SlideShare a Scribd company logo
1 of 6
Download to read offline
Fred P. Hochberg
President
Export-Import Bank of the United States
Washington, D.C.
[Via e-mail]

May 10, 2010

Re: Pascua Lama

Dear President Hochberg,

It has come to our attention that the Ex-Im Bank has received a request to finance the
binational Pascua Lama mine. We are writing to strongly urge that the Ex-Im Bank
reject financing for the Pascua Lama mine.

The Pascua Lama project company, Barrick Gold, has taken a number of actions that
have caused significant environmental, social and human rights impacts, and that
undermine Chilean institutions and laws. These actions threaten the last remaining
fertile valley in the Atacama Desert, an area that is inhabited by seventy thousand
people, whose well-being is directly linked to the thriving agricultural economy.
Moreover, these actions raise serious doubts regarding the company’s compliance with
Ex-Im Bank policies.

I. Barrick Gold’s Pascua Lama mining project has promoted a weakening of
Chilean environmental institutions and laws. The Free Trade Agreement
negotiated between Chile and the United States identified the need to strengthen
this same regulatory apparatus.

1. Environmental assessment

The company deliberately undermined the Chilean environmental impact assessment
system (SEIA) by dividing the Pascua Lama project into parts, which it presented
separately for evaluation. At least five components have been assessed independently of
the mineral extraction project, following approval of the latter.1 This strategy allowed
the company to minimize the overall impact of the project and to hide its inter-regional
character, thereby avoiding an environmental evaluation at the national level (as
opposed to the less complex regional assessment). In addition, the company was able to
submit relatively small projects to the evaluation system, which involve a much simpler
procedure (“simple declaration”) than if the project had been considered as a whole.


1
 Extension and Improvement of the Transmission Line Punta Colorada-Tres Quebradas environmental permit
https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=2464432
Thermoelectric Center Punto Colorada environmental permit
https://www.e-seia.cl/archivos/962_111.pdf
Access Roads and High Tension Lines for the Nevada and El Indio Projects environmental permit
https://www.e-seia.cl/expediente/expedientesEvaluacion.php?modo=ficha&id_expediente=48
Vallenar Logistics Center environmental permit
https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=1641285
Limestone Quarry environmental permit
https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=3738154
2. Appearance of corruption and conflict of interest

Pascua Lama has promoted corruption among Chilean authorities, including regional
authorities involved in project approval, local leaders and communities.

a.     Barrick silenced the principal farmers’ organization2 in the Huasco Valley by
       giving its management money. In June 2005, eight of the organization’s directors
       met with the company to sign an Agreement Protocol, which provides that Barrick
       Gold will pay the organization $60 million. The money is to be administered by
       the organization’s directors, the regional “Intendente”3 and other public
       authorities who are involved in the project approval process. In exchange for the
       payment, the organization agreed to end its opposition to the project. The
       agreement was recognized as illegitimate by the national government. Under
       Chilean law, organizations of water-users are required to ratify such agreements in
       formal assemblies. The Barrick agreement has never received such sanction.
       While the government recognized the agreement’s invalidity, it declined to
       intervene in what it characterized as a private matter.4

b.     Barrick gave money to government authorities who were involved in the
       environmental approval process for the project. In 2005, the company announced
       the creation of a “Sustainable Development” Foundation for which it established a
       $10 million fund.5 The Foundation was to be presided over by the Regional
       “Intendente,” who is also responsible for the Regional Environment Commission
       (COREMA), the state entity that issues project environmental permits. The
       environmental permit for the Pascua Lama project was approved in February 2006
       by COREMA, following Barrick’s announcement. Thus far, no information has
       been publicly disseminated regarding the creation of the Foundation, although
       payments have been made to public entities.6

c.     Barrick sought public financing for infrastructure projects intended for its private
       use, two years before it initiated the environmental approval process for the
       Pascua Lama project. Barrick succeeded in obtaining an agreement with the
       regional government of Atacama, dated December 22, 1998, regarding the
       surfacing of roads for the mine project.7 The same government was later involved
       in the approval process for Pascua Lama. The agreement concerned the use of 10
       billion pesos (approximately $21 million) for works that favored Barrick and
       prejudiced local residents. Increased commercial traffic on the narrow,
       mountainous roads that were paved under the agreement has curtained the ability
       of locals to employ these surfaces for traditional uses, such as the movement of
       livestock.




