SEISMIC BASE ISOLATION FOR  BUILDINGS IN REGIONS OF LOW TO       MODERATE SEISIMICITYA.B.M. SAIFUL ISLAM, SYED ISHTIAQ,MOH...
OVERVIEW   EARTH QUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES   EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURE BY BASE    ISOLATION   A TEN STOREY BUILDI...
EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES   WHY DO WE NEED EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT    STRUCTURES?   WHAT DO WE DO TO MAKE A STRUCTURE...
EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES BY BASE               ISOLATION   WHAT IS BASE ISOLATION?   HOW DOES IT WORKS?   MATERI...
CONT   SUITABILITY OF BASE ISOLATORS   APPLICATION OF BASE ISOLATOR   PARAMETERS REQUIRED FOR SIESMIC BASE    ISOLATION...
CONT   PRELIMINARY EXPLORATION OF THE SUITABILITY    OF BASE ISOLATOR   SOPHISTICATED FEM SOFTWARE SAP2000 HAS    BEEN U...
ISOLATION DESIGN FLOW CHART   FLOW CHART FOR SEQUENTIAL ISOLATOR DESIGN    IS GIVEN                                      ...
EXPERIMENT   A TEN STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING LOCATED    IN DHAKA OF 4 SPACING AT 7.62M C/C SPACING IN    BOTH DIRECTION...
PLAN AND ELEVATION OF BUILDING                                 9
ESSENTIAL DATA   Fck = 28 MPa   FY = 414MPa   DEAD LOAD EXCLUDING SELF WEIGHT = 4.8    N/mm2   LIVE LOAD = 2.4 KN/mm2...
CONT   INTERIOR COLUMNS C3=1000mmX1000mm   GRADE BEAMS GB=300mmX375mm   GB1=525mmx825mm   GB2=600mmx900mm   GB3=550mm...
EXPERIMENT   EQUIVALENT STATIC ANALYSIS OF THE    CONVENTIONAL FIXED BUILDING IS DONE BY    BNBC   BUT FOR ISOLATED BUIL...
STATIC ANALYSIS WITHOUT USING ISOLATOR                   TABLE1DATA ANALYSED                                 VALUESSTRUCTU...
ISOLATION DESIGN   RUBBER ISOLATORS ARE DESIGNED CONSIDERING    VERTICAL LOADS,ISOLATOR TYPES   THE MATERIAL DEFINITIONS...
MATERIAL DEFINITIONS TABLE2ELASTROMER                UNITS   VALUEPROPERTIESSHEAR MODULUS         KPa         400ULTIMATE ...
SEISMIC LOADS AND STRUCTURAL DATA TABLE3SEISMIC PROPERIES                         VALUESEISMIC ZONE FACTOR                ...
CONT   HDRB AND LRB HAVE BEEN ASSIGNED AT THE    MIDDLE C3 AND OUTSIDE C1 AND C2 COLUMNS    RESPECTIVLEY   TYPES OF ISOL...
TYPES OF ISOLATORS AND LOADS TABLE4BEARING TYPES AND LOAD DATA   LRB       HDRB       TOTALTYPE                          I...
ISOLATOR PERFORMANCE   THE TWO MAIN THHINGS NEEDED TO TAKE CARE ARE    1)THE STATUS OF THE ISOLATOR BEARING TO    SUPPORT...
CONT   SEISMIC COEFFICENT CORRESPONDING TO    CONSTANT ACCELERATION REGION    FOR DBE(CA) = 0.22    FOR MCE(CAM)= 0.35   ...
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS   ASSIGNING THE PROPERTIES TO THE ISOLATORS    AND LINKED TO THE STRUCTURE AND IS    ANALYSED   FROM TH...
CONT   THEN AFTER LINKING THE BI TO THE STRUCTURE THE    DYNAMIC ANALYSIS,RESPONSE SPECTRUM AND TIME    HISTORY IS PERFOR...
COMPOSITE RESPONSE SPECTRUM FOR DHAKAEARTHQUAKE                                    23
RESULTS   DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF FIXED BUILDING IS    PERFORMED BY SAP AND THE RESULTS ARE    SHOWN IN TABLE5   LINEAR STAT...
DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF FIXED BUILDING TABLE5                             RESPONSE            TIME HISTORY                    ...
RESULTS OF DYNAMIC ANALYSIS USINGISOLATOR TABLE 6STRUCTURAL PERIOD FOR MODE      ISOLATOR       TOTAL1                    ...
BASE SHEAR AND BASE MOMENT AFTERDYNAMIC ANALYSIS TABLE7                    RESPONSE SPECTRUM   TIME HISTORY               ...
CONT   SINCE ALL THE VALUES OF BASE SHEAR AND    DESIGN BASE MOMENT HAS DRASTICALLY    REDUCED BY INATALLATION OF ISOLATO...
ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS   THOUGH THE INSTALLATION OF ISOLATION    SYSTEM ADDS MORE TO INITIAL COST IT REDUCES    THE REINFO...
NET SAVINGS IN THE ISOLATED BUILDINGTABLE8NO OF     SAVINGS   NO OF      ISOLATOR   NET       NETSTORIES   FROM      ISOLA...
CONT   FOR THE SAME PLAN AREA BUILDINGS HAS BEEN    NALYSED FOR 4,5,6,7,8,9 STOREY TO REPRESENT A    COMPARITIVE GENERALI...
% SAVINGS IN REINFORCEMENT FOR BEAMSAND COLUMNS VERSUS DIFFERENT STORIES                                       32
INSIGHTS   DUE TO VAST CIVILISATION AND URBANISATION    MANY REGIONS OF EARTH ARE GOING TO BE    EARTHQUAKE PRONE IN FUTU...
CONCLUSIONS   EVEN THOUGH SEISMIC BASE ISOLATION    INCREASES THE INITIAL COST THE REDUCTION IN    REINFORCEMENT IN UPPER...
REFERENCES   BANGLADESH NATIONAL BUILDING CODE(19993)    HOUSING AND BUILDING RESEARCH INSTITUTE   DEB S.K(2004) “SEISMI...
THANK YOU            36
Upcoming SlideShare
Loading in …5
×

