For all the "Surrendeded Wife" types who think women should go back to being submissive, this book shows what it was really like. Ideally, people think of traditional roles as being protective and chivalrous toward women, but in the book, chivalry has nothing to do with it, and women are shown as being used- they do all the chores, they are told what to do, they are neglected (a lot of the ways the husbands treat their wives are now considered abuse), and finally, many of them live in poverty when their husbands find someone else. I think this is true of a lot of traditional societies- the ideal is protection, but the reality is different.
This book really shows the story of not one generation but two. Mira comes of age in the 50s and she ends up being a homemaker. I got an in-depth look at the lives of housewives. It showed that there were some joys in that life, but it also described the problems that people tried to keep under the surface. I am sure that there were also plenty of relationships that were better than the ones in this book, and there are plenty of women who were happy back then, but the problem is the insistence that every woman should be like this and only this.
Gender roles are of course based on biological differences, and in a few places this book lashes out not only at society, but at nature. The problem is that the roles apply even when the biological differences are flexible, and biology is used as an excuse to put both men and women into inflexible molds. The book shows that gender roles effect both sexes and the men in this book have problems of their own- for instance not being close to anyone in their own households.
But after getting divorced, Mira goes to college in the 60s and experiences the turbulence of that time period. I really liked Mira as a character and was happy to see her growth as a person. Her divorce was certainly for the better. I also liked her interaction with her sons. I also loved her closeness with her friends. The group of friends puts friendship at a higher priority than most people do, even daydreaming about living together as friends. This reminds me of the friendships that I used to have and the way I felt about them.
At first I thought that maybe men could read it, but I'm sure their reaction would be similar to my reaction to Omar Tyree. The only difference is, the author of this book at least showed why her characters grew to hate men. Early on, anger toward men or whites was understandable, but after establishing more rights and equality, it usually is counter-productive and just causes backlash. Of course, there is usually backlash even before full equality has been achieved.
I don't feel the same way that most of the characters end up feeling, and that's a good thing. This book can show you how many changes have occurred in a few decades, and can remind you not to take it for granted. Many women are in charge of their own lives and are excelling in their careers. Sexism sometimes effects men and in some cases it is in women's favor. Both women and men have progressed in the past decades. In my life I have been angry toward womankind as well as mankind.
But then, in some areas sexism is still abundant, and women still have to worry about sexual assault (more than men do). And early on, when Mira got married, she describes the feeling that it's the easy way out and it will keep her from having to make decisions about her life, it reminded me of me a lot.
For the whole book I was wondering who the narrator was. Her monologues were very cerebral and they were probably the part I liked least about the book. At the end of the book, Val comes to believe that all men are rapists, but that seemed more like her reaction as a character and not necessarily the author's opinion. The book makes men to be the problem, but in my experience, women are treacherous to each other and there are also plenty of decent men that get treated badly. There is maybe one example of women's backstabbing (Bliss) and maybe Martha was the woman who treated her husband badly, but mainly the book focuses on society being stacked up against women, showing every character being victimized in some way by a man, covering every possibility almost like it's from a checklist. Also, even the men that seemed decent ended up being a disappointment in the end, with the exception of Mira's sons.
Well, I guess that's a pretty big criticism for a 5 star rating, but I still really liked this book. It brings to light the similarities and differences between then and now. It has some wonderful characters and shows a lot of different points of view and thought patterns. It was very in-depth and I was totally engrossed in it.
less
0 comments
Post a comment