Men and Boys in Gender Research
Brian Heilman, ICRW & Ruti Levtov, Promundo US
bheilman@icrw.org ; r.levtov@promundo.org.b...
Outline
• Introductions
• Rationale for engaging men and boys in gender
research and programming?
• Examples:
1. Primary r...
INTRODUCTIONS
WHAT IS THE RATIONALE
FOR ENGAGING MEN AND
BOYS IN GENDER
RESEARCH AND
PROGRAMMING?
• Understanding men and boys as
enmeshed in gender norms and
social expectations
• Aspects of masculinity that are harmful...
EXAMPLE 1: PRIMARY
RESEARCH
IMAGES
Why IMAGES?
• Few studies that ask men and women
about violence, health, life
circumstances
• Often we ask women about men...
Multi-country study on men, gender equality,
health and GBV, asking men and women
about practices and attitudes:
• To date...
IMAGES Design
• Sampling
– Generally followed methodology of WHO
multi-country study
– Size: ~700-2,300 men, ~400-1,300 wo...
Research Questions
• Are men on board with the
gender equality agenda?
• How much are men
participating in the care of
chi...
Questionnaire Genealogy
• Gender Equality and Quality of Life Study – Norway
• WHO Multi-country study on VAW
• GEM Scale ...
Overall Topics
• Attitudes toward gender roles, gender equality, and gender-
related policies
• Use of, and attitudes rela...
Structural
Socio-demographic and cultural
factors
Economic stress/employment
Household composition
Childhood experiences
M...
Adaptation
• 80-90% of questionnaire is the same
across countries, to allow for comparison
• “Optional” or added sections:...
Key Findings from IMAGES
• Violence creates violence – and the most traumatic form
is witnessing violence against mothers
...
Uses of the IMAGES Data
• To develop a global and national database and
assessment of men’s behaviors and attitudes with
a...
How have IMAGES Findings Been
Used for Advocacy Purposes?
• Brazil: Used to encourage Ministry of Health to start new
coll...
Links to Programs:
Women’s Economic Empowerment
Living Peace: Trauma support, identity
creation for men in partnership with women
Intergenerational Transmission: MenCare
“Evolving Men” – Initial Multi-Country Report:
http://www.icrw.org/publications/evolving-men
Most Recent Country Report: D...
EXAMPLE 2: EVALUATION
RESEARCH
YOUNG MEN’S INITIATIVE
Be a Man: Change the
Rules!
Findings and Lessons from
Seven Years of CARE
International Balkans’ Young
Men Initiative
• WHY promote healthy, nonviolent, and gender-equitable
lifestyles among adolescent boys in the Balkans region?
• WHAT is ...
WHY promote healthy, nonviolent, and
gender-equitable lifestyles among
adolescent boys in the Balkans region?
Conflict in
...
WHAT is the Young Men Initiative?
SITES:
- Belgrade (Serbia)
- Prishtina (Kosovo)
- Sarajevo (Bosnia)
- Zagreb (Croatia)
WHAT is the Young Men Initiative?
• Thorough revision/adaptation of Promundo’s
Program H
• Aligns to local gender norms
• ...
WHAT is the Young Men Initiative?
WHAT is the Young Men Initiative?
HOW did we evaluate YMI?
• Three guiding questions
• Mixed methods approach
• Quantitative: Self-administered questionnair...
HOW did we evaluate YMI?
• Sample details:
WHAT did we learn?
Guiding Questions:
1. How was the program implemented?
2. To what extent can we identify outcomes relat...
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women
INDEX Illustrative questions from GEM scale:
Gender Roles A woma...
** p<.05 *p<.10  significant difference between intervention & control at p<.05
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women
Retreats
proved
powerful
Patriarchal
norms are
still prevalent
R...
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 2: Interpersonal violence
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 2: Interpersonal violence
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 2: Interpersonal violence
Greater
program focus
on violence
could help
Longer
timeline
needed
Les...
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing
Some students
require extra
attention
Classroom
sessions and
retrea...
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 4: Drug & alcohol use
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 4: Drug & alcohol use
WHAT did we learn?