B.praveen kumar

571 views

Published on

Published in: Career, Technology, Business
0 Comments
0 Likes
Statistics
Notes
  • Be the first to comment

  • Be the first to like this

No Downloads
Views
Total views
571
On SlideShare
0
From Embeds
0
Number of Embeds
4
Actions
Shares
0
Downloads
56
Comments
0
Likes
0
Embeds 0
No embeds

No notes for slide

B.praveen kumar

  1. 1. SEISMIC BASE ISOLATION FOR BUILDINGS IN REGIONS OF LOW TO MODERATE SEISIMICITYA.B.M. SAIFUL ISLAM, SYED ISHTIAQ,MOHAMEMMED JAMMEL MEMBERS OF ASCE PRACTICAL PERIODICAL ON STRUCTURAL DESIGN & CONSTRUCTION ,ASCE FEB 2012 BETHU PRAVEEN KUMAR(12CE65R11) STRUCTURAL ENGINEERING DEPARTMENT OF CIVIL ENGINEERING IIT KHARAGHPUR 1
  2. 2. OVERVIEW EARTH QUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURE BY BASE ISOLATION A TEN STOREY BUILDING IN DHAKA IS TAKEN AND ANALYSED RESULTS INSIGHTS CONCLUSIONS TYPICAL REFERENCES 2
  3. 3. EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES WHY DO WE NEED EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES? WHAT DO WE DO TO MAKE A STRUCTURE EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT? TECHNIQUES USED FOR EAARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES 3
  4. 4. EARTHQUAKE RESISTANT STRUCTURES BY BASE ISOLATION WHAT IS BASE ISOLATION? HOW DOES IT WORKS? MATERIAL USED AS BASE ISOLATORS LRB(1970’S) AND HDRB(1980’S) 4
  5. 5. CONT SUITABILITY OF BASE ISOLATORS APPLICATION OF BASE ISOLATOR PARAMETERS REQUIRED FOR SIESMIC BASE ISOLATION 5
  6. 6. CONT PRELIMINARY EXPLORATION OF THE SUITABILITY OF BASE ISOLATOR SOPHISTICATED FEM SOFTWARE SAP2000 HAS BEEN USED FOR ANALYSIS OF THE STRUCTURE IMPLEMENTATION OF BI IS A SUITABLE ALTERNATIVE AS IT INCREASES FLEXIBILITY AND REDUCES LATERAL FORCES 6
  7. 7. ISOLATION DESIGN FLOW CHART FLOW CHART FOR SEQUENTIAL ISOLATOR DESIGN IS GIVEN 7
  8. 8. EXPERIMENT A TEN STOREY RESIDENTIAL BUILDING LOCATED IN DHAKA OF 4 SPACING AT 7.62M C/C SPACING IN BOTH DIRECTIONS IS ANALYSED ESSENTIAL DATA REQUIRED FOR ANALYSIS IS SHOWN BELOW THE PLAN AND ELEVATION IS SHOWN 8
  9. 9. PLAN AND ELEVATION OF BUILDING 9
  10. 10. ESSENTIAL DATA Fck = 28 MPa FY = 414MPa DEAD LOAD EXCLUDING SELF WEIGHT = 4.8 N/mm2 LIVE LOAD = 2.4 KN/mm2 SLAB THICKNESS = 150mm EXTERIOR CORNER COLUMNS C1=750mmX750mm EXTERIOR MIDDLE COLUMNS C2=950mmX950mm 10