2
  Organization of those who hold water rights or “regantes.”
3
  Representative of the President of the Republic.
4
  DGA report that sets out the illegality of the agreement:
http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/dictamen_DGA_protocolo.pdf
5
  http://www.olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama36.htm
6
  See, for example, http://www.barricksudamerica.com/noticias/detalle_comunicados.php?id=314&info=Noticias
http://www.barricksudamerica.com/minera/atacama.php
7
  Text of the agreement http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/convenio_de_cofinanciamiento.pdf
d.      All of the municipalities located in the province of Huasco received money and
        other forms of support from Barrick prior to the approval of its EIA.8 These
        municipalities participated in the EIA approval process.


II. The project does not comply with Chilean environmental legislation.

1. Noncompliance with environmental permit

One month after the Pascua Lama mining project was initiated, serious irregularities
were identified during the first project inspection. The Environmental Qualification
Resolution (RCA) for the project (No. 024, February 16, 2006)9 states that “the holder
shall access the mineral resource, and works associated with the development of the
project in the area of glaciers Toro 1, Toro 2 and Esperanza (shall be undertaken), in a
manner that does not produce the removal, transfer, destruction or any other physical
intervention in (the glaciers).”

a.      In response to a report10 prepared by the Operative Control Committee,11 the
        Regional Environment Commission (COREMA) initiated a process12 to sanction
        the company for its failure to comply with the basic conditions established under
        its Environmental Qualification Resolution.13 Irregularities include the illegal
        extraction of water and an increase in the presence of particulate matter. The latter
        reflects the company’s failure to employ appropriate mitigation methods to
        prevent irreversible damage to neighboring glaciers. Under the project’s RCA, as
        indicated above, the company is obliged to protect both hydrological resources
        and glaciers.

b.      In its visit to the project site in November 2009, the Operative Control Committee
        also discovered the presence of an “unforeseen environmental impact” to the El
        Estrecho glacier that was not reported by the company. This violation of the
        company’s environmental permit (Environmental Qualification Resolution) has
        not yet received sanction. The damage to El Estrecho, which was not considered
        in the initial environmental evaluation process, may signal the need for a new
        project review.

2. Glacial damage

Barrick Gold caused significant damage to three Andean glaciers before beginning mine
construction. In its report of January 12, 2005, the General Water Department of the

8
  For example, see http://www.olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama54.htm
9
  Pascua Lama environmental permit https://www.e-
seia.cl/externos/admin_seia_web/archivos/6316_2006_2_15_RE.pdf
10
   DGA report regarding inspection of Pascua Lama
https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=4286234
11
   The Operative Control Committee (Comité Operativo de Fiscalización), which is coordinated by the National
Environment Commission (CONAMA), assesses compliance with Environmental Qualification Resolutions for
projects that are approved through the SEIA.
12
   Resolution that initiates sanction process against Pascua Lama
https://www.e-seia.cl/externos/sanciones/archivos/SAN__idExp1048260_idSan1963.PDF
13
   The RCA is the environmental permit issued by the Regional Environment Commission (COREMA) once the
environmental evaluation for a project has been completed. This document normally includes a summary of the
project, presents the most relevant environmental impacts, identifies required activities and establishes a technical
guide for the execution of the project.
Ministry of Public Works14 described the presence of “dirt on the surface of the
glaciers,” “loss of (glacial) mass” and the “removal” of ice from glaciers. The report
includes measurements indicating the significant reductions in mass experienced by
several glaciers. All of these impacts are directly attributed by the Department to the
activities of the company.

In a letter to the regional director of the National Environment Commission
(CONAMA) from Barrick’s subsidiary, Compañía Minera Nevada Ltda., dated
September 22, 2005, the company reports undertaking activities that have caused
irreversible damage to the glaciers Toro I, Toro II and Esperanza.15 On page 5 the letter
reads, "we are continuing with the construction of roads in the Cerro Esperanza area to
identify reserves and we’re drilling at 13 points on the glacier of the same name.” On
page 6: “during this time, we placed gravel on a strip approximately 3 meters wide and
100 meters long on glaciers Toro 1 and Toro 2 in order to drive on the glaciers without
affecting them (…) In the case of Toro 1, the snow that falls each year on this strip is
removed so that we can drive on the strip.”

