Uploaded on

A copy of the presentations by Garry Hall and Sue McGlynn delivered for the Bristol BfL12 day.

A copy of the presentations by Garry Hall and Sue McGlynn delivered for the Bristol BfL12 day.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
    Be the first to like this
No Downloads

Views

Total Views
410
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2

Actions

Shares
Downloads
7
Comments
0
Likes
0

Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
    No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. BfL12 TrainingBristol, 27th February 2013Sue McGlynn and Garry Hall
  • 2. About&OPUN:&• "We"operate"as"a"charity"with"low"overheads"• "Design"review"• "Not"for"profit""• "Trusted,"independent"and"impar=al"""
  • 3. OPUN"is"posi=oning"itself"as"the"leading&provider"of"""""""BfL"12"training"in"the"region"working"in"partnership"with"NoFngham"Trent"University"
  • 4. The&role&of&Architecture&Centres:&BfL12"training""Support"and"advice"–"enabling"Championing"the"use"of"BfL12"locally"Built"for"Life"–"key"opportunity"for"local"centres"
  • 5. A
  • 6. B
  • 7. C
  • 8. D
  • 9. E
  • 10. F
  • 11. The principles thatunderpin Building forLife 12Sue McGlynn
  • 12. Our vision is toimprove the urbandesign quality ofhouse building inEngland, helping thecountry to build moreand better homes andcommunities…
  • 13. Introduction: Searching for characterHow can we create places with a distinctivecharacter and their own sense of place?
  • 14. The&&quest&&for&&character&
  • 15. Movement and landscapeThe DNA ofplace Streets Neighbourhood Open spaces/gardens Building elements/materials
  • 16. Settlement form: Movement and landscape Urban form and functions Building form: Details & materials
  • 17. 1. Linking landscapes for humans + wildlife Balancing movement, access and ecology Tight urbanism v’s landscapeHanham Hall, Bristol Whitehill Bordon Masterplan
  • 18. ‘Feel and function’: Integrating sustainable drainage + waste Upton – NorthamptonMaking landscapes: Swales, permeable surfaces and even waste treatment can shape character
  • 19. Making space for green and blue infrastructure
  • 20. 2. Using landscape to generate character areasNeighbourhoods"defined"by"landscape"and"topography,"Sherford"
  • 21. Green corridors and streetsGreen routes for the whole movement network– from rural edge to town centre
  • 22. 3. Connections: Street spacing and walkability Connected streets and routes make places walkable and increase use of public transport!
  • 23. External&and&&internal&links&
  • 24. Streets are long-lasting elements of place A key influence on place making and local identityStreets: Give access and the potentialto experience places
  • 25. Streets as attractive, social spaces…Designing for the car but not letting it take over the social uses ofthe space.Standard highways geometries make places look the same
  • 26. Street design, street width, building placement:Varying character in a neighbourhoodLong or short streets, wiggly or straight?Front gardens or no front gardens? A walkable space or car-dominated?
  • 27. 4. Varying character by varying house types and styles
  • 28. 5. Time and personalisation add to character at the largest and smallest scalesDe Dijk, Rijswijk
  • 29. 6. Density and perception of densityDensity: A measure not a quality
