SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 9
Download to read offline
HetNet Orchestration
The fourth dimension for
wireless capacity growth
DAVID CHAMBERS
A White Paper sponsored by
Parallel Wireless
©ThinkSmallCell September 2015
Have we seen the end of the
10 year“Generation Gap”?
In the past, we’ve seen a regular 10 year technology refresh with 2G, 3G and 4G each being added
incrementally. Some believe that 5G will follow in the same cycle, although at the moment it remains
vague and unpredictable. Others point out that the benefits of each new generation – mainly
increasing spectral efficiency and releasing new spectrum – are reaching their full potential. This
has been a key argument for small cell deployment, which increases capacity through frequency reuse
without the need for additional spectrum or spectral efficiencies.
This ten-year cycle hides many complex factors placing demands on network planners
and managers, including but not limited to:
•	 Spectrum: Acquisition, trading and re-farming
•	 Radio interfaces: 2G/3G/4G/Wi-Fi
•	 Backhaul: Wired and many wireless alternatives
•	 RAN architecture: Integrated basestations vs C-RAN; Macro/Micro/Small
•	 Vendor selection: Single solution vs best of class ecosystem
•	 Ownership: Entirely owned vs RAN share/roaming
A sensible course of action is to enable the network to become agile, able to adapt and cope with
forthcoming technical and commercial challenges. At any time, the network should be delivering
the best performance from all available resources. Nirvana for an operator isn’t deploying some radical
new wireless interface, it’s ensuring that the complex mix of spectrum, radio technologies, backhaul
and other assets are operating coherently to best effect. It’s essential to have the tools, processes and
network architecture in place to take full advantage of whatever lies ahead.
This ten-year cycle hides many complex factors placing demands on network planners
and managers, including but not limited to:
•	 Spectrum: Acquisition, trading and re-farming
•	 Radio interfaces: 2G/3G/4G/Wi-Fi
•	 Backhaul: Wired and many wireless alternatives
•	 RAN architecture: Integrated basestations vs C-RAN; Macro/Micro/Small
•	 Vendor selection: Single solution vs best of class ecosystem
•	 Ownership: Entirely owned vs RAN share/roaming
A sensible course of action is to enable the network to become agile, able to adapt and cope with
forthcoming technical and commercial challenges. At any time, the network should be delivering
the best performance from all available resources. Nirvana for an operator isn’t deploying some radical
new wireless interface, it’s ensuring that the complex mix of spectrum, radio technologies, backhaul
and other assets are operating coherently to best effect. It’s essential to have the tools, processes and
network architecture in place to take full advantage of whatever lies ahead.
It’s essential to have the tools, processes
and network architecture in place to take
full advantage of whatever lies ahead.”
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 2
©ThinkSmallCell 2015
The four methods of wireless densification
There are commonly thought to be three ways to densify wireless traffic capacity:
1.	More spectrum (expensive, limited)
2.	More spectrally efficiency (e.g. LTE rather than 2G)
3.	More spatial reuse (i.e. small cells)
But there is also a fourth aspect which can deliver significant additional benefit
4. Orchestration and tighter control. (e.g. SON (Self Organising Networks),
traffic steering/shaping across and between all available wireless resources)
Network operators have already invested heavily to prepare
themselves for the onslaught of new spectrum and new radio
generations.
This has been a key factor driving replacement of outdated macrocells with “Single RAN” basestation
equipment that supports all generations of radio interface. These specifically address (1) and (2) above.
What’s needed next is investment in tools and equipment that provides similar flexibility for (3) and (4),
scaling to cope with an influx of small cells and introducing real-time management and co-ordination
across all available wireless technologies, both cellular and Wi-Fi.
Co-ordination between radio technologies is important, perhaps even more so than C-RAN which
tends to focus on a single technology, primarily LTE. Super-optimising a single RF technology isn’t
enough, especially if that would rely on a major hardware upgrade to smartphones as required by more
advanced LTE features such as CoMP (Co-ordinated Multi-Path) or LAA.
We have seen the industry adopt LTE quickly (422 commercially LTE networks to date), invest heavily in
new spectrum (e.g. $41 Billion in the US, $18 Billion in India), and allocate substantial funds for small cell
deployment (e.g. Verizon allocates $500 million). However, it’s less visibly obvious that operators are as
well prepared for HetNet Orchestration as they should be.
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 3
©ThinkSmallCell 2015
Radio technology evolution?
5G, should it ever take form, can’t just be about delivering yet another air interface and associated
infrastructure. It must satisfy needs which are otherwise unmet. A not unreasonable medium term
goal may be that ultimately almost everything cellular uses some form of LTE or Wi-Fi. This is likely
to take very long time for many reasons:
•	 Both LTE and Wi-Fi standards continue to evolve and add new capabilities (e.g. LTE Direct,
Wi-Gig etc.)
•	 The majority of wireless data sent today is and will remain Wi-Fi. Most Wi-Fi use will be through
private networks (residential), which also needs to be integrated and evolve to provide seamless
handoff to/from cellular. It’s just not feasible for either cellular or Wi-Fi to dominate and replace
the other.
•	 Profitable inbound roamers will continue to need to be supported, regardless of the technology and/
or band plan of their devices
•	 Much of the world can’t afford to adopt it very quickly. (LTE subscribers are only 10% of global total.
The majority of users remain 2G and will do until 3G takes over around 2019. Even by 2020 there will
still be more 2G users than 4G worldwide.)
•	 LowpowerM2Mdevicescan’tsupporttoday’sLTE,sowilleitherneedLTE-Mvariantoruseoneofmany
other competing wireless standards. It’s not entirely clear how much will bypass or be integrated into
cellular networks
•	 5G is still vague and unknown. It’s unlikely to be a single ubiquitous new radio interface and
perhaps more about the synergy of interworking between newer versions of LTE and Wi-Fi to
it all works in a simplified, seamless and efficient way.
So we will need to make best use of all existing channels need to support 3G, LTE and Wi-Fi for
some years. This needs flexibility to adapt, deploy, refarm any and all of these radio technologies.
It also requires the ability to manage and optimize across all resources to achieve the best
system performance.
So we will need to make best use
of all existing channels need to
support 3G, LTE and Wi-Fi for
some years. This needs flexibility
to adapt, deploy, refarm any and
all of these radio technologies.”
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 4
©ThinkSmallCell 2015
Commercial evolution
Different parts of the world operate on different commercial basis. In some countries, RAN sharing is
endemic – operators may own very little of the network equipment themselves. At the other extreme,
eventowersharingisrare.Wecanexpectincreasingcommercialpressuretoreducecostsandencourage
RAN share especially in areas of poor coverage.
Those networks that are technically better positioned and prepared for that eventuality will have
an advantage. They will be ready to cope with MNVOs who may want the option to deploy some
of their own in-building small cells and/or carrier grade Wi-Fi. They can accommodate whatever
commercial arrangements for network sharing might arise, including support for Public Safety
and private networks.
Some networks have chosen a single solution supplier, setting SLAs for service quality and
outsourcing both equipment and field activities. Often contracts are awarded on a regional/
geographic basis to different vendors in order to encourage competition. We have also seen
different vendors being introduced as an underlay (urban microcell/small cell) or in-building (enterprise
and/or residential).
This ability to be able to integrate and use other vendor RAN equipment adds enormous
commercial advantage. Open standard interfaces rather than proprietary ones have proven to