In addition, Barrick plans to locate its waste rock impoundment, which will receive 1.2
billion metric tons of rock, in the headwaters of the El Estrecho River. Exposure of this
rock will result in the release of heavy metals and acid mine drainage. Moreover, the
impoundment site coincides with the presence of a “rock glacier”, which will be buried
under the company’s waste.16


III. Barrick Gold has systematically violated the human rights of the inhabitants of
the Huasco Valley.

1. Thus far, fifteen of the company’s workers have died. These deaths were hidden by
Barrick until 2008, when local communities forced the company to disclose relevant
information, although the company has still not revealed the names of the deceased or
the cause of their deaths.17

2. The ancestral rights of the indigenous Diaguita Huascoaltina community have been
violated. The community submitted a complaint before the Inter-American Commission
on Human Rights against the Chilean state, accusing it of “denial of justice.” This is
based on the failure of national tribunals in Chile to address Diaguita complaints
regarding the inclusion of their territory in Barrick Gold’s mining concessions and the
fact that they were not consulted about this decision. The complaint was declared
admissible by the Commission.18

3. The Pascua Lama project continues to illegally block a public road, making the
passage of local vehicles and persons impossible and preventing traditional activities in
the area, such as the movement of livestock.19
14
   DGA report regarding inspection of Pascua Lama
http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/informe_comision_servicio_a_III_region.pdf
15
   Letter dated September 22, 2005 http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/barrick_glaciares.pdf
16
   Report regarding impact on rock glacier
http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/informe_botadero_sobre_glaciar_de_roca.pdf
17
   Barrick statement http://www.noapascualama.org/info.asp?Ob=9&Id=84
18
   Commission decision http://www.cidh.oas.org/annualrep/2009sp/Chile415-07.sp.htm
19
   Regional Secretary of Public Works denounces obstruction of a public road
https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=4246843
IV. Local, national and international resistance.

The Huasco Valley community has remained fiercely opposed to the Pascua Lama
project for over ten years. At first, this resistance was concentrated at the local level.
Later, local convictions and solid arguments took the struggle to the national and
international levels. Since 2005, the annual “March for Water and Life” has taken place
in Vallenar, bringing together more people than any other event in the area. Moreover,
numerous carnivals, artistic presentations, conferences, protests, Catholic masses,
pilgrimages, meetings, debates and international awareness-building campaigns have
taken place with regard to the project. Pascua Lama has motivated more university-level
theses, reports and independent documentary films than any other social /
environmental conflict in Chile. These efforts seek to counter the biased and polemic
media coverage that Barrick Gold’s project has received.

Despite having been deceived by their authorities, ignored by the mass media and
threatened daily by public institutions and the company, communities in the Huasco
Valley have pursued legal, academic and cultural initiatives over ten years to express
their opposition to this project and to raise awareness. These efforts have succeeded in
exposing the damage that Pascua Lama implies and in highlighting the importance of
self determination and the exercise of citizen rights in such conflicts.20


President Hochberg, given the information described above (which only addresses the
impacts of the project on the Chilean side of the binational Pascua Lama project), we
urge you to reject financing for this project, thereby avoiding responsibility for the illicit
actions that have been carried out by the project proponent and preventing American
resources from supporting the destruction of the Huasco Valley and the glacial
ecosystems of the Andean cordillera.

We would be pleased to provide you with further information and to meet with you. We
encourage you to visit the Huasco Valley and we await your response to this letter.

Yours truly,

Observatorio Latinoamericano de Conflictos Ambientales – OLCA

Agrupación Ecológica Atacama Limpio – Vallenar, Región de Atacama
Alianza por una Mejor Calidad de Vida RAP-AL, Chile
Centro Cultural Social y del Medio Ambiente Ceibo – Maipú, RM
Centro Ecoceanos - Chile
Columban Center for Advocacy and Outreach (USA)
Comité de Defensa del Valle de Chuchiñi – Salamanca, Región de Coquimbo
Comité Esperanza de Vida – Alto del Carmen, Región de Atacama
Consejo de Defensa del Valle del Huasco- Región de Atacama
Coordinadora Contra Pascua Lama - Santiago

