In Dante's Inferno those deepest in hell are those that can not accept love because they are too suspicious of the actions of others; they think of love as a con-job waiting to happen. Petruchio plays games that save Kathrina's heart, she accepts love, this tough love/ cruel to be kind method, and a sort of miracle happens and Petruchio fully deserves his reward. Petruchio did more than win Kate's love he saved her soul. Bianca suffers from an almost equally deadly disease, vanity, but will there be someone to save her from that? Highly doubtful and now she is the shrew and her husband, Lucentio, can expect a life of dread and discomfiture for being the overly lusty boy he was.
Much of Shakespeare is other than what it seems. Katharina has a cynical, jaded heart one that distrusts the idea of love, one that can not accept love, after being raised in a house where her father openly prefers her younger sister and her younger sister is paraded as the glimmering child of promise Katharina's heart has been drug through the mud.
Shakespeare read Ovid and alludes often to Ovid's idea that a happy marriage (if it exists at all) is between equals. Petruchio shows Kate through his unyielding efforts that he loves her, much of this strategy is to shine a mirror back in Katharina's face through his actions so she can see herself more clearly. Petruchio is her equal. Love is gained when Katharina takes over Petruchio's game herself and plays with Petruchio at it, but it is a loving game, being mean while saying that she loves him like he did; Petruchio's stubborness pays off and the words grow to mean what they say to both of them. Love takes time and commitment, it is a labor. Petruchio also convinces Katharina that he is willing to put his house in a caotic mess for her love.
Gremio never seeks to meet his equal in either looks nor wealth and got what Ovid would probably call a natural consequence.
Does anybody really doubt that the relationship between Petruchio and Kathrina will be of equals and loving? Gremio and Lucentio are set up for dread, they did not set out to find their equals. In a sense it is a tragedy for Lucentio because he fell to lust not to his studies and got what he deserved.
The comparison of dogs, particularly three dogs, at the beginning is interesting. Analogy: Dog is to nose, as single man is to woo-ing. Three men go about wooing and sniffing out the heart. The hunter's observations about each dog comes full circle.
Christopher Sly? Why, he is you.
The movie version with Richard Burton is very lively and enjoyable. It fails to probe the depth of the play yet still does do it justice. The Taming of the Shrew
The BBC version, which has the hopeful quality of having John Cleese in it, failed miserably. I think it lacked direction and sputered all over the place. I still felt sorry for Petruchio even in the winning of this Kate, but it was worse than even that and John Cleese was not a good match for this charactor Taming of the Shrew- tThe Comedies, Histories and Tragedies of William Shakespeare
less
0 comments
Post a comment