be very successful, with it being common to award contracts to different suppliers for core and
RAN equipment. Using a multi-vendor HetNet gateway expands choice. It empowers procurement
to be able to negotiate better pricing for equipment and allows flexibility to introduce new
products tailored toward specific markets such as Enterprise buildings.
Adding each new vendor increases complexity and support costs, so typically a compelling case
has to be made. Compliance with standards is hugely beneficial. Sometimes the subtleties of
technical features/choice are not fully appreciated by procurement departments focused only
on the cost of the box.
Using a multi-vendor HetNet gateway expands choice. It
empowers procurement to be able to negotiate better pricing
for equipment and allows flexibility to introduce new products
tailored toward specific markets such as Enterprise buildings.”
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 5
©ThinkSmallCell 2015
App evolution
Traffic is growing exponentially in volume, diversity and numbers of connected devices. The headline
growth figure relates to video, highlighted by Netflix consuming 34.5% of all US fixed internet traffic
in the evening. But few people walk around with video running on their devices, although they might
be on a call, streaming audio or downloading app/social media updates. Some think that augmented
reality may change that; the honest answer is “we just don’t know”. Perhaps the more likely answer is
high value paid traffic growth will come from something quite different, unrelated and unexpected.
The Internet ofThings (IoT) is expected to dramatically increase the number of connected device, but it’s
difficult to predict what percentage would be served by a cellular network operator. Usage would likely
impact signalling load than traffic volume and about resilience rather than speed of connection. This
includes avoiding heavy signalling loads on the core network, a lesson learnt early in LTE deployment
by SK Telecom who installed one of the first LTE gateways to offload and optimise that.
Cisco VNI and other reports predict that Wi-Fi offload will continue to grow, helped further by new
high speed Wi-Gig launching in 2017. This technology should be ideal for fast data synchronisation
if used well.
The main point is that predicting today’s traffic quantity and profile would have been difficult even
5 years ago, so we can’t be exactly sure of what’s coming next except it will be big. Agility, flexibility
and scalability of the network architecture will be key to responding quickly to handle future demand.
Managing this wide variety of traffic types using techniques such as traffic shaping, steering and
caching will grow in importance despite concerns about Internet neutrality.
Managing this wide variety of traffic
types using techniques such as
traffic shaping, steering and caching
will grow in importance despite
concerns about Internet neutrality.”
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 6
©ThinkSmallCell 2015
Today RAN expansion activity
Undoubtedly, today’s priority for network operators has been about maximising the return from
existing macrocell sites. Relatively few new sites are being acquired but many are being expanded
and upgraded. Many operators already have flexible basestations which can be remotely configured
between 2G/3G/LTE to refarm frequency bands. Most can achieve that with equipment swaps.
Investment has switched to LTE, increasing the wide area coverage footprint by using the lower 700MHz
frequency bands. This can be counter productive where there isn’t matching 3G coverage or VoLTE.
Europe has seen extensive refarming of the 900MHz band from 2G to 3G which should help, but that
option isn’t open to all operators.
Capacity investment in LTE varies widely between countries. Developed countries where users have LTE
smartphones would prioritise LTE, but may find that only the latest devices can access some frequency
bands, delaying the benefit of the investment. Sri Lanka has 4G but continues to build up 3G capacity
because that’s what their customers are equipped to use. North America has moved quickly with 4G
because Verizon/Sprint want to retire expensive/outdated CDMA systems, forcing competitors to keep
up. Australia has been slower with 4G because it originally deployed 3G at 700MHz which has very
good coverage range.
Sector splitting at high traffic sites remains popular where antenna can be mounted. Six sector
sites are not uncommon in central business districts, with all available frequencies being deployed
from 700MHz through 2.6GHz. Backhaul links have been upgraded to suit, with rates up to 1Gbps
not unusual.
Additionalspectrumandsiteexpansionhasitslimits,andwecanseemanyoperatorsactivelyconducting
small cell pilots, identifying the processes and methods for site acquisition, rapid configuration and
suitable backhaul methods. The industry is positioning and preparing itself for the inevitable need to
a small cell layer, even if it has been delayed longer than expected by the macrocell and spectrum
expansion listed above.
We’ve also seen a wide variety in approach to Wi-Fi. Insisting that all smartphones are Wi-Fi capable
has taken huge pressure off cellular networks, offloading the majority of wireless data to private, often
residential, Wi-Fi access points. Some operators have taken a more proactive approach, setting up
roaming agreements with public Wi-Fi networks and/or deploying their own Carrier Wi-Fi points. This
is rarely co-ordinated with the RAN planning departments and more often dealt with as a commercial
roamingtransaction.AlthoughmanysmallcellproductshaveWi-Ficapabilities,theseareoftendisabled
for organisational or commercial rather than technical reasons.
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 7
©ThinkSmallCell 2015
Future RAN expansion strategy
With a mix of cellular and Wi-Fi radio technologies to manage, a co-ordinated HetNet approach is
required.Thesecan’tbeoptimisedoroperatedpurelyasseparatesilos.Toolswillbeneededtodetermine
where, when and how best to invest in new capacity. Performance management reports can be used
to identify hotspots/notspots, but wider consideration is needed to determine which frequency band
and radio technology will provide the best return. This may include commercial options including RAN
sharing and roaming, with tighter integration with both trusted (i.e. Carrier deployed) and untrusted
(i.e. 3rd party) Wi-Fi.
An ability to expand the network efficiently and rapidly using any
current or future radio technologies will be essential. This includes
integrating new products and/or equipment vendors whether
directly or indirectly connected.
Once installed, active management of traffic and usage across and between these different radio
technologies becomes very important. It’s not enough to optimise performance of any individual radio
interface, traffic flow and steering in as close to real-time as practicable delivers great benefits. We can
expect to see greater use of SON, data caching and other techniques.
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 8
©ThinkSmallCell 2015
Conclusion
Perhaps greatest challenge for today’s CTO is not to predict exactly which RF interface, architecture,
App or technology will make the greatest demands on their network in the future. Instead, it’s about
shaping their organisation and operation to be in the best position to move quickly and adapt efficiently
when the industry does finally make its choice.
While we’ve seen new frequencies and capabilities enabled by LTE take up the majority of investment in
recent years, we can expect to see more emphasis on network densification through small cells, C-RAN
and Wi-Fi in the near future. Commercial disruption through increased RAN sharing, roaming and new
vendor equipment is also likely if unpredictable.
The best-positioned organisations will be those who put in place the capabilities to be agile, adaptable
to meet future unknown and unpredictable market demands. HetNet Orchestration provides the
flexibility to make the most of all the technologies brought to bear. Capabilities to rapidly deploy,
integrate, manage and optimise networks will be critical, and a holistic approach which deals with all
technologies in a co-ordinated manner will have a tremendous advantage.
The best-positioned organisations will be those who put in
place the capabilities to be agile, adaptable to meet future
unknown and unpredictable market demands.”
HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 9
©ThinkSmallCell 2015