  • 30. 7. A sense of community focus Community spacesThe Triangle, Swindon Ypenburg, The Hague -  Allotments / community gardens -  Play space -  Facilities for sport
  • 31. Landscape structureUrban structureSite structure
  • 32. Building for Life 12:Transition andRemodelling
  • 33. Why"the"Update?"
  • 34. • "Comprehensive"spending"review"–"dissolu=on"of"CABE""• "Slimmer,"less"resourced"Cabe"at"the"Design"Council""• "NPPF"and"Housing"Strategy"• "Growth"agenda"""• "Quality"agenda"""• "Fewer"resources"across"the"board"""• "Deregula=on"–"red"tape"‘witch"hunt’""• "Localism""
  • 35. Our vision is to improve the urban designquality of house building in England, helpingthe country to build more and better homesand communities, by:
  • 36. 1. Providing a clear quality framework (clarityand certainty for industry)
  • 37. 1.  Providing a clear quality framework2.  Promoting design dialogue at the start of the process
  • 38. 1.  Providing a clear quality framework2.  Promoting design dialogue at the start of the process3. Help stimulate consumer demand for and recognition of better quality
  • 39. 1.  Providing a clear quality framework2.  Promoting design dialogue at the start of the process3. Help stimulate consumer demand for and recognition of better quality4. Reward house builders for good design at point of sale
  • 40. Could&a&remodel&actually&achieve&more?""
  • 41. CABE"(2007)""
  • 42. CABE&(2010)&&
  • 43. BfL&was&not&delivering&the&change&expected""""
  • 44. Remodelling&BfL&was&not&a&choice,&but&a&necessity&if&it&were&to&survive&and&remain&relevant.""
  • 45. • "Remodelling"BfL"was"not"a"choice,"but"a"necessity"if"it"were"to"survive.""• "Could&we&remodel&in&a&way&that&secured&industry&support&but&also&added&value?"""
  • 46. Industry&frustraOon…&
  • 47. “Rubbish”
  • 48. Could&we&add&value&by&designing&out&issues&with&BfL&2008?"""
  • 49. Higher&res&v&lower&res&Points&chasing&Assessment&rather&than&dialogue&based""
  • 50. Status&of&Building&for&Life&&&
  • 51. “…moveawayfromthestandards2basedapproachandbacktobeingastar9ngpoint fornego9a9ons…”"""
  • 52. Published"21st"Nov"2011"Meant"to"‘get"the"na=on"building’"
  • 53. “ThisGovernmentrecognisesthatwhatwebuildisjustasimportantashowmanyhomeswebuild”"""
  • 54. “ToolssuchasBuildingforLifesetoutsomeofthefeaturesthatareusefultoconsiderwhendesigningnewhomesandneighbourhoods”"""
  • 55. “Wealsoseean opportunitytoadaptexis9ngsuccessfultoolkits,suchasBuildingforLife,to supportcommuni9es”"""
  • 56. “ThisGovernmentaEaches greatimportancetothe designofthebuilt environment”"""
  • 57. “respondtolocalcharacter”""" “createsafeandaccessible environments”""" “willfunc9onwell”"""“addtotheoverallqualityofthearea”""" “establishastrongsenseof place”"""
  • 58. “promoteorreinforcelocaldis9nc9veness”""" “addresstheconnec9ons betweenpeopleandplace”"""
  • 59. 3 sec=ons12 ques=ons60 good"prac=ce"recommenda=ons""""
  • 60. Underlying&principles:&Building"for"Life"must"be"seen"as"facilitator"of"quality,speedygrowth"""""
  • 61. Underlying&principles:&• "One"ques=on"(rather"than"two)"when"one"would"do"• "Lose"jargon"–"open"BfL"to"non]design"professionals"• "Shi^"from"assessment"to"dialogue"–"traffic"lights"• "Avoid"duplica=on""• "Don’t"‘overtake’"na=onal"policy/Building"Regula=ons"• "Post"bag"and"common"issues""
  • 62. Underlying&principles:&• "One"ques=on"(rather"than"two)"when"one"would"do"• "Lose"jargon"–"open"BfL"to"non]design"professionals"• "Shi^"from"assessment"to"dialogue"–"traffic"lights"• "Avoid"duplica=on""• "Don’t"‘overtake’"na=onal"policy""• "Post"bag"and"common"issues"• "Conformorrobustlyjus9fy
