0
Can we recover meaningful spatial informa-tion from multivariate pattern analysis?      Ga¨l Varoquaux        e           ...
Can we recover meaningful spatial informa-tion from multivariate pattern analysis?      Ga¨l Varoquaux        e           ...
Can we recover meaningful spatial informa-tion from multivariate pattern analysis?      Ga¨l Varoquaux        e           ...
1 Prediction versus recovery   2 Random parcellations and sparsityG Varoquaux                              2
1 Prediction versus recovery                ?G Varoquaux                       3
1 Standard analysis and MVPA  Standard analysis           MVPA  Test whether the voxel is   Overall predictive model  recr...
1 Standard analysis and MVPA  Standard analysis           MVPA  Test whether the voxel is   Overall predictive model  recr...
1 Good prediction = good recovery   Simple simulations: y = w X + e    X: observed fMRI images: spatially smooth    e: noi...
1 Good prediction = good recovery   Sparse models (lasso):   Prediction: 0.78 explained variance   Amplitude of the weight...
1 Good prediction = good recovery   SVM:   Prediction: 0.71 explained variance   Amplitude of the weights:                ...
1 Good prediction = good recovery   Standard univariate analysis (ANOVA):   F-score:                                      ...
1 Good prediction = good recovery  Lasso    Prediction: 0.77    Recovery: 0.461  SVM   Prediction: 0.71   Recovery: 0.464 ...
1 Multivariate analysis for recovery?       Considering each voxel separately is       suboptimal: they share information ...
1 Multivariate analysis for recovery?       Considering each voxel separately is       suboptimal: they share information ...
1 Sparse models    Compressive sensing:      detection of k signals out of p (voxels)      with only n observations ∝ k   ...
1 Sparse models    Compressive sensing:      detection of k signals out of p (voxels)      with only n observations ∝ k   ...
1 Spatial models    Brain parcellations:    Ward clustering to reduce voxel numbers          Supervised clustering [Michel...
2 Random parcellations and     sparsity                    Combining                     Clustering                     Sp...
2 Random parcellations and     sparsity                            +                        Randomization                 ...
2 Algorithm 1 loop: perturb randomly data 2     Ward agglomeration to form n features 3     sparse linear model on reduced...
2 Recovery performance   RandomizedClusteredLasso:   Selection scores                               max                   ...
2 What is the best method for feature recovery?   For small brain regions: elastic net   For large brain regions: randomiz...
2 fMRI: face vs house discrimination   [Haxby 2001]        F-scores                                             L         ...
2 fMRI: face vs house discrimination   [Haxby 2001]        Randomized Clustered Sparsity                                  ...
2 Predictive power of selected voxels   Object recognition [Haxby 2001]      Using recovered voxels improves predictionG V...
Can we recover meaningful spatial information        from multivariate pattern analysis?     SVM and sparse models less po...
For more details G. Varoquaux, A. Gramfort, and B. Thirion, Small-sample brain mapping: sparse recovery on spatially corre...
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5
×

Can we recover meaning full spatial information from multivariate pattern analysis

709

Published on

Slides of the HBM 2012 symposium on recovery of spatial information using machine learning and multivariate pattern analysis from fMRI brain images.

Published in: Technology, Education
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total Views
709
On Slideshare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
1
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
21
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

Transcript of "Can we recover meaning full spatial information from multivariate pattern analysis"