20
     http://www.olca.cl/oca/chile/pascualama.htm
Corporación de Defensa y Promoción de los Derechos del Pueblo, CODEPU-Chile
Acción por los Cisnes - Valdivia - Región de los Ríos
La Coalición Ecuménica por el Cuidado de la Creación - Chile
Centro Ecuménico Diego de Medellín
Departamento de Paz Justicia e Integridad de la Creación, CONFERRE-Chile
El Comité de Defensa y Recuperación del Cobre - Chile
Organización Ciudadana Ambiental de Salamanca, OCAS – Región de Coquimbo
Oficina de Justicia, Paz e Integridad de la Creación. Sociedad Misionera de San
Columbano
Pastoral Salvaguarda de la Creación – Alto del Carmen, Valle del Huasco
Red Ciudadana por la Defensa de la Precordillera de Santiago, RM Chile



Cc:

Chairman Barney Frank
House Committee on Financial Services

Chairman Christopher Dodd
Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs

Eric Siegel
President and CEO
Export Development Canada

Doug Norlen
Pacific Environment

Karyn Keenan
Halifax Initiative

More Related Content

Similar to Pascua lama

USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...
USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...
USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...Graeme Donaldson
 
Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04
Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04
Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04rahsco3
 
RadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdf
RadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdfRadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdf
RadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdfStopForeverWipp
 
Petrobras presentation
Petrobras presentationPetrobras presentation
Petrobras presentationManu Caddie
 
Renewing natural processes_in_an_urban_area
Renewing natural processes_in_an_urban_areaRenewing natural processes_in_an_urban_area
Renewing natural processes_in_an_urban_areaaslfadmin
 
IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16
IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16
IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16Graeme Donaldson
 
Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...
Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...
Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...LOWaterkeeper
 
Port lavaca desalination study
Port lavaca desalination studyPort lavaca desalination study
Port lavaca desalination studyJeffrey Pickett
 
IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15
IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15
IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15Graeme Donaldson
 
Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...
Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...
Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...LOWaterkeeper
 
The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...
The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...
The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...Michelle Brown
 
Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15
Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15
Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15Lori Trottier, AICP
 
Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...
Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...
Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...LOWaterkeeper
 
San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006
San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006
San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006rahsco3
 
Water Management and Flood Mitigation
Water Management and Flood MitigationWater Management and Flood Mitigation
Water Management and Flood Mitigationpaul young cpa, cga
 

Similar to Pascua lama (20)

Fracking Essay Due December 1st
Fracking Essay Due December 1stFracking Essay Due December 1st
Fracking Essay Due December 1st
 
USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...
USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...
USCID conference in San Diego May 17-20, 2016_GrD Salton Sea update presentat...
 
Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04
Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04
Environmental Cleaning Update 2-13-04
 
Keystone XL Feedback
Keystone XL FeedbackKeystone XL Feedback
Keystone XL Feedback
 
RadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdf
RadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdfRadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdf
RadHaz SRIC Testimony 080522.pdf
 
Picatinny2
Picatinny2Picatinny2
Picatinny2
 
Petrobras presentation
Petrobras presentationPetrobras presentation
Petrobras presentation
 
Renewing natural processes_in_an_urban_area
Renewing natural processes_in_an_urban_areaRenewing natural processes_in_an_urban_area
Renewing natural processes_in_an_urban_area
 
IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16
IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16
IID Quechan Tribe_Salton Sea update-5.4.16
 
Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...
Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...
Swim Drink Fish Canada submission for relicensing written hearing for the Del...
 
Port lavaca desalination study
Port lavaca desalination studyPort lavaca desalination study
Port lavaca desalination study
 
IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15
IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15
IID WCAC_Salton Sea update-12.10.15_GrD final-12.9.15
 
Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...
Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...
Submission of Lake Ontario Waterkeeper - Reviewing Canadian Nuclear Safety Co...
 
The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...
The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...
The Importance Of Comprehensive Site Investigations And...
 
Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15
Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15
Lori_Trottier_Project list_2-7-15
 
storage tanks
storage tanksstorage tanks
storage tanks
 
Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...
Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...
Waterkeeper's Review of CNSC's Regulatory Oversight Report for Uranium and Nu...
 