More Related Content

What's hot

Huawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SON
Huawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SONHuawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SON
Huawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SONSmall Cell Forum
 
Small cell Evolution final
Small cell Evolution finalSmall cell Evolution final
Small cell Evolution finalXian Sun-Ilmonen
 
Haig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business Case
Haig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business CaseHaig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business Case
Haig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business CaseSmall Cell Forum
 
Medium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case Studies
Medium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case StudiesMedium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case Studies
Medium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case StudiesSmall Cell Forum
 
The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile
The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile
The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile Small Cell Forum
 
Neutral Host, Small Networks
Neutral Host, Small NetworksNeutral Host, Small Networks
Neutral Host, Small NetworksSmall Cell Forum
 
5G Evolution: VP Access Architecture and Device
5G Evolution:  VP Access Architecture and Device5G Evolution:  VP Access Architecture and Device
5G Evolution: VP Access Architecture and DeviceSmall Cell Forum
 
Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016
Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016
Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016Parallel Wireless, Inc.
 
Starship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered Before
Starship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered BeforeStarship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered Before
Starship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered BeforeSmall Cell Forum
 
Virtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RAN
Virtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RANVirtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RAN
Virtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RANSmall Cell Forum
 
Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016
Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016
Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016Small Cell Forum
 
Unleash the cloud + 5 g + ai era
Unleash the cloud + 5 g + ai eraUnleash the cloud + 5 g + ai era
Unleash the cloud + 5 g + ai eramyehuman
 
Small Cells Win the Super Bowl
Small Cells Win the Super BowlSmall Cells Win the Super Bowl
Small Cells Win the Super BowlSmall Cell Forum
 
Radisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network Efficiency
Radisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network EfficiencyRadisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network Efficiency
Radisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network EfficiencySmall Cell Forum
 
Parallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case Study
Parallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case StudyParallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case Study
Parallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case StudySmall Cell Forum
 
Parallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data Sheet
Parallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data SheetParallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data Sheet
Parallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data SheetParallel Wireless, Inc.
 