THEME 4: Drug & alcohol use
Social media
can be effective
in promoting
new behaviors
YMI alone may
be i...
WHAT did we learn?
Limitations:
Sample
attrition
Short time
frame
Social
desirability
bias
“Be a Man, Change the Rules” – Seven Year Summative Report:
http://www.icrw.org/files/publications/YMI_ExecutiveSummary_20...
EXAMPLE 3: EVALUATION
RESEARCH
GENDER EQUITY
MOVEMENT IN SCHOOLS
Fosters gender equality, redefines
masculinity & negates all forms of violence
to promote SRH of YA
GEMS
3. Teacher Sensit...
Content of
Group Education Activities
Gender Body Violence Relationships
GEMS Evaluation Design
754 students participated in all three rounds, while 909 participated in baseline and 2nd follow-
up
WHAT were the evaluation results?
Attitudes about
gender equality
improved
Outcome Outcome Process
1 2 3
Examples of positive shifts in gender
attitude
49
67
18
36
64
71
39
39
14
13
66
62
0
10
20
30
40
50
60
70
80
Baseline 2nd ...
Attitudes about
gender equality
improved
Students think
differently about
age of marriage
Outcome Outcome Process
1 2 3
WH...
Students suggesting 21 yrs or
more as appropriate age at
marriage for girls
* Diff sig. at p <0.05 compared to control
Attitudes about
gender equality
improved
Students think
differently about
age of marriage
GEA and
campaigns work
best toge...
The girl should study. She has the right to study. It is
illegal to get her married before the age of 18.
A boy from GEA+
...
GEMS Diary:
http://www.icrw.org/publications/my-gems-diary
Evaluation Results:
http://www.icrw.org/files/publications/GEMS...
Q & A
Additional Slides
on IMAGES
Attitudes about violence
70
0
20
40
60
80
100
Bosnia Brazil Chile Croatia DRC India Mexico Rwanda
%whoagreeorpartiallyagre...
IPV Perpetration
71
26.0 24.3
29.5
32.6
44.0
37.4
17.4
38.7
0
10
20
30
40
50
To end men’s use of violence we have
to pay attention to the violence in
boys’s lives
• 20% to 85% of men report having ex...
IMAGES Data Linked Directly to Programs…
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar

716

Published on

Presented as part of the IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar Series, hosted by the IFPRI Gender Task Force. Presenters: Brian Heilman & Ruti Levtov.

Published in: Government & Nonprofit
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
716
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
2
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
11
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Men and Boys in Gender Research - IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar

  1. 1. Men and Boys in Gender Research Brian Heilman, ICRW & Ruti Levtov, Promundo US bheilman@icrw.org ; r.levtov@promundo.org.br IFPRI Gender Methods Seminar August 4, 2014
  2. 2. Outline • Introductions • Rationale for engaging men and boys in gender research and programming? • Examples: 1. Primary research: IMAGES 2. Evaluation research: Young Men Initiative 3. Evaluation research: GEMS • Q&A
  3. 3. INTRODUCTIONS
  4. 4. WHAT IS THE RATIONALE FOR ENGAGING MEN AND BOYS IN GENDER RESEARCH AND PROGRAMMING?
