Executive benefits consulting firm, Fulcrum Partners LLC, is pleased to distribute this AALU Washington Report to its clients and friends. This continuing series of articles is intended to provide deep insight into trends, events, and issues that impact the design and operation of nonqualified executive benefit plans. To read other similiar articles, visit the Fulcrum Partners blog at www.fulcrumpartnersllc.com/news.
Fulcrum Partners LLC is one of the nation’s leading and largest executive benefits consultancy. Its consultants focus on an integrated approach to the design, financing and plan administration of executive benefit programs.
2. 2
NONQUALIFIED
DEFERRED
COMPENSATION
Do your company’s plans really work?
92% OF THE
FORTUNE 1000 OFFER A
§409A NONQUALIFIED
DEFERRED COMPENSATION
PLAN TO KEY EXECUTIVES.
And §409A Nonqualified Deferred
Compensation (NQDC) can be
the most versatile pay element
of Total Rewards.
Yet for many, NQDC is the
FORGOTTEN pay element.
SM
Having a “plan” does not necessarily mean
you have your best “strategy.”
3. 3
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
A strategy means
that Fulcrum
Partners has
tested variations of
plan designs with
your unique needs
in mind.
… We measure
inputs.
… And we analyze
outcomes.
A plan shouldn’t be casually selected
… as if you picked it off the shelf.
4. 4
CHART 1: RETIREMENT COMPENSATION SUMMARY: CEO
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
CEO A
CEO B
CEO C
CEO D
CEO E
CEO F
CEO G
CEO H
CEO I
CEO J
CEO K
CEO L
Company contributions, as a percentage of salary, to all qualified and
nonqualified retirement plans. Real data regarding a sampling of 12
companies, all within the same industry.
Why do these numbers vary so much from one executive to the next?
5. 5
CHART 2: CAREER RETIREMENT BENEFIT: RETIREMENT INCOME
REPLACEMENT RATIO (RIRR) CEO
Annual lifetime income replacement, as a percentage of projected final total
cash compensation (salary plus bonus), created by company contributions to
all retirement plans, assuming target performance.
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
CEO D
CEO A
CEO C
CEO L
CEO E
CEO B
CEO J
CEO F
CEO H
CEO K
CEO I
CEO G
Clearly … some companies treat retirement as a significant pay element
… while other companies have no strategies at all.
6. 6
QUESTIONS YOU MUST ASK
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
What is your CEO’s projected retirement income replacement ratio
(RIRR)?
Why is it what it is?
What should it be?
Does your CEO’s
projected RIRR
reflect your overall
compensation
strategy?
What about your
other key
executives?
7. 7
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
CONSIDER CORPORATE OBJECTIVES
COMPANIES HAVE MANY REASONS TO USE DEFERRED OR FUTURE
COMPENSATION.
Drive performance.
Drive corporate messaging.
Incentivize and retain new hires.
Replace lost benefits (“make whole” arrangements) for new hires.
Improve employee morale.
Award spot bonuses or special project bonuses.
Manage compensation subject to clawback.
Incentivize employees to accumulate company stock on a tax
preferred basis.
Supplement existing retirement programs and Social Security.
Facilitate financial wellness, creating consistency with other
companies’ initiatives.
And inspire retention … which is a reflection of loyalty.
8. 8
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
RETENTION
… a of loyalty.
Loyalty occurs when the needs of both parties are satisfied.
Deferring income is an act of trust and faith between the company
and the employee.
Employers and employees who partner for their common
interests, achieve strategic success through effective plan
sponsorship.
Loyalty from employer to employee.
And from employee to employer.
9. 9
Retirement security.
Financial wellness.
Flexibility to handle financial uncertainties.
Employees today
face many financial
insecurities.
Increasing
numbers of
workers
postponing
retirement beyond
age 65.
70% of workers
planning a second
career after
retiring from their
first one.
And most
depending on
Social Security
and employer
sponsored plans
alone.
CONSIDER EXECUTIVE OBJECTIVES
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
Rule of Thumb: Annual retirement income
TARGET X 20 = RETIREMENT SAVINGS TARGET.
For example, to have $100,000 in annual cash flow
at retirement, you need savings of $2,000,000.
10. 10
Employers want maximum performance from executives.
Employees want incomes, retirement security, tools for saving,
tools for retirement, and partnership with their employer.
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
CONSIDER MUTUAL OBJECTIVES
IRS CODE §409A impacts both corporate and executive objectives. Both
organizations and executives must look at deferred compensation as
part of Total Rewards, asking: Why? And, how does it benefit me?
11. 11
WHO IS IMPACTED MOST WHEN YOUR COMPANY’S
PLANS FALL SHORT?
NOT THE CORE EMPLOYEES
NOT THE C-SUITE
Your Core Management Team is at greatest risk.
In general, employees in this group are:
Over the Social Security wage base.
Limited in qualified plan contributions.
Missing out on the C-Suite incentives.
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM
THE MOST SIGNIFICANT IMPEDIMENT TO WEALTH IS TAXES.
12. 12
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
CONSIDER THE GAP
SM
Today’s tax qualified retirement plans and social programs, for the most
part, adequately provide for the worker earning $90,000 and under.
However, those earning over the social security wage base of $113,700
start losing benefits. Additionally, tax qualified plan limits do not allow those
employees to save enough for a comfortable retirement.
The most efficient way to address this issue is to supplement the 401(k) with
a §409A plan. A §409A plan affords your core management team the same
opportunity to provide for retirement as your core employees receive.
A §409A plan can complement the 401(k). A §409A plan, with an egalitarian
design, goes a long way in neutralizing the impact of reverse discrimination
in retirement planning.
13. 13
Many companies demonstrate a commitment to employees in health
and wellness.
Extending that commitment to financial wellness through a non-
qualified strategy is LOGICAL.
Install an Executive Partnership Plan utilizing §409A.
Sponsors who partner with key employees; discover the win-win.
A well-strategized nonqualified deferred compensation plan is not a
product you buy off a shelf. Instead, it is a customized strategy designed
for your needs and your future. NQDC plans are the most effective, tax-
efficient, wealth-accumulating vehicles for highly compensated executives.
If you don’t have a plan, you need one.
If you do have a plan, let Fulcrum Partners review it for you.
MAXIMIZE UTILITY FOR BOTH THE PLAN SPONSOR …
AND THE PARTICIPANT.
WORTH REPEATING:
A NONQUALIFIED BENEFIT STRATEGY IS THE
MOST VERSATILE PAY ELEMENT WITHIN TOTAL
REWARDS.
SUMMARY
DO YOUR COMPANY’S PLANS REALLY WORK?
SM