Huawei - Making the World Smaller with Small Cell
Huawei  - Making the World Smaller with Small CellHuawei  - Making the World Smaller with Small Cell
Huawei - Making the World Smaller with Small CellSmall Cell Forum
 
Rural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and Tomorrow
Rural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and TomorrowRural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and Tomorrow
Rural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and TomorrowSmall Cell Forum
 

What's hot (20)

Huawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SON
Huawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SONHuawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SON
Huawei: Extending MBB with HetNet and SON
 
Small cell Evolution final
Small cell Evolution finalSmall cell Evolution final
Small cell Evolution final
 
Haig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business Case
Haig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business CaseHaig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business Case
Haig Sarkissian: The Economic Impact of Femtocells on the 4G LTE Business Case
 
Medium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case Studies
Medium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case StudiesMedium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case Studies
Medium-Large Enterprise Small Cell Deployment Case Studies
 
The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile
The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile
The role of licence exempt spectrum in mobile
 
Neutral Host, Small Networks
Neutral Host, Small NetworksNeutral Host, Small Networks
Neutral Host, Small Networks
 
5G Evolution: VP Access Architecture and Device
5G Evolution:  VP Access Architecture and Device5G Evolution:  VP Access Architecture and Device
5G Evolution: VP Access Architecture and Device
 
Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016
Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016
Parallel Wireless Band 14 Case Studies at IWCE 2016
 
Starship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered Before
Starship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered BeforeStarship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered Before
Starship (Medium) Enterprise, To Boldly Cover Where No One Has Covered Before
 
Virtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RAN
Virtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RANVirtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RAN
Virtualized platform for in-premises enterprise RAN
 
Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016
Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016
Small Cell Forum State of the Market Workshop 2016
 
Unleash the cloud + 5 g + ai era
Unleash the cloud + 5 g + ai eraUnleash the cloud + 5 g + ai era
Unleash the cloud + 5 g + ai era
 
Small Cells Win the Super Bowl
Small Cells Win the Super BowlSmall Cells Win the Super Bowl
Small Cells Win the Super Bowl
 
Radisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network Efficiency
Radisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network EfficiencyRadisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network Efficiency
Radisys - Cloud-RAN: Improving Mobile Operators’ Network Efficiency
 
Small cell 2020
Small cell 2020Small cell 2020
Small cell 2020
 
Parallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case Study
Parallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case StudyParallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case Study
Parallel Wireless: Rural HetNet Case Study
 
Parallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data Sheet
Parallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data SheetParallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data Sheet
Parallel Wireless In-Vehicle CWS-210 Data Sheet
 
Huawei - Making the World Smaller with Small Cell
Huawei  - Making the World Smaller with Small CellHuawei  - Making the World Smaller with Small Cell
Huawei - Making the World Smaller with Small Cell
 
Rural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and Tomorrow
Rural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and TomorrowRural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and Tomorrow
Rural 5G Small Cells: Connecting the Unconnected Today and Tomorrow
 
Node-H SON
Node-H SONNode-H SON
Node-H SON
 

Viewers also liked

Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016
Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016
Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016David Chambers
 
Antenna Evolution: From 4G to 5G
Antenna Evolution: From 4G to 5GAntenna Evolution: From 4G to 5G
Antenna Evolution: From 4G to 5GKarva Carbi
 
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment Stories
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment StoriesParallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment Stories
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment StoriesParallel Wireless, Inc.
 
An Introduction to Macrocells & Small Cells
An Introduction to Macrocells & Small CellsAn Introduction to Macrocells & Small Cells
An Introduction to Macrocells & Small Cells3G4G
 
Urban Case Studies Invisible Sites: Ericsson
Urban Case Studies Invisible Sites: EricssonUrban Case Studies Invisible Sites: Ericsson
Urban Case Studies Invisible Sites: EricssonSmall Cell Forum
 

Viewers also liked (6)

Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016
Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016
Thinksmallcell Analyst Spotlight Webinar Jan 2016
 
Vehicular CrowdCell
Vehicular CrowdCellVehicular CrowdCell
Vehicular CrowdCell
 
Antenna Evolution: From 4G to 5G
Antenna Evolution: From 4G to 5GAntenna Evolution: From 4G to 5G
Antenna Evolution: From 4G to 5G
 
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment Stories
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment StoriesParallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment Stories
Parallel Wireless Public Safety LTE Deployment Stories
 
An Introduction to Macrocells & Small Cells
An Introduction to Macrocells & Small CellsAn Introduction to Macrocells & Small Cells
An Introduction to Macrocells & Small Cells
 
Urban Case Studies Invisible Sites: Ericsson
Urban Case Studies Invisible Sites: EricssonUrban Case Studies Invisible Sites: Ericsson
Urban Case Studies Invisible Sites: Ericsson
 

Similar to Fourth Dimension RAN white paper - ThinkSmallCell

The path to 5G mobile networks
The path to 5G mobile networksThe path to 5G mobile networks
The path to 5G mobile networksBearingPoint
 
Nokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdf
Nokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdfNokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdf
Nokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdfsehat maruli
 
Challenges&opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2
Challenges&opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2Challenges&opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2
Challenges&opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2frankjoh
 
Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’
Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’
Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’eXplanoTech
 
Overview Of Internet And Telecom Services Providers
Overview Of Internet And Telecom Services ProvidersOverview Of Internet And Telecom Services Providers
Overview Of Internet And Telecom Services ProvidersMeghan Howard
 
5G Challenges and Opportunities
5G Challenges and Opportunities5G Challenges and Opportunities
5G Challenges and OpportunitiesAliMohamedAhmed2
 
The road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-cost
The road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-costThe road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-cost
The road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-costAurelio Machado
 
5g-a-network-transformation-imperative
5g-a-network-transformation-imperative5g-a-network-transformation-imperative
5g-a-network-transformation-imperativeAmar Ravi
 
Whitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G Era
Whitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G EraWhitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G Era
Whitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G EraST Engineering iDirect
 
LTE_Inbuilding_SWP
LTE_Inbuilding_SWPLTE_Inbuilding_SWP
LTE_Inbuilding_SWPBen O'Nolan
 
MOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4G
MOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4GMOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4G
MOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4GNishmi Suresh
 
4 g lte as wan solution white paper
4 g lte as wan solution white paper4 g lte as wan solution white paper
4 g lte as wan solution white paperMark Zumwalt
 
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.frankjoh
 
Mobility Management For Next Generation Networks
Mobility Management For Next Generation NetworksMobility Management For Next Generation Networks
Mobility Management For Next Generation NetworksGreen Packet
 

Similar to Fourth Dimension RAN white paper - ThinkSmallCell (20)

The path to 5G mobile networks
The path to 5G mobile networksThe path to 5G mobile networks
The path to 5G mobile networks
 
Nokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdf
Nokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdfNokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdf
Nokia_single_ran_advanced_evolution_whit.pdf
 
Challenges&opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2
Challenges&opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2Challenges&opportunities 2017   onwards v5.2
Challenges&opportunities 2017 onwards v5.2
 
Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’
Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’
Operators strategy for supporting the ‘Mobile Data Explosion’
 
Wi-Fi -3GPP LTE in HetNets
Wi-Fi -3GPP LTE in HetNetsWi-Fi -3GPP LTE in HetNets
Wi-Fi -3GPP LTE in HetNets
 
Wi fi - 3 gpp hetnet - internal v.2a
Wi fi - 3 gpp hetnet -  internal v.2aWi fi - 3 gpp hetnet -  internal v.2a
Wi fi - 3 gpp hetnet - internal v.2a
 
Overview Of Internet And Telecom Services Providers
Overview Of Internet And Telecom Services ProvidersOverview Of Internet And Telecom Services Providers
Overview Of Internet And Telecom Services Providers
 
5G Challenges and Opportunities
5G Challenges and Opportunities5G Challenges and Opportunities
5G Challenges and Opportunities
 
The road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-cost
The road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-costThe road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-cost
The road-to-5 g-the-inevitable-growth-of-infrastructure-cost
 
LTE Vision 2020
LTE Vision 2020LTE Vision 2020
LTE Vision 2020
 
Report on 4 g
Report on 4 gReport on 4 g
Report on 4 g
 
5g-a-network-transformation-imperative
5g-a-network-transformation-imperative5g-a-network-transformation-imperative
5g-a-network-transformation-imperative
 
5G design concepts
5G design concepts5G design concepts
5G design concepts
 
Whitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G Era
Whitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G EraWhitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G Era
Whitepaper : Breaking Ground In The 5G Era
 
LTE_Inbuilding_SWP
LTE_Inbuilding_SWPLTE_Inbuilding_SWP
LTE_Inbuilding_SWP
 
MOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4G
MOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4GMOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4G
MOBILE VIRTUAL NETWORK OPERATOR STRATEGY FOR MIGRATION TOWARDS 4G
 
4 g lte as wan solution white paper
4 g lte as wan solution white paper4 g lte as wan solution white paper
4 g lte as wan solution white paper
 
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.Challenges opportunities 2017   onwards v5.0.
Challenges opportunities 2017 onwards v5.0.
 
Mobility Management For Next Generation Networks
Mobility Management For Next Generation NetworksMobility Management For Next Generation Networks
Mobility Management For Next Generation Networks
 
R&s 10 juin 2015 sequans ambroise
R&s 10 juin 2015 sequans ambroiseR&s 10 juin 2015 sequans ambroise
R&s 10 juin 2015 sequans ambroise
 

More from Parallel Wireless, Inc.

Parallel Wireless Urban Solution - Media
Parallel Wireless Urban Solution - MediaParallel Wireless Urban Solution - Media
Parallel Wireless Urban Solution - MediaParallel Wireless, Inc.
 
Parallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass Giveaway
Parallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass GiveawayParallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass Giveaway
Parallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass GiveawayParallel Wireless, Inc.
 
Parallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution Overview
Parallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution OverviewParallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution Overview
Parallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution OverviewParallel Wireless, Inc.
 
EU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel Wireless
EU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel WirelessEU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel Wireless
EU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel WirelessParallel Wireless, Inc.
 
Parallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rules
Parallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rulesParallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rules
Parallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rulesParallel Wireless, Inc.
 

More from Parallel Wireless, Inc. (8)

Parallel Wireless Urban Solution - Media
Parallel Wireless Urban Solution - MediaParallel Wireless Urban Solution - Media
Parallel Wireless Urban Solution - Media
 
Parallel Wireless Webinar: 5G at #MWC19
Parallel Wireless Webinar: 5G at #MWC19Parallel Wireless Webinar: 5G at #MWC19
Parallel Wireless Webinar: 5G at #MWC19
 
Parallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass Giveaway
Parallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass GiveawayParallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass Giveaway
Parallel Wireless terms and conditions, MWC 2019 Exhibition Pass Giveaway
 
Parallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution Overview
Parallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution OverviewParallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution Overview
Parallel Wireless Rural Coverage Solution Overview
 
EU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel Wireless
EU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel WirelessEU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel Wireless
EU Declaration of Conformity - Parallel Wireless
 
Parallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rules
Parallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rulesParallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rules
Parallel Wireless Band 14 In A Box contest rules
 
Terms and Conditions
Terms and ConditionsTerms and Conditions
Terms and Conditions
 
