What to Do When You Can't Chuck The Book

Uploaded on

Talk given at TESOL France 2013 Annual Colloquium. In person it was run as a workshop with ideas for each example discussed by participants before solutions were presented.

Talk given at TESOL France 2013 Annual Colloquium. In person it was run as a workshop with ideas for each example discussed by participants before solutions were presented.

More in: Education , Technology
  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
    Be the first to comment
No Downloads


Total Views
On Slideshare
From Embeds
Number of Embeds



Embeds 0

No embeds

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

    No notes for slide


  • 1. + What To Do When You Can‟t Chuck The Book Federico Espinosa TESOL France Annual Colloquium November 24th, 2013
  • 2. + The Debate Pro-Coursebooks Anti-Coursebooks
  • 3. + The Debate Pro-Coursebook  They provide structure and direction to a course  Help standardize instruction and quality across courses  More and more are based on authentic and learner corpora  Provide learners with a tangible display of progress  Provide guidance for inexperienced teachers  They are a great time saving tool Source: Cambridge ELT Interview with Jack C. Richards
  • 4. + The Debate Anti-Coursebook  They inadvertently impose rigid methodologies   Leave little room for creativity   Littlejohn, 1998 Stifle opportunities for conversation and open discussion   Nunan, 1988 Transfer control of classroom time from the students to the materials   Cunningsworth, 1995 Thornbury & Meddings, 2009 Put forward a specific version of truth, beliefs and morality which do not correspond to the reality of every student.  Ilieva, 2000
  • 5. + The Reality It‟s often not even up to us to choose
  • 6. + So, What CAN We Do?
  • 7. + First off…. Have you exhausted the materials? Are you sure??  Extra activities in the back of the coursebook.  Photocopiables in Teacher‟s Book  Games/Suggestions “hidden” in the TB Instructions  Teacher‟s Resource Disk  Materials Available on Publisher‟s Website  Student Workbook  Flashcard/Story Card Sets  Etc…
  • 8. + Ok, fine, the materials are lacking. So what now?  Adapt  The materials may be ok, but need just need a little tweaking to work with your group.  Personalize  Think about your students and make it relevant to their lives.  Supplement  The material may be good in itself but need some follow up to address other known issues.  Skip  Maybe the material just doesn‟t fit your class‟ needs. That‟s fine. Skip it.
  • 9. + What must we ask ourselves before we begin?  “Demand High Asks:  Are our learners capable of more, much more?  Have the tasks and techniques we use in class become rituals and ends in themselves?  How can we stop „covering material‟ and focus on the potential for deep learning?  What small tweaks and adjustments can we make to shift the whole focus of our teaching towards getting that engine of learning going?” (Scrivner & Underhill, 2012)
  • 10. + Exam Preparation Writing, Organization and PeerFeedback
  • 11. + The Students  A class of 14 adult Czechnative English teachers  Advanced (C1) CAE Prep  In a part-time Bachelor‟s degree program in TEFL at AKCENT College  VERY chatty  Struggle with written organization  Exhausted (intensive weekend course)
  • 12. + The Activity p. 30 of Advanced Expert CAE After activities focusing on outline writing for a Review (Part 2)  Task 1 – Discuss various methods of outlining a writing task  Task 2 – Plan and write a film review  Task 3 – Compare with classmates
  • 13. + One Solution (Discussion)  Various strategies for text organization are pinned up around the room  Students walk around in pairs/threes and discuss the pros of each   They are asked to agree on the best two It‟s treated as a sort of museum visit with music playing in the background
  • 14. + One Solution (Planning & PeerEditing)  Students write a plan/sketch/outline/draft for their review  Each review plan gets a large postit placed next to it  Students all move one chair over clockwise and have one minute to read/skim their neighbor‟s plan and write a short comment on the post it.  A bell rings and they move over another chair and have another minute  Repeat until all have been read by all, then discuss comments.
  • 15. + Young Learners Story Reading with a Grammar Focus
  • 16. + The Students  A class of 8 young learners (912 y/o)  Pre-Intermediate (A2)  In an extra-curricular English class at IH Prague  A bit shy  Struggle with spelling  Like competition
  • 17. + The Activity p. 35 of Messages 2 At the end of a unit focusing on interesting trips and the past simple.  Task 1 (Pre-reading): Look at the pictures and put them in the correct order.  Task 2 (Language Focus): Find 21 different verbs in the past simple. Make a list.  Task 3 (Feedback): Retell the story using the verbs.
  • 18. + One Solution (Pre-Reading)  Students are given one enlarged and cut-out picture from the story.  They work in small groups to discuss what is happening in their picture, and to color it in.  The pictures are presented and pinned up on the board.  Students work as a class to put the pictures in the order which makes the most sense.  Students read the story to confirm.
  • 19. + One Solution (Language Focus)  To focus on the verbs. Students are given a “Double Puzzle” of the target verbs  They work in pairs to race each other to discover the hidden message  The first team gets a prize (stickers work well, candy works amazingly well)
  • 20. + One Solution (Personalization)  As a final task, students are asked to write a story about their life  They can use the verbs from their Double Puzzle to guide them  To fit the theme of the book, mine wrote about their summer vacation.  At the end each can give a quick presentation of their story.