San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006
San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006
San Antonio Environmental Seminar August 2006
 
Water Management and Flood Mitigation
Water Management and Flood MitigationWater Management and Flood Mitigation
Water Management and Flood Mitigation
 
Superfund sites
Superfund sitesSuperfund sites
Superfund sites
 

More from Jaume Satorra

Generalitat de catalunya
Generalitat de catalunyaGeneralitat de catalunya
Generalitat de catalunyaJaume Satorra
 
informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...
informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...
informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...Jaume Satorra
 
Resolucion del Ministerio de Defensa
Resolucion del Ministerio de  DefensaResolucion del Ministerio de  Defensa
Resolucion del Ministerio de DefensaJaume Satorra
 
Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...
Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...
Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...Jaume Satorra
 
Cincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestation
Cincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestationCincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestation
Cincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestationJaume Satorra
 
Carolina c.punset diputada en el parlamento europeo
Carolina c.punset   diputada en el parlamento europeoCarolina c.punset   diputada en el parlamento europeo
Carolina c.punset diputada en el parlamento europeoJaume Satorra
 
Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019
Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019
Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019Jaume Satorra
 
Plan anula antartico 2017 2018
Plan anula antartico 2017 2018Plan anula antartico 2017 2018
Plan anula antartico 2017 2018Jaume Satorra
 
Ministerio de educacion cultura y deporte
Ministerio de educacion cultura y deporteMinisterio de educacion cultura y deporte
Ministerio de educacion cultura y deporteJaume Satorra
 
Un funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy bey
Un funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy beyUn funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy bey
Un funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy beyJaume Satorra
 
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritasLos provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritasJaume Satorra
 
La corrupción de la marca españa
La corrupción de la marca españaLa corrupción de la marca españa
La corrupción de la marca españaJaume Satorra
 
Mas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunya
Mas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunyaMas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunya
Mas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunyaJaume Satorra
 
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritasLos provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritasJaume Satorra
 
Informe Trabajo en el Mundo
Informe Trabajo en el MundoInforme Trabajo en el Mundo
Informe Trabajo en el MundoJaume Satorra
 

More from Jaume Satorra (20)

Generalitat de catalunya
Generalitat de catalunyaGeneralitat de catalunya
Generalitat de catalunya
 
informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...
informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...
informe de la Federació internacional pels drets humans denuncia ‘serioses ir...
 
Consell de l'europe
Consell de l'europeConsell de l'europe
Consell de l'europe
 
Resolucion del Ministerio de Defensa
Resolucion del Ministerio de  DefensaResolucion del Ministerio de  Defensa
Resolucion del Ministerio de Defensa
 
Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...
Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...
Manifiesto de-miguel-primo-de-rivera-publicado-en-abc-el-14-de-septiembre-de-...
 
Cincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestation
Cincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestationCincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestation
Cincia research-brief-1-three-decades-of-deforestation
 
Carolina c.punset diputada en el parlamento europeo
Carolina c.punset   diputada en el parlamento europeoCarolina c.punset   diputada en el parlamento europeo
Carolina c.punset diputada en el parlamento europeo
 
Tribunal supremo
Tribunal supremoTribunal supremo
Tribunal supremo
 
Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019
Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019
Presupuestos generales del Estado 2019
 
Plan anula antartico 2017 2018
Plan anula antartico 2017 2018Plan anula antartico 2017 2018
Plan anula antartico 2017 2018
 
Ministerio de educacion cultura y deporte
Ministerio de educacion cultura y deporteMinisterio de educacion cultura y deporte
Ministerio de educacion cultura y deporte
 
Un funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy bey
Un funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy beyUn funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy bey
Un funcionario en funciones llamado mariano rajoy bey
 
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritasLos provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
 
La corrupción de la marca españa
La corrupción de la marca españaLa corrupción de la marca españa
La corrupción de la marca españa
 
Wiki manresa
Wiki   manresaWiki   manresa
Wiki manresa
 
Mas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunya
Mas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunyaMas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunya
Mas conversaciones historico politicas sobre catalunya
 
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritasLos provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
Los provocadores bolcheviques de caritas
 
Informe Trabajo en el Mundo
Informe Trabajo en el MundoInforme Trabajo en el Mundo
Informe Trabajo en el Mundo
 
