Your SlideShare is downloading. ×
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Thanks for flagging this SlideShare!

Oops! An error has occurred.

×
Saving this for later? Get the SlideShare app to save on your phone or tablet. Read anywhere, anytime – even offline.
Text the download link to your phone
Standard text messaging rates apply

Science of Team Science Conference - Research Networking Tools Workshop - Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of Michigan

1,176

Published on

Published in: Education
0 Comments
1 Like
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
1,176
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
3
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
21
Comments
0
Likes
1
Embeds 0
No embeds

Report content
Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

Cancel
No notes for slide

Transcript

  • 1. Elsevier SciVal Experts at the University of MichiganJeff Horon (jhoron@umich.edu) – April 2011
  • 2. What is SciVal Experts?ImplementationUse casesWhat‟s next? jhoron@umich.edu
  • 3. http://www.researchprofiles.collexis.com/umichigan/ is now http://www.experts.scival.com/umichigan jhoron@umich.edu
  • 4. SciVal Experts is a customizable directory of research expertise,automatically populated with publication data. jhoron@umich.edu
  • 5. Find an Expert Search using a concept SciVal Experts identifies START concept University of Michigan you are interested in experts See the experts found Add related concepts additional concept Add to refine your search (optional) Review publication lists for your experts jhoron@umich.edu
  • 6. Identifying Experts based on Concept Search and Discovery jhoron@umich.edu
  • 7. It uses „fingerprint’ technology to provide researchers, researchadministrators, and senior leadership with the ability to understandand utilize the expertise across their institution. Compendex Text Knowledge Base Fingerprint jhoron@umich.edu
  • 8. Fingerprinting is accomplished by: Creating lists of publications for each author to accurately represent them • Built automatically using disambiguation algorithm • Manually checked by a quality assurance team to ensure accuracy Automatic Process Algorithm using identifying J. Smith elements determines clusters: J. Smith • Name John Smith • Location • Co-Authors • Key Concepts JT Smith • Journals • more… Manual Process Human quality assurance team builds profiles, John T. Smith reviews results quarterly jhoron@umich.edu
  • 9. Fingerprinting is accomplished by: Creating lists of publications for each author to accurately represent them • Built automatically using disambiguation algorithm • Manually checked by a quality assurance team to ensure accuracy Automatic Process Algorithm using identifying J. Smith elements determines C.V.-by-C.V., Publication- clusters: by-Publication validation of J. Smith • Name John all profiled faculty • Location Smith • Co-Authors Result: Extemely high Key Concepts • JT quality data in terms•of Smith comprehensiveness, Journals • more… accuracy, and ease of use Manual Process Improved user experience, quality assurance Human adoption, and enables team builds profiles, administrative use reviews results quarterly John T. Smith jhoron@umich.edu
  • 10. Extracting concepts from those publications to create a FingerprintSciVal Experts (formerly Collexis Research Profiles)and department or showing their expertise at both the researcher center level jhoron@umich.edu
  • 11. Aggregating individual fingerprints across organizational units allows for theFingerprints can be aggregated at various levelsorganization to know what individuals know and what groups knowtogether… • New publications and grants? • Emerging trends? • Who is working together? Who isn’t? • With which other organizations (internal and external) are we Aggregated Fingerprints collaborating? Department • What are we good at? Individual Fingerprints Institute Research Group jhoron@umich.edu
  • 12. This information is combined to create an application that lets you-Search and explore expertise across the University of Michigan-Analyze Department level information about publications, expertise andmore, and-View related concepts or publications from similar experts jhoron@umich.edu
  • 13. Fingerprints built from Grants and Publications jhoron@umich.edu
  • 14. Understand which experts are (or are not) working together across the organization and view external collaborations jhoron@umich.edu
  • 15. Participation across SciVal Experts implementations…… and in customized multi-institution implementations and other nationalnetworks jhoron@umich.edu
  • 16. Implementation2007: Increased interest in an internal expertise and research activity system and a non-financial view of faculty activity “Why can’t you just make a system I can search that says what everyone is working on? It seems so simple.” – Biochemistry researcherInitial approach was an internal C.V. system, but this had a high data entry burden and faced severe impediments to adoptionLearned about commercial options, including NIH-Collexis reviewer-finding tools jhoron@umich.edu
