I was motivated to read this collection solely on the power behind Todd Fields fantastic film `In The Bedroom' which hails it's magnificent plot from the short story `Killings'. `Killings' subsequently opens this collection strong, its dark underlining chaos perfectly laced subtly between pure and simple fear of tragedy. There comes along only once in many years a piece of literature so subtle yet so real and raw that it speaks to you, and this short story as well as the movie that it inspired truly manage to capture the essence of what makes quality entertainment. `Killings', which only covers the final frames of the film (which serves as further proof that the movie itself is a work of genius), may serve as the best of the collection, but there are plenty of other treats to be found in the six other offerings.
`The Winter Father' is the first of two stories dealing with a fathers desire to keep his relationship with his children alive after his marriage falls to pieces. This is the weaker of the two, a bit dry and unfulfilling as far as story wise. It just seems to carry on with no real objective.
`Rose' on the other hand has quite a powerful objective, and that is to evoke heartbreak and compassion for this woman's horrific story of abuse and broken trust. As our narrator retells a story of a woman whom he meets in a bar we are brought into her world slowly but surely. I will admit that in the beginning I was a bit turned off, for I was afraid it would take me no where yet again, but as the meat of the story began to unfold I found myself glued to each passing page. As Rose recounts her story of a tortured marriage, an abusive and horrific man and her struggle to save her children from this monster the reader can do nothing but hope and pray everything turns out better in the end.
`The Fat Girl' is actually my favorite story here, aside from `Killings'. It just explores the desire to belong so perfectly, taking a problem (or supposed problem) that every girl goes through and delves into the inner demons so brilliantly that you'd swear Andre Dubus himself were a woman who struggled with weight growing up. The story so elegantly yet bluntly uncovers that inane desire to belong to something that in the end causes us to become the one thing we never wanted to be.
I'm not too fond of `Delivering'; it just fails to richly examine infidelity and the broken home. It's not bad per say, and it's short so it's an easy read, just not an ultimately satisfying one.
`A Father's Story' on the other hand is very satisfying and is one of the best offerings here. As it delves into the struggle of a father to make an impact on his daughter's life, and that willingness to do any and everything to protect her, it really grabs your heartstrings and plays the saddest of sad songs. Dubus delicately weaves us a story of a man who has to make a decision, right or wrong, which ultimately will change his daughter's life forever. It's not the easiest decision to make, but in the end you understand fully why it was made.
The final story, while decent, is not as gripping or as satisfying as some of the other stories. `All the Time in the World' delves into relationships of a different nature, those of a man and woman, romantic, destructive, healthy and problematic. It does a decent job at rendering feeling and justification in the eyes and actions of those who have difficulty making a commitment; who seem determined to find love but continue to propel it away, but it ends on a note the reader will appreciate. This collection, while not quote-unquote perfect, delivers so much in its small body that it's well worth the time spent to uncover the riches within. Andre Dubus was such a wonderfully talented author, and reading his work is nothing short of a privilege!
less
0 comments
Post a comment