Resumen Informe
Resumen InformeResumen Informe
Resumen Informe
 
Pegaso
PegasoPegaso
Pegaso
 

Pascua lama

  • 1. Fred P. Hochberg President Export-Import Bank of the United States Washington, D.C. [Via e-mail] May 10, 2010 Re: Pascua Lama Dear President Hochberg, It has come to our attention that the Ex-Im Bank has received a request to finance the binational Pascua Lama mine. We are writing to strongly urge that the Ex-Im Bank reject financing for the Pascua Lama mine. The Pascua Lama project company, Barrick Gold, has taken a number of actions that have caused significant environmental, social and human rights impacts, and that undermine Chilean institutions and laws. These actions threaten the last remaining fertile valley in the Atacama Desert, an area that is inhabited by seventy thousand people, whose well-being is directly linked to the thriving agricultural economy. Moreover, these actions raise serious doubts regarding the company’s compliance with Ex-Im Bank policies. I. Barrick Gold’s Pascua Lama mining project has promoted a weakening of Chilean environmental institutions and laws. The Free Trade Agreement negotiated between Chile and the United States identified the need to strengthen this same regulatory apparatus. 1. Environmental assessment The company deliberately undermined the Chilean environmental impact assessment system (SEIA) by dividing the Pascua Lama project into parts, which it presented separately for evaluation. At least five components have been assessed independently of the mineral extraction project, following approval of the latter.1 This strategy allowed the company to minimize the overall impact of the project and to hide its inter-regional character, thereby avoiding an environmental evaluation at the national level (as opposed to the less complex regional assessment). In addition, the company was able to submit relatively small projects to the evaluation system, which involve a much simpler procedure (“simple declaration”) than if the project had been considered as a whole. 1 Extension and Improvement of the Transmission Line Punta Colorada-Tres Quebradas environmental permit https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=2464432 Thermoelectric Center Punto Colorada environmental permit https://www.e-seia.cl/archivos/962_111.pdf Access Roads and High Tension Lines for the Nevada and El Indio Projects environmental permit https://www.e-seia.cl/expediente/expedientesEvaluacion.php?modo=ficha&id_expediente=48 Vallenar Logistics Center environmental permit https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=1641285 Limestone Quarry environmental permit https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=3738154
  • 2. 2. Appearance of corruption and conflict of interest Pascua Lama has promoted corruption among Chilean authorities, including regional authorities involved in project approval, local leaders and communities. a. Barrick silenced the principal farmers’ organization2 in the Huasco Valley by giving its management money. In June 2005, eight of the organization’s directors met with the company to sign an Agreement Protocol, which provides that Barrick Gold will pay the organization $60 million. The money is to be administered by the organization’s directors, the regional “Intendente”3 and other public authorities who are involved in the project approval process. In exchange for the payment, the organization agreed to end its opposition to the project. The agreement was recognized as illegitimate by the national government. Under Chilean law, organizations of water-users are required to ratify such agreements in formal assemblies. The Barrick agreement has never received such sanction. While the government recognized the agreement’s invalidity, it declined to intervene in what it characterized as a private matter.4 b. Barrick gave money to government authorities who were involved in the environmental approval process for the project. In 2005, the company announced the creation of a “Sustainable Development” Foundation for which it established a $10 million fund.5 The Foundation was to be presided over by the Regional “Intendente,” who is also responsible for the Regional Environment Commission (COREMA), the state entity that issues project environmental permits. The environmental permit for the Pascua Lama project was approved in February 2006 by COREMA, following Barrick’s announcement. Thus far, no information has been publicly disseminated regarding the creation of the Foundation, although payments have been made to public entities.6 c. Barrick sought public financing for infrastructure projects intended for its private use, two years before it initiated the environmental approval process for the Pascua Lama project. Barrick succeeded in obtaining an agreement with the regional government of Atacama, dated December 22, 1998, regarding the surfacing of roads for the mine project.7 The same government was later involved in the approval process for Pascua Lama. The agreement concerned the use of 10 billion pesos (approximately $21 million) for works that favored Barrick and prejudiced local residents. Increased commercial traffic on the narrow, mountainous roads that were paved under the agreement has curtained the ability of locals to employ these surfaces for traditional uses, such as the movement of livestock. 2 Organization of those who hold water rights or “regantes.” 3 Representative of the President of the Republic. 4 DGA report that sets out the illegality of the agreement: http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/dictamen_DGA_protocolo.pdf 5 http://www.olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama36.htm 6 See, for example, http://www.barricksudamerica.com/noticias/detalle_comunicados.php?id=314&info=Noticias http://www.barricksudamerica.com/minera/atacama.php 7 Text of the agreement http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/convenio_de_cofinanciamiento.pdf