  • 63. Conformorrobustlyjus9fyAmbers"–"factors"outside"the"control"of"the"applicant,"e.g."third"party"land"ownership"(connec=ons)"Or:""Off"site"housing"contribu=ons!!
  • 64. Building for Life 12:The questions andhow it works
  • 65. • "12"ques=ons"(ra=onalisa=on)""• "More"accessible""• "Designed"for"community"engagement""• "StarOng&point&for&discussions"""• "No"scoring"regime""• "Avoid"reds,"minimise"ambers,"aim"for"greens""""
  • 66. Start&the&process&with&all&quesOons&set&at&‘amber’"""""We&recommend&that&local&authoriOes&avoid&fixed&thresholds,&i.e.&only&approve&12&‘greens’&&12"‘greens’""versus"11"‘greens’"and"1"(robustly"jus=fied)"‘amber’?""
  • 67. Q1.&ConnecOons&• "Prompts"you"to"think"beyond"the"red"line"• "Suggests"overlooked"routes"as"best"prac=ce"• "Warns"against"insular"developments"–"this"would"score"a"‘red’"if"no"good"explana=on"is"given"
  • 68. Q6.&Working&with&the&site&and&its&context&• "Prompts"discussion"of"site"analysis"• "Role"of"landscape"in"adding"character"• "Highlights"the"need"to"integrate"natural"and"human"systems"–"lots"of"research"to"support"this"as"important"
  • 69. Q7.&CreaOng&well&defined&streets&and&spaces&&• "Recognising"the"value"of"the"street"as"the"key"structural"element"of"urbanised"areas"• "Role"of"landscape"in"defining"streets"and"spaces"• "The"importance"of"perimeter"block"forma=on,"logical"building"lines"and"corners"
  • 70. Trn corner
  • 71. Q9.&Streets&for&all&• "Natural"signpost"to"MfS"–"user"hierarchy""• "Prompts"put"emphasis"on"design"to"influence"behaviour"• "Also"talks"about"overlooking"
  • 72. Q9.&Car&parking&• "Stresses"convenience"–"as"this"is"how"people"WILL"park"• "Prompts"suggest"parking"in"the"street"as"an"op=on"• "Emphasis"on"overlooked"parking"too"
  • 73. Q11.&Public&and&private&spaces&• "Steers"discussion"to"le^"over"spaces"and"ownership"• "Prompts"you"to"think"about"loca=on"AND"quality"of"amenity"space"• "Fenced"play"areas"are"not"recommended"
  • 74. Q12.&External&storage&and&amenity&space&• "Gets"you"talking"about"these"issues"at"an"early"stage"• "Prompts"talk"about"bikes"and"bins,"but"also"the"realis=c"use"of"garages"too"• "Steers"you"away"from"unsecure"cycle"storage"etc"–"overlaps"with"crime"preven=on"agenda"
  • 75. Case&Study:&Manor&Kingsway,&Derby&
  • 76. Image credit: OPUN/HCA
  • 77. Image credit: OPUN/HCA
  • 78. Image credit: OPUN/HCA
  • 79. Built&for&Life&awards&&
  • 80. • "Built"for"Life"will"reward"developers"at"the"point"of"sale"for"good"design.""• "Annual"league"tables"–"possibly"the"first"being"published"in"2014"to"give"the"industry"=me"to"respond."• "Launches"6"February"at"Westminster"with"Nick"Bowles"MP"and"Lord"Carlisle"""• "Significant"interest"from"industry"in"the"scheme"already"(and"this"is"before"the"launch!)"
  • 81. • "‘12"green’"schemes"independently"verified"by"an"architecture"centre"will"be"en=tled"to"apply"for"a"Built"for"Life"licence"from"the"BfL"Partnership."• "Local"centres"will"be"permihed"to"charge"for"this"service,"but"fees"will"need"to"be"agreed"collec=vely"so"there’s"consistent"pricing"in"consulta=on"with"Design"for"Homes"as"price"points"are"sensi=ve."• "Licences"will"be"charged"per"market"rate"sale"unit"""• "Local"centres"need"to"iden=fy"Building"for"Life"advisors"to"undertake"these"reviews.""
  • 82. Desktop&Exercise&&