellings in 1982, market share for 1990, in line with expert opinion
1987, 1990, and 1995 were estimated at 95, 91, 85, and 90%, (Boonekamp 1994).
respectively (de Graaf 1988; Boonekamp 1994; Boonekamp
1995). Of the wooden frames applied in OFD's in 1996,        4.7
13% is coniferous and 87% hardwood according to              Doors
Buildsight (see Table 2). This ratio is roughly in line with In 1996, 232,000 outer doors were used for all new OFD's
estimates of Boonekamp (1995) who states that the ratio of (Buildsight 1997). It is estimated that of this total number
there were 25,000 doors for sheds and 10,000 doors to          wood is put at 30:70 and for 1981 and 1982 70:30 and for
      garages. Furthermore it is assumed that 90% of all outer       1996 at 75:25. The above mentioned estimates are in line
      doors of OFD's are made of wood and that the ratio             with the data reported by van der Werff (1984b) and es-
      hardwood to coniferous wood is 85:15. In 1987, of wooden       timates by de Graaf (1988); Boonekamp (1994) and
      outer doors in all dwellings, hardwood had a share of 81%      Boonekamp (1995).
      and coniferous wood of 9%. Merbau was by far the most              Table 3 summarizes the total amount of wood products
      popular wood used for hardwood outer doors, followed by        applied in OFD's built in the period 1969±1982 and in
      meranti (de Graaf 1988).                                       1996, as well as the calculated amount per OFD for these
         Most inner doors are made of spruce in combination          years. For a good interpretation of the data derived from
      with plywood or chipboard. In 1996, the total amount of        the QMD, it is important to realise that they are an average
      inner doors was 610,000 (Buildsight 1996). Using a con-        from three categories of one-family dwellings, namely
412
      version factor, the total amount of wood used for inner        Housing Act (HA) houses, Premium houses (P) and non-
      doors can be estimated. The total area of wooden inner         subsidized houses. The ®rst two categories are more (HA)
      door frames in 1996 was 1,541,000 m2; this equals a market     or less (P) subsidized by the government. It should be
      share of wood of 13% (Buildsight 1997). This percentage is     noted that in the non-subsidized category, twice or even
      lower than the market share for wood of 20% of all             thrice as much timber is applied as in Housing Act houses
      dwellings built in 1995 by housing corporations (Beukema       (Eisma 1979) (NEI 1983). For this reason, the share of the
      1997) but higher than the estimates for 1987 (de Graaf         non-subsidized category within the OFD sector is also
      1988) and 1990 (Boonekamp 1994): 10% and 5±10%, re-            given in Table 3.
      spectively. Of the wooden inner door frames used in OFD's          It should also be noted that for the period of 1969±1982,
      in 1996, 86% were made from hardwood, 14% of conifer-          the wood use refers to OFD's built in 1970±1983. The
      ous wood (Buildsight 1997). In 1982, still 29% of the          values for 1996 are representative for the OFD's built in the
      wooden inner door frames in all dwellings were made of         same year.
      coniferous wood and 71% of hardwood (van der Werff                 It can be learnt from Table 3 that from 1969 to 1982, the
      1984b), so between 1982 and 1996 coniferous wood lost          total amount of wood products used in all OFD's is almost
      market shares at the cost of (mostly tropical) hardwood.       constantly declining, the years 1976 and 1977 being the
                                                                     exception to the rule. In this period, a relative great vari-
      4.8                                                            ation in roofs was a fashion among architects, which may
      Staircases                                                     partly explain the higher average (van der Werff 1980).
      About 115,000 staircases were built into all new OFD's in      Furthermore, in 1976±1979 the share of unsubsidized
      1996 (Buildsight 1997). It is assumed that they are all made   houses was relatively high, leading to a higher volume of
      from wood. It can be derived from de Graaf (1988) that in      wood used in OFD's. In 1969, over half a million m3 wood
      1987, of wooden staircases in all dwellings, hardwood had      products were used in OFD's, while in 1982 and 1996 only
      a market share of 72% and coniferous wood of 18%.              200,000 m3 wood products were applied. In 1972, the year
         In Table 2, the estimates of the wood use per building      with the highest number of OFD's planned, the total wood
      element in 1996 in new OFD's are given. To determine the       use was also the highest of the 69±82 period. The total use
      amount of m3 per application, use is made of conversion        of products of coniferous wood (mainly spruce) declined
      factors in line with de Graaf (1996) and Oskam (1995).         dramatically in the period 1969±1982. For 1996, the total
                                                                     use of coniferous wood is estimated less than in 1982. The
      5                                                              application of hardwood reached its peak in 1976 and 1977
      Total wood use in new OFD's                                    and maintained a yearly level of about 30,000 m3. As far as
      The data from Table 1 can be converted into m3 wood            sheet material (®bre/chip boards, plywood) is concerned,
      products and accumulated to coniferous wood, hardwood          it should be noted that, due to changes in the documen-
      and sheet material (chipboard, plywood, soft- and hard-        tation, a strange jump occurs in the data around 1978. This
      board). For the determination of conversion factors, use is    is related to a modi®ed calculation method of the boarding
      made of information in Oskam (1995); de Graaf (1996).          of roofs, being the main outlet for sheet material.
         As to the kind of wood product, it should be noted that        Coniferous wood was, in 1969, by far the main category,
      for kitchen/terrace/balcony doors and for staircases to the    accounting for more than 92% of the total amount of
      ®rst ¯oor, the assumption is made that in the period be-       wood, while in 1982 this share had declined to just over
      fore 1976 the ratio between hardwood and coniferous            50%. In 1996, coniferous wood makes up 48% of all wood
      wood was 20:80 and afterwards 80:20. For staircases to the     products applied in OFD's. In 1969, solid tropical hard-
      ®rst ¯oor, the ratio between hardwood and coniferous           wood had a share of only 3% of the total amount of wood
      wood is estimated at 20:80. For pivotal windows, the as-       used in OFD's. In 1996, 14% of all wood products in OFD's
      sumption is made that until 1975 all of them were made         were made from solid tropical hardwood. For sheet ma-
      from coniferous wood, after 1975, 10% is assumed to be         terial (in 1969 mainly ®breboard, chipboard and plywood)
      made of hardwood. For wooden dormers, the assumption           the share increased from 5% in 1969 to 38% in 1996
      is made that until 1975 all of them were from coniferous       (mainly chipboard, OSB and plywood), with a notably
      wood, after 1975, 80% is assumed to be made of hardwood.       strong increase in chipboard during the seventies.
      For wooden inner door frames the assumption is made               Per OFD, the average wood use dropped from 6.19 m3
      that until 1975 they were all made of coniferous wood,         in 1969 to 3.22 m3 in 1982 and 3.35 m3 in 1996. Excluding
      between 1976 and 1980 the ratio hardwood to coniferous         wooden foundation piles from the analysis in 1969,
Fraanje (1999)  Use of Wood in new Dutch one family Dwellings since 1969
Fraanje (1999)  Use of Wood in new Dutch one family Dwellings since 1969
Fraanje (1999)  Use of Wood in new Dutch one family Dwellings since 1969
Fraanje (1999)  Use of Wood in new Dutch one family Dwellings since 1969
Fraanje (1999)  Use of Wood in new Dutch one family Dwellings since 1969