  11. 11. CONT INTERIOR COLUMNS C3=1000mmX1000mm GRADE BEAMS GB=300mmX375mm GB1=525mmx825mm GB2=600mmx900mm GB3=550mmX900mm 11
  12. 12. EXPERIMENT EQUIVALENT STATIC ANALYSIS OF THE CONVENTIONAL FIXED BUILDING IS DONE BY BNBC BUT FOR ISOLATED BUILDINGS RESPONSE REDUCTION FACTOR=2 AND IMPORTANCE FACTOR=1 IS TAKEN THE STATIC ANALYSIS RESULTS ARE SHOWN IN TABLE 1 12
  13. 13. STATIC ANALYSIS WITHOUT USING ISOLATOR TABLE1DATA ANALYSED VALUESSTRUCTURAL TIME PERIOD 0.913secDESIGN BASE SHEAR(EQ LOAD) 4565KNDESIGN BASE SHEAR(WIND LOAD) 2698KNMAXIMUM TOP STORY DISPLACEMENT(EQ LOAD) 13.63mmMAXIMUM TOP STORY DISPLACEMENT(WIND LOAD) 6.63mmTOTAL WEIGHT OF THE BUILDING 127766KNGOVERNING AXIAL LOAD UNDER COLUMN C3 7215KNGOVERNING AXIAL LOAD UNDER COLUMN C2 4546KNGOVERNING AXIAL LOAD UNDER COLUMN C1 2544KN 13
  14. 14. ISOLATION DESIGN RUBBER ISOLATORS ARE DESIGNED CONSIDERING VERTICAL LOADS,ISOLATOR TYPES THE MATERIAL DEFINITIONS IN TABLE2 IS THE BASIC INFORMATION FOR DESIGN PROCESS TABLE3 PROVIDES THE INFORMATION OF THE SEISMIC LOADS AND STRUCTURAL DATA 14
  15. 15. MATERIAL DEFINITIONS TABLE2ELASTROMER UNITS VALUEPROPERTIESSHEAR MODULUS KPa 400ULTIMATE ELONGATION % 65MATERIAL CONSTANT k ---- 0.87ELASTIC MODUKUS KPa 1350 15
  16. 16. SEISMIC LOADS AND STRUCTURAL DATA TABLE3SEISMIC PROPERIES VALUESEISMIC ZONE FACTOR 0.15SOIL PROFILE TYPE S3SEISMIC COEFFICIENT CA 0.22SEISMIC COEFFICIENT CV 0.32ISOLATED LATERAL FORCE COEFFICIENT RI 2FIXED BASE LATERAL FORCE COEFFICIENT R 8IMPORTANCE FACTOR 1SEISMIC COEFFICIENT CAM 0.35SEISMIC COEFFICIENT CVM 0.55 16
  17. 17. CONT HDRB AND LRB HAVE BEEN ASSIGNED AT THE MIDDLE C3 AND OUTSIDE C1 AND C2 COLUMNS RESPECTIVLEY TYPES OF ISOLATORS AND LOADS ACTING ON THE COLUMN BASE SUBJECTED TO BEARINGS IS SHOWN IN TABLE4 17
  18. 18. TYPES OF ISOLATORS AND LOADS TABLE4BEARING TYPES AND LOAD DATA LRB HDRB TOTALTYPE ISOLATO ISOLATOR R1 1NO OF BEARINGS 16 9 25AVERAGE DEAD LOAD+SLL(KN) 4035 7024MAXIMUM DEAD LOAD+LL(KN) 4546 7215MAXIMUM DEAD 4063 7220LOAD+SLL+EQL(KN)SEISMIC WEIGHT W(KN) 127766TOTAL WIND LOAD(KN) 2698 18
