I absolutely loved this book. I am a horse person, and have no idea how significant that fact is to my enjoyment; but certainly I liked the book more than most books about horses, because this gal knew her stuff, where so many authors don't. But it was also a quietly unfolding and totally believable picture of a particular time and place and the people in it.
While I agree with an earlier reviewer that sometimes the author tells rather than shows, I personally was happy with that. I didn't need to be shown every encounter between people; sometimes being told they happened is sufficient. There were in fact plenty of opportunities to be shown things, about countryside, people, horses, and the time.
The author used an interesting convention that bothered me the first time but I enjoyed more and more as time went along. Once in a while, and not often, the omniscient narrator appeared to compare the time being written about with times to come. For example, she refers to the advent of electric power, noting that power would not come to this valley until after the next war. After the first occasion, this was not intrusive, but gave a perspective to the piece whenever it was employed.
The one factual criticism I might make I will also entirely forgive, but must make note of: it is extremely unlikely that even a young woman such as Martha would so successfully use the horse training methods described. This is a very recent improvement in horsemanship, which developed near to the area Ms Gloss describes, but not for another generation. Still, the author has got it right, and it's not impossible that someone - perhaps even particularly most likely a woman - would have developed the thinking prior to the Dorrance brothers - and in any case, I enjoyed reading of her efforts from the perspective of a would-be follower of that approach today, the so-called natural horsemanship.
Martha is a very appealing, believable character that I found it very easy to relate to personally, and the scene in which she is living is also appealing and believable. A wonderful book.
less
0 comments
Post a comment