More Related Content

Viewers also liked

Viewers also liked (11)

Housing in delhi
Housing in delhiHousing in delhi
Housing in delhi
 
TYPES OF HOUSING AND RESIDINTIAL BLOCKS
TYPES OF HOUSING AND RESIDINTIAL BLOCKSTYPES OF HOUSING AND RESIDINTIAL BLOCKS
TYPES OF HOUSING AND RESIDINTIAL BLOCKS
 
type of housing
type of housing type of housing
type of housing
 
Study of housing typologies
Study of housing typologiesStudy of housing typologies
Study of housing typologies
 
Types of houses
Types of housesTypes of houses
Types of houses
 
Type of houses
Type of housesType of houses
Type of houses
 
Housing project
Housing projectHousing project
Housing project
 
Jindal group housing case study
Jindal group housing case studyJindal group housing case study
Jindal group housing case study
 
Types of Houses: PowerPoint
Types of Houses: PowerPointTypes of Houses: PowerPoint
Types of Houses: PowerPoint
 
HOUSING CASE STUDY
HOUSING CASE STUDYHOUSING CASE STUDY
HOUSING CASE STUDY
 
Exterior finish
Exterior finishExterior finish
Exterior finish
 

More from Peter Fraanje

De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118
De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118
De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118Peter Fraanje
 
Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018
Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018
Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018Peter Fraanje
 
Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017
Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017
Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017Peter Fraanje
 
Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317
Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317
Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317Peter Fraanje
 
Renovatie én vervanging 2015
Renovatie én vervanging 2015Renovatie én vervanging 2015
Renovatie én vervanging 2015Peter Fraanje
 
TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615
TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615
TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615Peter Fraanje
 
De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297
De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297
De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297Peter Fraanje
 
Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415
Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415
Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415Peter Fraanje
 
Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014
Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014
Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014Peter Fraanje
 
Een woning is een product met specs 2015
Een woning is een product met specs 2015Een woning is een product met specs 2015
Een woning is een product met specs 2015Peter Fraanje
 
De bouw innoveert poster 160209
De bouw innoveert poster 160209De bouw innoveert poster 160209
De bouw innoveert poster 160209Peter Fraanje
 
Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014
Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014
Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014Peter Fraanje
 
Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010
Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010
Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010Peter Fraanje
 
Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014
Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014
Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014Peter Fraanje
 
Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406
Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406
Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406Peter Fraanje
 
Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988
Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988
Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988Peter Fraanje
 
De Bouw Kleurt Groen
De Bouw Kleurt GroenDe Bouw Kleurt Groen
De Bouw Kleurt GroenPeter Fraanje
 
Thermisch Actief Bouwen
Thermisch Actief BouwenThermisch Actief Bouwen
Thermisch Actief BouwenPeter Fraanje
 

More from Peter Fraanje (20)

Nu is het moment
Nu is het momentNu is het moment
Nu is het moment
 
De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118
De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118
De woningbouw industrialiseert 090118
 
Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018
Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018
Top 40 bouwinnovatie 2018
 
Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017
Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017
Innovaties die de bouw echt veranderen 2017
 
Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317
Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317
Vervangende Nieuwbouw brochure 150317
 