  • 3. d. All of the municipalities located in the province of Huasco received money and other forms of support from Barrick prior to the approval of its EIA.8 These municipalities participated in the EIA approval process. II. The project does not comply with Chilean environmental legislation. 1. Noncompliance with environmental permit One month after the Pascua Lama mining project was initiated, serious irregularities were identified during the first project inspection. The Environmental Qualification Resolution (RCA) for the project (No. 024, February 16, 2006)9 states that “the holder shall access the mineral resource, and works associated with the development of the project in the area of glaciers Toro 1, Toro 2 and Esperanza (shall be undertaken), in a manner that does not produce the removal, transfer, destruction or any other physical intervention in (the glaciers).” a. In response to a report10 prepared by the Operative Control Committee,11 the Regional Environment Commission (COREMA) initiated a process12 to sanction the company for its failure to comply with the basic conditions established under its Environmental Qualification Resolution.13 Irregularities include the illegal extraction of water and an increase in the presence of particulate matter. The latter reflects the company’s failure to employ appropriate mitigation methods to prevent irreversible damage to neighboring glaciers. Under the project’s RCA, as indicated above, the company is obliged to protect both hydrological resources and glaciers. b. In its visit to the project site in November 2009, the Operative Control Committee also discovered the presence of an “unforeseen environmental impact” to the El Estrecho glacier that was not reported by the company. This violation of the company’s environmental permit (Environmental Qualification Resolution) has not yet received sanction. The damage to El Estrecho, which was not considered in the initial environmental evaluation process, may signal the need for a new project review. 2. Glacial damage Barrick Gold caused significant damage to three Andean glaciers before beginning mine construction. In its report of January 12, 2005, the General Water Department of the 8 For example, see http://www.olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama54.htm 9 Pascua Lama environmental permit https://www.e- seia.cl/externos/admin_seia_web/archivos/6316_2006_2_15_RE.pdf 10 DGA report regarding inspection of Pascua Lama https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=4286234 11 The Operative Control Committee (Comité Operativo de Fiscalización), which is coordinated by the National Environment Commission (CONAMA), assesses compliance with Environmental Qualification Resolutions for projects that are approved through the SEIA. 12 Resolution that initiates sanction process against Pascua Lama https://www.e-seia.cl/externos/sanciones/archivos/SAN__idExp1048260_idSan1963.PDF 13 The RCA is the environmental permit issued by the Regional Environment Commission (COREMA) once the environmental evaluation for a project has been completed. This document normally includes a summary of the project, presents the most relevant environmental impacts, identifies required activities and establishes a technical guide for the execution of the project.
  • 4. Ministry of Public Works14 described the presence of “dirt on the surface of the glaciers,” “loss of (glacial) mass” and the “removal” of ice from glaciers. The report includes measurements indicating the significant reductions in mass experienced by several glaciers. All of these impacts are directly attributed by the Department to the activities of the company. In a letter to the regional director of the National Environment Commission (CONAMA) from Barrick’s subsidiary, Compañía Minera Nevada Ltda., dated September 22, 2005, the company reports undertaking activities that have caused irreversible damage to the glaciers Toro I, Toro II and Esperanza.15 On page 5 the letter reads, "we are continuing with the construction of roads in the Cerro Esperanza area to identify reserves and we’re drilling at 13 points on the glacier of the same name.” On page 6: “during this time, we placed gravel on a strip approximately 3 meters wide and 100 meters long on glaciers Toro 1 and Toro 2 in order to drive on the glaciers without affecting them (…) In the case of Toro 1, the snow that falls each year on this strip is removed so that we can drive on the strip.” In addition, Barrick plans to locate its waste rock impoundment, which will receive 1.2 billion metric tons of rock, in the headwaters of the El Estrecho River. Exposure of this rock will result in the release of heavy metals and acid mine drainage. Moreover, the impoundment site coincides with the presence of a “rock glacier”, which will be buried under the company’s waste.16 III. Barrick Gold has systematically violated the human rights of the inhabitants of the Huasco Valley. 