Privacy Policy
Privacy PolicyPrivacy Policy
Privacy Policy
 

Recently uploaded

Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1
Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1
Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1DianaGray10
 
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )Brian Pichman
 
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...DianaGray10
 
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding TeamAdam Moalla
 
Igniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration Workflows
Igniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration WorkflowsIgniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration Workflows
Igniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration WorkflowsSafe Software
 
Designing A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URLDesigning A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URLRuncy Oommen
 
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarAI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarPrecisely
 
NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 Workshop
NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 WorkshopNIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 Workshop
NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 WorkshopBachir Benyammi
 
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?IES VE
 
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystemBird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystemAsko Soukka
 
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptxCybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptxGDSC PJATK
 
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation DevelopersUiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation DevelopersUiPathCommunity
 
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXVoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXTarek Kalaji
 
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesAI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesMd Hossain Ali
 
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and HazardsComputer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and HazardsSeth Reyes
 
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdfNanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdfPedro Manuel
 
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureOpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureEric D. Schabell
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IES VE
 
Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)
Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)
Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)Commit University
 
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDEADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDELiveplex
 

Recently uploaded (20)

Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1
Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1
Secure your environment with UiPath and CyberArk technologies - Session 1
 
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
Building Your Own AI Instance (TBLC AI )
 
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
Connector Corner: Extending LLM automation use cases with UiPath GenAI connec...
 
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
9 Steps For Building Winning Founding Team
 
Igniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration Workflows
Igniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration WorkflowsIgniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration Workflows
Igniting Next Level Productivity with AI-Infused Data Integration Workflows
 
Designing A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URLDesigning A Time bound resource download URL
Designing A Time bound resource download URL
 
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity WebinarAI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
AI You Can Trust - Ensuring Success with Data Integrity Webinar
 
NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 Workshop
NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 WorkshopNIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 Workshop
NIST Cybersecurity Framework (CSF) 2.0 Workshop
 
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
How Accurate are Carbon Emissions Projections?
 
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystemBird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
Bird eye's view on Camunda open source ecosystem
 
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptxCybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
Cybersecurity Workshop #1.pptx
 
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation DevelopersUiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
UiPath Community: AI for UiPath Automation Developers
 
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBXVoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
VoIP Service and Marketing using Odoo and Asterisk PBX
 
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just MinutesAI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
AI Fame Rush Review – Virtual Influencer Creation In Just Minutes
 
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and HazardsComputer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
Computer 10: Lesson 10 - Online Crimes and Hazards
 
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdfNanopower  In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
Nanopower In Semiconductor Industry.pdf
 
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability AdventureOpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
OpenShift Commons Paris - Choose Your Own Observability Adventure
 
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
IESVE Software for Florida Code Compliance Using ASHRAE 90.1-2019
 
Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)
Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)
Crea il tuo assistente AI con lo Stregatto (open source python framework)
 
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDEADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
ADOPTING WEB 3 FOR YOUR BUSINESS: A STEP-BY-STEP GUIDE
 