Renovatie én vervanging 2015
Renovatie én vervanging 2015Renovatie én vervanging 2015
Renovatie én vervanging 2015
 
TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615
TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615
TNO rapport Vervangende Nieuwbouw 170615
 
De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297
De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297
De zeven levens van een houten balk Volkskrant 080297
 
Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415
Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415
Voorkeursmaten industrieel bouwen TU/e NVTB 240415
 
Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014
Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014
Hoe wil jij wonen? Bouwformatie 2014
 
Een woning is een product met specs 2015
Een woning is een product met specs 2015Een woning is een product met specs 2015
Een woning is een product met specs 2015
 
De bouw innoveert poster 160209
De bouw innoveert poster 160209De bouw innoveert poster 160209
De bouw innoveert poster 160209
 
Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014
Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014
Renovatie is niet zaligmakend 2014
 
Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010
Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010
Steeds beter en steeds sneller bouwen 2010
 
Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014
Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014
Bij welke woonprovider zit jij? 2014
 
Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406
Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406
Verbouwshop NRC Handelsblad 200406
 
Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988
Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988
Fraanje Peter J. publicaties 2018-1988
 
De Bouw Kleurt Groen
De Bouw Kleurt GroenDe Bouw Kleurt Groen
De Bouw Kleurt Groen
 
Werk in Uitvoering
Werk in UitvoeringWerk in Uitvoering
Werk in Uitvoering
 
Thermisch Actief Bouwen
Thermisch Actief BouwenThermisch Actief Bouwen
Thermisch Actief Bouwen
 

