I loved this novel! Recommended, and lent, by a friend of my wife's who lamented, "I wish I could have conversations like this," Haven Kimmel did not disappoint. I was wowed, and found myself constantly torn between not wanting to stop reading, but having to stop reading to reflect on what she had just written.
One reviewer decried the fact that this novel may have been (based on comments in her acknowledgements) birthed by Kimmel's unrealized desire to write a doctoral dissertation on a related subject. Why not use a novel as a vehicle to explore the complex and interwoven tapestry of literature, theology, philosophy and art? In fact, I think it's freaking brilliant to take the stuff of doctor's theses and share it via novel. Who reads doctors' theses other than doctoral candidates? Maybe we'd all get better exposed to high-quality thinking if more authors latched on to Kimmel's idea.
Not all novels have to be fluff, junk food for the soul, light beach reading (hey, I enjoy my light reading, too). It's perfectly okay that Kimmel departed from (apparently, since I haven't read anything else from her--yet) her norm with this work. Perhaps, when I read more of her stuff, I will be as disappointed with what I perceive as a step down as many of the reviewers here seem disappointed with her stepping her work up intellectually. If you want light, literary pabulum, this book is not for you. Perhaps if you have a PhD in theology, literature, or philosophy, this book might be far too simplistic. However, if you're intellectually curious, and prone to stopping in the middle of a book to further explore some tangent, then this book is for you.
Some reviewers have labeled the characters and conversations implausible. Au contraire! I'd characterize them both as intriguing and extraordinary. Her dialog is rich and inviting. Others have criticized this book as an indictment of small town America. Again, far from it! In her work, Kimmel depicts well the depth and substance which belies conventional wisdom regarding rural communities.
Reading Kimmel's book inspired me to order two additional books from Amazon (three, if you count buying my own copy of this book) and to spend a few hours surfing the net in search of more information about some of the concepts Kimmel introduced me to. If you measure a book by the impact it has on your thinking, the impression which lingers a week later, The Solace of Leaving Early scores high.
less
0 comments
Post a comment