CAS Chemistry Research Report  - Nanofiltration Shows Promise in the Quest for Pure Water
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

CAS Chemistry Research Report - Nanofiltration Shows Promise in the Quest for Pure Water



Water scarcity is driving a wave of innovation in water filtration technology from Asian nations. Asian researchers now lead the world in patent activity related to nanofiltration, the most-researched ...

Water scarcity is driving a wave of innovation in water filtration technology from Asian nations. Asian researchers now lead the world in patent activity related to nanofiltration, the most-researched method of water filtration. To learn more, read our latest CAS Chemistry Research Report.



Total Views
Views on SlideShare
Embed Views



0 Embeds 0

No embeds



Upload Details

Uploaded via as Adobe PDF

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
Post Comment
Edit your comment

    CAS Chemistry Research Report  - Nanofiltration Shows Promise in the Quest for Pure Water CAS Chemistry Research Report - Nanofiltration Shows Promise in the Quest for Pure Water Document Transcript

    • CAS Chemistry Research Report Delivering the latest trends in global chemistry researchNanofiltrationShows Promisein the Questfor Pure Water
    • CAS Chemistry Research Report 1970 to 2009, the United States led in nanofiltration research, while Asian countries dominated the majority of commercial initiatives. When the well’s dry, we know the worth of water. – Benjamin Franklin, Poor Richard’s Almanack, 1746 The Need for Water Purification Among the many environmental issues following the Deepwater Horizon oil spill is water purity. BP, the U.S. Government, and private contractors have already used chemical, physical, and biological methods of water purification to restore the Gulf waters to their pre-spill state. Used individually or jointly, physical, biological, and chemical methods purify wastewater, drinking water, and even seawater. Waves, wind, and vessel operations physically disperse spilled oil in seawater. Filtration is the major physical method of purifying wastewaterSafety and Scarcity Drives Water and drinking water. It works by trapping large particles or solutes in much the same way a colander lets waterPurification Research drain from cooked pasta. Different-sized membraneFrom April 20 until July 15, 2010, the Deepwater Horizon filters used in series remove progressively smalleroffshore oil drilling rig spilled more than 200 million solutes from microfiltration, through ultrafiltration,gallons of oil into the Gulf of Mexico.1 It was the latest nanofiltration, and reverse osmosis (RO). In biologicalnotable setback in the worldwide quest to improve methods of water purification, microorganismswater safety. degrade organic materials. Chemical methods are usually specific (chlorine) to the contaminantThe United Nations predicts that by 2015, five billion (disinfectant) being addressed.people (two-thirds of the world’s population) will livein areas of significant water stress, lacking sufficient In addition to physically separating solutes bysafe water for drinking, industry, or agriculture.2 size, nanofiltration is influenced by the chemicalApproximately 3.5 million deaths—6.3 percent of all composition and behavior of the membrane.3 Thedeaths worldwide—could be prevented through the asymmetrical membranes are commonly composedsimple provision of safe water. of polysulfone (CAS Registry Number [RN]: 25135-51-7) and superimposed with a thin top layer with a negativeWater purification is one way to address the world’s chemical charge. In some cases, the negative chargeinadequate supply of safe water. Researchers from repels other negatively charged solutes, which mayCAS, a division of the American Chemical Society and cause membrane swelling or shrinking in response.the world’s authority for chemical information, studied40 years of water purification literature in patent and Nanofiltration emerged in the late 1980s, filling the gapjournal publications. They found that filtration, and between ultrafiltration and RO. Nanofiltration removesparticularly nanofiltration, is the emerging method smaller solutes than are captured by ultrafiltrationof water purification studied and commercialized and has a higher filtrate flow rate than RO at equalworldwide. CAS researchers also noted that from pressure, leading to smaller systems with the same 2