Fraanje (1999) Use of Wood in new Dutch one family Dwellings since 1969

  • 1. Originalarbeiten á Originals Holz als Roh- und Werkstoff 57 (1999) 407±417 Ó Springer-Verlag 1999 Use of wood in new Dutch one family dwellings since 1969 P. J. Fraanje 407 The application of wood for building purposes, especially È È Holzverwendung fur neue hollandische when used in constructions, can be seen as a high quality È Einfamilienhauser seit 1969 application. As wood is, in contrast with most other Die Verwendung des Rohstoffs Holz im Bauwesen, vor al- building materials, a renewable resource, and because the È lem fur Holzkonstruktionen, kann man als Nutzung von environmental impact is relatively low, wood is promoted È hoher Qualitat ansehen. Holz ist im Gegensatz zu den by the Dutch government in the ``20% more wood for the meisten anderen Baumaterialien ein erneuerbarer Rohstoff. building sector'' programme. In this article an overview is Weil die Belastung der Umwelt relativ niedrig ist, wird die given of wood utilization in new one family dwellings È Holzverwendung durch die niederlandische Regierung im (OFD's), built in the past three decades. The wood use per Rahmen des Programms ,,20% mehr Holz im Bau`` gefor- È average OFD dropped from 6.2 m3 in 1969 to 3.4 m3 in È dert. In diesem Beitrag wird die Holzverwendung fur neue 1996. Most of the wood is currently applied to roof and È Einfamilienhauser (EFH) in den letzten dreiûig Jahren window frames. It appears that there is a decrease in the analysiert. Fur ein EFH brauchte man im Jahre 1969 6,2 m3 È total wood use for new OFD's and that the amount of wood Holz, 1996 dagegen nur 3,4 m3. Heute sind Dach und products per average OFD also shows a declining ten- È Fenster die wichtigsten Bauteile fur die Holzverwendung. dency, counterbalanced however by a growing gross ¯oor Es zeigt sich, daû sowohl die gesamte Holzverwendung als area and an increasing number of unsubsidized OFD's. For auch die durchschnittliche pro EFH laufend sinkt, obwohl 1996, a balance of the total amount of wood applied in all È die Brutto-Boden¯ache der EFH gestiegen ist. Dies liegt OFD's with the input and output of wood products is daran, daû der Anteil nicht subventionierter EFH in den presented. The total wood stock in all OFD's is estimated È letzten Jahren zunahm. Fur 1996 wird hier eine Bilanz der to amount 21 ´ 106 tonnes for 1996. This can be seen as a È gesamten Holzmenge fur alle EFH zusammen mit In- und reservoir out of which wood becomes available every year È Output von Holzprodukten prasentiert. Die gesamte through renovation and demolition of OFD's. This sec- Holzmenge in EFH betragt rund 21 ´ 106 t und steht jedes È ondary wood (together with wood waste from newly built È Jahr fur Abbruch und Renovierung von EFH bereit. Das OFD's) can be cascaded, so that the resource wood is È Altholz kann (zusammen mit Holzabfallen von Neubauten) optimally used. The article concludes with options to in- wieder verwendet werden (cascade), so daû der Rohstoff crease the amount of wood used in new OFD's, by ± È Holz optimal genutzt wird. Eine Moglichkeit zur Steigerung amongst others ± increasing the market shares of timber È È der Holzverwendung fur EFH bietet z.B. die Erhohung des frame dwellings, wooden ¯ooring and wooden foundation È È Marktanteils im Holzskelettbau, bei holzernen Fuûboden piles. und Fundamentierungspfahlen.È 1 Introduction The use of timber in dwellings is interesting from an en- vironmental point of view, as wood is, in contrast to most P.J. Fraanje other building materials, a renewable resource with rela- IVAM Environmental Research tively low environmental impact and a positive effect on University of Amsterdam the indoor environment (Schneider 1986; Fraanje et al. P.O. Box 18180, 1990; La¯eur and Fraanje 1997). The utilization of the 1001 ZB Amsterdam, The Netherlands resource of wood in the building sector, especially when I thank Prof. Dr. L. Reijnders of the Interfaculty Department of used for structural purposes, can be seen as a high quality Environmental Sciences (IDES) of the University of Amsterdam application and therefore is a good start for a cascading for his comments. I am grateful to Mr. W.J. de Graaf of PRC strategy (Fraanje 1997; La¯eur and Fraanje 1997). In Bouwcentrum in Bodegraven, Mr. F.G.M. van Swam and Mr. general, the use of wood as a building material is envi- È R.G.A. Bult of Hugli Pollock Read in Utrecht, Mr. A.G. Oskam of ronmentally preferable to application in products with a Damen Consultants in Rotterdam (now working at Centre for shorter life time e.g. pallets, as carbon locked up in wood is Sustainable Building in Utrecht) and Mr. E. Knapper of the Netherlands Central Bureau of Statistics (CBS), for supplying stored for a longer period of time (Fraanje and La¯eur data. The research for this article was ®nancially sponsored by the 1994; Fraanje 1997; Drunen 1997). NWO-research programme for sustainability and environmental Against this background, the Dutch Ministry of Hous- quality. ing, Physical Planning and Environment (VROM) pub-