1. Thus far, fifteen of the company’s workers have died. These deaths were hidden by Barrick until 2008, when local communities forced the company to disclose relevant information, although the company has still not revealed the names of the deceased or the cause of their deaths.17 2. The ancestral rights of the indigenous Diaguita Huascoaltina community have been violated. The community submitted a complaint before the Inter-American Commission on Human Rights against the Chilean state, accusing it of “denial of justice.” This is based on the failure of national tribunals in Chile to address Diaguita complaints regarding the inclusion of their territory in Barrick Gold’s mining concessions and the fact that they were not consulted about this decision. The complaint was declared admissible by the Commission.18 3. The Pascua Lama project continues to illegally block a public road, making the passage of local vehicles and persons impossible and preventing traditional activities in the area, such as the movement of livestock.19 14 DGA report regarding inspection of Pascua Lama http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/informe_comision_servicio_a_III_region.pdf 15 Letter dated September 22, 2005 http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/barrick_glaciares.pdf 16 Report regarding impact on rock glacier http://olca.cl/oca/chile/region03/pascualama/informe_botadero_sobre_glaciar_de_roca.pdf 17 Barrick statement http://www.noapascualama.org/info.asp?Ob=9&Id=84 18 Commission decision http://www.cidh.oas.org/annualrep/2009sp/Chile415-07.sp.htm 19 Regional Secretary of Public Works denounces obstruction of a public road https://www.e-seia.cl/documentos/documento.php?idDocumento=4246843
  • 5. IV. Local, national and international resistance. The Huasco Valley community has remained fiercely opposed to the Pascua Lama project for over ten years. At first, this resistance was concentrated at the local level. Later, local convictions and solid arguments took the struggle to the national and international levels. Since 2005, the annual “March for Water and Life” has taken place in Vallenar, bringing together more people than any other event in the area. Moreover, numerous carnivals, artistic presentations, conferences, protests, Catholic masses, pilgrimages, meetings, debates and international awareness-building campaigns have taken place with regard to the project. Pascua Lama has motivated more university-level theses, reports and independent documentary films than any other social / environmental conflict in Chile. These efforts seek to counter the biased and polemic media coverage that Barrick Gold’s project has received. Despite having been deceived by their authorities, ignored by the mass media and threatened daily by public institutions and the company, communities in the Huasco Valley have pursued legal, academic and cultural initiatives over ten years to express their opposition to this project and to raise awareness. These efforts have succeeded in exposing the damage that Pascua Lama implies and in highlighting the importance of self determination and the exercise of citizen rights in such conflicts.20 President Hochberg, given the information described above (which only addresses the impacts of the project on the Chilean side of the binational Pascua Lama project), we urge you to reject financing for this project, thereby avoiding responsibility for the illicit actions that have been carried out by the project proponent and preventing American resources from supporting the destruction of the Huasco Valley and the glacial ecosystems of the Andean cordillera. We would be pleased to provide you with further information and to meet with you. We encourage you to visit the Huasco Valley and we await your response to this letter. Yours truly, Observatorio Latinoamericano de Conflictos Ambientales – OLCA Agrupación Ecológica Atacama Limpio – Vallenar, Región de Atacama Alianza por una Mejor Calidad de Vida RAP-AL, Chile Centro Cultural Social y del Medio Ambiente Ceibo – Maipú, RM Centro Ecoceanos - Chile Columban Center for Advocacy and Outreach (USA) Comité de Defensa del Valle de Chuchiñi – Salamanca, Región de Coquimbo Comité Esperanza de Vida – Alto del Carmen, Región de Atacama Consejo de Defensa del Valle del Huasco- Región de Atacama Coordinadora Contra Pascua Lama - Santiago 20 http://www.olca.cl/oca/chile/pascualama.htm
  • 6. Corporación de Defensa y Promoción de los Derechos del Pueblo, CODEPU-Chile Acción por los Cisnes - Valdivia - Región de los Ríos La Coalición Ecuménica por el Cuidado de la Creación - Chile Centro Ecuménico Diego de Medellín Departamento de Paz Justicia e Integridad de la Creación, CONFERRE-Chile El Comité de Defensa y Recuperación del Cobre - Chile Organización Ciudadana Ambiental de Salamanca, OCAS – Región de Coquimbo Oficina de Justicia, Paz e Integridad de la Creación. Sociedad Misionera de San Columbano Pastoral Salvaguarda de la Creación – Alto del Carmen, Valle del Huasco Red Ciudadana por la Defensa de la Precordillera de Santiago, RM Chile Cc: Chairman Barney Frank House Committee on Financial Services Chairman Christopher Dodd Senate Committee on Banking, Housing and Urban Affairs Eric Siegel President and CEO Export Development Canada Doug Norlen Pacific Environment Karyn Keenan Halifax Initiative