    • CAS Chemistry Research ReportMultiple Methods Purify Water PHYSICAL Filtration: separates out solutes based on size (sand, screens, membranes) BIOLOGICAL Biological: uses bacteria and other microorganisms to destroy organic material naturally CHEMICAL Clarification: clusters solids to be removed by gravity Ion Exchange: removes charged solutes (water softeners) Disinfection: kills microorganisms (ozone, chlorine, UV-radiation)Figure 1. Methods of Water PurificationCAS researchers investigated major physical, biological, and chemical water purification methods.production capacity. Advances in new applications of 2000 ▬ Total Chemicalnanofiltration technology such as desalination and Published Documents (Total Number) ▬ Disinfectionself-cleaning may address the looming scarcity of safe ▬ Clarificationwater, according to the U.S. Environmental Protection ▬ Ion Exchange 1500 ▬ FiltrationAgency.4 ▬ BiologicalThis Chemistry Research Report investigates 40 years of 1000water purification research to reveal increased interestin filtration as represented in the CAS databases, 500the world’s most authoritative and comprehensivecollection of chemistry and science-related information.Nanofiltration attracted increased research and 0commercial interest since its emergence in 1987, 1970 1975 1980 1985 1990 1995 2000 2005according to CAS researchers. Major Methods of Water Purification 1970-2009The Emergence of Nanofiltration Figure 2. Filtration Ahead after 40 Years of WaterFrom 1970 to 2009, global researchers produced more Purificationjournal and patent publications about filtration than Filtration-related journal and patent publications increasedabout any chemical or biological method of water 8,500 percent from 1970-2009.purification (Figure 2). During this time, filtration-related publications increased 8,500 percent, withfiltration-related patent publications exceeding journalpublications by 25 percent in 2009. 3
    • CAS Chemistry Research ReportNanofiltration Related Publications Emerged in 1987 500Published Documents (Total Number) ▬ Microfiltration ▬ Journals Published Documents (Total Number) ▬ Ultrafiltration ▬ Patents ▬ Nanofiltration 150 400 300 100 200 50 100 0 0 1987 1989 1991 1993 1995 1997 1999 2001 2003 2005 2007 2009 1990 1995 2000 2005 Filtration Methods 1990-2009 Nanofiltration-Related Publications Figure 3. Nanofiltration Increased Most Figure 4. Nanofiltration Research Expands Exponentially Nanofiltration research emerged most recently, with total Nanofiltration-related journal and patent publications recently publications increasing five-fold between 1999 and 2009. emerged in the past 20 years.Contaminants or Impurities Removed Depend on Filtration Method Operating Method of Filtration Pore Size Pressure Required Materials Removed Microfiltration (MF) ≥ 0.1 µm Low Bacteria, large viruses, solids Ultrafiltration (UF) ≥ 0.005 µm Moderately Low Viruses, proteins, starches Nanofiltration (NF) ≥ 0.0005 µm Moderate Pesticides, herbicides, iron, nickel, mercury, sulfate and hardnessTable 1. Major Methods of Filtration Remove Large and Small Solutes 4
    • CAS Chemistry Research Report United States Veolia Environment (France) Peoples Republic of China Kiwa N.V. (Netherlands) France Katholieke Universiteit Leuven (Belgium) Germany Tsinghua University (China) Japan Gwangju Institute of Science and Technology (South Korea) Netherlands University of Central Florida (United States) 0 5 10 15 20 25 30 0 10 20 30 Nanofiltration Journal Publications (% Total) Journal Sources in Nanofiltration (Number of Articles) Figure 5. U.S. Ahead in Nanofiltration Research Figure 6. France Tops Corporate Nanofiltration Research U.S. affiliated authors accounted for one-quarter of all nanofiltration-related journal articles. Veolia Environment topped other corporate sources for the most nanofiltration-related publications with 2 percent of all journal documents.CAS scientists analyzed research publications covering friendly, removes pathogens and pharmaceuticals,microfiltration, ultrafiltration, and nanofiltration and can desalinate brackish water. According to amethods of water purification (Figure 3, Table 1). 2007 report, the commercial success of nanofiltrationNanofiltration-related patent and journal publications technology will reach $310 million worldwide by 2012.5increased 6,300 percent from 1990 through 2009,advancing more than microfiltration and ultrafiltration. U.S., France Author Most Research CAS scientists determined that through 2009,Research Interest in Nanofiltration the United States (U.S.) authored more than one-Accelerates quarter of nanofiltration-related journal articlesTotal published nanofiltration-related journal articles (Figure 5). U.S. authorship almost doubled Chineseincreased 3,375 percent from 1990-2009 (Figure 4). authorship, the second most prolific nation inNanofiltration-related patent publications grew nearly nanofiltration publications.600 percent from 1999-2009, despite having fewer Among academic and corporate affiliations ondocuments than journal article publications overall. nanofiltration-related journal articles, the French entityGrowth in nanofiltration research supports worldwide Veolia Environment was the leading individual firmefforts to improve water quality and quantity. (Figure 6), despite that U.S. combined corporate sourcesAs nanofiltration-related research increases, safe are three times greater. Veolia was established asdrinking water becomes more environmentally and Compagnie Générale des Eaux by Napoleon III ineconomically affordable. Due to lower operating 1853 and today provides drinking water and wastewaterpressures, nanofiltration reduces energy consumption, services to 163 million people in France.6operation costs, and waste. It is also environmentally 5