  5. 5. • Understanding men and boys as enmeshed in gender norms and social expectations • Aspects of masculinity that are harmful to both men and women • Men too often seen from a deficit perspective and not enough as agents of change • Strong evidence that when done right, brings benefits for women, children and men themselves Our Approach
  6. 6. EXAMPLE 1: PRIMARY RESEARCH IMAGES
  7. 7. Why IMAGES? • Few studies that ask men and women about violence, health, life circumstances • Often we ask women about men but don’t ask men themselves • Seeking to understand lives of men in all their complexity
  8. 8. Multi-country study on men, gender equality, health and GBV, asking men and women about practices and attitudes: • To date, approximately 20,000 interviews in 9 countries completed • Brazil, India, Croatia, Chile, Mexico, Rwanda, Bosnia, DRC, Mali • In process: Malawi, Mozambique, Nigeria • “Sister” studies with Partners for Prevention: China, Bangladesh, Indonesia, Cambodia, PNG, Sri Lanka About IMAGES
  9. 9. IMAGES Design • Sampling – Generally followed methodology of WHO multi-country study – Size: ~700-2,300 men, ~400-1,300 women • Ethical considerations • In-person, paper surveys • Sex-matching of interviewers • Qualitative component
  10. 10. Research Questions • Are men on board with the gender equality agenda? • How much are men participating in the care of children and other domestic activities? • How common is men’s use of intimate partners violence? What factors are associated with this violence? • What do men think about laws and policies related to gender equality? • What are men’s current needs, vulnerabilities in terms of health, life conditions, and violence? • What is the impact of economic stress on men and gender relations? • New component: Exploring these issues in post- conflict settings
  11. 11. Questionnaire Genealogy • Gender Equality and Quality of Life Study – Norway • WHO Multi-country study on VAW • GEM Scale – used in over 20 countries, validated • Childhood Trauma Scale • DHS • Men, Health and Violence Study – South Africa – Medical Research Council • Evaluation studies from Promundo and ICRW
  12. 12. Overall Topics • Attitudes toward gender roles, gender equality, and gender- related policies • Use of, and attitudes related to, gender based violence • Health and health related practices • Household decision making and division of labor • Men’s participation in caregiving and as fathers • Transactional sex and paying for sex • Reports of criminal behavior, delinquency and childhood experiences of violence • Happiness and quality of life
  13. 13. Structural Socio-demographic and cultural factors Economic stress/employment Household composition Childhood experiences Men abused during childhood Childhood household gender dynamics Culture of and experiences of violence at school and neighborhood Gender attitudes GEM Scale Gender attitudes related to rights Related to women’s economic empowerment Exposure to policies and campaigns Fatherhood VAW Sexual diversity Women and children Marital status Length of relationship Partner’s socio-demographic characteristics Partner’s employment situation Number and age of children Previous unions Men’s Practices Violence Physical violence against partner Perpetration of sexual violence Involvement in criminal acts Parenting Participation in maternal health Taking paternity leave Caring for children Responsibilities with biological children Relationship dynamics Decision-making dynamics Participation in household tasks Couple communication Support abortion decision Health Sexuality SRH care Help and health-seeking behaviors Drugs and alcohol abuse Transactional sex Sexual relations with sex workers Transactional sex for goods
  14. 14. Adaptation • 80-90% of questionnaire is the same across countries, to allow for comparison • “Optional” or added sections: – Experiences of conflict – Measures of SES – Cultural practices – Family planning
  15. 15. Key Findings from IMAGES • Violence creates violence – and the most traumatic form is witnessing violence against mothers • Caregiving creates caregiving: men who see their fathers in caring relationships more likely to do same • Large portion of men with limited opportunities whose lives present vulnerabilities for themselves and for women • Gender attitudes matter – they predict use of violence, participation in household, caregiving, and satisfaction: • Men who buy into gender equality are happier and healthier - and their female partners are happier and healthier
  16. 16. Uses of the IMAGES Data • To develop a global and national database and assessment of men’s behaviors and attitudes with a standardized instrument • To provide a baseline or benchmark for monitoring changes in men’s behaviors and attitudes in line with various international processes, including CSW agreements and the Millenium Development Goals • For awareness-raising activities and advocacy nationally and internationally • For program development and planning
  17. 17. How have IMAGES Findings Been Used for Advocacy Purposes? • Brazil: Used to encourage Ministry of Health to start new collaboration with Promundo to engage men in MCH, violence interventions for men • Chile: Used to encourage the government to engage men in MCH and early childhood development as well as promote support for government funding for GBV prevention that includes reaching men and boys • Croatia: Presentations to government ministers key in promoting new more progressive sexuality education policies and governmental support to the Young Men’s Initiative
  18. 18. Links to Programs: Women’s Economic Empowerment
