4th OpenAIRE Workshop, Nils Dietrich

426 views
370 views

Published on

4th OpenAIRE Workshop - Legal and Sustainability Issues for Open Access Infrastructures
Nov. Vilnius
Legal prototype of e-infrastructure – legal evaluation of selected usage scenarios - Nils Dietrich, Faculty of law, Goettingen University

Published in: Technology, Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
426
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
2
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

4th OpenAIRE Workshop, Nils Dietrich

  1. 1. N l s D et ri c h, LL. M i i . Uni vers i t ät Göt t i ngen Cont ac t : n. di et ri c h@ ura. uni - goet t i ngen. de j Cas e St udi es Spec i f i c Us age Sc enari os T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1
  2. 2. “Legal P rot ot ype” of e- i nf ras t ruc t ure •Wt hi n i t hi s part us e of of dat a t he s t udy t he c ons t rai nt s on t he s t em i ng m f rom IP ri ght s are el aborat ed on i n det ai l . •The anal ys i s i s bas ed on s el ec t ed s c enari os f or t he us age of res earc h dat a. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 •The 2
  3. 3. End us er s c enari o A P ct ure i a res earcher w ho i s a part i ci pant i n an EC proj ect and report s i n O penA R I Epl us an O pen A cces s publ i cat i on res ul t i ng f rom t hi s EC proj ect . The publ i cat i on ref ers t o al ready avai l abl e pri m ary dat a t hat has a D aCi t e- D I . at O The res earcher can ei t her ent er t hi s D I or O brow e dat as et s w t h D aCi t e- D I s t o generat e s i at O t he l i nk bet w een t he publ i cat i on and t he dat a. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 3
  4. 4. W c h t ypes of us age are hi rel evant ? •Thi s s c enari o i s an exam e of t he l i nki ng of a pl publ i c at i on t o pri m ary dat a. • The s c i ent i s t i s abl e t o generat e a l i nk bet w een t he publ i c at i on and t he dat a. • The s c i ent i s t i s abl e t o ac c es s dat as et s . • OpenAIR has t o res ol ve t he D us i ng t he D aCi t e E OI at dat abas e. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 4
  5. 5. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •The t ype of res earc h dat a t hat i s deal t w t h here i s i pri m ary dat a. •Suc h pri m ary dat a w l l norm l y not be prot ec t ed by i al c opyri ght . •B t he ut dat abas e t hat c ont ai ns t he pri m ary dat a i s T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 5
  6. 6. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •The us e of a s ubs t ant i al part of a(-) abas e dat • The us e by t he s i ngl e res earc her (+) • The us e by t he OpenAIR i nf ras t ruc t ure i t s el f E •Ext rac t i o n and re- ut i l i s at i on • Ac c es s i ng • Li nki ng T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 6
  7. 7. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •Ac c es s i ng • B t he us er y • B t he OpenAIR i nf ras t ruc t ure y E •Li nki ng • It depends on t he nat i onal j uri s di c t i on, w her het l i nki ng i s a rel evant ac t . T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 7
  8. 8. Cons equenc es •It i s s t i l l not c l ear w het her us ers are al l ow ed t o generat e l i nks t o dat a t hat i s al ready avai l abl e on t he i nt ernet . •OpenAIR Ep l us w oul d i nf ri nge t he s ui generi s dat abas e prot ec t i on ri ght i f i t proc es s es t he dat a of t he D OI w t hout t he perm s s i on of t he ri ght hol der of i i t he D aCi t e dat abas e. at T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 8
  9. 9. Thi rd- part y provi der s c enari o D I n t he N herl ands al l uni vers i t i es and t he R et oyal N herl ands A et cadem y of A s and Sci ences us e t he res earch i nf orm i on s ys t em cal l ed rt at , M S. I n t he open acces s part i nf orm i on on res earch proj ect s , ETI at i ncl udi ng t hei r out put , m be f ound. P s i bl e t ypes of out put ay os i ncl ude dat as et s , art i cl es , conf erence papers and pres ent at i ons . The N R S s ys t em w ch i s us ed as an aggregat or f or A CI , hi O penA R I Epl us , harves t s m adat a f rom M S, publ i cat i on et ETI repos i t ori es and dat as et repos i t ori es . W hen m adat a of t hes e et di f f erent s ources s hares a com on m adat a el em , f or i ns t ance m et ent t he EU proj ect code, N R S i s abl e t o s how t he rel at i ons hi ps A CI bet teen p n earch p r h 2 1 T elg lwd o O e A R pu . cproj t 0 3 , h e a su y f res I E ls o y ig ect s organi s at i ons , res earchers and 9
  10. 10. W c h t ypes of us age are hi rel evant ? •M adat a et i s harves t ed f rom M ETIS and ot her repos i t ori es . •Af t er harves t i ng, t he m adat a i s s t ored i n et OpenAIR Epl us . •NAR CIS i s abl e t o s how w c h doc um s s hare a m adat a hi ent et el em , e. g. w c h dat a bel ongs t o a s pec i f i c ent hi T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 0
  11. 11. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •The ac t i ons of harves t i ng m adat a c arri ed out by et N CIS i n t hi s s c enari o c oul d es pec i al l y AR i nf ri nge t he s ui generi s dat abas e prot ec t i on ri ght of t he di f f erent repos i t ori es . •If s om e of t he m adat a i s prot ec t ed by c opyri ght , t he et harves t i ng c oul d al s o i nf ri nge c opyri ght . T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 1
  12. 12. Is t here i nf ri ngem ent of IP ri ght s •At f i rs t N CIS ac c es s es t he open ac c es s part of t he AR repos i t ori es . •One c oul d t hi nk about t he appl i c at i on of t he s c i ent i f i c res earc h exc ept i on. •NAR CIS s how rel at i ons hi ps bet w s een t he dat a. T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 2
  13. 13. Cons equenc es •Wt hout i an agreem ent w t h t he repos i t ori es on t he i c opyi ng of t hei r dat a, OpenAIR i s not al l ow E ed t o harves t t hei r dat a and c opy i t i nt o t he OpenAIR i nf ras t ruc t ure. E •As i t i s one of t he goal s of t he proj ec t t o enabl e t he m ual harves t i ng of res ourc es bet w ut een OpenAIR E and ext ernal s ourc es , i t i s very i m port ant t o T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 3
  14. 14. Thank you f or your at t ent i on! T elg l td o O e A R pu . c p r h 2 1 h e a su y f p n I E ls o y ig t 0 3 1 4

×