  • 2. lished a report within the framework of its programme for working in renovation projects. Although being quantita- sustainable building in which an effort to increase the tively less important, this article is limited to newly built application of timber and other wood products in the dwellings. Speci®c data on wood use for renovation of building sector by 20% is formulated (Boonekamp 1995). dwellings are not available as most of the renovation Some important institutions in the building and civil en- activities are not recorded. gineering market, like the Ministry of Public Works and Apart from the new OFD's yearly some 20±30% of all Water Management as well as two umbrella organisations dwellings are new apartments in multi storey blocks. The of housing corporations, have committed themselves to amount of wood products per apartment constitutes a this goal. In 1990, the year of reference of the 20% more fraction of the wood products used for OFD's; in apart- wood programme, 2,150,000 m3 of wood products were ments built after 1968, 2.5 times less wood is applied than used in the whole Dutch building sector (residential, non in an OFD (de Graaf 1996). Therefore, within the section of 408 residential and civil engineering) (Boonekamp 1995). For new dwellings only newly built one family houses (without 1990, the use of sawn wood and sheet material was esti- sheds) (OFD's) are taken into account. mated at an average of 2.8 m3 wood product per new dwelling, totalling 280,000 m3 net and 400,000 m3 gross 3 (excluding wooden foundation piles) for 97,500 new The use of wood in dwellings dwellings built in this year (Boonekamp 1995). In 1980, thebuilt between 1969 and 1982 average still was 3.8 m3 wood product per new dwelling There are unfortunately no detailed data covering the use (Fraanje et al. 1990). of wood in Dutch new OFD's during the 20th century. Within the framework of the 20% more wood pro- Estimates for the 1900±1945 period suggest that roughly gramme, the total amount of wood for the new dwellings 10.4 m3 of timber was applied in new OFD's (Botman has to be enlarged by about 100,000 m3 in the year 2000 1979), whereas only about 8.5 m3 were used in the 1945± (Boonekamp 1995). The object in view is to double the 1970 period (Botman 1979). It should be noted that earlier number of timber frame dwellings and to expand the mentioned estimates refer to analyses of typical single number of wooden carrying inner cavity walls, sloping OFD's; they are not a result of a representative cross-sec- roofs, wooden foundation piles and sheds (Boonekamp tion. Detailed data are available as to OFD's built between 1995). 1969 and 1982. In this paragraph, the application of wood Exact data on wood applications in new dwellings since products in new one-family dwellings in the period be- 1982 in the Netherlands are not available, but experts havetween 1969 and 1982 is analyzed. In the period between the impression that timber products lost ground in the 1969 and 1982, the Ministry of Housing and Physical residential sector (Eisma 1979) (Boonekamp 1995). Wood Planning (VRO) documented the use of building materials products seem to be more and more replaced by other in new dwellings, in the Quantitative Material Documen- materials like concrete and plastics, so the actual trend of tation (QMD). For a period of fourteen years, a unique wood utilization in the building sector tends towards the documentation was developed, however published only opposite direction of the ``20% more wood programme''. partly and at different places (CBS 1976±1984; Eisma 1973± In an effort to trace the actual development of wood use1980 and van derWerff 1980±1985). In 1983, the Dutch and to view this against the background of longer term government decided to stop this documentation, due to trends, it is attempted to determine the average amount of cuts in expenditure. Since then some consultants have wood in new one family dwellings (OFD) in the Nether- emerged offering information per building product or lands over the last three decades. OFD's in the Netherlandselement for a commercial price, but no overview is given, built in this period typically have two ¯oors and an attic.and data are hardly published anymore. The attention is focused on which building elements are For the QMD, the utilized building material according usually made of wood and changes therein. Further, the to 1000±1200 plans for new dwellings was recorded. This total amount of wood in all OFD's in the Netherlands is represented a 1% cross-section of all new dwellings. Such estimated and a wood balance for 1996 is presented. Data recording was possible, as for all new houses authorization on the total wood stock and wood ¯ows are relevant for of the central government on the basis of drawings and determining the cascading potential of timber in the Dutch speci®cations was necessary. It should be noted that as OFD stock. Finally, some options for an increase in wood plans for building were used, the data for 1969 are rep- utilization for OFD's are given. resentative for the dwellings built in 1970, etc. A slight drawback of this method may be that minor differences 2 between plans and the actual dwellings are possible, New one family dwellings especially where ®nishing materials are concerned. Most of the timber used annually in the Netherlands is Based on the primary data of the Quantitative Material applied in the residential sector (NEI 1983; NEHEM 1983; Documentation, Table 1 lists the use of wood in different Fraanje and La¯eur 1994; Boonekamp 1995). Apart from construction elements and building products for one the 400,000 m3 for new dwellings, also about 650,000 m3 family dwellings without shed for the period 1969±1982. (gross) of wood and sheet material (boards, plywood etc) The table is divided into the categories foundation, ¯oor, was used for renovating dwellings in 1990 (Boonekamp facade, ceiling, wall, roof, door and staircase. Not included 1995). Wood is a light weight, strong, ¯exible, easy in the QMD are skirtings, roof laths, thresholds and indoor adaptable and workable (on the building site) building ®nishings, as well as timber used for shuttering and scaf- material which explains its popularity amongst contractors folding. Also excluded from the QMD is the use of wood