  19. 19. ISOLATOR PERFORMANCE THE TWO MAIN THHINGS NEEDED TO TAKE CARE ARE 1)THE STATUS OF THE ISOLATOR BEARING TO SUPPORT THE LOAD SAFELY 2)THE PERFORMANCE OF ISOLATED BEARING WHICH IS EVALUATED FOR BOTH DEB AND MCE THE COEFFICINTS TAKEN FOR ANALYSIS ARE SHOWN 19
  20. 20. CONT SEISMIC COEFFICENT CORRESPONDING TO CONSTANT ACCELERATION REGION FOR DBE(CA) = 0.22 FOR MCE(CAM)= 0.35 SEISMIC COEFFICIENT CORRESPONDING TO CONSTANT VELOCITY REGION FOR DBE(CV) = 0.32 FOR MCE(CVM)= 0.55 ZONE FACTOR FOR DHAKA = 0.15 20
  21. 21. DYNAMIC ANALYSIS ASSIGNING THE PROPERTIES TO THE ISOLATORS AND LINKED TO THE STRUCTURE AND IS ANALYSED FROM THE TIME HISTORY OF THE NEAREST EQ,SOIL CHARACTERISTICS,SEISIMIC COEFFICIENTS,ALONG WITH GENERATED TIME HISTORY DUHAMELS INTEGRAL 5% DAMPED RESPONSE SPECTRUM IS ESTABLISHED 21
  22. 22. CONT THEN AFTER LINKING THE BI TO THE STRUCTURE THE DYNAMIC ANALYSIS,RESPONSE SPECTRUM AND TIME HISTORY IS PERFORMED WITH 2 MODIFICATIONSACCOUNTING FOR BI 1)SPRINGS WITH EFFECTIVE STIFFNESS OF THE ISOLATOR ARE MODELED TO CONNECT THE BASE LEVEL OF THE STRUCTURE TO GROUND 2)THE RESPONSE SPECTRUM IS MODIFIED TO ACCOUNT FOR DAMPING PROVIDED IN ISOLATED MODES TO USE A COMPOSITESPECTRUM.THE 5% DAMPING SPECTRUM HAS BEEN REDUCED BY B FACTOR IN ISOLATED MODES 22
  23. 23. COMPOSITE RESPONSE SPECTRUM FOR DHAKAEARTHQUAKE 23
  24. 24. RESULTS DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF FIXED BUILDING IS PERFORMED BY SAP AND THE RESULTS ARE SHOWN IN TABLE5 LINEAR STATIC AND NON LINEAR DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF THE BUILDING WITH ISOLATORS ARE AS SHOWN IN TABLE 6 AND TABLE7 24
  25. 25. DYNAMIC ANALYSIS OF FIXED BUILDING TABLE5 RESPONSE TIME HISTORY SPECTRUM ANALYSIS ANALYSISDESIGN BASE SHEAR(KN) IN X 22221 19610DIRECTIONDESIGN BASE SHEAR(KN) IN Y 16666 14528DIRECTIONDESIGN BASE MOMENT(KN-M) 143114 123726IN X DIRECTIONDESIGN BASE MOMENT(KN-M) 87047 76880IN Y DIRECTIONTOP STORY 67.1 35DISPLACEMENT(mm) IN U1DIRECTIONTOP STORY 40.1 31.7DISPLACEMENT(mm) IN U1DIRECTION 25
  26. 26. RESULTS OF DYNAMIC ANALYSIS USINGISOLATOR TABLE 6STRUCTURAL PERIOD FOR MODE ISOLATOR TOTAL1 DISPLACEMENT STRUCTURAL DRIFTU1 DIRECTION(STATIC ANALYSIS) 151.6 56.3U2 DIRECTION(STATIC ANALYSIS) 145.8 53.1U1 DIRECTION(RESPONSE 134.4 35.4SPECTRUM ANALYSIS)U2 DIRECTION(RESPONSE 83.3 31.2SPECTRUM ANALYSIS)U1 DIRECTION(TIME HISTORY 119.1 30.1ANALYSIS)U2 DIRECTION(TIME HISTORY 73.8 28.6ANALYSIS) 26