  19. 19. Living Peace: Trauma support, identity creation for men in partnership with women
  20. 20. Intergenerational Transmission: MenCare
  21. 21. “Evolving Men” – Initial Multi-Country Report: http://www.icrw.org/publications/evolving-men Most Recent Country Report: DRC http://www.promundo.org.br/en/wp-content/uploads/2013/01/DRC_IMAGES-FINAL.pdf New Analysis of Sexual Violence Perpetration with IMAGES data: http://www.icrw.org/publications/making-sexual-violence IMAGES central website w many reports/resources/q’aires: http://www.promundo.org.br/en/activities/activities-posts/international-men-and-gender- equality-survey-images-3/ “Bridges to Adulthood” – Links betw Childhood and Adult Violence in IMAGES data http://www.icrw.org/publications/bridges-adulthood
  22. 22. EXAMPLE 2: EVALUATION RESEARCH YOUNG MEN’S INITIATIVE
  23. 23. Be a Man: Change the Rules! Findings and Lessons from Seven Years of CARE International Balkans’ Young Men Initiative
  24. 24. • WHY promote healthy, nonviolent, and gender-equitable lifestyles among adolescent boys in the Balkans region? • WHAT is the Young Men Initiative? • HOW did we evaluate it? • WHAT did we learn? • THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women • THEME 2: Interpersonal violence • THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing • THEME 4: Drug and alcohol use Outline
  25. 25. WHY promote healthy, nonviolent, and gender-equitable lifestyles among adolescent boys in the Balkans region? Conflict in recent memory High levels of violence and violent attitudes Gaps in SRH knowledge
  26. 26. WHAT is the Young Men Initiative? SITES: - Belgrade (Serbia) - Prishtina (Kosovo) - Sarajevo (Bosnia) - Zagreb (Croatia)
  27. 27. WHAT is the Young Men Initiative? • Thorough revision/adaptation of Promundo’s Program H • Aligns to local gender norms • Redesigned to be delivered in high schools • Informed by formative “participatory action research” in 2007 • Activities: 24-hour cycles, maps of local youth spaces, 3D images of “masculinity” and “femininity”, power maps, more
  28. 28. WHAT is the Young Men Initiative?
  29. 29. WHAT is the Young Men Initiative?
  30. 30. HOW did we evaluate YMI? • Three guiding questions • Mixed methods approach • Quantitative: Self-administered questionnaire conducted at the beginning and end of the academic year • Qualitative: FGDs and IDIs with male students, school teachers, and program facilitators • Two cities per academic year: • 2011-2012: Sarajevo and Zagreb • 2012-2013: Belgrade and Prishtina • Comparison site in Prishtina
  31. 31. HOW did we evaluate YMI? • Sample details:
  32. 32. WHAT did we learn? Guiding Questions: 1. How was the program implemented? 2. To what extent can we identify outcomes related to the project’s four thematic areas? • THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women • THEME 2: Interpersonal violence • THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing • THEME 4: Drug and alcohol use 3. Did participating in the retreats – in addition to classroom sessions – produce any differential effect?
  33. 33. WHAT did we learn? THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women
  34. 34. WHAT did we learn? THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women INDEX Illustrative questions from GEM scale: Gender Roles A woman’s most important role is to take care of the home and cook for the family […4 items included] Gender Norms (masculinity) The most important quality for a man is physical strength and power [… 3 items included] Homophobia I would never have a gay friend [… 3 items included] Violence Against Women It is OKAY for a man to hit his wife if she refuses to have sex [… 4 items included]
  35. 35. ** p<.05 *p<.10  significant difference between intervention & control at p<.05
  36. 36. WHAT did we learn? THEME 1: Attitudes about men and women Retreats proved powerful Patriarchal norms are still prevalent Rapport with students is critical Lessons:
  37. 37. WHAT did we learn? THEME 2: Interpersonal violence
  38. 38. WHAT did we learn? THEME 2: Interpersonal violence
  39. 39. WHAT did we learn? THEME 2: Interpersonal violence Greater program focus on violence could help Longer timeline needed Lessons:
  40. 40. WHAT did we learn? THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing
  41. 41. WHAT did we learn? THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing
  42. 42. WHAT did we learn? THEME 3: Sex, health, and wellbeing Some students require extra attention Classroom sessions and retreats equally effective Lessons:
  43. 43. WHAT did we learn? THEME 4: Drug & alcohol use
  44. 44. WHAT did we learn? THEME 4: Drug & alcohol use
  45. 45. WHAT did we learn? THEME 4: Drug & alcohol use Social media can be effective in promoting new behaviors YMI alone may be insufficient to achieve this change Lessons:
  46. 46. WHAT did we learn? Limitations: Sample attrition Short time frame Social desirability bias
  47. 47. “Be a Man, Change the Rules” – Seven Year Summative Report: http://www.icrw.org/files/publications/YMI_ExecutiveSummary_2013- WEB-PREVIEW.pdf Formative Research Report – Participatory Learning & Action: http://www.icrw.org/files/publications/Exploring-Dimensions-of- Masculinity-and-Violence.pdf YMI website: http://www.youngmeninitiative.net
  48. 48. EXAMPLE 3: EVALUATION RESEARCH GENDER EQUITY MOVEMENT IN SCHOOLS
  49. 49. Fosters gender equality, redefines masculinity & negates all forms of violence to promote SRH of YA GEMS 3. Teacher Sensitization ownership and conviction 1. Group Education Activities collective refection in a positive peer environment 2. Campaigns public dialogue within supportive school environment WHAT is GEMS?