  • 3. Table 1. The use of timber and boarding material in different construction elements and building products are given for one family dwellings without shed for the period 1969±1982 È È Tabelle 1. Die Verwendung von Schnittholz und Brettmaterial in verschiedenen Konstruktionselementen und Baustoffen fur Einfamilienhauser ohne Schuppen in den Niederlanden von 1969±1982 Wood use in new one family dwellings (OFD's) without shed 1969±1982 Number of OFD's 85100 91300 98500 112400 109900 100600 88600 93900 84500 81900 73300 68900 78375 63950 Building element year 69 70 71 72 73 74 75 76 77 78 79 80 81 82 Foundation pieces 346800 366400 386300 370600 326600 326500 283600 316100 284000 131200 135000 140800 90700 73400 Wooden foundation piles Floor Floor beams m3 39600 42600 33473 42311 36107 27145 19605 27188 22431 19162 16641 12513 7949 7642 Wooden ¯ooring 1000 m2 1484 1858 1936 2062 1482 808 610 687 464 392 331 274 121 111 Plywood 1000 m2 28 8 17 58 105 48 124 95 151 117 193 Chipboard 1000 m2 14 77 115 138 105 170 200 85 66 44 42 37 Planks of hardwood 1000 m2 31 5 10 4 16 0 0 22 0 0 0 0 0 0 Parquet 1000 m2 0 0 16 12 13 16 20 16 16 11 14 4 3 0 Facade Wooden facade 1000 m2 11 1 8 23 nb 11 13 15 0 15 21 40 24 20 Wooden sheatings OFD's 4400 4400 5900 5600 6300 6900 6300 3700 2800 2000 1700 1000 Coniferous window frames 1000 m2 2712 2790 2746 2958 2641 2123 1478 1178 757 670 751 626 625 435 Hardwood window frames 1000 m2 382 422 730 1126 1332 1277 1433 1949 2033 1819 1269 1157 1238 1020 Parapets wood 1000 m2 138 133 189 342 422 460 364 441 448 399 288 187 173 174 Parapets plywood 1000 m2 28 31 46 72 79 70 73 65 63 62 38 51 49 Parapets ®breboard 1000 m2 2 2 5 2 0 1 1 0 0 0 0 0 0 Wooden parapet for balconies 1000 m2 28 42 25 31 14 24 33 30 29 46 16 28 20 9 Ceiling Fibreboard ceiling 1000 m2 1467 1546 1606 1306 783 391 264 156 93 12 46 7 1 0 Wooden ceiling 1000 m2 234 250 219 356 759 641 535 605 687 289 211 204 103 55 Chipboard ceiling 1000 m2 nb nb 85 67 71 137 77 100 66 35 17 4 10 10 Wall Wooden carrying inner cavity wall 1000 m2 nb 108 90 99 101 221 Non carrying interior wall chipboard 1000 m2 8 13 nb 425 465 374 328 260 197 130 105 112 120 66 Roof Beams for roo®ng m3 80800 86900 82324 100482 102876 86139 76077 96266 88838 79523 61608 57123 53053 37893 Boarding spruce 1000 m2 3371 3215 2303 1880 1410 852 400 258 258 155 118 46 9 8 Boarding plywood 1000 m2 21 7 13 83 112 121 69 211 190 189 304 429 521 528 Boarding woodwool(cement) 1000 m2 239 69 174 156 260 120 60 48 35 45 22 0 1 3 Boarding chipboard* 1000 m2 137 65 119 83 278 6086 4839 4681 4435 3003 Reed ¯ax straw boarding 1000 m2 2324 3278 3648 5598 5993 5782 5485 6850 6217 included in chipboard data Roo®nsulation woodwool 1000 m2 119 76 142 136 63 78 18 0 62 0 0 0 0 0 (Ply)wood for gutters m3 1310 1260 1389 1618 1837 1820 1719 2190 2055 2156 1668 1157 713 575 Wooden dormer pieces 11440 10313 14300 12000 12900 10400 13840 15440 14160 17600 16800 12051 11092 8514 Wooden pivotal window pieces 5170 13630 20680 28012 24252 30174 32430 40138 29422 35881 43150 44556 61100 54219 Doors Front door coniferous pieces 29500 30400 30000 31300 20000 20900 14000 12700 6100 5700 6800 4400 5300 3900 Front door hardwood pieces 40100 37800 46500 52500 59500 50300 48900 58900 59100 64800 54900 48900 53100 44100 Front door plywood pieces 14300 22000 20600 23600 22000 17900 13500 13800 8600 24200 20500 8200 10900 6900 Kitchen, terrace, balconydoor pieces 129000 131000 139700 164500 169100 157000 137600 160700 148100 141000 108400 93200 91700 70700 Outer doors (total) pieces 212900 221200 236800 271900 270600 246100 214000 246100 221900 222900 181700 154700 161000 125600 409
  • 4. for constructions of inner walls and ceilings. Table 1 582 11100 52200 54358 shows dramatic decrease in wooden foundation piles, ¯oor beams, wooden ¯ooring and spruce boarding of roofs. Especially for window frames, inner door frames and front 743 13600 68000 66619 doors, hardwood gained market shares at the cost of co- niferous wood in the period 1969±1982. 663 4 19600 57600 58565 Estimation of the wood use in one-family dwellings (OFD's) in 1996 For the period after 1982, hardly any detailed information 729 22830 59800 62305 410 on wood use in new dwellings is available. There are, however, reports with estimates of wood product market shares (Dielen 1985; de Graaf 1988; Boonekamp 1995; de 822 37410 66200 69615 Graaf 1996). For 1996, there are also informations available È from BuildsightÒ (produced by Hugli Pollock Read, Ut- recht 1997), a software programme for producers in the 847 29000 68500 71825 building market. Buildsight is based on about 1400 inter- views on building sites in combination with statistical information on total area's of roofs, walls etc. of newly 953 36200 74400 79815 built OFD's. As the interviews take place on the building sites, the data gathered are representative for the same year, so in contrast to the QMD, the data for 1996 refer to 904 30600 73500 76000 the OFD's built in 1996. In the following the wood use for 1996 in new OFD's is estimated. In 1996, 61,007 OFD's were realized, of which 1033 41300 86900 83200 36% were detached, while the other 64% of OFD's were built in a row (Buildsight 1997). Table 2 summarizes the wood use in new OFD's in 1996. These elements are the 1158 59700 90200 92800 Table 2. The estimated amount of wood products (in m3) ap- 1230 67800 99300 91100 plied in one family dwellings (without shed) built in 1996 Tabelle 2. Geschatzte Menge an Holzprodukten (m3) in Einfa- È È milienhausern (ohne Schuppen), die 1996 gebaut wurden 1129 67200 93100 81048 Building element m3 (1996) Foundation Wood use in new one family dwellings (OFD's) without shed 1969±1982 1082 71600 80993 76158 Wooden foundation piles 5630 * documentation modi®ed in 1978 (accounts for a sudden increase) Floor Floorbeams 7240 Plywood/OSB ¯ooring 4935 1016 72200 78204 67905 Facade Wooden facade 2800 Coniferous window frames (spruce, pine) 2310 1000 pieces Hardwood window frames 19940 Ceiling no estimation OFD's Wall pieces pieces Carrying inner cavity wall 2860 Roof Beams for roo®ng 58230 Boarding plywood/chipboard/OSB 66175 ** after 1975 data are extrapolated Plywood for gutters 1095 Wooden staircase to ®rst ¯oor Wooden dormers 1315 Wooden staircase to attic** Wooden inner door frames Wooden pivotal windowÃ) 2865 Doors Wooden outer doors 5320 Inner doors of wood 5490 Wooden inner door frames 2040 Table 1. (cont.) Staircases Wooden staircase to the ®rst ¯oor 9900 Staircases Inner doors Wooden staircase to the attic 6000 Total 204.145 * wood for window frames of dormers