    • CAS Chemistry Research ReportAsia Commercializes Nanofiltration State Intellectual Property Office (China)Asian patent authorities represent 60 percent of allnanofiltration-related patent publications. The State Japan Patent OfficeIntellectual Patent Office (SIPO) of the People’s Republicof China had 33 percent of nanofiltration-related patent World Intellectual Property Organizationpublications (Figure 7), while the Japan Patent Office(JPO) and Korean Intellectual Property Office (KIPO) U.S. Patent and Trademark Officepublished 16 percent and 10 percent, respectively. Korean Intellectual Property OfficeCAS researchers found that most Asian patentassignees were domestic. In fact, KIPO patent German Patent and Trade Mark Officepublications were completely domestic, while less than2 percent of JPO and SIPO patent publications 0 10 20 30had nondomestic assignees. Nanofiltration Patent Publications (% Total)U.S. Leads WIPO Patent PublicationsThe U.S. contributed four times as many nanofiltration- Figure 7. Asian Patent Offices Dominate Nanofiltrationrelated patent publications to the World Intellectual Asian authorities accounted for 60 percent of nanofiltration- related patent publications.Property Organization (WIPO) as any other country(Figure 8). Patent applications to WIPO may indicatea desire for worldwide commercialization.U.S. assignees General Electric (GE) and the DowChemical Company produced 20 percent ofWIPO patent publications (Figure 9). Notably, GE United Statesnanofiltration technology recycled rainwater inthe National Stadium in Beijing, China for the 2008 NetherlandsWorld Olympics, while Dow technology (FILMTEC™) Francehas provided purified drinking water to Sweden’sresort community in Lofsdalen since 1998. Dow’s Germanynanomembrane technology utilizes polyamide(CAS RN: 83044-99-9P) thin film composites along United Kingdomwith other sulfone copolymers to better separatecharged particles. Akzo Nobel N.V. leads among CanadaWIPO patent assignees with nanofiltration-relatedpublications on salt recovery, wastewater treatment, 0 10 20 30 40and nanomembrane cleaning. Recently, Akzo Nobel WIPO Patent Assignee Country (Percent Total)endorsed the CEO Water Mandate, making it amongmore than 50 companies committed to developing,implementing, and sustaining water practices Figure 8. WIPO Patent Publications Are Mostly U.S.and policies. Through 2009, the U.S. was the chief assignee on nanofiltration-related patent publications from WIPO. 6
    • CAS Chemistry Research Report References Akzo Nobel N.V. (Netherlands) 1. Deepwater Horizon Unified Command, US Scientific Teams Refine Estimates of Oil Flow from BP’s Well Prior General Electric (United States) to Capping Gulf of Mexico Oil Spill Response 2010. (accessed Veolia Environment (France) August 20, 2010) 2. United Nations. The Millennium Development Goals Report Sasol (South Africa) 2010. (accessed August 30, 2010). Dow Chemical (United States) 3. Braghetta, A.; DiGiano, F.A. Organic Solute Association with Nanofiltration Membrane Surface: Influence of pH and Ionic Vasterguard S.A. (Switzerland) Strength on Membrane Performance. Proc., Annu. AWWA Cont. 1994, Sm. Water Works Association., New York, N.Y. 0 2 4 6 8 10 4. U.S. Environmental Protection Agency. Aging Water WIPO Nanofiltration Patents by Company (Total Number) Infrastructure (AWI) Research: Innovative Treatment Technologies. (accessed August 3, 2010). Figure 9. Netherlands Company Leads Corporate Nanofiltration 5. BCC Research Report NAN045A on Nanofiltration. Among corporate sources, Akzo Nobel N.V. had the most WIPO (accessed August 30, 2010). nanofiltration-related patent publications. 6. Veolia Environment. (accessed August 13, 2010).Conclusion CAS does not warrant or assume legal liability for the accuracy, completeness, or usefulness of information in the CAS ChemistryThis CAS Chemistry Research Report highlights Research Reports. While products and services may be mentionedincreased water purification research and in the reports, CAS does not endorse or recommend commercialcommercialization from 1970-2009, focusing on products, processes, or services.nanofiltration. Water purification research conducted FILMTECTM is a trademark of the Dow Chemical will address environmental and humanitarianwater stressors to preserve global health and a safeenvironment for future generations to enjoy. 7
    • CAS Chemistry Research Report CAS Chemistry Research ReportChemical Abstracts Service (CAS), a division ofthe American Chemical Society, is the world’sauthority for chemical information. Ourdatabases are curated and quality-controlledby CAS scientists, and recognized by chemicaland pharmaceutical companies, universities,government organizations, and patentoffices around the world as comprehensiveand authoritative. By combining thesedatabases with advanced search and analysistechnologies (SciFinder®, STN®, and ScienceIP® products and services), CAS delivers themost current, complete, and cross-linkedsecure digital information environment forscientific discovery.CAS800-753-4227 (North America)614-447-3700 (worldwide)© 2010 American Chemical Society 8