  1. 1. Can we recover meaningful spatial informa-tion from multivariate pattern analysis? Ga¨l Varoquaux e INRIA/Parietal Alexandre Gramfort Bertrand Thirion
  2. 2. Can we recover meaningful spatial informa-tion from multivariate pattern analysis? Ga¨l Varoquaux e INRIA/Parietal Alexandre Gramfort Bertrand Thirion Yes we can!
  3. 3. Can we recover meaningful spatial informa-tion from multivariate pattern analysis? Ga¨l Varoquaux e INRIA/Parietal Alexandre Gramfort Bertrand Thirion
  4. 4. 1 Prediction versus recovery 2 Random parcellations and sparsityG Varoquaux 2
  5. 5. 1 Prediction versus recovery ?G Varoquaux 3
  6. 6. 1 Standard analysis and MVPA Standard analysis MVPA Test whether the voxel is Overall predictive model recruited by the task Many voxels ⇒ problem Many voxels ⇒ curse of of multiple comparisons dimensionalityG Varoquaux 4
  7. 7. 1 Standard analysis and MVPA Standard analysis MVPA Test whether the voxel is Overall predictive model recruited by the task Many voxels ⇒ problem Many voxels ⇒ curse of of multiple comparisons dimensionalityF-test SearchlightAnalyzes of regional-average activation and multi-voxel pattern information tell complementary stories,K. Jimura, R.A. Poldrack, Neuropsychologia 2011G Varoquaux 4
  8. 8. 1 Good prediction = good recovery Simple simulations: y = w X + e X: observed fMRI images: spatially smooth e: noise w: coefficients (brain regions) Ground truthG Varoquaux 5
  9. 9. 1 Good prediction = good recovery Sparse models (lasso): Prediction: 0.78 explained variance Amplitude of the weights: max 0G Varoquaux 5
  10. 10. 1 Good prediction = good recovery SVM: Prediction: 0.71 explained variance Amplitude of the weights: max 0G Varoquaux 5
  11. 11. 1 Good prediction = good recovery Standard univariate analysis (ANOVA): F-score: max 0G Varoquaux 5
  12. 12. 1 Good prediction = good recovery Lasso Prediction: 0.77 Recovery: 0.461 SVM Prediction: 0.71 Recovery: 0.464 F-score Prediction: Recovery: 0.963G Varoquaux 6
  13. 13. 1 Multivariate analysis for recovery? Considering each voxel separately is suboptimal: they share information Most often, we know that we are looking for a small fraction of the cortex A voxel is more likely to be activated if its neighbor isG Varoquaux 7
  14. 14. 1 Multivariate analysis for recovery? Considering each voxel separately is suboptimal: they share information Most often, we know that we are looking for a small fraction of the cortex Sparse models A voxel is more likely to be activated if its neighbor is Spatial modelsG Varoquaux 7
  15. 15. 1 Sparse models Compressive sensing: detection of k signals out of p (voxels) with only n observations ∝ k Iterpretable Selects random subsets in correlated signals Face vs house discrimination Data from [Haxby 2001]G Varoquaux 8
  16. 16. 1 Sparse models Compressive sensing: detection of k signals out of p (voxels) with only n observations ∝ k Iterpretable Selects random subsets in correlated signals Stability selection: Face vsrandom perturbations to the data Apply house discrimination that are selected often Keep voxels Data from [Haxby 2001] [Meinhausen 2010]G Varoquaux 8
  17. 17. 1 Spatial models Brain parcellations: Ward clustering to reduce voxel numbers Supervised clustering [Michel 2011] ... ... ... ... ... Clustering blind to experimental conditionsG Varoquaux 9
  18. 18. 2 Random parcellations and sparsity Combining Clustering SparsityG Varoquaux 10
  19. 19. 2 Random parcellations and sparsity + Randomization Stability scoresG Varoquaux 10
  20. 20. 2 Algorithm 1 loop: perturb randomly data 2 Ward agglomeration to form n features 3 sparse linear model on reduced features 4 accumulate non-zero features 5 threshold map of apparition countsG Varoquaux 11
  21. 21. 2 Recovery performance RandomizedClusteredLasso: Selection scores max 0G Varoquaux 12
  22. 22. 2 What is the best method for feature recovery? For small brain regions: elastic net For large brain regions: randomized-clustered sparsity Large regions and very smooth images: F-tests [Varoquaux 2012] ICMLG Varoquaux 13
  23. 23. 2 fMRI: face vs house discrimination [Haxby 2001] F-scores L R L Ry=-31 x=17 z=-17 G Varoquaux 14
  24. 24. 2 fMRI: face vs house discrimination [Haxby 2001] Randomized Clustered Sparsity L R L Ry=-31 x=17 z=-17 Less background noise (source of false positive) G Varoquaux 14
  25. 25. 2 Predictive power of selected voxels Object recognition [Haxby 2001] Using recovered voxels improves predictionG Varoquaux 15
  26. 26. Can we recover meaningful spatial information from multivariate pattern analysis? SVM and sparse models less powerful then F-score Sparsity + clustering + randomization: excellent recovery ⇒ Multivariate brain mapping Simultaneous prediction and recovery Prediction accuracy: 93%G Varoquaux 16
  27. 27. For more details G. Varoquaux, A. Gramfort, and B. Thirion, Small-sample brain mapping: sparse recovery on spatially correlated de- signs with randomization and clustering, ICML 2012 Acknowledgments, for sharing data: J. Haxby R. Poldrack K. Jimura Softwarescikit-learn: machine learning in PythonG Varoquaux 17
  1. A particular slide catching your eye?

    Clipping is a handy way to collect important slides you want to go back to later.

×