Multilevel governance of
health promotion – on the
role of municipalities
Examples from Norway
Marit K. Helgesen
Norwegian...
Change in governance
• How is health promotion governed?
• Is there a role for municipalities?
• Do they have the necessar...
Content of speech
• Nordic welfare state and municipalities
• Health promotion and dterminants for health
• Theoretical pe...
Decentralised character of
welfare states
• Service provision traditionally a municipal
responsibility within limits of na...
Health promotion
• Health in the public sphere affect health
positively:
– Infrastructure for sanitation
– Building of wel...
Source: Dahlgren and
Whitehead 1991
Determinants for health
Multi-level governance
• Change from:
• Hierarchy: command and control targeting
content of services
• New Public Manageme...
Cooperative turn
• Change from hierachy towards network
modes of governance
• Bringing together diverse actors across
sect...
Capacity as municipal size
• D: 98 municipalities, average of 55 000
inhabitants, 5 regions
• S: 290 municipalities, 21 el...
Capacity as competence
• D: citizen-oriented prevention in municipalities,
patient-oriented shared with regions
• S: both ...
Legal instruments
• D: health promotion included in law on
health and care, agreements between
municipaliteis and regions
...
Economic instruments
• D: municipal co-funding of hospital
admissions, motivate health promotion
initiatives
• S: municipa...
Pedagogical steering instruments
• D: statistical tool focus healt behavior, individual
diseases and self-assessed health
...
PHA regulation: health profiles and
local knowledge on determinants for
health
• Health profiles basis of knowledge on hea...
Knowledge base
Planning
Decisions on
planning goals
Interventions and
measures
Evaluation
Source: Paulsen and
Moltumyr, Ko...
HCMA: Healthy living centers
• Defined as health care
• Target population in need of changing health
behavior; groups at r...
Multi-level governance
• Building on the traditions of decentralised
service provision in all Nordic countries
• A clear r...
The cooperative turn: two models of
health promotion in municipalities?
• Cooperative turn: municipal self regulation
• Tw...
Thank you for your attention
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Marit Helgesen NHPRC2013

86

Published on

Multilevel governance of health promotion – on the role of municipalities

0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
86
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
0
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
1
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Marit Helgesen NHPRC2013

  1. 1. Multilevel governance of health promotion – on the role of municipalities Examples from Norway Marit K. Helgesen Norwegian Institute for Urban and Regional Research (NIBR)
  2. 2. Change in governance • How is health promotion governed? • Is there a role for municipalities? • Do they have the necessary capcity? • How are policies framed? • Are there similarities and differences?
  3. 3. Content of speech • Nordic welfare state and municipalities • Health promotion and dterminants for health • Theoretical perspective: – Multi-level governance – The cooperative turn • Multi-level governance of health promotion in the four Nordic countries • The cooperative turn: two models of health promotion in municipalities?
  4. 4. Decentralised character of welfare states • Service provision traditionally a municipal responsibility within limits of national governmental regulations • Municipalities have a dual role – Implement national policy goals – Local democratic arena – prioritizing of funding • Important role in the provision of welfare services
  5. 5. Health promotion • Health in the public sphere affect health positively: – Infrastructure for sanitation – Building of welfare state • Individual lifestyles in focus – Patients take part in producing their own health • Changing theoretical backdrop health promotion
  6. 6. Source: Dahlgren and Whitehead 1991 Determinants for health
  7. 7. Multi-level governance • Change from: • Hierarchy: command and control targeting content of services • New Public Management: contracts, performance- and strategic management measures targeting results • New Public Governance: designing and framing networks targeting processes
  8. 8. Cooperative turn • Change from hierachy towards network modes of governance • Bringing together diverse actors across sectors and levels of formal authority • National state taking the interest of actors at lower levels into consideration • Combine central intervention with local self regulation
  9. 9. Capacity as municipal size • D: 98 municipalities, average of 55 000 inhabitants, 5 regions • S: 290 municipalities, 21 elected county authorities • F: 320 municipalities, wanted average of 20 000 inhabitants not reached, samkommuner • N: 428 municicpalities, 19 elected county authotrities, average of 10 000 inabitants – about 100 municipalities with 3000 inh. or less
  10. 10. Capacity as competence • D: citizen-oriented prevention in municipalities, patient-oriented shared with regions • S: both levels to carry out health promotion, established political or administrative board, county autorhorites often take the role as initiators • F: municipalities decides on health promotion • N: included in municipal planning, have public health coordinator
  11. 11. Legal instruments • D: health promotion included in law on health and care, agreements between municipaliteis and regions • S: health promotion in law on health and care • F: act on health promotion and health and care • N: acts on health promotion and health and care, agreements between municipaliteis and regions
  12. 12. Economic instruments • D: municipal co-funding of hospital admissions, motivate health promotion initiatives • S: municipalities fund their health promotion • F: grants are given to fund trials and reforms • N: municipal co-funding of hospital admissions, motivate health promotion initiatives
  13. 13. Pedagogical steering instruments • D: statistical tool focus healt behavior, individual diseases and self-assessed health • S: follow ups on national goals publicized, hp in cooperation with county councils • F: «Welfare Compass» information on various determinants for health, state agencies provide policy support • N: «Health profiles» information on various determinants for health, state agencies provide policy support, hp in cooperation with county councils
  14. 14. PHA regulation: health profiles and local knowledge on determinants for health • Health profiles basis of knowledge on health determinants • Provided by Public Health Institute, issued once a year, statistical indicators accommodated to the local level • Municipalities and counties complete by qualitative indicators for local areas • Input for planning • Few national guidelines and exmples
  15. 15. Knowledge base Planning Decisions on planning goals Interventions and measures Evaluation Source: Paulsen and Moltumyr, Kommunetorget.no The systematic health promotion
  16. 16. HCMA: Healthy living centers • Defined as health care • Target population in need of changing health behavior; groups at risk • Pedagogical instrument, voluntary for municipalities • Municipalities can apply for special grants • Evidence based, thorough elaborated guidelines
  17. 17. Multi-level governance • Building on the traditions of decentralised service provision in all Nordic countries • A clear role for municipalities in health promotion • Similar between countries: to provide the contingencies of prevention and the services of which health promotion can be a part
  18. 18. The cooperative turn: two models of health promotion in municipalities? • Cooperative turn: municipal self regulation • Two models: S and F apparently more autonomous in their implementation of health promotion • D and N: health promotion the twin practice of health care • Economic NPM incentives motivate municipal self regulation to establish health promotion as health care service in the municipal health sector
  19. 19. Thank you for your attention
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×