  • 5. same as the ones covered by the QMD (Table 1), with the hardwood to coniferous wood was about 90:10 in 1990 but exception of parapets. In order to outline the underlying changed to 85:15 in 1993 (Boonekamp 1994). Probably, data and assumptions for 1996, the speci®c building ele- this has to do with campaigns against the use of tropical ments of OFD's built in 1996 in which wood is applied are hardwood in combination with the emergence of techni- reviewed: cally well-constructed coniferous window frames. 4.1 4.4 Foundation Ceiling Most wooden foundation piles are made of spruce (about Wood does not play a role anymore in this building element 75%), the other 25% are larch and douglas (de Graaf 1988). except as a construction for ®xing gypsum board. This According to (Beukema 1997) 1±5% of all dwellings built in application was not recorded in the QMD. For all 110,000 411 1995 by housing corporations is built on wooden piles. dwellings in 1987 de Graaf (1988) estimated a total wood use Another estimate for 1996 arrives at 1% (Swam 1997). In of over 8,000 m3, mainly used in about 5,500 timber frame this article, the assumption is made that the market share of houses. For 1996, no data are available, and in accordance wooden piles amounts 2% of all OFD's, and that every house with Eisma (1979), no estimate is given in Table 2. is founded on 18 piles. This is less than the percentages of all new dwellings in 1987 (9%), 1990 (7%), and 1995 (8%) 4.5 (see Boonekamp 1994; de Graaf 1988; de Graaf 1996). Wall Wooden load carrying inner cavity walls seem to be quite 4.2 popular in new residential buildings. Their market share Floor was estimated at 20% of all dwellings built by housing Wooden ground ¯oors have completely disappeared from corporations in 1995 (Beukema 1997). According to in- the OFD market (Eisma 1979e) and wooden ®rst ¯oors are formation of Buildsight however, the market share rare in newly built houses. Excluding timber frame amounts to only 5% of the total area load-bearing inner buildings, the market share of wooden ®rst ¯oors in 1990 walls in all new OFD's; this equals 57,000 m2 in 1996 is estimated at 1 to 2% (Boonekamp 1994). This is in ac- (Buildsight 1997). cordance with the share of 1% which can be derived from It is unknown, how much wood is used for inner non- (Beukema 1997). In 1996, there was a total surface of bearing walls. A relatively small amount of timber, mostly 329,000 m2 of wooden ¯oors in all new OFD's (3% of the spruce, is used in combination with gypsumboards total ¯oorarca in OFD's). The amount of beams necessary (Boonekamp 1994). For 1996 there are no data on wood is calculated from the ratio ¯oorarea ¯oorbeams in 1982. use in inner walls. In line with Eisma (1979) and Far out most popular for ¯ooring is sheet material like Boonekamp (1994) this wood use is neglected. oriented strand board, underlayment and plywood. It is assumed that the average thickness of the ¯ooring material 4.6 is 15 mm and that the area of wooden (spruce) ¯ooring is Roof nil (see Table 2). From Buildsight (1997), it can be derived that the total surface of sloping roofs of OFD's in 1996 was 5,882,000 m2. 4.3 With the ratio of wooden beams to roof area, the total Facade amount of beams can be calculated. The 1996 market share Buildsight lists 140,000 m2 of wooden facades, corre- of beams in sloping roofs is estimated at 90%. sponding to a market share for OFD's of 1.5%. Pre-fabri- For boarding of roofs, it is assumed that 75% of the total cated facades often have wooden parapets. Buildsight gives sloping roof area of OFD's is boarded with plywood and no information on parapets; no estimate is given in chipboard, with a thickness of 15 mm. The wood use in Table 2, as the total surface is not known. In the period ¯at roofs in OFD's (504,000 m2 in 1996) is neglected. 1980±1982 about 3,000 m3 of wood were used for parapets In 1996, 32% of all OFD's had a gutter boarded with related to window frames. In line with the data for 1987 wood products (Buildsight 1997), most of it plywood (de and 1990, indicating a market share of 50% for wooden Graaf 1988). Detached houses had a facade of 9.82 in parapets related to window frames in facades for all width, while an OFD in a row had a facade of 5.43 m in dwellings (de Graaf 1988; Boonekamp 1995), the market width (Buildsight 1997). If the assumption is made that the share of wooden parapets for 1996 is estimated at 50%. length of gutters is twice the width of the facade, an esti- Wood is market leader in window frames for new mate can be derived of the wood use for gutters in 1996. OFD's. According to (Buildsight 1997), the total window In 1996, 20.5% of all new OFD's had a dormer. The frame surface in facades of OFD's built in 1996 was market share of wood is put at 50% (see Table 2). This 1,246,000 m2, 92% of which was wood. The total market means an increase compared with the estimated 35% shares of wood for window frames in all dwellings in 1982, market share for 1990, in line with expert opinion 1987, 1990, and 1995 were estimated at 95, 91, 85, and 90%, (Boonekamp 1994). respectively (de Graaf 1988; Boonekamp 1994; Boonekamp 1995). Of the wooden frames applied in OFD's in 1996, 4.7 13% is coniferous and 87% hardwood according to Doors Buildsight (see Table 2). This ratio is roughly in line with In 1996, 232,000 outer doors were used for all new OFD's estimates of Boonekamp (1995) who states that the ratio of (Buildsight 1997). It is estimated that of this total number
