I usually avoid books on history published by The National Geographic Society. I have found them to be written in too simple a style and without a great deal of either new or deep intellectual content. I happened to pick up this book at the local library and turn randomly to page 194. It began:
"The Taiping Rebellion, a peasant uprising that occurred in mid 19th century China, involved more combatants than any other war in the 19th century, killed more people that any other conflict apart from World War II (estimates range from 20 million to 40 million)...and changed the future of an entire country. Yet very few people outside of China have ever heard of it. Nor do many know of its messianic leader, Hong Xiuquan, who claimed to have had an apocalyptic vision that revealed he was Jesus Christ's younger brother."
I had heard of it, but knew little about it - or about many of the other events described in the book. They are all (to those of us who enjoy history) interesting - and most are fascinating. The author has the unexpected and intellectually mature view that not everything done by western Europeans and Americans has been totally angelic.
The reviewer who gave the book only 2 stars says "Any reasonably serious student of history will be familiar with all the stories Cummins chooses to tell." All right, let's see if you are a reasonably serious student of history. What do you know about the following:
1. The Cadaver Synod, 2. The Leper King of Jerusalem, 3. Subotai, 4. Rabban Sauma, 5. The Chinese Treasure Fleet of Xuan He, 6. William the 1st of Orange, 7.The Shimabara Uprising, 8.Roger Williams (of Providence Plantation, not the singer), 9. The Battle of Poltava, 10. Vitus Bering, 11. Francisco Dagohoy and the Rebels of Bohol, 12. The British Abolition Movement, 13. David Thompson, North America's Greatest Geographer, 14. George Augustus Robinson, The Great Conciliator of Van Dieman's Land.
Those are the first fourteen (of twenty-eight) chapters. How did you do?
How do you think the two-star reviewer who made the statement did? The book is well written, in a very accessible style; I would recommend it not only to get a teenager interested in history, but as interesting and unusual fare for the experienced history buff.
less
0 comments
Post a comment