Extract Information Limited
www.extractinfo.info

Consultancy
Search Services
Training

Jane List

© Extract Information L...
Untangling the scientific
information web:
Jane List
Monday 14th October 2013
Extract Information Ltd
www.extractinfo.info...
Consultancy
Evaluating databases
Preparing presentations and training materials
Writing grant applications

Search Service...
Overview
Review

and

How useful are these tools to professional patent
searchers for retrieval and full text document ret...
Patent information professionals
search the scientific literature
• (Non-Patent Literature) for prior art (patentability a...
Patent information professionals use
of scientific information sources

Search
collections

60% >once
per week

Select ful...
Patent information professionals:
Direct Publisher sources
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•
•

Science Direct
ACS
Wiley
IOP
IEEE
IE...
Patent information professionals
use of secondary sources.
Documents cited
directly to internet

Primary research & S. Ada...
Search Overview
Search criteria

Preferred

Google Scholar

Microsoft Academic Search

Article Title

89%

No

No

Author(...
Full text articles and more….
View / download
criteria

Google Scholar

Microsoft Academic Search

doi

yes

yes

Export c...
Google scholar

© Extract Information Limited
Microsoft Academic Search

© Extract Information Limited
Reference management / search
challengers:

Mendeley

Qiqqa

Year founded

2007

2010

Cost?

Free version available - $$
...
Elsevier scirus is closing in 2014
ScienceDirect, Scopus

Open Access: An STM Publisher’s Perspective, 2012. D. Gardner

©...
Future for scientific search
document
supplier

document
archive
search
engine
copyright

publisher
researcher

© Extract ...
Extract Information Limited
www.extractinfo.info

Thank you for listening!
Jane@extractinfo.info

© Extract Information Li...
References
http://www.oxbridgebiotech.com/review/careers-2/innovator-spotlight-james-jardine-andqiqqa-a-company-created-in...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

ICIC 2013 Conference Proceedings Jane List Extract Information

684

Published on

Untangling the scientific information web
Jane List (Extract Information Limited, UK)
Professional users of information expect their sources to be reliable, secure, complete and current Microsoft Academic search, Google Scholar, and Elsevier’s scirus all provide access to academic scientific, technical, legal and medical information. All three provide search of academic journal articles, theses, ebooks, abstracts, and conference papers from academic publishers, universities, and professional societies. This paper will review the three search engines by comparing inclusion criteria, ranking methodology, citation analysis, link analysis, visualisation, social media and collaborative tools. Could a professional search service depend on Elsevier, Google or Microsoft to straighten out the tangled web of published academic information? More recently reference management tools have entered the scientific search arena, for instance Mendeley, and Qiqqa. These tools are rapidly growing content of cited articles which users can access through social networking linkages and user added search tags. This paper will conclude by considering the searching opportunities offered by reference management products; could they offer users a real alternative to the ranked results search engine?

Published in: Technology, Business
0 Comments
2 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
684
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
5
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
3
Comments
0
Likes
2
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

ICIC 2013 Conference Proceedings Jane List Extract Information

  1. 1. Extract Information Limited www.extractinfo.info Consultancy Search Services Training Jane List © Extract Information Limited
  2. 2. Untangling the scientific information web: Jane List Monday 14th October 2013 Extract Information Ltd www.extractinfo.info © Extract Information Limited
  3. 3. Consultancy Evaluating databases Preparing presentations and training materials Writing grant applications Search Services Technology scouting Patent searching (Invalidity, State of the Art, Prior Art) Technical commercialisation Training Extract Information Ltd www.extractinfo.info At conferences/events and in-house: Asian patent searching- CN, JP, KR + more countries in 2014 Commercialisation of early stage IP © Extract Information Limited
  4. 4. Overview Review and How useful are these tools to professional patent searchers for retrieval and full text document retrieval? © Extract Information Limited
  5. 5. Patent information professionals search the scientific literature • (Non-Patent Literature) for prior art (patentability and invalidity) and competitive intelligence. • WIPO PCT minimum documentation list 191 journal titles • Scientific* literature differs from patent literature in that:  multiple and varying formats –2,000 publishers, conference proceedings, books.  not always easy to determine the exact publication date  SEARCH of complete text not always possible  VIEW-ing the complete text is dependent on Copyright restrictions © Extract Information Limited
  6. 6. Patent information professionals use of scientific information sources Search collections 60% >once per week Select full articles of interest Answer immediate question. Integrate into Project / R&D / internal library for future use Industry Search Firm Academia Government © Extract Information Limited
  7. 7. Patent information professionals: Direct Publisher sources • • • • • • • • • • • • • Science Direct ACS Wiley IOP IEEE IET Ei Springer Link RSC Epoquenet Amazon Inside BL Direct EBL (Electronic Book Library) © Extract Information Limited
  8. 8. Patent information professionals use of secondary sources. Documents cited directly to internet Primary research & S. Adams, WPI, 2012, Survey of PCT search reports – internet as source of NPL. © Extract Information Limited
  9. 9. Search Overview Search criteria Preferred Google Scholar Microsoft Academic Search Article Title 89% No No Author(s) 68% Advanced search Advanced search Journal Title 6% Advanced search Advanced search Institute 2% No Advanced search Publication Year 30% Yes Advanced search Subject Categories n/a No 15 broad categories Related articles n/a By Link By keyword Cited references 24% No No Citing references n/a Yes Yes Type of literature n/a books, conferences, journals conferences, journals http://scholar.google.co.uk/ http://academic.research.microsoft.com/ url © Extract Information Limited
  10. 10. Full text articles and more…. View / download criteria Google Scholar Microsoft Academic Search doi yes yes Export citation No BibTex : RIS : RefWorks Link to Publisher yes Yes Direct download Yes (from author / institute) Through ResearchGate Profile Yes Yes Cumulative citation map No Yes Author network No Yes Rightslink Yes Publisher dependent © Extract Information Limited
  11. 11. Google scholar © Extract Information Limited
  12. 12. Microsoft Academic Search © Extract Information Limited
  13. 13. Reference management / search challengers: Mendeley Qiqqa Year founded 2007 2010 Cost? Free version available - $$ Free version available - $$ Stores PDFs Yes Yes Annotate PDFs Yes Yes Share papers Recommends papers based on own collection Yes Yes Collaborate yes yes url www.mendeley.com/ www.qiqqa.com © Extract Information Limited
  14. 14. Elsevier scirus is closing in 2014 ScienceDirect, Scopus Open Access: An STM Publisher’s Perspective, 2012. D. Gardner © Extract Information Limited
  15. 15. Future for scientific search document supplier document archive search engine copyright publisher researcher © Extract Information Limited
  16. 16. Extract Information Limited www.extractinfo.info Thank you for listening! Jane@extractinfo.info © Extract Information Limited
  17. 17. References http://www.oxbridgebiotech.com/review/careers-2/innovator-spotlight-james-jardine-andqiqqa-a-company-created-in-light-of-personal-need/ STM Report, 2009 http://www.stm-assoc.org/2009_10_13_MWC_STM_Report.pdf Toward the next generation of recommender systems: a survey of the state of the art and possible extensions. 2005 http://ieeexplore.ieee.org/xpl/articleDetails.jsp?arnumber=1423975 Extract Information Ltd www.extractinfo.info © Extract Information Limited
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×