  27. 27. BASE SHEAR AND BASE MOMENT AFTERDYNAMIC ANALYSIS TABLE7 RESPONSE SPECTRUM TIME HISTORY ANALYSIS ANALYSISDESIGN BASE 8842.5 7803.2SHEAR(KN) IN XDIRECTIONDESIGN BASE 5526.9 4837.3SHEAR(KN) IN YDIRECTIONDESIGN BASE 49923.7 43932.1MOMENT(KN-M) IN XDIRECTIONDESIGN BASE 30955.67 26.930.8MOMENT(KN-M) IN YDIRECTION 27
  28. 28. CONT SINCE ALL THE VALUES OF BASE SHEAR AND DESIGN BASE MOMENT HAS DRASTICALLY REDUCED BY INATALLATION OF ISOLATOR SO IT IS SATISFACTORY TO USE BI 28
  29. 29. ECONOMIC IMPLICATIONS THOUGH THE INSTALLATION OF ISOLATION SYSTEM ADDS MORE TO INITIAL COST IT REDUCES THE REINFORCEMENT REQUIRMENTS OF BUILDINGAND ULTIMATELY REDUCES THE COST COST ANALYSIS FOR A 10 STORY BUILDING IS PERFORMED FOR A 10 STORY BUILDING SAVING IN REINFORCEMANT REQUIRMENT ALONG WITH INITIAL COSTS ARE DETERMINED IN TABLE8 29
  30. 30. NET SAVINGS IN THE ISOLATED BUILDINGTABLE8NO OF SAVINGS NO OF ISOLATOR NET NETSTORIES FROM ISOLATOR COSTS IN SAVINGS SAVINGS BEAMS S US $ IN US $ % OF AND REINFORC COLUMNS EMENT IN $10 40980 25 24926 16054 7.75 30
  31. 31. CONT FOR THE SAME PLAN AREA BUILDINGS HAS BEEN NALYSED FOR 4,5,6,7,8,9 STOREY TO REPRESENT A COMPARITIVE GENERALISED RELATIONSHIP FOR SAVINGS IN REINFORCEMENT FOR AN ISOLATED BUILDINGS 31
  32. 32. % SAVINGS IN REINFORCEMENT FOR BEAMSAND COLUMNS VERSUS DIFFERENT STORIES 32
  33. 33. INSIGHTS DUE TO VAST CIVILISATION AND URBANISATION MANY REGIONS OF EARTH ARE GOING TO BE EARTHQUAKE PRONE IN FUTURE SINCE THE BASE ISOLATION CAN ACCOMIDATE FOR IT EVEN WITH SOME COST REDUCTION IT MAY BE WIDELY USED IN FUTURE 33
  34. 34. CONCLUSIONS EVEN THOUGH SEISMIC BASE ISOLATION INCREASES THE INITIAL COST THE REDUCTION IN REINFORCEMENT IN UPPER FLOORS WILL MAKE UP THAT COST AND EVEN REDUCES THE TOTAL COST EVEN BI BUILDINGS PROVE EFFECTIVE FOR LOW TO MEDIUM RISE BUILDINGS WITH A GOOD FOUNDATION SOIL. 34
  35. 35. REFERENCES BANGLADESH NATIONAL BUILDING CODE(19993) HOUSING AND BUILDING RESEARCH INSTITUTE DEB S.K(2004) “SEISMIC BASE ISOLATION – AN OVERVIEW” 35
  36. 36. THANK YOU 36

×