Fourth Dimension RAN white paper - ThinkSmallCell

  • 1. HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth DAVID CHAMBERS A White Paper sponsored by Parallel Wireless ©ThinkSmallCell September 2015
  • 2. Have we seen the end of the 10 year“Generation Gap”? In the past, we’ve seen a regular 10 year technology refresh with 2G, 3G and 4G each being added incrementally. Some believe that 5G will follow in the same cycle, although at the moment it remains vague and unpredictable. Others point out that the benefits of each new generation – mainly increasing spectral efficiency and releasing new spectrum – are reaching their full potential. This has been a key argument for small cell deployment, which increases capacity through frequency reuse without the need for additional spectrum or spectral efficiencies. This ten-year cycle hides many complex factors placing demands on network planners and managers, including but not limited to: • Spectrum: Acquisition, trading and re-farming • Radio interfaces: 2G/3G/4G/Wi-Fi • Backhaul: Wired and many wireless alternatives • RAN architecture: Integrated basestations vs C-RAN; Macro/Micro/Small • Vendor selection: Single solution vs best of class ecosystem • Ownership: Entirely owned vs RAN share/roaming A sensible course of action is to enable the network to become agile, able to adapt and cope with forthcoming technical and commercial challenges. At any time, the network should be delivering the best performance from all available resources. Nirvana for an operator isn’t deploying some radical new wireless interface, it’s ensuring that the complex mix of spectrum, radio technologies, backhaul and other assets are operating coherently to best effect. It’s essential to have the tools, processes and network architecture in place to take full advantage of whatever lies ahead. This ten-year cycle hides many complex factors placing demands on network planners and managers, including but not limited to: • Spectrum: Acquisition, trading and re-farming • Radio interfaces: 2G/3G/4G/Wi-Fi • Backhaul: Wired and many wireless alternatives • RAN architecture: Integrated basestations vs C-RAN; Macro/Micro/Small • Vendor selection: Single solution vs best of class ecosystem • Ownership: Entirely owned vs RAN share/roaming A sensible course of action is to enable the network to become agile, able to adapt and cope with forthcoming technical and commercial challenges. At any time, the network should be delivering the best performance from all available resources. Nirvana for an operator isn’t deploying some radical new wireless interface, it’s ensuring that the complex mix of spectrum, radio technologies, backhaul and other assets are operating coherently to best effect. It’s essential to have the tools, processes and network architecture in place to take full advantage of whatever lies ahead. It’s essential to have the tools, processes and network architecture in place to take full advantage of whatever lies ahead.” HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 2 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015
  • 3. The four methods of wireless densification There are commonly thought to be three ways to densify wireless traffic capacity: 1. More spectrum (expensive, limited) 2. More spectrally efficiency (e.g. LTE rather than 2G) 3. More spatial reuse (i.e. small cells) But there is also a fourth aspect which can deliver significant additional benefit 4. Orchestration and tighter control. (e.g. SON (Self Organising Networks), traffic steering/shaping across and between all available wireless resources) Network operators have already invested heavily to prepare themselves for the onslaught of new spectrum and new radio generations. This has been a key factor driving replacement of outdated macrocells with “Single RAN” basestation equipment that supports all generations of radio interface. These specifically address (1) and (2) above. What’s needed next is investment in tools and equipment that provides similar flexibility for (3) and (4), scaling to cope with an influx of small cells and introducing real-time management and co-ordination across all available wireless technologies, both cellular and Wi-Fi. Co-ordination between radio technologies is important, perhaps even more so than C-RAN which tends to focus on a single technology, primarily LTE. Super-optimising a single RF technology isn’t enough, especially if that would rely on a major hardware upgrade to smartphones as required by more advanced LTE features such as CoMP (Co-ordinated Multi-Path) or LAA. We have seen the industry adopt LTE quickly (422 commercially LTE networks to date), invest heavily in new spectrum (e.g. $41 Billion in the US, $18 Billion in India), and allocate substantial funds for small cell deployment (e.g. Verizon allocates $500 million). However, it’s less visibly obvious that operators are as well prepared for HetNet Orchestration as they should be. HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 3 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015
  • 4. Radio technology evolution? 5G, should it ever take form, can’t just be about delivering yet another air interface and associated infrastructure. It must satisfy needs which are otherwise unmet. A not unreasonable medium term goal may be that ultimately almost everything cellular uses some form of LTE or Wi-Fi. This is likely to take very long time for many reasons: • Both LTE and Wi-Fi standards continue to evolve and add new capabilities (e.g. LTE Direct, Wi-Gig etc.) • The majority of wireless data sent today is and will remain Wi-Fi. Most Wi-Fi use will be through private networks (residential), which also needs to be integrated and evolve to provide seamless handoff to/from cellular. It’s just not feasible for either cellular or Wi-Fi to dominate and replace the other. • Profitable inbound roamers will continue to need to be supported, regardless of the technology and/ or band plan of their devices • Much of the world can’t afford to adopt it very quickly. (LTE subscribers are only 10% of global total. The majority of users remain 2G and will do until 3G takes over around 2019. Even by 2020 there will still be more 2G users than 4G worldwide.) • LowpowerM2Mdevicescan’tsupporttoday’sLTE,sowilleitherneedLTE-Mvariantoruseoneofmany other competing wireless standards. It’s not entirely clear how much will bypass or be integrated into cellular networks • 5G is still vague and unknown. It’s unlikely to be a single ubiquitous new radio interface and perhaps more about the synergy of interworking between newer versions of LTE and Wi-Fi to it all works in a simplified, seamless and efficient way. So we will need to make best use of all existing channels need to support 3G, LTE and Wi-Fi for some years. This needs flexibility to adapt, deploy, refarm any and all of these radio technologies. It also requires the ability to manage and optimize across all resources to achieve the best system performance. So we will need to make best use of all existing channels need to support 3G, LTE and Wi-Fi for some years. This needs flexibility to adapt, deploy, refarm any and all of these radio technologies.” HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 4 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015
  • 5. Commercial evolution Different parts of the world operate on different commercial basis. In some countries, RAN sharing is endemic – operators may own very little of the network equipment themselves. At the other extreme, eventowersharingisrare.Wecanexpectincreasingcommercialpressuretoreducecostsandencourage RAN share especially in areas of poor coverage. Those networks that are technically better positioned and prepared for that eventuality will have an advantage. They will be ready to cope with MNVOs who may want the option to deploy some of their own in-building small cells and/or carrier grade Wi-Fi. They can accommodate whatever commercial arrangements for network sharing might arise, including support for Public Safety and private networks. Some networks have chosen a single solution supplier, setting SLAs for service quality and outsourcing both equipment and field activities. Often contracts are awarded on a regional/ geographic basis to different vendors in order to encourage competition. We have also seen different vendors being introduced as an underlay (urban microcell/small cell) or in-building (enterprise and/or residential). This ability to be able to integrate and use other vendor RAN equipment adds enormous commercial advantage. Open standard interfaces rather than proprietary ones have proven to be very successful, with it being common to award contracts to different suppliers for core and RAN equipment. Using a multi-vendor HetNet gateway expands choice. It empowers procurement to be able to negotiate better pricing for equipment and allows flexibility to introduce new products tailored toward specific markets such as Enterprise buildings. Adding each new vendor increases complexity and support costs, so typically a compelling case has to be made. Compliance with standards is hugely beneficial. Sometimes the subtleties of technical features/choice are not fully appreciated by procurement departments focused only on the cost of the box. Using a multi-vendor HetNet gateway expands choice. It empowers procurement to be able to negotiate better pricing for equipment and allows flexibility to introduce new products tailored toward specific markets such as Enterprise buildings.” HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 5 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015
