Delivering Ice to Every House Olga Belevantseva Andrey Belykh Dmitriy Polyektov Said Ibragimov Changellenge Cup Moscow 2011 MGIMOGINATION
The target of Unilever is to double the sales of ice cream in Russia by 2015 * See Appendix 1 The maximum production capacity of Unilever allows to reach the target. However the market is growing at a lower rate than necessary. Therefore the company needs to increase its market share. Attention should be concentrated on structuring the distribution and logistic systems in order to confront the competitors
To reach the target Unilever should increase its share on the ice cream market*
See Appendix 1
** Where the company holds strong positions
Inmarko holds strong positions on the Far Eastern and Siberian markets while its market share in the European part of Russia is not so significant. The worst positions are in the Northern region where the company is only on the 7 th place.
The main competitors of Inmarko on the ice cream market in the European part of Russia are Nestle, Talosto and Iceberry.
Nestle is mainly operating in the premium segment while Inmarko and the other two companies are operating in the lower price category. Therefore Nestle poses no competition to them.
Talosto is strong in North West and is characterized by the well developed own system of distribution and logistics. It operates in Modern trade segment.
The main competitor of Inmarko operating in the same sales channel is Iceberry. Its structure of distributional channels is similar to Inmarko’s. However it should be noted that the major part of branches of Inmarko falls on the Eastern part of Russia. On the European part the most developed own distribution system of Inmarko is in Moscow.
1. Develop own distribution system ?
2. Increase the share of the Modern trade?
Competitor Market share Coverage** Target audience** Distribution channel** Sales channel** Inmarko 22% One price category Traditional trade Iceberry 14% Traditional trade Russkiy Kholod 7% Modern trade Traditional trade Talosto 6% Modern trade Nestle 15% Premium segment Modern trade
To increase the market share Unilever should start from developing its own distribution system
advanced level of influence on the market
additional advertising through a net of branded kiosks and chests
ability to implement own marketing strategies
establishing long-term relations with customers
ability to react fast on changing demand
implementation of latest WMS
optimisation of transportation that will lead to decrease in cost
decline in demand in the areas of representation
growth of maintenance costs due to external factors (growth of tariffs on electricity, gas , heating etc.)
requires large amount of investments
significant fixed costs connected with maintenance of the network
inability to leave a certain region in case of falling demand without considerable losses
long pay-off period
well-organized dealer system
admission to small retailers and stores which mainly buy products in from regional distributors
ability to send low-volume batches in order to respond properly to the retail demand
no need for having large sales departments
- possibility of overpricing
in case of non-exclusive contract distributors could give preference to another client in terms of delivery order
need to possess at least 25-30% market share and strong brand in order to avoid overpricing
the end customer is beyond the control due to complicated chain
Own distribution system Distributors services
Despite the fact that the own distribution system (ODS) implies high costs and long pay-off period it provides a lot of benefits and helps to prepare the ground for the further steps and in particular for expanding relationships with distributors when the maximum production capacity reaches 200 mln litres.
ODS allows to offer lower prices to consumers which automatically boosts sales.
Moreover ODS contributes to gaining the market share and establishing strong brand on the market which eliminates most weaknesses and threats of expanding the share of distributors services in future. That will help to diversify distribution channels and reduce costs in the long-run according to our estimations.
Development of own distribution network will increase loyalty of customers, lower prices and, ultimately, will boost sales
Unilever should take into account seasonal features when developing its own distribution system Seasonality of sales, by type Two main sales channels Modern Trade / Key accounts Traditional Trade
There is a stable demand throughout the year for home consumption purposes.
Modern Trade accounts for only 25% in total sales of Inmarko.
The demand is driven mainly by impulse consumption which is most active during four months – from May to August.
By increasing the share of Modern trade in the sales channel structure Unilever could enlarge sales during the cold months reduce costs of transportation and warehousing Enlargement of retail branches (shops, stalls) and installation of branded stalls as part of the marketing program
According to our estimations it is better to have the own stalls than to rent them due to several reasons. First of all, rental costs are very high. Moreover the group possesses the production facilities which reduces the costs.
Branded stalls provide better recognizability among customers and increase loyalty.
The enlargement of retail branches will help the company to meet the demand during the ‘high season’, increase recognizability of the brand and facilitate the access to the production – all this factors jointly will lead to the boost in sales
The priority for Unilever is to improve its situation in the Northern regions, and in particular in St. Petersburg where the company holds the low 7 th place.
The second step is to increase the share of Modern Trade in order to meet the demand in cold months.
Enlargement of retail branches will help to gain the market share and build stronger relations with the customers.
Due to the increase in the production capacities additional transport fleet may be necessary.
There is an option to start enlarging relationships with distributors in 2014-2015. The company will have competitive advantage by then and will be able to negotiate necessary terms successfully.
In this case the target of doubling the sales by 2015 will be reached Actions 2012 2013 2014 2015 Increase the number of stalls in Northern regions and in the South region Increase the share of Modern trade Enlarge retail branches in Western regions Enlarge transport park upon necessity Enlarge relationships with distributors
Appendix 1 * Conversion rate of 40 rubles per euro was used The market share of 30,65% should be achieved in order to reach the target by 2015. 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 mln litres 60 80 100 120 200 ths tons 41,1 54,8 68,5 82,2 137 price 200,9 215,8 231,3 246,4 259,2 potential sales (mln rub) 8258,1 11825,6 15846,3 20251,6 35507,8 potential sales (mln euro)* 283,52 295,6 396,2 506,3 887,7 2011 2012 2013 2014 2015 mln people 79,5 81,2 82,5 83,9 85 consumption per person (litres) 3,8 3,9 4,0 4,1 4,2 consumption per person (kg) 3,04 3,13 3,21 3,28 3,36 total consumption 241,68 254,25 264,78 275,20 285,50 price 200,9 215,8 231,3 246,4 259,2 sales (mln rub) 48560,134 54866,88 61252,93 67800,89 73995,9 sales (mln euro) 1214,00335 1371,672 1531,323 1695,022 1849,89 30,65%