2007 KMWorld Presentation on Augmented Social Cognition Research at PARC

Web 2.0 in the Enterprise Improving collaboration through research insights in coordination costs KMWorld & Intranets 2007 November 7, 2007 Ed H. Chi, Ph.D. Manager, Augmented Social Cognition Area echi@parc.com Lawrence C. Lee Director of Business Development lawrence.lee@parc.com Intelligent Systems Laboratory Palo Alto Research Center Inc.

PARC Overview   Interdisciplinary research center   Founded in 1970   Spun out of Xerox in 2002   Business model: –  Contract research –  Licensing –  Joint ventures –  Spinoffs KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 2

Web 2.0 and Enterprise 2.0 Software as a Service (SaaS) Remixing and Mashup of Services Rich User Interactions Social Networks Network Effects and Collective Intelligence Disruptive New Collaboration Environments Potential KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 3

Benefits of Web 2.0   Web 2.0 tools in the enterprise: –  Blogs –  Wikis –  Social bookmarking –  RSS –  Search –  Social networking   Benefits –  Simple to set up –  Easy to use –  Knowledge captured as side effect of communication KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 4

Costs of Web 2.0   Benefits of Web 2.0 do not come for free –  Interference effects –  Interaction costs –  Noisy folksonomies   Research Methodology –  Analyze activity on social systems –  Develop models on interaction dynamics –  Design new systems to increase benefits and reduce cost –  Test systems in Living Laboratories KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 5

Research Foundation   PARC’s rich history of research in information systems –  User interface research –  Information foraging theory –  Sensemaking   Augmented Social Cognition –  Vision: Enhance the ability of a group of people to remember, think, and reason –  Combines cognitive science with social computing research KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 6

Outline   Overview –  Benefits of Web 2.0 in the Enterprise –  Costs of Web 2.0 »  Interference effects, interaction costs, noisy folksonomies   Three examples of PARC research and solutions –  WikiDashboard: Providing social transparency in Wikispaces –  SparTag.us: Lowering interaction costs in tagging systems –  TagSearch: Reducing noise in tagged data and harnessing tags for search KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 7

I. Interference Effects in Wikipedia Declining percentage of activity devoted to article editing in Wikipedia Source: Wikipedia (Kittur, Suh, Pendelton, Chi) KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 8

Visualizing Interference and Conflict Revert Graph for Wikipedia page: Terry Schiavo Anonymous (vandals/ spammers) Sympathetic to husband Mediators Sympathetic to parents Source: Wikipedia (Kittur, Suh, Pendelton, Chi) KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 9

WikiDashboard   Transparency of social dynamics can reduce conflict and coordination issues –  WikiDashboard: Social dashboard for wikis –  Prototype system: http://wikidashboard.parc.com   Visualization for every wiki page showing edit history timeline and top individual editors   Can drill down into activity history for specific editors and view edits to see changes side-by-side KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 10

WikiDashboard Summary   Key problems –  Lack of visibility into social dynamics of wikis –  Lack of transparency in individual activity   PARC’s solution –  Visualization of individual edit activity to increase transparency, accountability, and quality of wikis –  Connect individuals with shared interests by reviewing activity on specific wiki topics KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 11

II. Interaction Costs and Social Systems   Interaction costs determine # People willing to produce for “free” number of people who participate   Surplus of attention & motivation at small transaction costs   Therefore…   Important to keep interaction costs low Cost of participation KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 12

Social Bookmarking   Means of storing, annotating, and sharing links   Typically done for oneself   But implicit sharing promotes transfer of expertise   Lightweight form of enterprise knowledge sharing   Players: –  Del.icio.us –  Connotea –  CiteUlike –  and many enterprise social bookmarking systems (that operate behind the firewall) KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 13

SparTag.us   Social bookmarking is easy to do but there is still friction in the process –  Tagging in new window separate from document –  Tagging limited to page level even though you want to tag a paragraph only –  Tags and annotations do not remain with paragraphs if referenced on other pages   New approach: Make tagging and retrieval of tagged content easier   Lower interaction costs and increase participation KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 14

SparTag.us   Key innovations –  Click-to-tag –  Paragraph-level tags –  Social annotations –  Tag portability Highlights (annotations) Paragraph-level tagging KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 15

SparTag.us Summary   Key problems –  Friction in current tagging process –  Tags are limited to page level only –  Difficult to find content of interest on page later   PARC’s solution –  In situ tagging on the same page using click-to-tag –  Tags applied to paragraphs –  Tags and annotations stay with paragraph, even on new pages (e.g. block quote on a blog post) –  My SparTag.us notebook displays all tagged and annotated paragraphs KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 17

III. Noise in Social Tagging Systems   Folksonomies emerge from social tagging systems   Benefits –  Freeform tagging instead of conforming to rigid taxonomies –  More flexibility allows users to recall information later –  Information discovery using tag browsing   Weaknesses –  Noise –  Inconsistency –  Difficult to leverage for search KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 18

Information Theoretic Measures   Mutual information I(Doc; Tag) –  Amount of information known about documents given knowledge of tags   Conditional entropy H(Doc|Tag) I(Doc;Tag) –  Additional amount of H(Doc|Tag) information needed to be known in order to identify a document given knowledge of tags Knowledge Knowledge of tags of documents KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 20

H(Doc | Tag)   More information needs to be known over time, over and above what is given by tags Source: del.icio.us (Chi & Mytkowicz) KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 22

Rise in Average Tags per Bookmark   Note parallel with increasing average number of words in a search query Source: del.icio.us (Chi & Mytkowicz) KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 23

But Social Tagging Creates Noise •  Synonyms •  Misspellings •  Morphologies People use different tag words to express similar concepts. KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 24

Use Semantic Analysis to Reduce Noise Semantic Similarity Graph Web Tools Reference Guide Howto Tutorial Tips Help Tip Tutorials Tricks KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 25

TagSearch – A New Search Engine   New approach: harness human intelligence encoded in tags on documents and web pages to improve search precision KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 26

TagSearch Summary   Key problems –  Noisy tag data –  Users do not want to conform to rigid taxonomies –  Too many irrelevant results in enterprise search   PARC’s solution –  Let users tag freeform but use data mining techniques to reduce noise –  Harness normalized tag data in new search algorithm –  Result: High precision enterprise search engine trained on content tagged by enterprise community KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 27

Conclusion   Effective deployment of Web 2.0 tools requires understanding of both costs and benefits. –  Increasing transparency results in higher quality –  Lowering interaction costs results in higher participation –  Decreasing noise results in greater search precision   PARC works with enterprises to solve specific problems and deploy customized versions of its suite of Web 2.0 technologies. KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 28

Contacts   Stop by our booth at the Expo - Booth 313   Our contact information: Ed H. Chi, Ph.D. Manager, Augmented Social Cognition Area echi@parc.com 650.812.4312 Lawrence C. Lee Director of Business Development lawrence.lee@parc.com 650.812.4756 KM World & Intranets 2007 – © 2007 Palo Alto Research Center Inc. 29

2007 KMWorld Presentation on Augmented Social Cognition Research at PARC

by Ed Chi on Jan 22, 2009

Accessibility

Categories

Tags

Upload Details

Usage Rights

1 Embed 1

Statistics

2007 KMWorld Presentation on Augmented Social Cognition Research at PARC — Presentation Transcript