Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
0
Steven Moustafa Kassem
Steven Moustafa Kassem
unknown or unacknowledged error created
during the design, measurement, sampling,
procedure, or choice of problem studied
◦ bias is so pervasive because we want to confirm our
beliefs
◦ science is organized around proving itself wrong
not right...
 when the study fails to identify the validity problems
 when publicity about the research fails to incorporate
the rese...
 selecting the most or least of anything
creates a regression effect
 selecting the lowest functioning mentally ill people to
study the effects of a therapy program
 selecting the poorest p...
 Study Dropouts may be the ones who needed
it most
 People also drop out when the program
works
 Occurs when researcher fails to control for the
effects of data collection and measurement
 using self report is often ...
Differential Bias occurs when one group of study
participants is more likely to be misclassified than
the other
Misclassif...
 Occurs when we administer the research
interview or questionnaire under adverse
conditions
 Poor layout, obligatory par...
 only cases within a limited range of a disease
spectrum are included.
 This more commonly occurs with more obvious
or a...
 occurs when individual preferences or local
practices determine which subjects undergo a
certain treatment or imaging st...
 Exists when study subjects are self-
selected for enrollment for treatment or
imaging
 Differences may exist between th...
 may arise in studies in which subjects are
interviewed by an investigator who is also
involved in the interpretation of ...
 results when additional factors or
variables are associated with exposure
and disease status
 Common confounding variab...
 journals tend to publish studies with positive
results or better-quality study designs
 does not arise within a given s...
 retained knowledge of the results of one
study influences the interpretation of the
second study, potentially leading to...
 study subjects are randomly allocated to
receive one or other of the alternative
treatments under study.
 Methods inclu...
 Allows for consideration of time factors
 i.e.: differences in patients who visit an
emergency room in the morning vers...
 Information such as pertinent test results,
demographic data, or disease status, which
may affect an investigator's test...
Good
Intentions
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Biases

558

Published on

By Prof. Steven Kassem as part of the 5th Research Summer School by King Abdullah International Medical Research Center (KAIMRC) - Western region

Published in: Education, Business, Technology
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
558
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
9
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Transcript of "Biases"

  1. 1. Steven Moustafa Kassem
  2. 2. Steven Moustafa Kassem
  3. 3. unknown or unacknowledged error created during the design, measurement, sampling, procedure, or choice of problem studied
  4. 4. ◦ bias is so pervasive because we want to confirm our beliefs ◦ science is organized around proving itself wrong not right ◦ key difference between qualitative and quantitative research is  attempts to eliminate bias by quantitative researcher  explicit acknowledgement of bias by qualitative researchers
  5. 5.  when the study fails to identify the validity problems  when publicity about the research fails to incorporate the researchers cautions
  6. 6.  selecting the most or least of anything creates a regression effect
  7. 7.  selecting the lowest functioning mentally ill people to study the effects of a therapy program  selecting the poorest people to study the effects of an anti-poverty program  selecting chronic homeless to study the effects of a housing program
  8. 8.  Study Dropouts may be the ones who needed it most  People also drop out when the program works
  9. 9.  Occurs when researcher fails to control for the effects of data collection and measurement  using self report is often biased by social desirability  most clinical research is highly vulnerable to measurement bias  when the person perceives there is something to lose by their answer
  10. 10. Differential Bias occurs when one group of study participants is more likely to be misclassified than the other Misclassification of exposure is non-differential if it is similar among cases and controls i.e. the exposure (mis)classification is not related to the person's disease status Interviewer bias happens when interviewers ask questions differently in case-control or cohort studies a histopathologist may be more likely to report on a biopsy specimen as mesothelioma if a history of asbestos exposure is reported (biased follow-up) Salmonella cases may be more likely to remember
  11. 11.  Occurs when we administer the research interview or questionnaire under adverse conditions  Poor layout, obligatory participation, uncomfortable settings, etc…
  12. 12.  only cases within a limited range of a disease spectrum are included.  This more commonly occurs with more obvious or advanced disease.  For example, in a study investigating the ability of MR imaging to depict cirrhosis, if only advanced clinical cases are included the sensitivity will be overestimated.
  13. 13.  occurs when individual preferences or local practices determine which subjects undergo a certain treatment or imaging study  New treatments or imaging studies that have not been universally accepted into clinical practice are particularly prone to this type of bias.
  14. 14.  Exists when study subjects are self- selected for enrollment for treatment or imaging  Differences may exist between those who volunteer and those who refuse participation  Volunteers may be more health conscious or even healthier than the general population
  15. 15.  may arise in studies in which subjects are interviewed by an investigator who is also involved in the interpretation of a test result or determination of disease classification.  The investigator may inadvertently “coach” subjects or selectively review entire medical records
  16. 16.  results when additional factors or variables are associated with exposure and disease status  Common confounding variables are age and sex  Stratification (separation based on variables) is a common method to address confounding in the analysis phase
  17. 17.  journals tend to publish studies with positive results or better-quality study designs  does not arise within a given single study but can be seen in a review and analysis of the literature, as in a meta-analysis  leads to overly optimistic results or inflated associations
  18. 18.  retained knowledge of the results of one study influences the interpretation of the second study, potentially leading to a more accurate reading or diagnosis  learning-curve phenomenon
  19. 19.  study subjects are randomly allocated to receive one or other of the alternative treatments under study.  Methods include allocation concealment and blinding
  20. 20.  Allows for consideration of time factors  i.e.: differences in patients who visit an emergency room in the morning versus those who visit during the night
  21. 21.  Information such as pertinent test results, demographic data, or disease status, which may affect an investigator's test interpretation or assessment of an outcome, is not available to the investigator  A double-blinded study refers to one in which both the investigator and study subject are blinded to group assignment
  22. 22. Good Intentions
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×