  • 17. ImplementationSelected Collexis Research Profiles due to: -Significantly lower cost of implementation (cost approximates 1 developer FTE) -Lower risk, fixed costs leave no potential for a runaway IT project -No manual data collection -Automatic, ongoing data collection requires minimal internal FTE commitments -Control of the author-publication (‘who wrote what’) list -Ability to download underlying data, permissive use jhoron@umich.edu
  • 18. Value PropositionsImplementation guided by layered value propositions: Macro: Supporting strategic decision making and analysis Meso: Supporting faculty data infrastructure Micro: Supporting collaboration and connection The combination of all three was an easy institutional support decision. jhoron@umich.edu
  • 19. Implemented 2008-2009; Launched 2009Site Traffic ~70% search ~20% direct ~10% link Global user base jhoron@umich.edu
  • 20. Value to Faculty Increases faculty Makes it easier ‘discoverability’ for faculty to to external users: find each other -External collaborators -Students -Sponsors -Media Faculty jhoron@umich.edu
  • 21. Value to Departments / Centers Makes it easier to track publications, working relationships, and research trends Departments / Centers Faculty jhoron@umich.edu
  • 22. Value to Schools / Colleges [System] Makes it easier to find experts, engage with external contacts, and observe trends School / College Departments / Centers Faculty jhoron@umich.edu
  • 23. Value to Schools / Colleges [Data] Data feeds allow for customized analysis and reporting (e.g. publication output, collaborations between center members, etc.) School / College Departments / Centers Faculty jhoron@umich.edu
  • 24. Value Across Schools / Colleges School / College School / College Departments / Centers Departments / Centers Faculty FacultyCross-School / College‘Discoverability’ concept jhoron@umich.edu
  • 25. „Micro‟ Use CasesSupporting CollaborationSystem: Finding similar experts for new faculty onboardingAd Hoc: Supporting a conference jhoron@umich.edu
  • 26. Finding similar experts for new faculty onboarding How can we help to match new faculty to the people that they should connect with at Michigan? “I get most of my information on who to connect with from the people who are near my office.” – Pediatric neurosurgery researcher “Most of my connections stem from the people I met on my evaluation/selection committee during hiring after my fellowship.” – Orthopaedic surgery researcher jhoron@umich.edu
  • 27. Finding similar experts for new faculty onboarding jhoron@umich.edu
  • 28. Finding similar experts for new faculty onboarding Organizational and scientific context of a grant or publication jhoron@umich.edu
  • 29. Gartner‟s Hype Cycle jhoron@umich.edu Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gartner_Hype_Cycle.svg
  • 30. Short Circuit the Hype Cycle jhoron@umich.edu Source: http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/File:Gartner_Hype_Cycle.svg
  • 31. About Norms The world is a blunt normalizing instrument Achieving different results requires continuously introducing positive variation jhoron@umich.edu
  • 32. Supporting a Conference How do we use the data to support „Health Services Research Day‟? -Match research interests, project needs, opinions -Shuffle existing working relationships, rank, etc. Social interaction models for different events throughout the day using a combination of SciVal Experts concepts and attendee survey data Senior Faculty Junior Faculty„Pitch‟ Group Mentoring Mixed Equals jhoron@umich.edu
  • 33. „Meso‟ Use CasesSupporting Leadership (Department Chairs, Deans)System: „Research Network‟ visualization and expertise discoveryAd Hoc: Strategic analysis jhoron@umich.edu
  • 34. „Research Network‟ visualization and expertisediscovery “I can connect people in my department based on what I know about their expertise, but I’d love to a system to help make sure I’m capturing everything.” – Pediatric cancer chair “It would be great to know that I could route someone to a system that helps expose expertise in case I can’t respond to their request as soon as possible.” Ensuring that we deliver on the promise of strategic recruitment efforts by monitoring collaboration jhoron@umich.edu
  • 35. „Research Network‟ visualization and expertise discovery Cardiology Department May 2010 Jalife J jhoron@umich.edu
  • 36. „Research Network‟ visualization and expertise discovery Cardiology jhoron@umich.edu Department April 2011
  • 37. Strategic analysisWhat are we good at?How can we understand our expertise broadly?What new centers or institutes should we create? jhoron@umich.edu
  • 38. [Social] Network AnalysisSo, like Facebook? Sort of.But networks are everywhere.And they aren‟t necessarily “social.” jhoron@umich.edu
  • 39. Building BlocksNodes [Vertices] – People, Things, IdeasLinks [Edges] – Relationships or jhoron@umich.edu
  • 40. Visualization jhoron@umich.edu
  • 41. Visualization jhoron@umich.edu
  • 42. Metrics – Degree Highest Degree jhoron@umich.edu
  • 43. Metrics – Degree – In-Degree Highest In-Degree “Popular” jhoron@umich.edu
  • 44. Metrics – Degree – Out-Degree Highest Out-Degree “Gregarious” jhoron@umich.edu
  • 45. Metrics – Betweenness jhoron@umich.edu
  • 46. Metrics – Betweenness Highest Betweenness “Bridge” “Commonalities” jhoron@umich.edu
