Advantages and Disadvantages of Integration_Pablo Stansbery_10.16.13
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in...5

Advantages and Disadvantages of Integration_Pablo Stansbery_10.16.13






Total Views
Views on SlideShare
Embed Views



0 Embeds 0

No embeds


Upload Details

Uploaded via as Microsoft PowerPoint

Usage Rights

© All Rights Reserved

Report content

Flagged as inappropriate Flag as inappropriate
Flag as inappropriate

Select your reason for flagging this presentation as inappropriate.

  • Full Name Full Name Comment goes here.
    Are you sure you want to
    Your message goes here
Post Comment
Edit your comment

Advantages and Disadvantages of Integration_Pablo Stansbery_10.16.13 Advantages and Disadvantages of Integration_Pablo Stansbery_10.16.13 Presentation Transcript

  • Early Childhood Development + Health/ Nutrition
  • Caregiver/Family Child Family Home to Early Learning Environment Birth PreSchool to Primary School Child’s Development Prenatal Birth - 3 Ages 3 5 Ages 5 - 8
  • 1. Early Experiences Matter
  • 2. Social Referencing
  • 3. Nature versus Nurture Approaches to Learning
  • Milestones for early motor development
  • Promise of Preschool in Africa Mozambique 2011
  • ECD ACCESS Conventional Pre-Primary (GMR, 2012) Country Sub-Saharan Africa Birundi 1999 2010 10 1 17 9 Comoros 2 22 Ethiopia 1 5 21 65 South Africa
  • Development risks at baseline Risks Stunting Percentage 42.3% Risk of delays in fine motor skills (36-41 months) 70% Risk of developmental delays (36-41 months) 65% Orphaned Caregiver does not know how to read 10.01% 42% 51.35% Caregiver does not speak Portuguese Source: Authors calculation from the baseline data for the impact evaluation (2008)
  • Peabody: Receptive Vocabulary (2008)
  • ECD/Preschool Conclusions  ECD/Preschool model effective at:  Target Children:  Increasing primary enrollment & attendance  Improve pro-social behaviors & decrease hyperactivity behavior  Improving hygiene practices and reduce diarrhea & skin infex  Reducing children’s time working on family farm  Older Siblings:  Increasing in school enrollment  Parents:  Changing parenting practices  Increasing labor market participation  NO IMPACT: Improve child growth (stunting)**
  • What’s Trending: ECD ACCESS Integrated, innovative, scalable Home-based (Essential Package) Community Healthcare Workers (C4D) Cascade ECD-Health Fairs Parent-Child Community Gatherings Mobile Program Interactive Radio/ Phone Messages/ Email/ TV
  • Interventions with stunted children highlight the importance of stimulation  Integration of health, nutrition and education/cognitive stimulation (comprehensive programs) has larger and sustained impacts for children Non-stunted children DQ 110 Supplemented and stimulated 105 Stimulated 100 Supplemented 95 Control 90 85 Baseline 6 mo 12 mo Grantham-McGregor et al, 1991 18 mo 24 mo
  • 4. Integrated Programming: Nutrition/Stimulation
  • ECD Lifespan Approach Economic Strengthening / Health- Nutrition / Women’s Development Adolescent s Pregnancy Birth to 30 days 1 month to 3 years 3 to 4 years Nutrition/Food Security Adolescent Development Maternal and Child Health 5 to 6 years 7 to 8 years Primary Education School health and nutrition Child Protection, Global Warming, AIDS
  • Integration: Program + (ECD)  Maternal and Child Health  WASH  Maternal Education  Emergency Response  Youth  HIV/Protection  Resiliency and Peace Building  Basic Education (Emergent Literacy)
  • “Advantages and Disadvantages of Integration: Opportunities for Integrating Early Childhood Development (ECD) and Nutrition Programming” Ann M. DiGirolamoa, Pablo Stansberyb, , Mary Lung’ahoa,c a CARE International; b Save the Children; c Nutrition Policy & Practice Annals of the New York Academy of Sciences entitled “Integrated Interventions in Child Development, and Nutrition (forthcoming) Dr Mandana Arabi, Dr Maureen Black, Dr Lia Fernald, Dr Sally McGregor, Dr Ted Wachs, Dr Susan Walkers, Dr Aisha Yusafzai
  • Health Nutrition ECD (HNECD) Advantages Staff workload Supervisory Responsibilities 3. 2. 1. 2. 1. Cost effectiveness of HNECD programming Challenges Common language activities Co-location of services 3. Coordinated messaging 4. HNECD programs protect and promote children’s growth and development across multiple domains 4. 5. Training/Orientation
  • ECD Menu of Services
  • USG Children in Adversity 1. Build Strong Beginnings 2. Put Family care first 3. Protect children from violence, exploitation, abuse and neglect
  • 2 new ECD Resources
  • Essential Package Building Blocks 1. Positive caregiver-child interaction 2. Developmentally- appropriate approach 3. Link to broader systems of integrated care 4. Eliminate barriers to care and support
  • Activities parents can do with child… 0-2 months
  • Group Discussion 1. Identify examples of promising practices of integrated programming. 2. Post- MDG agenda: Where sits early childhood? Should there be a separate ECD goal or embedded in current health/ nutrition goal. What might that look like?