Clearly it isn't easy to whisk your way through 1000+ pages of dense mathematical, graduate level (and above) material. I have managed to read the first few chapters, with more emphasis on the ones dealing with differential geometry. From what I saw, most of the subsequent chapters discussing physical applications are basically a reiteration of similar parts from the Emperor's New Mind (ENM), so if you have already read this book, you will see many familiar faces. Make no mistakes, this isn't the kind of book you read in bed before you sleep! You will probably need a hard surface, pen and paper. It isn't for the layman either. If you are not well acquainted with advanced mathematics or physics, you should probably avoid it. My father has a Bachelor in Physics and had trouble reading even ENM. I have a PhD in theoretical physics and still I get to discover many new things in Road to Reality, or see things I already knew about from a completely new perspective, and also lots of topics I knew nothing about.
The first half of the book, where the mathematical exposition takes place, is like ENM on steroids. Penrose stops carrying about losing half of his readers with every new equation. You will see here mathematical formulas that you would normally have to fork out $ 100+ on some specialized textbook to take a look at. So, what makes it any different from a regular textbook, you would ask? Well, it is the uniquely original and lucid exposition that makes this book transcend its original designation as textbook/popular science book hybrid. It becomes the textbook you would like to have read as a graduate student, but was not around at the time. It is not written in the usual dry style of mathematical literature that makes simple things seem arcane. And it includes a multitude of excellent pictures/artwork, as every good differential geometry book should. The diagrams and pictures are worth the price of admission alone. Penrose also succeeds in making his book exciting and engaging. He takes you by the hand and shows you why the ideas he discusses are interesting and important. You feel the thrill of discovering new things, of learning and being proud to be taught. Formulas and jargon are not introduced without an explanation and motivation, contrary to most textbooks. You are given the chance to really understand what a Lie and a covariant derivative is, not just how to calculate one. The chapter on fiber bundles is a poem of clarity of exposition. It achieves what every good textbook should-giving you a flavor and letting you craving for more.
As a first impression, this book seems unique, if only for its stimulating, refreshing and unconventional mathematical first part. If you are already experienced with differential geometry and general relativity, it is a delight to read and will provide you with incredible new insight and encyclopedic knowledge. You can then go on to read more details in standard textbooks. Graduate students should see it as an excellent complement to their curriculum.
less
0 comments
Post a comment