Stephan Züchner discusses major developments in human genetics including improved genome sequencing capabilities and declining costs. He summarizes research on inherited axonopathies like hereditary spastic paraplegias and Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease, which are clinically and genetically heterogeneous. Züchner leads a large international collaborative effort called GEM.app involving over 450 investigators that has identified numerous genes for various neurodegenerative and neuromuscular disorders through shared exome and genome data.
1. Stephan Züchner, MD, PhD
Department of Human Genetics and
Hussman Institute for Human Genomics
University of Miami
2. Major developments have put human genetics
on a new trajectory in recent years
o Sequencing has improved >100,000 fold in the past 10 years.
o Cost for an individual whole human genome is now ~$5,000.
o Importantly, next year below $2,000
I.
4. Excess of rare variants in human populations
Tennessen et al. 2012
III.
The number of rare variants growths unabated.
Nelson, 2012
5. Our genome composition is tied to our
(recent) history as a species
• Todays heterogeneous Mendelian diseases arose in recent history.
• It will be challenging to sort out true disease causing variants from high
background of rare variation.
6. Inherited axonopathies
• Inherited neurodegenerative diseases of long axons
• Archetypical diseases include:
• Hereditary Spastic Paraplegias
• Hereditary Motor and Sensory Neuropathies
(Charcot-Marie-Tooth disease)
• Clinically heterogeneous and neurologically distinct
(central vs peripheral),
• but, these diseases share biology and genetics.
• >120 known disease genes
• 40 – 70% of patients without
diagnosis
9. Interest in phenotyping
Insight into overlap and
heterogeneity of motoneuron
diseases
+ + $$$
• We decided to sequence a large number of patients with such phenotypes
• Convinced many colleagues to join in
• CREATE
• INC
10. • Interest in phenotyping
• Insight into overlap and
heterogeneity of
motoneuron diseases
+ + $$$
11. The joys of working with “big data” …
Typical next-generation sequencing analysis file (.VCF file)
12. •effectively managing larger exome and/or genome datasets, especially
for smaller labs
•direct hands-on analysis and contextual interpretation of variant data
for many genomes
•Combining data from small and medium-sized clinical and research-
based teams around the world will significantly increase the
opportunities for the entire community to identify new genes.
Challenges that come with large scale genomic
data
15. • Invite collaborators
• Create Shared Projects
• Manage who can see what
• Expand your own team
• etc
16. >450 investigators 36 countries >5,000 exomes 90
phenotypes
~1,000 genomes
GEM.app is used world-wide
17. Examples of diseases and participating groups
• Mitochondrial disease community (UMDF/ MSeqDR)
• Inherited Neuropathy Consortium (INC)
• European epilepsy consortia
• Hereditary spastic paraplegia network
• Ataxia initiative
• Amyotrophic Lateral Sclerosis group
• Alzheimer disease, cardiomyopathy, rare and unique syndromes, deafness,
motor neuron diseases, optic atrophy, ichthyosis, schizophrenia, …
18. 1. No sharing of data
2. Full mutual access to exomes/ genomes
• anything from individual exomes to sets of cases and controls
3. Anonymous sharing of variants
• Via genotype counts across entire GEM.app database
• via a new ‘hit’ feature showing significant changes per gene and phenotype
• on a gene-by gene basis in GVDHD
(opt-in)
Collaborative data mining
24. • BICD2 is part of the dynein/dynactin complex
• DYNC1H1 is also part of this complex
--> shows very similar phenotype
similar MRI findings
BICD2 and DYNC1H1 act as molecular motors
25. Example: VCP gene identification
Sizable CMT2 family with negative clinical testing results
26. Whole exome sequencing
Severity
prediction
Value Range
GERP score 6.07 -12.3 - 6.17
PhastCons 1 0 - 1
PolyPhen2 Probably
damaging
Benign, Possibly damaging, Probably
damaging
MutationTaster Disease
causing
Polymorphism - Disease causing
MutationAssessor High Neutral, Low, Medium, High
LRT Deleterious Unknown, Neutral, Deleterious
SIFT Tolerated Tolerated - Damaging
Disruption of autophagosome maturationComplete segregation in large family
27. The VCP protein is an important functional hub
Gene-interaction analysis:
Diseases caused by VCP:
•1-2% of familial amyotrophic lateral sclerosis
•inclusion body myopathy with Paget’s disease of the bone
•frontotemporal dementia
•hereditary spastic paraplegia
Gonzalez et al, 2014
• BioGrid experimental
interactions
• Up to two intermediates
• Flexible grid pulls interacting
genes towards each other
30. Triad of Boucher Neuhäuser syndrome
Hypogonadism Chorioretinal dystrophy Ataxia
31. The phenotype of PNPLA6 is broad
J Med Genetics
Neuropathy target esterase impairments cause Oliver–McFarlane
and Laurence–Moon syndromes
Triad of congenital trichomegaly, chorioretinal atrophy, and hypopituitarism. In our
patients, thyroid and growth hormone replacement during childhood successfully
improved the pituitary sequelae of intellectual disability and short stature. However,
vision loss was progressive and devastating.
32.
33. What is happening right now?
• Unprecedented pace of gene discovery
• In the coming decade the genotype/ phenotype relationships in motor
neuron diseases will be defined in great detail
• Inflationary value of new gene discovery
What is the outlook?
• It will get more difficult to identify sufficient genetic support for new genes
(second family).
• Still, we believe each of the classic phenotypes will contain several
hundred genes in the end to explain >95%of patients.
• Huge opportunity to define the biology through genetics (pathways).
34. o Hussman Institute for Human Genomics: faculty and especially Michael Gonzalez, Fiorella Speziani,
Rafael Acosta, Mustafa Tekin, Gladys Montenegro, Eric Powel, William Hulme, Ioanna Konidari
o The Inherited Neuropathies Consortium (INC); Mike Shy, Mary Reilly, Steve Scherer, David
Herrmann, …
o Rebecca Schule, Michael Benatar, Giovanni Stevanin, Ludger Schols, Peter de Jonghe, Garth
Nicholson, Marina Kennerson, Manoj Menezes, Wilson Marques, Michaela Auer-Grumbach, Antonio
Orlacchio, …
o These studies were supported by the National Institute for Neurology and Stroke (R01NS065712,
R01NS072248, R01NS075764, U54NS065712 to SZ), MDA, CMTA
Miami Key Biscayne
Coconut Grove
Editor's Notes
In this figure you see all known genes and loci for hereditary neuropathies. The genes are marked in orange, and loci are highlighted in blue. Until now 17genes were identified, with many more surely to follow.
This is in contras to the clinical homogeneity of the disease.
even CMT receives not so muchpublic attention it is the most ....
What turned out several years ago is that the disease is extremely genetically heterogeneous.
Each disease is its own xperiment that tells us about the function of one aspect