Blandin Foundation Webinar Broadband Best Practices Bill Coleman Community Technology Advisors October 20, 2009

Discussion What broadband changes are you struggling to make happen in your community?

What broadband changes are you struggling to make happen in your community?

Private Sector Qwest Regional carriers like Zayo and Enventis Independent telephone companies Cable television companies CLECs National carriers Cellular carriers Public Sector State of Minnesota (mostly leased) Public safety wireless School districts (owned and leased) Counties and municipalities I-Nets ISPs/Triple play

Private Sector

Qwest

Regional carriers like Zayo and Enventis

Independent telephone companies

Cable television companies

CLECs

National carriers

Cellular carriers

Public Sector

State of Minnesota (mostly leased)

Public safety wireless

School districts (owned and leased)

Counties and municipalities

I-Nets

ISPs/Triple play

786k 10 Mb 100 Mb 1 Gb

According to Connected Nation, 96% of Minnesotans have access to broadband at 786k download or better Almost all without broadband connection options are in rural areas 80/20 rule of deployment costs What is the situation in your community? How does your ubiquity change as the bandwidth standard goes up? Is broadband ubiquitous if it is beyond the financial reach of many citizens?

According to Connected Nation, 96% of Minnesotans have access to broadband at 786k download or better

Almost all without broadband connection options are in rural areas

80/20 rule of deployment costs

What is the situation in your community?

How does your ubiquity change as the bandwidth standard goes up?

Is broadband ubiquitous if it is beyond the financial reach of many citizens?

Internet Connection Costs 100 Mb at the Minneapolis NAP = $4-$8/Mb 100 Mb to greater MN locations = $65-$88/Mb Within a network Operational costs of bandwidth flowing within a network are very low. State BB task force recommends that providers make efforts to keep more network traffic in MN rather than pay to send it to Chicago and back

Internet Connection Costs

100 Mb at the Minneapolis NAP = $4-$8/Mb

100 Mb to greater MN locations = $65-$88/Mb

Within a network

Operational costs of bandwidth flowing within a network are very low.

State BB task force recommends that providers make efforts to keep more network traffic in MN rather than pay to send it to Chicago and back

Stimulating Network Investment

Best Practices

Partnering in Brainerd Lakes Area to use school district fiber ring investment to jumpstart CLEC activities in Brainerd, Baxter and Nisswa – filling the “black hole” and stimulating competitive response from Qwest and Charter. Partnering in Staples to build community fiber ring connecting key institutions and deploying wireless technology to serve the greater Staples area.

Partnering in Brainerd Lakes Area to use school district fiber ring investment to jumpstart CLEC activities in Brainerd, Baxter and Nisswa – filling the “black hole” and stimulating competitive response from Qwest and Charter.

Partnering in Staples to build community fiber ring connecting key institutions and deploying wireless technology to serve the greater Staples area.

ECMECC ( East Central MN Education Cable Cooperative) Cooperative connects 13 school districts throughout east central region with high capacity fiber Fiber provided by US Cable and SGI Cable companies Companies leveraged fiber investment to bring broadband to small communities within the region

Cooperative connects 13 school districts throughout east central region with high capacity fiber

Fiber provided by US Cable and SGI Cable companies

Companies leveraged fiber investment to bring broadband to small communities within the region

High capacity fiber network investment in partnership with private sector to link all Scott County facilities and communities Partnerships with Dakota and Blue Earth Counties and Minnesota State University-Mankato to add redundancy and value Enables easier entry for competitive broadband services throughout the county

High capacity fiber network investment in partnership with private sector to link all Scott County facilities and communities

Partnerships with Dakota and Blue Earth Counties and Minnesota State University-Mankato to add redundancy and value

Enables easier entry for competitive broadband services throughout the county

Committed municipal effort to build FTTH TDS competitive response with FTTH Is this really a best practice case study? Double investment in fiber capacity Huge legal fees by city and TDS Lost time before deployment Community energy

Committed municipal effort to build FTTH

TDS competitive response with FTTH

Is this really a best practice case study?

Double investment in fiber capacity

Huge legal fees by city and TDS

Lost time before deployment

Community energy

Emerging Projects Southwest Fiber Project – extension of Windom city network to surrounding rural communities Cook County – countywide FTTP network Lake County – countywide FTTP network Lac qui Parle County – county partnership with Farmers Telephone to explore 100% FTTH Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe

Southwest Fiber Project – extension of Windom city network to surrounding rural communities

Cook County – countywide FTTP network

Lake County – countywide FTTP network

Lac qui Parle County – county partnership with Farmers Telephone to explore 100% FTTH

Leech Lake Band of Ojibwe

The most important connections are within your own community The network value accelerates with more people connected Tech-centered companies want high-capacity, low-cost, redundant networks Entrepreneurs want connectivity in the places where they want to live which may be outside of the community

The most important connections are within your own community

The network value accelerates with more people connected

Tech-centered companies want high-capacity, low-cost, redundant networks

Entrepreneurs want connectivity in the places where they want to live which may be outside of the community

Discussion How is your network treating your community?

How is your network treating your community?

Growing Sector Sophistication

Best Practices

Best Practices - Subscription Education of targeted groups through tech classes, tech fairs Recycling of used computers to those without them, especially tied to classes Increase access at libraries, schools, senior centers and other places

Education of targeted groups through tech classes, tech fairs

Recycling of used computers to those without them, especially tied to classes

Increase access at libraries, schools, senior centers and other places

Best Practices - Sophistication Web site and other technology training, especially for small businesses, non-profits and community organizations Web site assessment services, especially for small businesses, non-profits, community organizations Web site development subsidies for small businesses Facilitated discussions about community web site linking strategies, especially Web 2.0 applications

Web site and other technology training, especially for small businesses, non-profits and community organizations

Web site assessment services, especially for small businesses, non-profits, community organizations

Web site development subsidies for small businesses

Facilitated discussions about community web site linking strategies, especially Web 2.0 applications

Best Practices – Tech Support Add capacity to existing tech support companies through training Bundle demand for tech support via joint purchasing and by vetting quality Attract tech support companies to your community through attraction and entrepreneurial support

Add capacity to existing tech support companies through training

Bundle demand for tech support via joint purchasing and by vetting quality

Attract tech support companies to your community through attraction and entrepreneurial support

Create and Support Tech Champions Identify those with tech vision in schools, government, health care and business Bring tech visionaries together to discuss plans and collaboration opportunities Use community communication vehicles like web sites, newspapers, newsletters and cafes to promote technology Support technology investments

Identify those with tech vision in schools, government, health care and business

Bring tech visionaries together to discuss plans and collaboration opportunities

Use community communication vehicles like web sites, newspapers, newsletters and cafes to promote technology

Support technology investments

Discussion What are the barriers to technology adoption in your community?

What are the barriers to technology adoption in your community?

Bill Coleman