  50. 50. Content of Group Education Activities Gender Body Violence Relationships
  51. 51. GEMS Evaluation Design 754 students participated in all three rounds, while 909 participated in baseline and 2nd follow- up
  52. 52. WHAT were the evaluation results? Attitudes about gender equality improved Outcome Outcome Process 1 2 3
  53. 53. Examples of positive shifts in gender attitude 49 67 18 36 64 71 39 39 14 13 66 62 0 10 20 30 40 50 60 70 80 Baseline 2nd Follow-up Baseline 2nd Follow-up Baseline 2nd Follow-up girls shdn't sent for higher education Giving kids bath and feeding are mother’s responsibility girl’s fault if a boy or teacher sexually harass her %disagreed GEA+ Control
  54. 54. Attitudes about gender equality improved Students think differently about age of marriage Outcome Outcome Process 1 2 3 WHAT were the evaluation results?
  55. 55. Students suggesting 21 yrs or more as appropriate age at marriage for girls * Diff sig. at p <0.05 compared to control
  56. 56. Attitudes about gender equality improved Students think differently about age of marriage GEA and campaigns work best together Outcome Outcome Process 1 2 3 WHAT were the evaluation results?
  57. 57. The girl should study. She has the right to study. It is illegal to get her married before the age of 18. A boy from GEA+ I will make my parents understand that they should get me married off after I turn eighteen. They should also let me complete a master’s degree. That will help me get a good job and better money. The problems that happen due to lack of education will be out of the way. A girl from GEA+ WHAT do boys and girls in the program say?
  58. 58. GEMS Diary: http://www.icrw.org/publications/my-gems-diary Evaluation Results: http://www.icrw.org/files/publications/GEMS%20Building%20Support%2 0for%20Gender%20Equality%20Adolescents_0.pdf Campaign Guide: http://www.icrw.org/publications/gems-campaign-guide Training Manual for Facilitators: http://www.icrw.org/publications/gems-training-manual-facilitators a Gender Year 1Module 1 Training Manual for Facilitators GEMS Gender Equity Movement inSchools
  59. 59. Q & A
  60. 60. Additional Slides on IMAGES
  61. 61. Attitudes about violence 70 0 20 40 60 80 100 Bosnia Brazil Chile Croatia DRC India Mexico Rwanda %whoagreeorpartiallyagree There are times when a woman deserves to be beaten: nMen nWomen
  62. 62. IPV Perpetration 71 26.0 24.3 29.5 32.6 44.0 37.4 17.4 38.7 0 10 20 30 40 50
  63. 63. To end men’s use of violence we have to pay attention to the violence in boys’s lives • 20% to 85% of men report having experienced psychological violence as children; • 26% to 67% of men report having experienced physical violence as children in their homes; • 16% to 44% of men report witnessing their mother being beaten by their father or another male partner; • 1% to 21% of men report having experienced sexual volence as children; • 34% to 79% report having been bullied in their neighobrhoods or physically punished by teachers
  64. 64. IMAGES Data Linked Directly to Programs…
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×