  • 6. App evolution Traffic is growing exponentially in volume, diversity and numbers of connected devices. The headline growth figure relates to video, highlighted by Netflix consuming 34.5% of all US fixed internet traffic in the evening. But few people walk around with video running on their devices, although they might be on a call, streaming audio or downloading app/social media updates. Some think that augmented reality may change that; the honest answer is “we just don’t know”. Perhaps the more likely answer is high value paid traffic growth will come from something quite different, unrelated and unexpected. The Internet ofThings (IoT) is expected to dramatically increase the number of connected device, but it’s difficult to predict what percentage would be served by a cellular network operator. Usage would likely impact signalling load than traffic volume and about resilience rather than speed of connection. This includes avoiding heavy signalling loads on the core network, a lesson learnt early in LTE deployment by SK Telecom who installed one of the first LTE gateways to offload and optimise that. Cisco VNI and other reports predict that Wi-Fi offload will continue to grow, helped further by new high speed Wi-Gig launching in 2017. This technology should be ideal for fast data synchronisation if used well. The main point is that predicting today’s traffic quantity and profile would have been difficult even 5 years ago, so we can’t be exactly sure of what’s coming next except it will be big. Agility, flexibility and scalability of the network architecture will be key to responding quickly to handle future demand. Managing this wide variety of traffic types using techniques such as traffic shaping, steering and caching will grow in importance despite concerns about Internet neutrality. Managing this wide variety of traffic types using techniques such as traffic shaping, steering and caching will grow in importance despite concerns about Internet neutrality.” HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 6 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015
  • 7. Today RAN expansion activity Undoubtedly, today’s priority for network operators has been about maximising the return from existing macrocell sites. Relatively few new sites are being acquired but many are being expanded and upgraded. Many operators already have flexible basestations which can be remotely configured between 2G/3G/LTE to refarm frequency bands. Most can achieve that with equipment swaps. Investment has switched to LTE, increasing the wide area coverage footprint by using the lower 700MHz frequency bands. This can be counter productive where there isn’t matching 3G coverage or VoLTE. Europe has seen extensive refarming of the 900MHz band from 2G to 3G which should help, but that option isn’t open to all operators. Capacity investment in LTE varies widely between countries. Developed countries where users have LTE smartphones would prioritise LTE, but may find that only the latest devices can access some frequency bands, delaying the benefit of the investment. Sri Lanka has 4G but continues to build up 3G capacity because that’s what their customers are equipped to use. North America has moved quickly with 4G because Verizon/Sprint want to retire expensive/outdated CDMA systems, forcing competitors to keep up. Australia has been slower with 4G because it originally deployed 3G at 700MHz which has very good coverage range. Sector splitting at high traffic sites remains popular where antenna can be mounted. Six sector sites are not uncommon in central business districts, with all available frequencies being deployed from 700MHz through 2.6GHz. Backhaul links have been upgraded to suit, with rates up to 1Gbps not unusual. Additionalspectrumandsiteexpansionhasitslimits,andwecanseemanyoperatorsactivelyconducting small cell pilots, identifying the processes and methods for site acquisition, rapid configuration and suitable backhaul methods. The industry is positioning and preparing itself for the inevitable need to a small cell layer, even if it has been delayed longer than expected by the macrocell and spectrum expansion listed above. We’ve also seen a wide variety in approach to Wi-Fi. Insisting that all smartphones are Wi-Fi capable has taken huge pressure off cellular networks, offloading the majority of wireless data to private, often residential, Wi-Fi access points. Some operators have taken a more proactive approach, setting up roaming agreements with public Wi-Fi networks and/or deploying their own Carrier Wi-Fi points. This is rarely co-ordinated with the RAN planning departments and more often dealt with as a commercial roamingtransaction.AlthoughmanysmallcellproductshaveWi-Ficapabilities,theseareoftendisabled for organisational or commercial rather than technical reasons. HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 7 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015
  • 8. Future RAN expansion strategy With a mix of cellular and Wi-Fi radio technologies to manage, a co-ordinated HetNet approach is required.Thesecan’tbeoptimisedoroperatedpurelyasseparatesilos.Toolswillbeneededtodetermine where, when and how best to invest in new capacity. Performance management reports can be used to identify hotspots/notspots, but wider consideration is needed to determine which frequency band and radio technology will provide the best return. This may include commercial options including RAN sharing and roaming, with tighter integration with both trusted (i.e. Carrier deployed) and untrusted (i.e. 3rd party) Wi-Fi. An ability to expand the network efficiently and rapidly using any current or future radio technologies will be essential. This includes integrating new products and/or equipment vendors whether directly or indirectly connected. Once installed, active management of traffic and usage across and between these different radio technologies becomes very important. It’s not enough to optimise performance of any individual radio interface, traffic flow and steering in as close to real-time as practicable delivers great benefits. We can expect to see greater use of SON, data caching and other techniques. HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 8 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015
  • 9. Conclusion Perhaps greatest challenge for today’s CTO is not to predict exactly which RF interface, architecture, App or technology will make the greatest demands on their network in the future. Instead, it’s about shaping their organisation and operation to be in the best position to move quickly and adapt efficiently when the industry does finally make its choice. While we’ve seen new frequencies and capabilities enabled by LTE take up the majority of investment in recent years, we can expect to see more emphasis on network densification through small cells, C-RAN and Wi-Fi in the near future. Commercial disruption through increased RAN sharing, roaming and new vendor equipment is also likely if unpredictable. The best-positioned organisations will be those who put in place the capabilities to be agile, adaptable to meet future unknown and unpredictable market demands. HetNet Orchestration provides the flexibility to make the most of all the technologies brought to bear. Capabilities to rapidly deploy, integrate, manage and optimise networks will be critical, and a holistic approach which deals with all technologies in a co-ordinated manner will have a tremendous advantage. The best-positioned organisations will be those who put in place the capabilities to be agile, adaptable to meet future unknown and unpredictable market demands.” HetNet Orchestration The fourth dimension for wireless capacity growth 9 ©ThinkSmallCell 2015