  • 6. there were 25,000 doors for sheds and 10,000 doors to wood is put at 30:70 and for 1981 and 1982 70:30 and for garages. Furthermore it is assumed that 90% of all outer 1996 at 75:25. The above mentioned estimates are in line doors of OFD's are made of wood and that the ratio with the data reported by van der Werff (1984b) and es- hardwood to coniferous wood is 85:15. In 1987, of wooden timates by de Graaf (1988); Boonekamp (1994) and outer doors in all dwellings, hardwood had a share of 81% Boonekamp (1995). and coniferous wood of 9%. Merbau was by far the most Table 3 summarizes the total amount of wood products popular wood used for hardwood outer doors, followed by applied in OFD's built in the period 1969±1982 and in meranti (de Graaf 1988). 1996, as well as the calculated amount per OFD for these Most inner doors are made of spruce in combination years. For a good interpretation of the data derived from with plywood or chipboard. In 1996, the total amount of the QMD, it is important to realise that they are an average inner doors was 610,000 (Buildsight 1996). Using a con- from three categories of one-family dwellings, namely 412 version factor, the total amount of wood used for inner Housing Act (HA) houses, Premium houses (P) and non- doors can be estimated. The total area of wooden inner subsidized houses. The ®rst two categories are more (HA) door frames in 1996 was 1,541,000 m2; this equals a market or less (P) subsidized by the government. It should be share of wood of 13% (Buildsight 1997). This percentage is noted that in the non-subsidized category, twice or even lower than the market share for wood of 20% of all thrice as much timber is applied as in Housing Act houses dwellings built in 1995 by housing corporations (Beukema (Eisma 1979) (NEI 1983). For this reason, the share of the 1997) but higher than the estimates for 1987 (de Graaf non-subsidized category within the OFD sector is also 1988) and 1990 (Boonekamp 1994): 10% and 5±10%, re- given in Table 3. spectively. Of the wooden inner door frames used in OFD's It should also be noted that for the period of 1969±1982, in 1996, 86% were made from hardwood, 14% of conifer- the wood use refers to OFD's built in 1970±1983. The ous wood (Buildsight 1997). In 1982, still 29% of the values for 1996 are representative for the OFD's built in the wooden inner door frames in all dwellings were made of same year. coniferous wood and 71% of hardwood (van der Werff It can be learnt from Table 3 that from 1969 to 1982, the 1984b), so between 1982 and 1996 coniferous wood lost total amount of wood products used in all OFD's is almost market shares at the cost of (mostly tropical) hardwood. constantly declining, the years 1976 and 1977 being the exception to the rule. In this period, a relative great vari- 4.8 ation in roofs was a fashion among architects, which may Staircases partly explain the higher average (van der Werff 1980). About 115,000 staircases were built into all new OFD's in Furthermore, in 1976±1979 the share of unsubsidized 1996 (Buildsight 1997). It is assumed that they are all made houses was relatively high, leading to a higher volume of from wood. It can be derived from de Graaf (1988) that in wood used in OFD's. In 1969, over half a million m3 wood 1987, of wooden staircases in all dwellings, hardwood had products were used in OFD's, while in 1982 and 1996 only a market share of 72% and coniferous wood of 18%. 200,000 m3 wood products were applied. In 1972, the year In Table 2, the estimates of the wood use per building with the highest number of OFD's planned, the total wood element in 1996 in new OFD's are given. To determine the use was also the highest of the 69±82 period. The total use amount of m3 per application, use is made of conversion of products of coniferous wood (mainly spruce) declined factors in line with de Graaf (1996) and Oskam (1995). dramatically in the period 1969±1982. For 1996, the total use of coniferous wood is estimated less than in 1982. The 5 application of hardwood reached its peak in 1976 and 1977 Total wood use in new OFD's and maintained a yearly level of about 30,000 m3. As far as The data from Table 1 can be converted into m3 wood sheet material (®bre/chip boards, plywood) is concerned, products and accumulated to coniferous wood, hardwood it should be noted that, due to changes in the documen- and sheet material (chipboard, plywood, soft- and hard- tation, a strange jump occurs in the data around 1978. This board). For the determination of conversion factors, use is is related to a modi®ed calculation method of the boarding made of information in Oskam (1995); de Graaf (1996). of roofs, being the main outlet for sheet material. As to the kind of wood product, it should be noted that Coniferous wood was, in 1969, by far the main category, for kitchen/terrace/balcony doors and for staircases to the accounting for more than 92% of the total amount of ®rst ¯oor, the assumption is made that in the period be- wood, while in 1982 this share had declined to just over fore 1976 the ratio between hardwood and coniferous 50%. In 1996, coniferous wood makes up 48% of all wood wood was 20:80 and afterwards 80:20. For staircases to the products applied in OFD's. In 1969, solid tropical hard- ®rst ¯oor, the ratio between hardwood and coniferous wood had a share of only 3% of the total amount of wood wood is estimated at 20:80. For pivotal windows, the as- used in OFD's. In 1996, 14% of all wood products in OFD's sumption is made that until 1975 all of them were made were made from solid tropical hardwood. For sheet ma- from coniferous wood, after 1975, 10% is assumed to be terial (in 1969 mainly ®breboard, chipboard and plywood) made of hardwood. For wooden dormers, the assumption the share increased from 5% in 1969 to 38% in 1996 is made that until 1975 all of them were from coniferous (mainly chipboard, OSB and plywood), with a notably wood, after 1975, 80% is assumed to be made of hardwood. strong increase in chipboard during the seventies. For wooden inner door frames the assumption is made Per OFD, the average wood use dropped from 6.19 m3 that until 1975 they were all made of coniferous wood, in 1969 to 3.22 m3 in 1982 and 3.35 m3 in 1996. Excluding between 1976 and 1980 the ratio hardwood to coniferous wooden foundation piles from the analysis in 1969,