  • 21. + Teens Vocabulary Exposition
  • 22. + The Students  A group of 12 teenagers (1318 y/o)  Advanced (C1)  In an extra-curricular English course at IH Prague  Mixed Chatty/Introverted  Mixed Motivated/Unmotivated  Mixed Snarky/Eager
  • 23. + The Activity (1) pp. 26 of Face2Face Advanced Activity focused on introducing some character adjectives.  Students are asked to “Tick the words they know” and refer to the glossary for the others.  Words: Courageous, Determined, Meticulous, Generous, Trusting, Thrifty, Confident, Spontaneous, & Cautious.
  • 24. + The Activity (2) p. 124 of Face2Face Advanced Follow up activity to character adjectives  Students are asked to look at the negative equivalents of the positive adjectives from before.  Words: Arrogant, Reckless, Tight-Fisted, Finicky, Extravagant, Gullible, Obstinate, Impetuous, Timid.
  • 25. + One Solution (Part 1)  Students are given a post-it with one of the character words written on it.  The post-it goes on their forehead (or back) without them seeing it.  Students mill around the classroom and elicit the mystery words from each other.
  • 26. + One Solution (Part 2)  Once all the words have been elicited, the corresponding negative equivalents are posted at various points around the room.  Students start in the middle and race to find their equivalent negative word and stand by it.  Points are awarded to first few to find it.  Students then read out both adjectives to the class and explain the difference.
  • 27. + General English Extension of Theme
  • 28. + The Students  A group of 10 adults  Upper-Intermediate (B2)  Intensive 20 hours/week course at a New York City Language School  Mixed-nationality/language  Generally well-motivated  Chatty
  • 29. + The Activity pp. 92-93 of American English File 4 Unit focusing on creativity and discovery.  Reading and Listening on creativity and innovation.  Four-question quiz to determine if you are creative or not.
  • 30. + One Solution Innovative Team Game  After the book‟s material introducing innovation and the short quiz, students get into small groups  Each group draws three random cards from this set of normal objects  They are given time to come up with a new product using all three objects and produce a TV commercial for it
  • 31. + In-Company Functional Language
  • 32. + The Students  A group of 5 insurance company executives  Upper-Intermediate (B2)  In-company class in a conference room  Unmotivated  Tired (end of the day)  Not chatty
  • 33. + The Activity p. 44 of Face2Face UpperIntermediate Unit focusing on expressing opinions.  Look at adjectives for expressing opinions.  Read a short article about ecological footprints.  Discuss the validity of this idea.  Branch off into discussion of other suggested topics.
  • 34. + One Solution (Part One)  Students are each given a pile of cut up scrap paper.  (Good use of that stack sitting in your office)  They watch a video clip and are asked to write down contradictory phrases. One per piece of paper.  After each view, the slips are compared and re-written so that each small group has one complete set.
  • 35. + One Solution (Part Two) Monty Python “Argument Clinic” Sketch
  • 36. + One Solution (Part Three) p. 94 of Pronunciation Games Photocopiables Book  Using their collected phrases, students play this quick card game.  They read their statement and their team members compete to be the first to correct it.  Extra Challenge: They draw their phrase cards randomly to avoid repetitive language.
  • 37. + But none of this works for me! How could we adapt material for these contexts?  Large class sizes  One-to-ones  Mixed-ability classrooms  Very young learners  Illiterate students  Students with mobility disability  Students unaccustomed to a classroom environment
  • 38. + In Conclusion • Think about your class‟ needs • Think about your lesson aims • When life gives you lemons…
  • 39. + Background References  Cunningsworth, A. (1995). Choosing your Coursebook. Oxford: Macmillan Heinemann ELT.  Ilieva, R. (2000). Exploring Culture in Texts Designed for Use in Adult ESL Classrooms. TESL Canada Journal , 17 (2), 50-63.  Littlejohn, A. (1998). The Analysis of Langauge Teaching Materials: Inside the Trojan Horse. In B. Tomlinson (Ed.), Materials Development in Language Teaching (pp. 190-216). Camridge: Cambridge University Press.  Nunan, D. (1988). The Learner-Centered Curriculum. Cambridge: Cambridge University Press.  Richards, J. C. (2000, 3 14). The role of textbooks in a language program. Retrieved 11 10, 2013, from Cambridge ELT Online - Brazil: http://www.cambridge.org.br/authorsarticles/articles?the-role-of-textbooks-in-a-language-program&id=337  Thornbury, S., & Meddings, L. (2009). Teaching Unplugged: Dogme in ELT Teaching. Surrey: DELTA Publishing.  Underhill, A., & Scrivner, J. (2012, March). Demand High ELT. Retrieved November 10, 2013, from http://demandhighelt.wordpress.com/
  • 40. + Materials References  Advanced Expert CAE by Jan Bell, Roger Gower and Drew Hyde (Pearson Longman, 2011)  American English File 4 by Clive Oxenden and Christina Latham-Koenig (Oxford University Press, 2008)  Face2Face Advanced by Gillie Cunningham, Jan Bell & Chris Redston (Cambridge University Press, 2009)  Face2Face Upper-Intetmediate by Chris Redston and Gillie Cunningham (Cambridge University Press, 2007)  Messages 2 by Diana and Noel Goodey (Cambridge University Press, 2005)  Pronunciation Games Photocopiables by Mark Hancock (Cambridge University Press, 1996)  Monty Python Skit on YouTube: “Monty Python Live at the Hollywood Bowl – Argument Clinic”  PuzzleMaker Site: http://www.puzzlemaker.com  Disabled Access Friendly Campaign Site: http://www.disabled-accessfriendly.com/
  • 41. + Thank You ! A copy of the presentation slides can be found at http://tinyurl.com/workwiththebook Or by scanning this QR code