  • 47. Metrics – Closeness Highest Closeness “Who could spread a rumor?” jhoron@umich.edu
  • 48. Metrics – Closeness jhoron@umich.edu
  • 49. Metrics – Eigenvector Centrality Highest Eigenvector Centrality “Importance” jhoron@umich.edu
  • 50. Metrics – Eigenvector Centrality Increasing Eigenvector Centralityjhoron@umich.edu
  • 51. Recap Degree (undirected): Number of connections In- / Out-Degree (directed): “Popular” / “Gregarious” Betweenness: “Bridges” / “Commonalities” Closeness: “Rumor starting point” Eigenvector Centrality: “Importance” jhoron@umich.edu
  • 52. Connect:People to Other PeopleThings/Ideas to Other Things/IdeasPeople to Things/Ideas jhoron@umich.edu
  • 53. Connect:People to Other PeopleThings/Ideas to Other Things/IdeasPeople to Things/Ideas to Other People jhoron@umich.edu
  • 54. Data You May Already HaveFaculty/Staff and Appointing DepartmentsFaculty/Staff and GroupsPrincipal Investigators and Sponsored ProjectsSponsored Projects and ParticipantsAuthors and PublicationsCitations jhoron@umich.edu
  • 55. Specific ExamplesThings/Ideas and Other Things/IdeasConcepts and Other Concepts in Publications and Sponsored Project Proposal / Award Data jhoron@umich.edu
  • 56. Specific ExamplesPeople and Things/IdeasPeople and Sponsored ProjectsAuthors and Publication Concepts jhoron@umich.edu
  • 57. Specific ExamplesPeople and Other PeopleCo-Participation on Sponsored Projects, Co-Authorship jhoron@umich.edu
  • 58. If the other attendees are starting to looklike this to you… jhoron@umich.edu
  • 59. Strategic Analysis: What are our top disease areas? jhoron@umich.edu
  • 60. Strategic Analysis: What are our top disease areas? Depression Center Brehm Center (Diabetes) Cardiovascular Center Pain Center Cancer Center jhoron@umich.edu
  • 61. Strategic Analysis: What are our top disease areas? Basic/Animal Science jhoron@umich.edu
  • 62. Strategic Analysis: Who can we build a program around? jhoron@umich.edu
  • 63. Recall: Metrics – Eigenvector Centralityjhoron@umich.edu
  • 64. Strategic Analysis: Who can we build a program around? jhoron@umich.edu
  • 65. „Macro‟ Use Cases Funding, Funding, Funding, F-u-n-d-i-n-g System: RFA targeting Ad Hoc: Supporting program project applications jhoron@umich.edu
  • 66. RFA Targeting Mass e-mail, likely to be New funding ignoredannouncement, RFA, opportunity, initiative (or Targeted, personalized e-mails other text) jhoron@umich.edu
  • 67. RFA Targeting jhoron@umich.edu
  • 68. RFA Targeting jhoron@umich.edu
  • 69. RFA Targeting Led to design of an automated matching process using SciVal Funding (currently being beta tested): jhoron@umich.edu
  • 70. Supporting program project applications Data-gathering challenge at the limits of „human scale‟ • # true/false values = (# investigators2 - # investigators) (# types of working relationships) • 100 investigators, 1 type of relationship = 9,900 values Researcher Researcher Researcher Researcher 1 2 3 4 Researcher --- 1 Researcher Co-author: Y --- 2 Co-grant: N Researcher Co-author: N Co-author: Y --- 3 Co-grant: N Co-grant: Y Researcher Co-author: N Co-author: N Co-author: Y --- 4 Co-grant: Y Co-grant: Y Co-grant: Y jhoron@umich.edu
  • 71. Supporting program project applications jhoron@umich.edu
  • 72. Supporting program project applications jhoron@umich.edu
  • 73. Supporting program project applications P30 collaboration network jhoron@umich.edu
  • 74. Supporting program project applications P30 collaboration network demonstrates that PI (center) bridges multiple clusters of researchers jhoron@umich.edu
  • 75. SciVal Experts at the Univeristy of Michigan National Research Networks Participation in SciVal Experts community and national network search at no additional cost or effort jhoron@umich.edu
  • 76. Future of SciVal Experts at the University of MichiganUniversity Research Corridor (URC) -Michigan State University -Wayne State University -University of MichiganCurrently in development discussions with business engagement and research groups from all three institutionsPlan is to combine implementations of SciVal Experts across the three institutions, but customized into a business development portalOrganized by strategic initiatives that URC is pursuing, not by organizational structure, such as clean water, stem cell research and more jhoron@umich.edu
  • 77. Scopus-based version beyond the Medical School Can we do this for the whole University? 16,500 peer-reviewed journals (including more than 1,200 Open Access journals) Extensive conference coverage (3.6 million conference papers) 600 trade publications 350 book series Elsevier Thesauri Model of publication-driven expertise isn‟t a perfect match for all departments jhoron@umich.edu
  • 78. Scopus-based version beyond the Medical School Elsevier Thesauri …. enables… jhoron@umich.edu
  • 79. Scopus-based version beyond the Medical Schooljhoron@umich.edu
  • 80. jhoron@umich.edu
  • 81. ResourcesSciVal Experts for the University of Michigan:http://www.experts.scival.com/umichiganElsevier SciVal Experts Info Site:http://www.info.scival.com/expertsNodeXLhttp://nodexl.codeplex.com-Microsoft Research and University Collaborators-Installs as an Excel 2007+ Template-Free, easy, and powerful with top-notch visualization jhoron@umich.edu

×